I'm tying a bunch of smaller flies (size 16-22) this winter. At what size and type (nymph, emerger, dry) of fly do you think it's best to use down turned eye hooks vs. straight eye hooks?
Question by dleurquin. Uploaded on January 16, 2012
Only consideration that needs to be made is....on small flies like say # 20 and smaller..maybe #18's as well, the down eye takes up some of the hook "GAPE", or gap, and you might not hook a fish as securely. I might make a case that a straight eyed hook is easier to tie in that I can see the head area better, and not crowd the eye because it is under somewhat. You might also like to thread the tippet through a straight eye believing it is easier to do than a down eye. I've had trouble threading a leader through a down eye, and turn the fly upside down, and the tippet goes right through. You probably have good eye sight, and not a problem. I never see a straight eyed hook for flies fished subsurface..all are down eyed.
Where are you going to be fishing? I have a serious lack of midges to fish with, so I'm in the same boat. Especially since the trout I was fishing for came from a spring creek, I needed to have midges for sure.
Only consideration that needs to be made is....on small flies like say # 20 and smaller..maybe #18's as well, the down eye takes up some of the hook "GAPE", or gap, and you might not hook a fish as securely. I might make a case that a straight eyed hook is easier to tie in that I can see the head area better, and not crowd the eye because it is under somewhat. You might also like to thread the tippet through a straight eye believing it is easier to do than a down eye. I've had trouble threading a leader through a down eye, and turn the fly upside down, and the tippet goes right through. You probably have good eye sight, and not a problem. I never see a straight eyed hook for flies fished subsurface..all are down eyed.
Where are you going to be fishing? I have a serious lack of midges to fish with, so I'm in the same boat. Especially since the trout I was fishing for came from a spring creek, I needed to have midges for sure.
Answers (3)
Only consideration that needs to be made is....on small flies like say # 20 and smaller..maybe #18's as well, the down eye takes up some of the hook "GAPE", or gap, and you might not hook a fish as securely. I might make a case that a straight eyed hook is easier to tie in that I can see the head area better, and not crowd the eye because it is under somewhat. You might also like to thread the tippet through a straight eye believing it is easier to do than a down eye. I've had trouble threading a leader through a down eye, and turn the fly upside down, and the tippet goes right through. You probably have good eye sight, and not a problem. I never see a straight eyed hook for flies fished subsurface..all are down eyed.
Hey, thanks Sayfu. I'm about to buy some hooks and thinking about getting some straight eye ones.
Where are you going to be fishing? I have a serious lack of midges to fish with, so I'm in the same boat. Especially since the trout I was fishing for came from a spring creek, I needed to have midges for sure.
Post an Answer
Only consideration that needs to be made is....on small flies like say # 20 and smaller..maybe #18's as well, the down eye takes up some of the hook "GAPE", or gap, and you might not hook a fish as securely. I might make a case that a straight eyed hook is easier to tie in that I can see the head area better, and not crowd the eye because it is under somewhat. You might also like to thread the tippet through a straight eye believing it is easier to do than a down eye. I've had trouble threading a leader through a down eye, and turn the fly upside down, and the tippet goes right through. You probably have good eye sight, and not a problem. I never see a straight eyed hook for flies fished subsurface..all are down eyed.
Hey, thanks Sayfu. I'm about to buy some hooks and thinking about getting some straight eye ones.
Where are you going to be fishing? I have a serious lack of midges to fish with, so I'm in the same boat. Especially since the trout I was fishing for came from a spring creek, I needed to have midges for sure.
Post an Answer