
Photo by Field & Stream Online Editors
They say you can't go back, that the past is better served by a selective memory than by second sight. That pond where you once fished for bluegills will be paved over by now; the woodcock covert in the birch bottom, drained and subdivided for tract homes. I wondered about this as the road bent along Tom Creek in Idaho's Centennial Mountains. It had been 20 years since I had last seen it. Not a remarkable piece of water, it was just another in a series of short, spring-fed creeks that plunged from the Continental Divide through alpine fir forest. I had shot my second elk on the shoulder of the mountain above, and the water that poured from my cupped hands when I slaked my thirst after a hard day's hunting was as sweet as nectar.
"So this is what I was named for," my son said, shaking his head sadly as we walked to the bank. "A creek."
"No, I was just kidding. But it's not just any creek, Tom. It's the best water on God's green earth."
"You aren't really going to drink from it?" he said, unbelieving.
"Why not?"
But of course I knew why not. On the surface of the creek, nothing may have changed. The problem was in the current underneath, in the form of protozoan cysts spread by animal (including human) droppings that, when swallowed, result in a serious intestinal disorder: giardiasis, otherwise known as hiker's diarrhea, backpacker's curse, beaver fever.
I remembered encountering a young man on the path up Maine's Mount Katahdin. He'd hiked almost the entire length of the Appalachian Trail, some 2,500 miles, only to be laid low by giardiasis 2 miles from the summit. He said he was afraid to climb above timberline, where he would have to drop his pants in full view of passersby if the bug got the better of him. And I recalled my friend, fisheries biologist Fred Nelson, who, after falling ill following a hike to high-altitude lakes, had walked around town for three days with a length of string taped to his cheek, the other end of which he had swallowed and was working its convoluted way through his upper intestine. When his doctor pulled the string up out of his mouth (think about that), the microscopic organisms clinging to the lower end confirmed what his gut had already told him. He, too, had giardiasis.
The Giardia lamblia cyst is so widespread that one study of 10,000 samples from streams across North America, including Alaska, could not find a single source that was uncontaminated. One Wilderness Society staffer contracted giardiasis after drinking water running off a glacier. Possibly a marmot or a mouse had defecated on the glacier farther up.
It's not just Giardia that can bring a careless hunter or hiker to a compromising position. The Cryptosporidium cyst is also spread by animal feces. Symptoms sound familiar notes to anyone who has suffered from giardiasis: abdominal cramps, bloating, fatigue, flatulence, diarrhea, and weight loss, with the bonus of a low-grade fever. Bacteria, including E. coli and salmonella, and viruses that carry diseases such as polio and hepatitis A are also prevalent in the earth's surface waters, although they pose greater risks for sportsmen who are traveling abroad, or who drink from still waters near popular hiking trails or in agricultural areas, than they do for deer trackers in Vermont or Alberta sheep hunters.
The bottom line is that all water must be treated before it can be safely drunk or used for cooking or washing dishes in camp. Options include boiling, chemical halogens, filtration, and ultraviolet radiation.
Boiling. The surest way to eliminate all dangerous microorganisms. Contrary to popular belief, you don't need to boil water for 10 minutes for disinfection. Just bringing water to a boil, even at the lower boiling point of high elevation, will do the trick. The flat taste can be improved by pouring the water between contaainers.
Chemicals. Iodine crystals (Polar Pure) and iodine tablets (Potable Aqua) both effectively eliminate bacteria, viruses, and the Giardia cyst; however, Cryptosporidium is resistant to chemical halogens like iodine, which may be a problem in some areas.
The disagreeable taste these treatments leave behind can be eliminated with neutralizing tablets or vitamin C, but long exposure to iodine-treated water can cause side effects. Limit its use to trips lasting only a few days. Iodine should not be used by pregnant women or anyone who suffers from a thyroid condition. Instead, they can use chlorine dioxide droplets (Aquamira), which eliminate bacteria. (McNett Corp., the manufacturer, is currently in the process of registering Aquamira as a purifier as well.)
Filters. These strain all sources of contamination except viruses and the smallest bacterias. Options include bottle filters (scoop water into the bottle and squeeze it into your mouth), pump filters (drop the intake hose into the stream and pump the handle to draw it through the filter cartridge into your water bottle), and gravity-fed filters (fill a reservoir with water and allow gravity to trickle the water through the filter into a receptacle). To effectively trap Giardia and Cryptosporidium cysts, the pore size of the filter must be 1 micron or less in diameter. Most pumps sold as "microfilters" will do the job, but read the fine print.
Lisa Lange, a microbiologist who tests filter systems for several companies, including MSR and SweetWater, advises that for complete purification, iodine or chlorine dioxide should be added to water after it is pumped through a filter. She is skeptical of so-called water purifiers that incorporate positively charged filters or iodine cartridges into a filter system to eliminate viruses, saying, "There are just too many variables, and more quality-control testing needs to be done."
However, two manufacturers claim their purifiers have passed rigorous EPA standards: First Need (www.first-need.com) and Exstream (see "What's Your Drink?" on the previous page). These purifiers provide one-step options that will probably eliminate most of the contaminants that hikers are likely to encounter within U.S. and Canadian borders. I highly recommend the Exstream Mackenzie for hunters and anglers for its light weight and simplicity of design.
n Ultraviolet radiation. These devices are the new kids on the block-and at $200, the most expensive. Ultraviolet radiation zaps all sources of contamination, though a review of one early model cites reliability problems. I'd wait until the bugs have been worked out and the prices come down.
A Few Tips
Before disinfecting murky water, decant it for an hour or so by letting the sediment settle to the bottom of a container. If you can't wait that long, drop a pinch of alum (sold as pickling powder in grocery stores) into your water bucket and swirl it around. Suspended particles, including algae, will clump together and can be scooped out. White campfire ashes work almost as well.
Many filter pumps come with a pre-filter with a large mesh size (the fine pores of a microfilter will clog if you attempt to force sedimented water through them). Take care not to spill untreated water onto water-bottle lids or dishes. Last, and most important, always carry either chlorine dioxide drops or iodine tablets as a backup in case a filter pump clogs or breaks down, and for use in addition to filters for water that may harbor viruses.
Post a Comment
Post a Comment