


July 06, 2012
Releasing a Mako Shark is More Impressive Than Killing One
By Kirk Deeter
Following up on the catch-and-release thread from the other day, I will admit to being ashamed when I read about anglers killing fish for the sake of testosterone rather than for food. What triggered the thought is this story of two anglers who killed an 800-pound shortfin mako (a prime female breeder) in California.
I know, rules are rules. But I wish the media would stop with the shark-killing hero worship.
We even ran a story here a couple years ago about mako shark bowfishing. If it's within the regulations, I guess that's fine. But as a bowhunter and someone who has fly fished a lot for mako sharks with my friends Conway Bowman and Dave Trimble in San Diego, I can tell you that using a compound bow to shoot an arrow into a mako that's been chummed to the boat would be about as difficult as hitting the boat cooler if you dropped it overboard.
I can't imagine that pulling on a mortally wounded (harpooned) shark is nearly as tough as fighting one that's only hooked in the mouth. And if you ask me what the ultimate test of fishing nerve is, I'd say it's looking straight into the toothy maw of a live mako and using a metal tool to pull the fly out. Releasing a shark alive takes more guts than posing with a dead one.
It's just not as easy to make a story about that, but it can happen.
Comments (14)
I am with you on this one, Deeter. Let them go let them grow.
Another case for setting new take regulations for pelagic sharks ( makos, threshers)
Its hard to believe this sort of thing still happens. It's actually really dissapointing to see this time and time again. Real bummer.....
Great job KD ! Thanks for making yet another stand on this issue.
"Speed,Muscle and Teeth"
On my boat and those of most of my friends all sharks are released unless they are a first mako for the angler or potential tournament winner.
So far this season on my boat we have 25 releases and 0 kept.
I almost hate to say this for fear of making a sayfuism but, don't some sharks die from the sport of fly fishing? And, isn't chumming up a shark and tossing a huge red fly in front of them also easy? Is an arrow to the head a quicker more humane death than being exhausted to death at the end of a fly rod?
Oh Gosh! I feel so dirty. You can revoke my Fly Talk membership at any time.
Have been bowhunting and fly fishing for 30+ years. I guess I am torn. I will agree Chris Brackett is a complete idiot.
Conway, Love the show. Keep up the good work.
Buckhunter,
Those are valid points. It would be interesting to see the survival rate of big game fish which are released after a long hard fought battle and are completely exhausted. At least by releasing them they have a chance as opposed to getting a gaff or an arrow in the gills.
Unfortunately killing big breeder females not only kills that fish but wipes out multiple generations. It surely has a big impact on a species which has declining populations.
Easy to see that Mako was feeding on emergers..I generally go to 6x, and tie on a #20 flashback PT nymph.
"I know, rules are rules." Not all rules are good and some should be changed. I think "Chumming" for fish, bear, big cat or anything should be totally against the rules and only fair chase is true hunting, regardless if with bow or powder. Fish in a barrel is easy, takes no skill and admittedly I've fished area's where the fish are flooding a hole. That is a total estrogen rush for me as well. However, chumming some thing into to be killed...totally cowardly.
Sayfu. roflmao ololololol
flutter...the key is all in the hookset..you have to be quick about it otherwise they take the bug too deep, and tend to cut your leader...kinda like kissin a ducks butt without getting feathers up your nose...blooooooooooooooow-kiss.....but you have to be quick about it.
As an avid fisherman growing up, I understand the thrill of the sport, but SCUBA diving changed a lot for me. Granted diving isn't for everyone, but it gives you a secondary perspective on the sport.
To illustrate how big a problem overfishing and shark finning can be, I'd like to share a recent experience. We actually went snorkeling with mako sharks about a month ago, off the coast of San Diego, and spent some time swimming with makos. Despite waiting hours for the first one to show up, we learned via the radio that one nearby boat had caught and kept 4 mako sharks in the span of about 2 hours! If that is happening in one small spot on one day by one sportfishing (non-commercial) boat, you can see why our shark populations are so depleted and threatened.
I can't argue with people keeping legal catches they intend to eat but just invite everyone to please consider future generations, current laws, and the animals involved when out fishing. It's a much bigger and more widespread problem that most people realize.
Same reasoning applies to a lot of our fisheries. Remember that even legal limits set for fish to eat are set by states that have to sell licenses to try and meet budgets.
Good story Deeter. I think releasing a Mako by hand would show that you got some stones, Or an air-head. Now if somebody does it, more power to them, I'm just saying I wouldn't do it.
release is all in the technique. If you are right handed, you wiggle your left hand fingers in front of his face getting his attention, and then quickly release the hook with the right hand...old Indian trick.
Sayfu, Be careful with the wiggle-the-fingers trick. Tried it once as a kid and had my hand swallowed by a bass.
I'm a little disappointed this topic did not take off. But I guess shark fishing must not be that popular.
Buckhunter..Ya gotta be quick!... know when to hold'um, and when to fold'um. You were probably trying to impress some gal in a two piece on the Cedar Point beach, and weren't focused on what you should have been focused on. And a bass big enough to swallow your whole hand?! Not even Bill Dance can tell one that big.
Post a Comment
I am with you on this one, Deeter. Let them go let them grow.
Another case for setting new take regulations for pelagic sharks ( makos, threshers)
Its hard to believe this sort of thing still happens. It's actually really dissapointing to see this time and time again. Real bummer.....
Great job KD ! Thanks for making yet another stand on this issue.
"Speed,Muscle and Teeth"
On my boat and those of most of my friends all sharks are released unless they are a first mako for the angler or potential tournament winner.
So far this season on my boat we have 25 releases and 0 kept.
As an avid fisherman growing up, I understand the thrill of the sport, but SCUBA diving changed a lot for me. Granted diving isn't for everyone, but it gives you a secondary perspective on the sport.
To illustrate how big a problem overfishing and shark finning can be, I'd like to share a recent experience. We actually went snorkeling with mako sharks about a month ago, off the coast of San Diego, and spent some time swimming with makos. Despite waiting hours for the first one to show up, we learned via the radio that one nearby boat had caught and kept 4 mako sharks in the span of about 2 hours! If that is happening in one small spot on one day by one sportfishing (non-commercial) boat, you can see why our shark populations are so depleted and threatened.
I can't argue with people keeping legal catches they intend to eat but just invite everyone to please consider future generations, current laws, and the animals involved when out fishing. It's a much bigger and more widespread problem that most people realize.
I almost hate to say this for fear of making a sayfuism but, don't some sharks die from the sport of fly fishing? And, isn't chumming up a shark and tossing a huge red fly in front of them also easy? Is an arrow to the head a quicker more humane death than being exhausted to death at the end of a fly rod?
Oh Gosh! I feel so dirty. You can revoke my Fly Talk membership at any time.
Have been bowhunting and fly fishing for 30+ years. I guess I am torn. I will agree Chris Brackett is a complete idiot.
Conway, Love the show. Keep up the good work.
Buckhunter,
Those are valid points. It would be interesting to see the survival rate of big game fish which are released after a long hard fought battle and are completely exhausted. At least by releasing them they have a chance as opposed to getting a gaff or an arrow in the gills.
Unfortunately killing big breeder females not only kills that fish but wipes out multiple generations. It surely has a big impact on a species which has declining populations.
Easy to see that Mako was feeding on emergers..I generally go to 6x, and tie on a #20 flashback PT nymph.
"I know, rules are rules." Not all rules are good and some should be changed. I think "Chumming" for fish, bear, big cat or anything should be totally against the rules and only fair chase is true hunting, regardless if with bow or powder. Fish in a barrel is easy, takes no skill and admittedly I've fished area's where the fish are flooding a hole. That is a total estrogen rush for me as well. However, chumming some thing into to be killed...totally cowardly.
Sayfu. roflmao ololololol
flutter...the key is all in the hookset..you have to be quick about it otherwise they take the bug too deep, and tend to cut your leader...kinda like kissin a ducks butt without getting feathers up your nose...blooooooooooooooow-kiss.....but you have to be quick about it.
Same reasoning applies to a lot of our fisheries. Remember that even legal limits set for fish to eat are set by states that have to sell licenses to try and meet budgets.
Good story Deeter. I think releasing a Mako by hand would show that you got some stones, Or an air-head. Now if somebody does it, more power to them, I'm just saying I wouldn't do it.
release is all in the technique. If you are right handed, you wiggle your left hand fingers in front of his face getting his attention, and then quickly release the hook with the right hand...old Indian trick.
Sayfu, Be careful with the wiggle-the-fingers trick. Tried it once as a kid and had my hand swallowed by a bass.
I'm a little disappointed this topic did not take off. But I guess shark fishing must not be that popular.
Buckhunter..Ya gotta be quick!... know when to hold'um, and when to fold'um. You were probably trying to impress some gal in a two piece on the Cedar Point beach, and weren't focused on what you should have been focused on. And a bass big enough to swallow your whole hand?! Not even Bill Dance can tell one that big.
Post a Comment