


May 29, 2013
Judgement Call: Casting at Fish You Might Not be Able to Land
By Tim Romano
This video from of Jazz and Fly Fishing begs the question that I'm sure most of us have come across at some point in our fishing careers: Do you cast at fish that probably aren't land-able from a bridge, pier, or any other abutment above water?
I'll be honest; when I'm in one of these situations, I typically take a look around and tell myself that while not probable, there might be a way to land said fish. It's a bad idea most of the time. Either the fish gets a piece of face jewelry or I lose a leader and occasionally the fly line. On the other hand, it's almost always a miraculous feat if manage to you pull it off—and you will cheered on by any fishing pals nearby.
What do you think? Is this poor form or a fishing feat?
Comments (8)
I've cast for steelhead and salmon off piers in both the Pacific Ocean and Lake Erie. On those ocassions I was casting spoons or spinners with a baitcast rod. And there were other fisherfolks around who were doing the same. I'd walk the fish eventually to the shore where it was landed. Never tried it with a fly rod. If the situation was right I certainly would.
Watched any of the Jazz and Fly Fishing videos? Seems the guy with the cigarette is of the 5% of fisherman. The one who always seems to be catching the fish...
Have made a few cast I have regretted but you have to try.
When I was a kid I learned about this the hard way. We lived next to a nice little trout stream and I'd often drop a line from the dirt-road bridge, especially when I only had a few minutes before school. After having a brookie that had to be all of sixteen inches snap my line, I always took the time to walk down into the pasture.
seems that this is pretty much the same thing as taking a shot at an animal that doesn't present a clean kill. Would these same guys casting to a fish they could only hook and not land take a poor shot at a trophy deer. I hope not.
I love fishing from bridges but I know the feeling! Its worse when your on a boat and your not prepared to catch a big one and when you do you don't have a net!
A fish you MIGHT NOT be able to land is a fish which you MIGHT be ABLE to land.
One day I was watching some guys fish from the riverwalk in Grand Rapids, Michigan. The river walk is about fifteen feet above the water level. I was interested in seeing how they would retrieve fish they caught. These guys had a net on a long rope that they lowered into the water to net the fish. I didn't get good look at the net, but it must have been weighted to allow them to manuever it once it was in the water. Then they'd bring the fish up in the net.
Retired Chief, I MIGHT hit an elk six hundred yards away and I MIGHT hit a whitetail running full-bore through some brush, but I MIGHT also just inflict a non-lethal wound and condemn it to a slow death. So I don't take shots like those. Fish can die from the stress of fighting against a rod, wounds to the gills, etc. It happens often enough when you're doing everything ethically in the first place.
Post a Comment
I've cast for steelhead and salmon off piers in both the Pacific Ocean and Lake Erie. On those ocassions I was casting spoons or spinners with a baitcast rod. And there were other fisherfolks around who were doing the same. I'd walk the fish eventually to the shore where it was landed. Never tried it with a fly rod. If the situation was right I certainly would.
Watched any of the Jazz and Fly Fishing videos? Seems the guy with the cigarette is of the 5% of fisherman. The one who always seems to be catching the fish...
Have made a few cast I have regretted but you have to try.
When I was a kid I learned about this the hard way. We lived next to a nice little trout stream and I'd often drop a line from the dirt-road bridge, especially when I only had a few minutes before school. After having a brookie that had to be all of sixteen inches snap my line, I always took the time to walk down into the pasture.
seems that this is pretty much the same thing as taking a shot at an animal that doesn't present a clean kill. Would these same guys casting to a fish they could only hook and not land take a poor shot at a trophy deer. I hope not.
I love fishing from bridges but I know the feeling! Its worse when your on a boat and your not prepared to catch a big one and when you do you don't have a net!
A fish you MIGHT NOT be able to land is a fish which you MIGHT be ABLE to land.
One day I was watching some guys fish from the riverwalk in Grand Rapids, Michigan. The river walk is about fifteen feet above the water level. I was interested in seeing how they would retrieve fish they caught. These guys had a net on a long rope that they lowered into the water to net the fish. I didn't get good look at the net, but it must have been weighted to allow them to manuever it once it was in the water. Then they'd bring the fish up in the net.
Retired Chief, I MIGHT hit an elk six hundred yards away and I MIGHT hit a whitetail running full-bore through some brush, but I MIGHT also just inflict a non-lethal wound and condemn it to a slow death. So I don't take shots like those. Fish can die from the stress of fighting against a rod, wounds to the gills, etc. It happens often enough when you're doing everything ethically in the first place.
Post a Comment