Please Sign In

Please enter a valid username and password
  • Log in with Facebook
» Not a member? Take a moment to register
» Forgot Username or Password

Why Register?
Signing up could earn you gear (click here to learn how)! It also keeps offensive content off our site.

AnswersASK YOUR QUESTION

Answers

Q:
I have been doing mostly catch and release lately and I was just wondering what is everyone's opinion on catch and release with different types of fish and also with fresh and saltwater.

Question by riverdemon10. Uploaded on August 25, 2009

Answers (21)

Top Rated
All Answers
from kyle wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

I mostly catch and release, let them get bigger for the next fishermen or fisherwomen to enjoy. This past summer I caught and release a 23 1/2 inch largemouth bass and numerous that were over 20 inches. I love being on the lake and enjoying time with my dad. I think you remember the fight more than you remember eating it!!!!

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from kyle wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

and spending time with dad

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from Hunt_Hard wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

My outlook on this is, if your going to eat it keep it, if your just out there to fish and be out there by all means throw them back.

+3 Good Comment? | | Report
from Wonko wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

I'm with Hunt_Hard. If your salt water fishing in deep water plan on keeping them, as the swim bladder will blow up like a ballon and if you release they they will die anyway, because they can't swim back down.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from jbird wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

It it's a big bass, I throw it back, otherwise, heat up the grease! It does have to be legal length, but man, if there's a better meal than fried fish and cold beer, I'd love to hear it.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from kyle wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

I think I be fine with just a cold beer or two, or three or.....................

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from woodtick wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

I keep enough so I always have a meal in the freeze. I love to fish but i don't like wasting them, so after i have a meal in the freeze I release what I catch, when I fish for Musky I release all I catch if its a wall hanger I take pics and measurments.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from fishallday wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

Well I don't always catch and release but it is a good thing to practice.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from seadog wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

If you're going to eat it, "filet & release" is the way to go. Otherwise, let it grow.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Skeeb wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

I release everything except for natives 12 and above.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Cgull wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

good to hear more catch and release, I fish fresh and salt water when ever I can. It's recommended not to fight the fish you plan top realease too hard as it will cause the build up of latic acid, sorta like the cramps we get when running very far or weight training too hard. Wearing out a fish while bringing in makes the fish weak and susceptible to bigger prey fish. sometimes cradling weak fish while moving water thru the gills will rejuvenate these fish. Deep water fish that have their inflatted air bladders released by punctuing it with a ice pick or simular object. Keep on catchin, catch em all. Just dont keep more than you need. We've all been with the guy that keeps 10 fish and a 5-6 lb'r then at the boat ramp, says " anybody want these? I jus don't feel like cleaing fish today"

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from DakotaMan wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

I release most fresh water fish I catch. With deep caught salt water fish and fresh water salmon, I keep most of them because of the problem Wonko sited above. On most states that have slot limits, you are forced to release out of range fish even if they are dead when you release them. If it is a bill fish or a trophy fish, I release it too so that someone else will have a chance to catch it. If I want it mounted, the taxidermist only needs the dimensions to do a nice mount.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from riverdemon10 wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

these are all great answers. I didnt expect to so many. I agree with everyone. Keep the answers coming. Thanks guys.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from shane wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

I release practically everything. The exception seems to be lake trout. Some places I'll just keep one or two to eat, and other places I kill every last one I catch. There are a few bodies of water/locales where they're invasive and screwing things up for native trout, Glacier (bull trout) and Yellowstone (cutthroats) National Parks being the well known places.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from chuckles wrote 2 years 23 weeks ago

I release the bass I catch. Otherwise, Northerns, walleye, panfish, trout all are liable to end up in the pan if I am camping or hungry. I let most larger fish go and keep the eaters. By the way, bass are not bad eating I just like to catch em more than eat em.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from kyle wrote 2 years 23 weeks ago

Nice job of catching and releasing fish, now what about shooting and releasing? I had to say it, LOL
Good luck fishing and hunting everybody!!!

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from RobinHood wrote 2 years 23 weeks ago

There was a huge push by BASS to do catch and release on largemouth, and now there is this big stigma people have with keeping them. This has lead to some difficult issues for fisheries managers when trying to create desirable conditions for anglers, as harvest is being lost as a tool due to all catch and release. If you see a population of over crowded fish that look either malnourished, or all stuck at the same size, by all means, harvest those fish and eat them, otherwise they won't get any bigger. By having fewer bass, they will have more food to go around, allowing them to get bigger faster. Now, if it is a big fish, take some great pictures and let it go so that it can reproduce, as we all know that genetics is one of those factors we have very little control over.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from stick500 wrote 2 years 22 weeks ago

I do almost all catch and release but I sometimes keep a few trout and catfish (trout are so easy to clean!).
I love catching big carp and I always let them go even though anyone around seems to argue with me that it's illegal to put them back- they're wrong! Sometimes people ask to have the carp when they see me bring 'em in, and of course I give them to them.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from buckeyeben wrote 2 years 22 weeks ago

i mostly practice catch and release but if i'm catchin a few ill keep them but thats mostly when im walleye or catfishing but most everything else i put back

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from fisher girl wrote 2 years 20 weeks ago

I usuually catch and release. If we catch a fish and decide to eat it we take it home. Other than that it is catch and release.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from 268bull wrote 2 years 19 weeks ago

I think catch and release is fine, if that's what your into and truly believe is the thing to do. However, if the person across the stream from you isn't, that's fine too. Mutual respect. Personally, I keep and eat what I catch.

0 Good Comment? | | Report

Post an Answer

from Hunt_Hard wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

My outlook on this is, if your going to eat it keep it, if your just out there to fish and be out there by all means throw them back.

+3 Good Comment? | | Report
from Wonko wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

I'm with Hunt_Hard. If your salt water fishing in deep water plan on keeping them, as the swim bladder will blow up like a ballon and if you release they they will die anyway, because they can't swim back down.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from kyle wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

I mostly catch and release, let them get bigger for the next fishermen or fisherwomen to enjoy. This past summer I caught and release a 23 1/2 inch largemouth bass and numerous that were over 20 inches. I love being on the lake and enjoying time with my dad. I think you remember the fight more than you remember eating it!!!!

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from kyle wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

and spending time with dad

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from jbird wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

It it's a big bass, I throw it back, otherwise, heat up the grease! It does have to be legal length, but man, if there's a better meal than fried fish and cold beer, I'd love to hear it.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from kyle wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

I think I be fine with just a cold beer or two, or three or.....................

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from woodtick wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

I keep enough so I always have a meal in the freeze. I love to fish but i don't like wasting them, so after i have a meal in the freeze I release what I catch, when I fish for Musky I release all I catch if its a wall hanger I take pics and measurments.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from Cgull wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

good to hear more catch and release, I fish fresh and salt water when ever I can. It's recommended not to fight the fish you plan top realease too hard as it will cause the build up of latic acid, sorta like the cramps we get when running very far or weight training too hard. Wearing out a fish while bringing in makes the fish weak and susceptible to bigger prey fish. sometimes cradling weak fish while moving water thru the gills will rejuvenate these fish. Deep water fish that have their inflatted air bladders released by punctuing it with a ice pick or simular object. Keep on catchin, catch em all. Just dont keep more than you need. We've all been with the guy that keeps 10 fish and a 5-6 lb'r then at the boat ramp, says " anybody want these? I jus don't feel like cleaing fish today"

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from fishallday wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

Well I don't always catch and release but it is a good thing to practice.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from seadog wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

If you're going to eat it, "filet & release" is the way to go. Otherwise, let it grow.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Skeeb wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

I release everything except for natives 12 and above.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from DakotaMan wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

I release most fresh water fish I catch. With deep caught salt water fish and fresh water salmon, I keep most of them because of the problem Wonko sited above. On most states that have slot limits, you are forced to release out of range fish even if they are dead when you release them. If it is a bill fish or a trophy fish, I release it too so that someone else will have a chance to catch it. If I want it mounted, the taxidermist only needs the dimensions to do a nice mount.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from riverdemon10 wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

these are all great answers. I didnt expect to so many. I agree with everyone. Keep the answers coming. Thanks guys.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from shane wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

I release practically everything. The exception seems to be lake trout. Some places I'll just keep one or two to eat, and other places I kill every last one I catch. There are a few bodies of water/locales where they're invasive and screwing things up for native trout, Glacier (bull trout) and Yellowstone (cutthroats) National Parks being the well known places.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from chuckles wrote 2 years 23 weeks ago

I release the bass I catch. Otherwise, Northerns, walleye, panfish, trout all are liable to end up in the pan if I am camping or hungry. I let most larger fish go and keep the eaters. By the way, bass are not bad eating I just like to catch em more than eat em.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from kyle wrote 2 years 23 weeks ago

Nice job of catching and releasing fish, now what about shooting and releasing? I had to say it, LOL
Good luck fishing and hunting everybody!!!

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from RobinHood wrote 2 years 23 weeks ago

There was a huge push by BASS to do catch and release on largemouth, and now there is this big stigma people have with keeping them. This has lead to some difficult issues for fisheries managers when trying to create desirable conditions for anglers, as harvest is being lost as a tool due to all catch and release. If you see a population of over crowded fish that look either malnourished, or all stuck at the same size, by all means, harvest those fish and eat them, otherwise they won't get any bigger. By having fewer bass, they will have more food to go around, allowing them to get bigger faster. Now, if it is a big fish, take some great pictures and let it go so that it can reproduce, as we all know that genetics is one of those factors we have very little control over.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from stick500 wrote 2 years 22 weeks ago

I do almost all catch and release but I sometimes keep a few trout and catfish (trout are so easy to clean!).
I love catching big carp and I always let them go even though anyone around seems to argue with me that it's illegal to put them back- they're wrong! Sometimes people ask to have the carp when they see me bring 'em in, and of course I give them to them.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from buckeyeben wrote 2 years 22 weeks ago

i mostly practice catch and release but if i'm catchin a few ill keep them but thats mostly when im walleye or catfishing but most everything else i put back

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from fisher girl wrote 2 years 20 weeks ago

I usuually catch and release. If we catch a fish and decide to eat it we take it home. Other than that it is catch and release.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from 268bull wrote 2 years 19 weeks ago

I think catch and release is fine, if that's what your into and truly believe is the thing to do. However, if the person across the stream from you isn't, that's fine too. Mutual respect. Personally, I keep and eat what I catch.

0 Good Comment? | | Report

Post an Answer

bmxbiz-fs