Please Sign In

Please enter a valid username and password
  • Log in with Facebook
» Not a member? Take a moment to register
» Forgot Username or Password

Why Register?
Signing up could earn you gear (click here to learn how)! It also keeps offensive content off our site.

AnswersASK YOUR QUESTION

Answers

Q:
Would you recommend the Ka-bar U.S.M.C. fight knife for a survival knife?

Question by Dallas A. McWhorter. Uploaded on February 19, 2013

Answers (14)

Top Rated
All Answers
from 99explorer wrote 16 weeks 3 days ago

Affirmative, but I would prefer the Gerber Mark II with its double-edged spear-point, wasp-waisted blade with serrations.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from Edward J. Palumbo wrote 16 weeks 3 days ago

I was issued a Kabar, and I acknowledge it's a good utilitarian design that has withstood the test of time, but as a personal knife I would choose a Cold Steel Counter Tac I or SRK, a CRKT Ultima, a Gerber LMF II or the Gerber Mark II that 99 recommended, a version of which was in great demand during the Viet Nam years.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from ITHACASXS wrote 16 weeks 3 days ago

Edward Palumbo, your last name is a very common one in Buffalo NY (lots of Italians and Sicilans here). In fact, a Anthony Palumbo from Buffalo was killed in South VietNam in 1968. Within a few hours of his neighborhood finding out, the whole street and 'hood was flying the Flag for their fallen son and his grieving family.I just thought I'd pass that along.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from Treestand wrote 16 weeks 3 days ago

Any knife is better then NO-knife at all! The Kabar is good,But there is better out-there as 99& Ed.P stated! my pick is Gerbar Mark II,With a Case xx single blade in my pocket.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from PigHunter wrote 16 weeks 3 days ago

I've carried the Gerber Mark I when hunting and was not pleased with having to use a double edged blade for gutting and skinning tasks. I recomend staying away from any such knives for field use. My favorite 'survival' knife is the Cold Steel Bushman. Killed a large boar with one last September. Had the Bushman mounted on my hiking stick as a thrusting spear.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from FirstBubba wrote 16 weeks 3 days ago

The Ka-Bar needs to be a part of your outfit, just not the only cutting implement.
I prefer carbon steel over the hard stainless. Easier to sharpen.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from DesertWalker wrote 16 weeks 3 days ago

more than anything I have found that I never need just one knife. I live by the motto that my father gave me, "you can NEVER have to many knives or guns." fallowing this I normaly carry around three for different purposes. although my brother will sware by his KABAR, he will tell me "I trusted this to save my life in the war I can trust it to save my life anywere." as the gentlemen above have stated there are alot of good knives and in some opions could be even better than the KABAR. comes down to what you find to work best for you.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from NM wrote 16 weeks 3 days ago

The Gerber has had a reputation of breaking.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from AAM wrote 16 weeks 3 days ago

Yeah gerber also have a reputation of being very hard to resharpen, I should know I have a profile and dont even try to use it anymore.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Edward J. Palumbo wrote 16 weeks 3 days ago

ITHACASXS,
I was born and raised on the Lower East Side in Manhattan (NYC) and my grandparents immigrated through Ellis Island around 1908-1910. I was in RVN with 1st Marine Division in 1966-67 and, as I remember, another Palumbo (Nick) from Manhattan was KIA at much the same time. There was some confusion and, when I returned, a neighbor commented, "I heard you were killed." I suggested there may have been some error. I am sorry to learn of Anthony (no relation) but I have met a few with the same last name in my travels.

PigHunter,
I understandably would not recommend a double-edged dagger, dirk or boot knife for skinning. It was my presupposition or error when I saw "survival knife" in the question that a combat knife was part of the thought process, and I should have been thinking in terms of hunting and camping.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from Bioguy01 wrote 16 weeks 2 days ago

Yes

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from ITHACASXS wrote 16 weeks 2 days ago

Mr. Palumbo, thanks for responding. Since describing your background, may I recommend a neat book that you might find interesting, it's from a fellow New Yorker(Brooklyn, really), Richard Gambino, he was a professor at Queens College it's called: ''Blood of my Blood''. As a grandson of immigrants as well, it kind of explained for me some of the old school quirks I was raised with.It was written in the '70's.Last but not least, thank you for serving during such a difficult time.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Edward J. Palumbo wrote 16 weeks 1 day ago

ITHACASXS,
Thank you for the book recommendation. I read a steady progression of books, fiction and nonfiction, history, mystery and tongue-in-cheek humor. I will seek that one out.
As for my service, I was one of a great many but it was my privilege to operate with a number of idealistic delinquents, several of whom are still like my brothers to this day, and I value those relationships highly.
Ed

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from barnhllo wrote 13 weeks 2 days ago

I just don't like the term "survival knife"...Any knife that you regularly carry, for whatever purpose, becomes a survival knife in a genuine emergency. Carry a three-blade stockman in your pocket and either a functional fixed blade or a 5" (closed) folder on your belt, and you will be prepared. Forget the Rambo or USMC knives; you don't need them.

0 Good Comment? | | Report

Post an Answer

from 99explorer wrote 16 weeks 3 days ago

Affirmative, but I would prefer the Gerber Mark II with its double-edged spear-point, wasp-waisted blade with serrations.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from Edward J. Palumbo wrote 16 weeks 3 days ago

I was issued a Kabar, and I acknowledge it's a good utilitarian design that has withstood the test of time, but as a personal knife I would choose a Cold Steel Counter Tac I or SRK, a CRKT Ultima, a Gerber LMF II or the Gerber Mark II that 99 recommended, a version of which was in great demand during the Viet Nam years.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from ITHACASXS wrote 16 weeks 3 days ago

Edward Palumbo, your last name is a very common one in Buffalo NY (lots of Italians and Sicilans here). In fact, a Anthony Palumbo from Buffalo was killed in South VietNam in 1968. Within a few hours of his neighborhood finding out, the whole street and 'hood was flying the Flag for their fallen son and his grieving family.I just thought I'd pass that along.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from Treestand wrote 16 weeks 3 days ago

Any knife is better then NO-knife at all! The Kabar is good,But there is better out-there as 99& Ed.P stated! my pick is Gerbar Mark II,With a Case xx single blade in my pocket.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from PigHunter wrote 16 weeks 3 days ago

I've carried the Gerber Mark I when hunting and was not pleased with having to use a double edged blade for gutting and skinning tasks. I recomend staying away from any such knives for field use. My favorite 'survival' knife is the Cold Steel Bushman. Killed a large boar with one last September. Had the Bushman mounted on my hiking stick as a thrusting spear.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from FirstBubba wrote 16 weeks 3 days ago

The Ka-Bar needs to be a part of your outfit, just not the only cutting implement.
I prefer carbon steel over the hard stainless. Easier to sharpen.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from Edward J. Palumbo wrote 16 weeks 3 days ago

ITHACASXS,
I was born and raised on the Lower East Side in Manhattan (NYC) and my grandparents immigrated through Ellis Island around 1908-1910. I was in RVN with 1st Marine Division in 1966-67 and, as I remember, another Palumbo (Nick) from Manhattan was KIA at much the same time. There was some confusion and, when I returned, a neighbor commented, "I heard you were killed." I suggested there may have been some error. I am sorry to learn of Anthony (no relation) but I have met a few with the same last name in my travels.

PigHunter,
I understandably would not recommend a double-edged dagger, dirk or boot knife for skinning. It was my presupposition or error when I saw "survival knife" in the question that a combat knife was part of the thought process, and I should have been thinking in terms of hunting and camping.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from DesertWalker wrote 16 weeks 3 days ago

more than anything I have found that I never need just one knife. I live by the motto that my father gave me, "you can NEVER have to many knives or guns." fallowing this I normaly carry around three for different purposes. although my brother will sware by his KABAR, he will tell me "I trusted this to save my life in the war I can trust it to save my life anywere." as the gentlemen above have stated there are alot of good knives and in some opions could be even better than the KABAR. comes down to what you find to work best for you.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from Edward J. Palumbo wrote 16 weeks 1 day ago

ITHACASXS,
Thank you for the book recommendation. I read a steady progression of books, fiction and nonfiction, history, mystery and tongue-in-cheek humor. I will seek that one out.
As for my service, I was one of a great many but it was my privilege to operate with a number of idealistic delinquents, several of whom are still like my brothers to this day, and I value those relationships highly.
Ed

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from NM wrote 16 weeks 3 days ago

The Gerber has had a reputation of breaking.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from AAM wrote 16 weeks 3 days ago

Yeah gerber also have a reputation of being very hard to resharpen, I should know I have a profile and dont even try to use it anymore.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Bioguy01 wrote 16 weeks 2 days ago

Yes

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from ITHACASXS wrote 16 weeks 2 days ago

Mr. Palumbo, thanks for responding. Since describing your background, may I recommend a neat book that you might find interesting, it's from a fellow New Yorker(Brooklyn, really), Richard Gambino, he was a professor at Queens College it's called: ''Blood of my Blood''. As a grandson of immigrants as well, it kind of explained for me some of the old school quirks I was raised with.It was written in the '70's.Last but not least, thank you for serving during such a difficult time.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from barnhllo wrote 13 weeks 2 days ago

I just don't like the term "survival knife"...Any knife that you regularly carry, for whatever purpose, becomes a survival knife in a genuine emergency. Carry a three-blade stockman in your pocket and either a functional fixed blade or a 5" (closed) folder on your belt, and you will be prepared. Forget the Rambo or USMC knives; you don't need them.

0 Good Comment? | | Report

Post an Answer