Jeep. I've driven both. If you jack up a Hummer your asking to bust your drive train or at least a joint. I not sure if it was the M38A1 but the military Jeeps I drove in the early 80's were badass.

I remember one day a guy asked how I got up into my treestands. They were always so high. I'd just glance over to my Jeep.

If the Hummer is an H-2, it's not even close--I'll take the jeep. The H-2 is just an overpriced, oversized SUV. If we're talking about the military version of the Hummer, the choice isn't so easy. I'd probably still take the jeep cause I could work on it. When they took carburators out & put computers in, they might as well have taken the hood release off too. The 53 Jeep gets my vote.

jeep because i would not be scared to beat it up because i know it can take it

Hummers always make me wonder what a fella is trying to compensate for... the jeep is the original git-er-done vehicle. No substitutions, exchanges, or refunds...

Jeep 100%, especially if the Hummer was lifted. They perform fine as stock trucks. There are many trails that are simply too wide for a Hummer to get down that a Jeep can do with ease. Though Jeeps are more likely to roll, with the right precaution I'd take a Jeep any day.

No dought the jeep.

don't have any experience with the jeep I'm sure they're great. But an old Scout I'd prefer any day over almost anything.

Back in '72 I tore the 4x4 out of my jeep messing around in the hills of N. Carolina (Fort Bragg). I limped it back to the motor pool and left it there. Three days later I went to the CO and complained that I saw someone using my jeep for mail call and now it's all messed up. Thank God he believed me.
If I had that old jeep today where could I find parts to fix it?
Just reminiscing about the old days.

More "cumfy" in the hummer, but the "Willie" will get you there and back, EVERY TIME !

The jeep hands down. That short wheel base and smaller size let you get between the trees and the rocks and over just about anything. There aren't many places you can't go with a good old Army jeep from the '40s.

Willys jeep over hummer any day, Willys jeeps take much smaller trails and is soo much lighter and terra friendly.I cut my teeth on a willys jeep, was the first vehicle (prolly a bad thing)I learned to drive. That thing would go anywhere, I once drove off into a deep hole,the fan splashed water onto the ingnition and killed it. I tied my bandana from a fan blade to the water hose to keep the engine dry till I could back out, what memories!! Never figured out why my dad sold that thing or why I wasnt the giving the chance to buy.