i'd go with a pump and im an 870 man myself, i not sure they make them (camo rifled barrels) but you could get one camo dipped pretty cheap if u really want one though.

Since you want to use it for everything, I would go 870.

I shoot an 870 too and am very happy with it. I used to shoot a Rem 1100 and a Browning and got the 870 for real rough hunting. I liked it so much, I use it all the time and got rid of the others. Camo barrels are hard to find for an 870 but may exist. I didn't see any in obvious places either but you can get it camoed reasonably if necessary. My gun is a blued Wingmaster with nice wood and I wrap it with camo tape if the game cares. I use it natural for pheasant, quail, and blind hunting. I use the 3" chamber because that is the largest shell I ever intend to shoot. Just get the Rem Choke. I use my regular barrel for slug hunting. It is accurate enough to bag deer within a hundred yards.

There is a lot of good information above. This is coming from someone who has owned and shot an 870. I just bought a brand-new Benelli Nova, based on 50 years of bird-hunting experience. They are in a class by themselves. They are light. It is extremely easy to work the action. They work every time. There was really not a realistic option.

I've owned an 870 and an 11-87, both are very good. I have had few probems with the 11-87 and noen with the 870. From a dependability standpoint I suggest a pimp shot gun as they have fewer parts to fail. The pump is also easier to take apart and clean.