Please Sign In

Please enter a valid username and password
  • Log in with Facebook
» Not a member? Take a moment to register
» Forgot Username or Password

Why Register?
Signing up could earn you gear (click here to learn how)! It also keeps offensive content off our site.

Fessing Up About Product Review Whiffs

Recent Comments

Categories

Recent Posts

Archives

Syndicate

Google Reader or Homepage
Add to My Yahoo!
Add to My AOL

FlyTalk
in your Inbox

Enter your email address to get our new post everyday.

July 18, 2012

Fessing Up About Product Review Whiffs

By Kirk Deeter

As many of you know, we are now knee-deep in the trade show season; when new products for 2013 are being unveiled at breakneck speeds and the hype machine is running full throttle. I admit to having been made a sucker by that hype machine in the past. The benefit of hindsight and many months of actually fishing with some of these products has helped me realize that, in some cases, I probably drank a little too much PR Kool-Aid. So in the interest of clearing my own conscience (before I start gulping the next batch), I want to come clean on some cases where I whiffed.

Sharkskin Fly Lines
I was completely amped about 3M’s Sharkskin at a time when, even out of the gate, a good percentage of my angler friends weren’t believers. I forgave the annoying sound (like fingernails on a chalkboard with every stroke of the rod) because I believed the theory that bumpy surfaces on a line's coating enhanced floating and shooting performance. But the 5-weight line I had broke 20 feet from the tip for no good reason after a few months, and the 8-weight grabbed so much grit and grime that the last 30 feet won’t float anymore, despite my best efforts to clean it. And for $100 (for a line?!), an angler should expect better. No wonder Tenkara fishing is gaining in popularity.

Korkers Svelte Wading Soles
I like Korkers boots a lot, and I love the BOA laces. I’m one of the few guys in my fishing circle who hasn’t left an interchangeable sole on a riverbank somewhere. I've tried two generations of Svelte, and wished very hard that it would be a solid alternative to felt. One lasted a month, and the other lasted about two weeks longer before they looked like tattered, stringy Brillo pads hanging off my boots.

Cloudveil Waders
Actually, I have no problem with any of the Cloudveil stuff I’ve worn. I’m still wearing much of it. It’s comfortable, durable and functional. But the company was sold twice (that I remember) and now fly fishing isn’t even an afterthought on the corporate radar. That’s a shame because the original owners were real anglers and they made good stuff. There was promise there, but now it’s gone.

Moffitt Angling System
I’m going to take a little bit of a pass here and say that I was never convinced on the premise that hooking fish in the sides of their faces was a kinder, gentler approach to catch-and-release angling. But Romano fell for it. At least a little. Now that fad is gone. I guess we can chalk that one up to consumer buying habits being the ultimate judge and jury. Good for you.

Polarized Sunglasses with Interchangeable Lenses
They don’t work. The lenses fall out. They get scratched. You think you’re scoring a two-for-one or three-for-one deal, but trust me, find one pair of lenses with a tint you like and stick with them. The gimmicks don’t last.

But honesty does. And I promise to shoot as straight as I can with the stuff I see in the coming weeks. You should expect nothing less.

 

Comments (20)

Top Rated
All Comments
from ckRich wrote 47 weeks 3 days ago

Feel better now?

Don't worry, it happens to everyone. No matter how much you try to resist the Kool-Aid, something is bound to come along and be just what you were hoping for. At least for a while.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Sayfu wrote 47 weeks 3 days ago

You softened the blow way too much...still way too much cool-aid. the felt movement was a big bowel movement. Cost the industry money, and gained nothing.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from buckhunter wrote 47 weeks 3 days ago

Felt is banned in Maryland and I fish Maryland often. Each time out I wear a different boot. The best sole I have found yet is the bottom of an old pair of New Balance sneakers. If the sneakers were high-tops, they would be perfect.

Fished Florida for a week last summer with a matched pair of Sage 9wts. One with Sharkskin, one without. The difference was very noticeable in favor of Sharkskin. Liked it so well I loaded my bass rod with it. Other than the finger burn, have had no problems.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Sayfu wrote 47 weeks 3 days ago

Once the water gets slightly above 50 degrees, I fish in shorts, and Clogs....but found a problem with the clogs with holes in them yesterday. I waded the perimeter of a nearby lake. (They do have Clogs without the holes). I didn't wade above my ankles, but when I got home, and kicked off my Clogs, the top of my foot itched. I looked down, and it looked like a piece of bark was on the top of my foot. I tried to kick it off, and could not...reached down, and had to pull fairly hard to get this big, fat, several inches long leech of the top of my foot. And why he was so fat?..from my blood. There was a blood hole in my foot, and blood ran everywhere. Took me some time, and washings to stop the blood flow. Shows to go you that all of those leeches in lakes do not just feast on detritus vegitation like you read in print.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from buckhunter wrote 47 weeks 3 days ago

Sayfu, Did you release the leech unharmed?

+5 Good Comment? | | Report
from Sayfu wrote 47 weeks 3 days ago

I flushed the critter, but told my wife I put it in her water cup in the BR, and saved it.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Sayfu wrote 47 weeks 3 days ago

Now that you mentioned it, I feel bad about flushing the critter. He feels like blood kin: one of my offsprings.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from buckhunter wrote 47 weeks 2 days ago

Deet, You have had a few whiffs but let us not dwell on them. If we had purchased Croc stock when you pointed out the price was down, we would have made some serious money. You have to admit,(which is hard for this Buckeye to do) you are very well tuned to the market.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from nehunter92 wrote 47 weeks 2 days ago

I know the feeling. Sometimes when you first see or try out a product, you think it is possibly the single greates creation in you have ever laid eyes upon. It seemingly fufills all your hopes and dreams that you poured into your search for whatever it was you needed, or just plain wanted. Then however, comes that cruel slap of reality. A fatal flaw is revealed when you take the product and begin to use it regularly. All of those dreams come crashing down. The same thing just happened to me with a pair of boots I bought last year. They were waterproof with 800 grams of thinsulate, whatever the heck that means. When I first started using them they were all I could ever ask for. They kept my feet warm enough when sitting still, but actually breathed to a certain degree when on the move. Thus they became my deer scouting and turkey hunting boots. Then the flaw..they lasted for about a year. Within a short time the sole began seperating from the boot, and durability began to fade in general. A hole soon appeared, and my feet that were once invincible to swamp, stream, and snow, got wet instantly.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from fflutterffly wrote 47 weeks 2 days ago

It's difficult being mortal.
I have to rely on critics reviews since I don't receive all the fly bling to try. And now I'll trust a review that gives both the truthful pro's and con's of a product, as I expect when honesty is paramount. Cloudvail early generation waders were a WoW and Sharkskin is noisy. Sages XP (one of my favs) was replaced by a superior Z-axis, The ONE will be replaced by the Great! It goes on and on and on. Marketing. But, some of these innovations are wonderful and I would expect you both to give us your best. Appreciate your candor.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from Sayfu wrote 47 weeks 2 days ago

Why won't someone show candor about the biggie...felts!?? Broken legs, dunkins at the least from the inferior replacements, broken profits at the mfger, and retail level, and no positive results. And the mfger of the replacement soles gave it up, and went back to felts!!

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Tom-Tom wrote 47 weeks 2 days ago

So what is your latest winning stock market pick, Kirk? Missed your tip about Croc.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Hornd wrote 47 weeks 1 day ago

Cabelas stock is hotter than Kate Uptons GQ Cover Shoot!

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Sayfu wrote 47 weeks 1 day ago

Hornd...Twer I, and I am an investor, I'd be putting money into a good dividend bearing stock like a utility stock..the flight is to dividend stocks for protection in this terrible economy. Consumer spending is DOWN...25,000,000 folks out of work, and about as many on food stamps doesn't make Cabelas a very attractive stock.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from bigz24bigbass wrote 46 weeks 5 days ago

Sounds similar to the hype I have at the beginning of the NFL season after a tall glass of training camp kool-aid. Lets go JETS!

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Sayfu wrote 46 weeks 5 days ago

Jet's? You had better go "T-boning" and give up on Sanchez.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Trapper Vic wrote 46 weeks 5 days ago

Should of saved the leach for you next walleye trip. Good bait!

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from Sayfu wrote 46 weeks 4 days ago

trapper... My brother is a charter boat skipper on Lake Erie. I was on his charter using a black leach fly catching small mouth bass. I fished off the front deck of his boat and out of the way of his clients. His clients brought big "flats" of black leaches, and soft shelled craws aboard. And the leaches were plenty big.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Trapper Vic wrote 46 weeks 1 day ago

Sayfu - Whats is charter name I'm looking for a good captain to hook up for next spring.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Merkincrab wrote 45 weeks 6 days ago

Actually, I'm still loving my Sharkskin lines: 5, 6, 8 and 10-wt. They perform great and are durable. They don't clean up as well, but still float fine.

0 Good Comment? | | Report

Post a Comment

from buckhunter wrote 47 weeks 3 days ago

Sayfu, Did you release the leech unharmed?

+5 Good Comment? | | Report
from nehunter92 wrote 47 weeks 2 days ago

I know the feeling. Sometimes when you first see or try out a product, you think it is possibly the single greates creation in you have ever laid eyes upon. It seemingly fufills all your hopes and dreams that you poured into your search for whatever it was you needed, or just plain wanted. Then however, comes that cruel slap of reality. A fatal flaw is revealed when you take the product and begin to use it regularly. All of those dreams come crashing down. The same thing just happened to me with a pair of boots I bought last year. They were waterproof with 800 grams of thinsulate, whatever the heck that means. When I first started using them they were all I could ever ask for. They kept my feet warm enough when sitting still, but actually breathed to a certain degree when on the move. Thus they became my deer scouting and turkey hunting boots. Then the flaw..they lasted for about a year. Within a short time the sole began seperating from the boot, and durability began to fade in general. A hole soon appeared, and my feet that were once invincible to swamp, stream, and snow, got wet instantly.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from fflutterffly wrote 47 weeks 2 days ago

It's difficult being mortal.
I have to rely on critics reviews since I don't receive all the fly bling to try. And now I'll trust a review that gives both the truthful pro's and con's of a product, as I expect when honesty is paramount. Cloudvail early generation waders were a WoW and Sharkskin is noisy. Sages XP (one of my favs) was replaced by a superior Z-axis, The ONE will be replaced by the Great! It goes on and on and on. Marketing. But, some of these innovations are wonderful and I would expect you both to give us your best. Appreciate your candor.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from Trapper Vic wrote 46 weeks 5 days ago

Should of saved the leach for you next walleye trip. Good bait!

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from ckRich wrote 47 weeks 3 days ago

Feel better now?

Don't worry, it happens to everyone. No matter how much you try to resist the Kool-Aid, something is bound to come along and be just what you were hoping for. At least for a while.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Sayfu wrote 47 weeks 3 days ago

You softened the blow way too much...still way too much cool-aid. the felt movement was a big bowel movement. Cost the industry money, and gained nothing.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from buckhunter wrote 47 weeks 3 days ago

Felt is banned in Maryland and I fish Maryland often. Each time out I wear a different boot. The best sole I have found yet is the bottom of an old pair of New Balance sneakers. If the sneakers were high-tops, they would be perfect.

Fished Florida for a week last summer with a matched pair of Sage 9wts. One with Sharkskin, one without. The difference was very noticeable in favor of Sharkskin. Liked it so well I loaded my bass rod with it. Other than the finger burn, have had no problems.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Sayfu wrote 47 weeks 3 days ago

Once the water gets slightly above 50 degrees, I fish in shorts, and Clogs....but found a problem with the clogs with holes in them yesterday. I waded the perimeter of a nearby lake. (They do have Clogs without the holes). I didn't wade above my ankles, but when I got home, and kicked off my Clogs, the top of my foot itched. I looked down, and it looked like a piece of bark was on the top of my foot. I tried to kick it off, and could not...reached down, and had to pull fairly hard to get this big, fat, several inches long leech of the top of my foot. And why he was so fat?..from my blood. There was a blood hole in my foot, and blood ran everywhere. Took me some time, and washings to stop the blood flow. Shows to go you that all of those leeches in lakes do not just feast on detritus vegitation like you read in print.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Sayfu wrote 47 weeks 3 days ago

I flushed the critter, but told my wife I put it in her water cup in the BR, and saved it.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Sayfu wrote 47 weeks 3 days ago

Now that you mentioned it, I feel bad about flushing the critter. He feels like blood kin: one of my offsprings.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from buckhunter wrote 47 weeks 2 days ago

Deet, You have had a few whiffs but let us not dwell on them. If we had purchased Croc stock when you pointed out the price was down, we would have made some serious money. You have to admit,(which is hard for this Buckeye to do) you are very well tuned to the market.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Sayfu wrote 47 weeks 2 days ago

Why won't someone show candor about the biggie...felts!?? Broken legs, dunkins at the least from the inferior replacements, broken profits at the mfger, and retail level, and no positive results. And the mfger of the replacement soles gave it up, and went back to felts!!

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Tom-Tom wrote 47 weeks 2 days ago

So what is your latest winning stock market pick, Kirk? Missed your tip about Croc.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Hornd wrote 47 weeks 1 day ago

Cabelas stock is hotter than Kate Uptons GQ Cover Shoot!

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Sayfu wrote 47 weeks 1 day ago

Hornd...Twer I, and I am an investor, I'd be putting money into a good dividend bearing stock like a utility stock..the flight is to dividend stocks for protection in this terrible economy. Consumer spending is DOWN...25,000,000 folks out of work, and about as many on food stamps doesn't make Cabelas a very attractive stock.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from bigz24bigbass wrote 46 weeks 5 days ago

Sounds similar to the hype I have at the beginning of the NFL season after a tall glass of training camp kool-aid. Lets go JETS!

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Sayfu wrote 46 weeks 5 days ago

Jet's? You had better go "T-boning" and give up on Sanchez.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Sayfu wrote 46 weeks 4 days ago

trapper... My brother is a charter boat skipper on Lake Erie. I was on his charter using a black leach fly catching small mouth bass. I fished off the front deck of his boat and out of the way of his clients. His clients brought big "flats" of black leaches, and soft shelled craws aboard. And the leaches were plenty big.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Trapper Vic wrote 46 weeks 1 day ago

Sayfu - Whats is charter name I'm looking for a good captain to hook up for next spring.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Merkincrab wrote 45 weeks 6 days ago

Actually, I'm still loving my Sharkskin lines: 5, 6, 8 and 10-wt. They perform great and are durable. They don't clean up as well, but still float fine.

0 Good Comment? | | Report

Post a Comment