Not a fan of combo edges personally. I prefer a plain edge on my knives which I can keep very sharp. I do have a fully serrated pocket knife (Cutco) that is very sharp, but only good for sawing action.
Since I typically buy knives with hunting/game processing in mind, I find a straight edge is best all around. I do have a couple of folders that include a small saw blade, which becomes handy in certain situations.
I prefer the stright edge, I have personally never seen a need arise for any of my knives to be partially serrated, and if the need did ever arise I would cut a sawtooth pattern into the spine of the knife.
I will be the contrary voice. I have a Ka-bar and a Gerber both which have partially serrated blades and I really like both of them. Excellent for cutting rope and such.
I prefer a straight edge for almost all purposes. I recently got a SOG revolver though with partial serration and a saw. It is the best field dressing knife I have owned.
I like a plain edge. Makes it easier to sharpen and just looks better then a combo knife IMO. But i have one or two combo knives since they are good for a work knife since you can cut bags of dirt open and then use the serrated part to cut small branches. It really just depends on the job.
I generally like a combo for a survival knife. Serrated edge on the backside for when I am short of a saw and a smooth edge when I'm just plain skinning an animal or something of the such.
Tough Call. Depends completely on the situation. Skinning is a straight edge, farm work is a combo, and as an athletic trainer we like to carry combos on the job.
I don't like a combo blade unless it's a longer blade. A Ka-bar is a perfect example of a knife that I like a little serrated section on. On pocket sized knives it just takes up too much of the straight edge that I use most of the time. You can cut rope pretty well with a straight bladed knife of the right steel that's sharpened well but skipped the final fine honing. Leaving those little microserrations in there can change the way it cuts significantly.
I like both. My EDC knife (a SOG Flash II) is a combo and while there are times I wish it was just a straight edge, I find something that the serrated portion helps with. So really I don't think I have a preference. My next knife wil probably be a straight edged Bench Made, but diversity is a good thing, especially for knives and guns.
I noticed some of you saying that a serrated edge is good for nothing but sawing, and while I agree that it is best suited for sawing, it is not entirely true. You can slice quite effectively with the larger indented parts of serrations. I'm not saying it is as good as a straight edge when it comes to slicing, but it works.
Depends on what I'm using it for. If it is just an everyday knife then I prefer a combo, but if I am using it to clean animals then I like to have one of each on hand as they can both come in handy. The reason why I don't like combos for cleaning is that a straight edge is way easier to sharpen.
It has:
> Pre-set carbides sharpen very dull edges quickly.
> Specialy shaped ceramic slot to finish edges and sharpen serrated blades.
> Tapered diamond rod for sharpening serrated and standard edges.
Not a fan of combo edges personally. I prefer a plain edge on my knives which I can keep very sharp. I do have a fully serrated pocket knife (Cutco) that is very sharp, but only good for sawing action.
Since I typically buy knives with hunting/game processing in mind, I find a straight edge is best all around. I do have a couple of folders that include a small saw blade, which becomes handy in certain situations.
I will be the contrary voice. I have a Ka-bar and a Gerber both which have partially serrated blades and I really like both of them. Excellent for cutting rope and such.
I like a plain edge. Makes it easier to sharpen and just looks better then a combo knife IMO. But i have one or two combo knives since they are good for a work knife since you can cut bags of dirt open and then use the serrated part to cut small branches. It really just depends on the job.
I generally like a combo for a survival knife. Serrated edge on the backside for when I am short of a saw and a smooth edge when I'm just plain skinning an animal or something of the such.
I prefer the stright edge, I have personally never seen a need arise for any of my knives to be partially serrated, and if the need did ever arise I would cut a sawtooth pattern into the spine of the knife.
I prefer a straight edge for almost all purposes. I recently got a SOG revolver though with partial serration and a saw. It is the best field dressing knife I have owned.
Tough Call. Depends completely on the situation. Skinning is a straight edge, farm work is a combo, and as an athletic trainer we like to carry combos on the job.
I don't like a combo blade unless it's a longer blade. A Ka-bar is a perfect example of a knife that I like a little serrated section on. On pocket sized knives it just takes up too much of the straight edge that I use most of the time. You can cut rope pretty well with a straight bladed knife of the right steel that's sharpened well but skipped the final fine honing. Leaving those little microserrations in there can change the way it cuts significantly.
I like both. My EDC knife (a SOG Flash II) is a combo and while there are times I wish it was just a straight edge, I find something that the serrated portion helps with. So really I don't think I have a preference. My next knife wil probably be a straight edged Bench Made, but diversity is a good thing, especially for knives and guns.
I noticed some of you saying that a serrated edge is good for nothing but sawing, and while I agree that it is best suited for sawing, it is not entirely true. You can slice quite effectively with the larger indented parts of serrations. I'm not saying it is as good as a straight edge when it comes to slicing, but it works.
Depends on what I'm using it for. If it is just an everyday knife then I prefer a combo, but if I am using it to clean animals then I like to have one of each on hand as they can both come in handy. The reason why I don't like combos for cleaning is that a straight edge is way easier to sharpen.
It has:
> Pre-set carbides sharpen very dull edges quickly.
> Specialy shaped ceramic slot to finish edges and sharpen serrated blades.
> Tapered diamond rod for sharpening serrated and standard edges.
Answers (32)
Not a fan of combo edges personally. I prefer a plain edge on my knives which I can keep very sharp. I do have a fully serrated pocket knife (Cutco) that is very sharp, but only good for sawing action.
Since I typically buy knives with hunting/game processing in mind, I find a straight edge is best all around. I do have a couple of folders that include a small saw blade, which becomes handy in certain situations.
Straight edge all the way.
I have a Cutco knife and love it -- you don't see these in many retail outlets though.
I prefer the stright edge, I have personally never seen a need arise for any of my knives to be partially serrated, and if the need did ever arise I would cut a sawtooth pattern into the spine of the knife.
I prefer a plain edge but have a couple of combos and like them almost as well. (Benchmade)
One more vote for the straight edge here. Like above, I've never come across a need for a serrated blade.
straight edge all the way.
I will be the contrary voice. I have a Ka-bar and a Gerber both which have partially serrated blades and I really like both of them. Excellent for cutting rope and such.
Straight edge for almost everything except my rafting/boating knife which has a combo edge as it needs to cut rope quickly when the time comes.
My knives are straight edged except for my SOG. My multitool has a serrated blade if I need it.
I prefer a straight edge for almost all purposes. I recently got a SOG revolver though with partial serration and a saw. It is the best field dressing knife I have owned.
Huntnow,
I have a SOG revolver as well which has a straight edge and a gut-hook on the knife and the saw. I agree that it cuts VERY well.
I like a plain edge. Makes it easier to sharpen and just looks better then a combo knife IMO. But i have one or two combo knives since they are good for a work knife since you can cut bags of dirt open and then use the serrated part to cut small branches. It really just depends on the job.
I generally like a combo for a survival knife. Serrated edge on the backside for when I am short of a saw and a smooth edge when I'm just plain skinning an animal or something of the such.
I prefer the plain edge, except on a steak knife.
Tough Call. Depends completely on the situation. Skinning is a straight edge, farm work is a combo, and as an athletic trainer we like to carry combos on the job.
Plain for tending to game animals and the kitchen but combo around horses in case I need to cust a rope with one quick clean swipe.
That's "cut" a rope
Ish,
No problem. I have "cussed" a few ropes around horses myself
Plain and sharp is my preference for hunting knives. I dress and cut up a lot more deer and antelope type things than loaves of bread.
Happy: There is nothing more delightful than a very intelligent man with a great sense of humor. Frankly I don't see that combination often.
Combo blade is my call, sharp enough to slice paper and cut rope.
I don't like a combo blade unless it's a longer blade. A Ka-bar is a perfect example of a knife that I like a little serrated section on. On pocket sized knives it just takes up too much of the straight edge that I use most of the time. You can cut rope pretty well with a straight bladed knife of the right steel that's sharpened well but skipped the final fine honing. Leaving those little microserrations in there can change the way it cuts significantly.
I like both. My EDC knife (a SOG Flash II) is a combo and while there are times I wish it was just a straight edge, I find something that the serrated portion helps with. So really I don't think I have a preference. My next knife wil probably be a straight edged Bench Made, but diversity is a good thing, especially for knives and guns.
for guting deer a straight blade works the best by far, but for everyday carrying, i use a combination
I noticed some of you saying that a serrated edge is good for nothing but sawing, and while I agree that it is best suited for sawing, it is not entirely true. You can slice quite effectively with the larger indented parts of serrations. I'm not saying it is as good as a straight edge when it comes to slicing, but it works.
Straight edge. I just never warmed up to serrated.
depends on what i use the knife for for camping or survival i like a combo
Depends on what I'm using it for. If it is just an everyday knife then I prefer a combo, but if I am using it to clean animals then I like to have one of each on hand as they can both come in handy. The reason why I don't like combos for cleaning is that a straight edge is way easier to sharpen.
Plain edge
A Smith's PP1 Pocket Pal Multifunction Sharpener is a handy tool for sharpening in the field. I keep one in my field kit.
http://www.amazon.com/Smiths-PP1-Pocket-Multifunction-Sharpener/dp/B000O...
It has:
> Pre-set carbides sharpen very dull edges quickly.
> Specialy shaped ceramic slot to finish edges and sharpen serrated blades.
> Tapered diamond rod for sharpening serrated and standard edges.
Post an Answer
Not a fan of combo edges personally. I prefer a plain edge on my knives which I can keep very sharp. I do have a fully serrated pocket knife (Cutco) that is very sharp, but only good for sawing action.
Since I typically buy knives with hunting/game processing in mind, I find a straight edge is best all around. I do have a couple of folders that include a small saw blade, which becomes handy in certain situations.
I prefer a plain edge but have a couple of combos and like them almost as well. (Benchmade)
Straight edge all the way.
I have a Cutco knife and love it -- you don't see these in many retail outlets though.
I will be the contrary voice. I have a Ka-bar and a Gerber both which have partially serrated blades and I really like both of them. Excellent for cutting rope and such.
My knives are straight edged except for my SOG. My multitool has a serrated blade if I need it.
Huntnow,
I have a SOG revolver as well which has a straight edge and a gut-hook on the knife and the saw. I agree that it cuts VERY well.
I like a plain edge. Makes it easier to sharpen and just looks better then a combo knife IMO. But i have one or two combo knives since they are good for a work knife since you can cut bags of dirt open and then use the serrated part to cut small branches. It really just depends on the job.
I generally like a combo for a survival knife. Serrated edge on the backside for when I am short of a saw and a smooth edge when I'm just plain skinning an animal or something of the such.
I prefer the plain edge, except on a steak knife.
Combo blade is my call, sharp enough to slice paper and cut rope.
I prefer the stright edge, I have personally never seen a need arise for any of my knives to be partially serrated, and if the need did ever arise I would cut a sawtooth pattern into the spine of the knife.
One more vote for the straight edge here. Like above, I've never come across a need for a serrated blade.
straight edge all the way.
Straight edge for almost everything except my rafting/boating knife which has a combo edge as it needs to cut rope quickly when the time comes.
I prefer a straight edge for almost all purposes. I recently got a SOG revolver though with partial serration and a saw. It is the best field dressing knife I have owned.
Tough Call. Depends completely on the situation. Skinning is a straight edge, farm work is a combo, and as an athletic trainer we like to carry combos on the job.
Plain for tending to game animals and the kitchen but combo around horses in case I need to cust a rope with one quick clean swipe.
That's "cut" a rope
Ish,
No problem. I have "cussed" a few ropes around horses myself
Plain and sharp is my preference for hunting knives. I dress and cut up a lot more deer and antelope type things than loaves of bread.
Happy: There is nothing more delightful than a very intelligent man with a great sense of humor. Frankly I don't see that combination often.
I don't like a combo blade unless it's a longer blade. A Ka-bar is a perfect example of a knife that I like a little serrated section on. On pocket sized knives it just takes up too much of the straight edge that I use most of the time. You can cut rope pretty well with a straight bladed knife of the right steel that's sharpened well but skipped the final fine honing. Leaving those little microserrations in there can change the way it cuts significantly.
I like both. My EDC knife (a SOG Flash II) is a combo and while there are times I wish it was just a straight edge, I find something that the serrated portion helps with. So really I don't think I have a preference. My next knife wil probably be a straight edged Bench Made, but diversity is a good thing, especially for knives and guns.
for guting deer a straight blade works the best by far, but for everyday carrying, i use a combination
I noticed some of you saying that a serrated edge is good for nothing but sawing, and while I agree that it is best suited for sawing, it is not entirely true. You can slice quite effectively with the larger indented parts of serrations. I'm not saying it is as good as a straight edge when it comes to slicing, but it works.
Straight edge. I just never warmed up to serrated.
depends on what i use the knife for for camping or survival i like a combo
Depends on what I'm using it for. If it is just an everyday knife then I prefer a combo, but if I am using it to clean animals then I like to have one of each on hand as they can both come in handy. The reason why I don't like combos for cleaning is that a straight edge is way easier to sharpen.
Plain edge
A Smith's PP1 Pocket Pal Multifunction Sharpener is a handy tool for sharpening in the field. I keep one in my field kit.
http://www.amazon.com/Smiths-PP1-Pocket-Multifunction-Sharpener/dp/B000O...
It has:
> Pre-set carbides sharpen very dull edges quickly.
> Specialy shaped ceramic slot to finish edges and sharpen serrated blades.
> Tapered diamond rod for sharpening serrated and standard edges.
Post an Answer