By Kirk Deeter
I can't trick you folks, can I? Yes, the answer is Mayaguana, Bahamas. You all are pretty dialed in... I'll have to up my game.
On this trip, I actually had a chance to hit three different islands--Crooked Island, Acklin's Island, and Mayaguana-- to sample the fishing. The photo was from Mayaguana. TimberDoodle, you were the name out of the hat, so hit me at firstname.lastname@example.org, and we'll get you some flies.