I shoot vanes....I'll probably catch hell for this but when I got started bow hunting the guy that helped me a lot shot vanes and he said that while vanes don't fly as good as feathers they are better than feathers if they get wet so I started shooting vanes and have always been pleased....

Vanes. I have cut and fletched many a turkey wing just for a nostalgic experience but I use plastic vanes for hunting. The feathers wear out too fast while practicing and require too much attention. The feathers sure look nice though.

Vanes are best.

Feathers are lighter, thicker, look better and have a more stabilizing effect but are more fragile. Vanes are quieter and more durable but less stabil. Ultimately you should use what works best for your needs. I use blazer vanes they work great with Rage 2 blade broadheads.

Vanes, they take more abuse.

Feathers are more forgiving if damaged

Vanes if damaged will not stabilize the arrow. Great for wet weather.

I use both depending on weather conditions.