


May 06, 2009
Petzal: Weightlifting, Public Embarrassment, etc.
By David E. Petzal
Herewith, some unfinished business from previous posts.
I mentioned that I had rotator-cuff problems. This was not from shooting, but from doing heavy bench presses without warming up first. Rotator cuffs are small muscles that require specialized exercises. I started doing them in 2000 and haven’t had a problem since. Strength is a good thing for rifle shooters to have; two of the best shots I know are as strong as oxen, and I don’t think it’s coincidental.
One blogger accused me of letting my prejudice against inexpensive shotguns show. Actually, I’ve never tried to hide it. If you can’t show up at a sporting clays event with a Caesar Guerini (which is a hell of a shotgun, by the way), a high-grade Beretta, a Perazzi, or a gun of that order, it’s the social equivalent of having Rosie O’Donnell kiss you in public. I am also prejudiced against Sporting Clays because if you are to shoot it successfully, you have to think. I dislike thinking; that’s why I like trap.
Referring back to the E.R. Shaw Mark VII .30/06, which shoots everything well, I was asked which load I would go with. Finn Aagaard gave the best answer to this question. He said that you stick with whatever will handle the biggest game you can reasonably expect to shoot with the gun. He favored the 180-grain Nosler Partition, and that is what I would pick as well.
Comments (53)
I have had surgery to both shoulders, and the rotator cuff shoulder is my shooting shoulder. Dave, do you have a website that will tell us what your shoulder exercises are? Thank you.
as much as i hate to say it, i have eased away from cheaper weapons as i have found the old adage is true in that you get what you pay for. this is true and expensive if you intend to learn the hard way. espicially if you want to do it with double barrel shotguns (for a pump gun i love the 870, own 3 of them) but that when compared with some other weapons on the market is closer to middle of the road than cheap. i have just completed an odyssey with double barrel products from a manufacturer (whom i won't name here) that has assured me that our american work ethic of why do it right when you can do it cheap is alive and well. actually it may be a brazillian work ethic. or wherever the hell they make that junk.
To Mr. Petzal:
You're choice of the partition is pretty hard to argue with. I use a 180 grain Hornady Interlock, but the biggest game I shoot is midwest cornfed whitetails. The bullets are very accurate in all of my rifles, have rarely recovered any, and the ones that I have held together very well. They are also relativelly inexpensive.
Can't go wrong with a Nosler Partition for just about any caliber!
Weight lifting huh?
How much were you bench pressing?
As one begins to age and looks into the mirror, the mind still has the fortitude to press on ...spirit is ready,but the flesh is weak.
My weight lifting program begins in June:}}
So far no rotator cuff problems although I am perfectly aware that no doubt my time will arrive. Until then I have to be satisfied with two buldged discs in the lumbar area and two in cervical. No I don't consider myself a surgical candidate, don't have time for such fixes. One of my hunting buddies showed up a few years ago with a Guerini. Neither of us even knew what it was but he figured it had to be a cheap shotgun since his wife had bought it brand new and gave it to him as a gift. I knew better. After doing a little research validating my initial impression regarding quality we really both enjoyed the gun for a couple years. The guy and his wife then divorced and he moved to California. Odd but I don't particularily miss him but I sure think about the Caesar everytime someone mentions the brand. High grade Berettas are OK but if you want continuous problems with your trap gun buy a Perazzi. Did you ever wonder why they always have a rep/repairman at the big trap tourniments? He usually is so busy he doesn't have time to visit.
I agree Beretta's are extremely nice to shoot in the field or in competition. I grudgingly admit I can shoot skeet and sporting clays as well with an 1100.
I also wonder why Italian names always end in a vowel.
BTW DP, you wrote...believe you wrote...the 200-grain bullet in a 30-06 makes it a different animal. Does this bullet pushes the 30-06 into medium bore territory?
mark-1,
Since Dave's comment I tried it and I don't think it does. I'll stick with 165gr Hornady softpoints for deer and 180gr Partitions for bigger. '06 has it's limits.
ishawooa and 2Poppa, before you spend time hurting yourself with weights and suffering through chronic back pain try yoga and/or T'ai Chi. I know, I know, but it works. I saved myself from herniated disk surgery and a host of other problems and now I practice at least three times a week. I will meld your mind and body. 5000+ years of study on the human body might have something going for it. I even got a crusty old cowboy to try it and he won't admit it to anyone but he practices in secret. It is good for what ails ya.
The shooter makes the gun, the gun doesn't make a shooter. Petzal is what is wrong with this country. To think that someone will respect you as a shooter just because you carry an expensive shotgun is extremely narcissistic, arrogant, and ignorant!
I don't quite understand why you need an 180 gr bullet for a whitetail?
I'm quite happy with my Beretta silver pidgeon 28 guage O/U. It didn't have the 5 figure price tag but I love to shoot it.
Agreed the 180 grain bullet probably is the best all around for a 30-06.
The case for expensive guns is
1. They ARE better (if competitive shotgunners could win with Mossberg 500s, they'd use them)
2. They are pretty (if you think that doesn't matter, sober up)
3. Since guns last almost forever, if you take care of them you won't lose any money on them over time.
The case against expensive guns is
1. You'd rather shoot now than miss ten years of hunting saving up for one.
2. You treat guns like farm implements, and you'd rather trash a $400 gun than a $4000 one.
That's it.
If something is trying to eat me I'll take a 220 grain Partition. I do however hunt Elk with the 180 Partition since a 200-300 yard shot is likely in this part of Colorado. The 30-06 zeroed with the 180 gain bullet zeroed at 200 yards doesnt require any drop inside 300 hundred yards or any adjustment at point blank timber ranges.
Shoot the very best you possess,
But shoot it very well.
If others don't like your finesse,
Let 'em jog to H___
Forgive the language.
Blue
focusfront has it correct.
I read this mornings post, and after much thought, I can only say...
huh?
I always thought it was fun shoot sporting clays with the guys who buy the real expensive guns.....and then wipe the floor with them shooting an 1100. I will admit that there is nothing finer than a shotgun that doesnt have any flaws in craftsmanship but it will be a hell of a long time before I am able/willing to throw money at one.
Don't forget to get up in the corners when you mop 'em up.
Jersey pig,
It is not the American work ethic that makes the gun cheap. It is the American management team that pushes quanity,quanity,quanity over quality. It is whatever pumps up the bottom line. What is the cheapest and fastest with the fewest workers to get this junk to the customer. For the most part the American worker wants to build Quality products. The blame all starts at the top.
Mark-1 do you remember that a guy won the Grand Nationals a few years ago shooting a slightly modified M-870? That was hard on the Perazzi guys.
Chuckles I will look into your suggestions as a work associate mentioned a similiar idea which he says works wonders for him. Thanks
For over forty years I have mostly loaded 165 gr BT in my .30-'06. It always drops them immediately except for one buck years ago that hit the ground, hopped up, and hauled butt. Unfortunately a search party and I never found him. This of course could have happened with most any caliber and bullet as apparently exact bullet placement was lacking. That aside the 165 in front of the right powder is about as flat as a .25-'06 and comes scary close to matching a 7 Rem Mag for speed and energy. Look it up and try it yourself, it will make you smile.
ishawooa
Having been the proud owner of a .30-06 only since 2002, I have to confess that I have not hunted with it every year. But, the four deer and one elk I have taken with it using 165 grain Trophy Bonded Bear Claws and 165 gr Barnes TSX boatails have gone down like the Titanic. Even factory velocities are almost the same as 160 grain 7mm Rem Mag. Those 2 bullets shoot exceptionally well in my Weatherby and I doubt that I switch. I might try some of the new Hornady GMX if they are substantially cheaper than the Barnes. Otherwise, I'll shoot the Barnes TSX until something much better comes along.
I never quite understood the significance of 15 grains of bullet weight in a .30 cal premium bullet for deer/elk (other than BC )? Now the differnce between a 150 and a 180 I can understand...
Ish,
I agree with you on the 165 grain load in the '06. I use the Nosler Accubond and Ballistic Tip. The 'tip usually gets the nod for deer size game and the 'Bond gets the nod on tougher stuff. Both shoot to the same point of impact in my favorite old Ruger M77MKII. You are right on on the ballistics also.
chuckles-
Thanks for the low impact suggestion ... I may take you up on that!
I still think that shooting is fun. I enjoy the outing and the challenge, I shoot the best I can with the guns I've got. Turns out to be about on par with many others gunning with 10X what I've spent.
I think dgbroox is new to the Blog and hasn't figured out yet that Mr. Petzal is far more arrogant and narcissistic than what he appears? It's okay though because after a while it becomes funny and when he doesn't let his true feelings be known, his posts aren't quite as interesting.
I have always wanted a custom or semi-custom gun. 32 years as an empoyee of the U.S. Postal Service left me short of extra cash. I have a good gun collection but it is Winchesters, Remington and Rugers. I have a 1940 era Browning A-5 as my only "best" gun. However, my dad and his friends made it with working man's guns. I have to. But it is nice to get a Weatherby catalog and dream.
Silvertip
I just find it humorous that you guys respect anything that this self proclaimed "gun nut" puts out. Petzal is the same "gun nut" who took up for Zumbo and his anti assault rifle comments. This gun nut would be all for infringing upon our rights in supporting a ban on assault rifles.
dgbroox, I myself have also defended Mr. Zumbo from time to time. If I'm not mistaken (and I could be, the incedent was a while back) Mr. Zumbo never stated that he supported a ban on assault weapons. His blog was in reference to HUNTING with assault weapons. He wrote it after a guide he had been predator hunting with brought up the growing number of people using "black" rifles while pursuing various game out west. To say that he supported a ban on all assault weapons is to prove your own ignorance.
I will also step out on a limb and say that both Mr. Petzal and Mr. Zumbo have more experience and knowledge of all things hunting and shooting than you could ever hope to obtain. Not to mention I was a big Zumbo fan. The man really was an excellent writer. Outdoor Life has lost their two best here recently; Jim Charmichael and Jim Zumbo.
I got the rotator tear throwing seed sacks up on a grain drill trying to beat a storm front. Tried rehab for 6 months then had surgery. Easy recovery, nice painkillers. Did rehab another 6 months or so,3 days/week (worker's comp). Did every exercise they had until I ran out of weights. Still creaked & was uncomfortable when fully extending arm or stretching up but now only hurts when I use it rather than all the time. Doc said he put a screw in there & it feels like maybe buttpad hits screw every shot off bench. Another good reason to keep off the bench. Glad I did it. If you suspect rotator tear, see Doc, SOON. Waiting lowers chance of complete recovery.
I find it interesting how the well to do look down on others by the equipment they have and how arrogant they are when they win. Funny thing though, when I showed up and whooped everyone’s ass they all got there thongs in a wad, slamming things down and around, cussing up a storm blaming there equipment and had the audacity to say I cheated. Several High masters asked the Range Ref to stand over the top of me to watch every single move knowing full well I wouldn’t cheat but they knew the outcome to be. I also find it interesting how a few of the High Master Teams when short of a person would gladly ask me to join.
I remember at age 12, I remember being at turkey shoots and kicking the adults butt with an open sighted Carl Gustaf Stads Gevarsfaktori Swedish 6.5x55 bolt-action carbine.
At age 15 against my parent’s wishes knowing I’d loose and be very upset; I entered a bike race against veterans with 10 speeds. You should have seen their faces when I put a whooping on them with a 3 speed! After the race the winning price was $100 dollars but for me it was $25 because I was an outsider. That’s OK because pretty boy didn’t get his picture in the paper and some stupid magazine!
There are two kinds of Sportsmen, the “Sportsmen” and the “UnSportsmen”!
How many ever gave a person a chance?
A leg up against all odds!
Ya’sure, this person isn’t worth messing with but I remember there were those, those who were the best in their field taken that moment to give me a crack at it!
Then there was that young Teenage Girl at Holloman AFB Sandra Worman who wanted to shoot alongside of us, the Holloman AFB High Power Team. Mike a NRA Coach and Captain of the Small Bore Team and I the Team Captain of the Base team brought her on board back around June of 85. She out grew me in 30 days and mike the following month and the call went out to another coach in Albuquerque NM. In June of 86 this young Lady was trying out for the US Olympics!
One of the most talented Teenage shooters and my pick for All American Sportsmen had a T-shirt that read,
“HOLD MY TROPHY WHILE I KISS YOUR GIRL!”
I have 2 Bolt action 30-06 rifles one is sighted in with Hornady 150 grain SST loaded with 54 grains of IMR4064 at 3080fps out of a 22 inch barrel and the other with Nosler 180 grain Partitions Loaded with 58.0 grains of IMR4831 with a Federal 215 Magnum Primer at 2850ish fps. Both loads are nestled in a Lake City Military Match brass.
alabamahunter,
Could you please get your opinions from somewhere other than google. I know you are a bright kid, but you need to start thinking for yourself.
NolanOsborn,
You don't need a 180 for deer but, it's nice to have at close range. The closer the deer the higher velocity the deer will be hit and more bullet weight loss, not to mention the bullet holding together. Don't get me started on the Federal Fusion, stay away. I split the difference in my 06 and shoot the 165 SPs on deer.
This is not on topic, but I am wonder if Dave hunts with a muzzle loader. I really appreciate the takes everyone has on their rifles and calibers and such but I have been getting more into old school and would love to be directed towards a blog about muskets, balls, and smoke poles.
dgbroox, I can assure you that I have never formed an opinion from a Google search. The fact of the matter is; you realized you were wrong, and resorted to claiming that my opinion was based on faulty information. It is a common claim that kids do not think for themselves. I hear it repeated countless times by any adult that does not see eye to eye with me on politics. By claiming that kids are not thinking for themselves it allows adults something of a defense mechanism if you will, protecting you from a bruised ego because you realize someone considerably younger than you is actually right.
, Good Day
alabamahunter,
I just put my opinion regarding petzal out there, and so did you. No hard feelings. Both of us being alabama sportsmen i think we have more in common than most. We should get together and do a little fishing!
Some of you already know my thoughts, so excuse me while set this one out and refill my glass of uncaffeinated glass of Ice Tea!
well, personally, i believe you are dead right on the strength / shooting topic. a year ago, i had sugery, that went terribly bad. i almost died. it took me many, many months to be able to semi-recover, and my muscles atrophied a lot. my shooting is no where near as good now as it used to be. i am working on that, but it will take some time.
as for the 30-06 loads, i personally like heavy bullets as opposed to lighter ones. there is just more real world killing power in heavier bullets than there is with light ones. IMO, 30 caliber just screams 180-190 grain bullets, unless of course you are dealing with the small end of the 30 caliber range (30 carbine, 30-30, etc). and then, i will still load as heavy a bullet as possible.
I find it humorous that only one blogger so far on this post has not agreed with Mr. Petzal, and therefore he gets thrown down. He is just stating his side of the opinion, and i don't see why you guys are so closed-minded about it.
I actually agree with 'dgbroox' first post.
Nate
Hey Dave...I too have rotator cuff problems. I used to play pro hockey and suffered dislocated shoulders-more than once. One surgery was a total reconstruct, then both cuffs have been done; and ripped again. The posts on varying results depending on the individual are right on. People I encounter have great to marginal results, and the follow-up and strict adherance to physio is critical. Today I do a shake to set them in place each morning (they go out of joint when I sleep on my side) and if I'm shooting or doing some other jerky shoulder stuff, I give them the same shake. It hurts but I'm used to it. You should hear the clunk...it makes my wife shiver.
I'd be very careful with the weights. Ligaments have little blood flow, and repaired ones like the r'cuff are so susceptble to tearing in this regard, you need to be low and slow. The yoga post may be the best suggestion.
The guys who shoot at my club mostly use Benelli Supersports...seems there's been a real run on them and the guys love 'em. Lot's of other guns but the most popular is the Benelli (clays and trap/skeet). I use my Citoris. Don't have the time for guns I can't use both in the field and for practicing for the field-which is what clays etc. is for me. Many like and have dedicated guns, and that's great-just not my deal.
Thanks!
@ 60256, dgbroox, and alabamahunter:
Your situation consists of "not enough time on the planet" and certainly not much time on this blog. Mr. Petzal's comments are often salty and tongue in cheek. Your experience hasn't quite prepared you for the level of discernment required to fully appreciate his wit.
As for Jim Zumbo, only a reactionary would have interpreted his controversial blog as being anti-gun. What he said was true, although a bit narrow. Generally speaking, "black rifles" aren't suited for hunting, aside from varmint shooting, in most hunter's opinions, including mine. And don't give me 12 reasons why they are good for hunting. I own one and was using one in combat long before you were born and know that they are not really designed for that purpose. But, you certainly have the right to use one hunting if that's what cranks your tractor. Zumbo has been a defender of wildlife conservation and gun rights as well as a proponent of the shooting sports longer than you have been on the planet. Go check out what he is doing with hunts for our wounded warriors. Or better yet, go join the Marines.
WMH
dgbroox
You are as full of sh1^ as a Christmas goose.
On the .30-'06, shoot the load your rifle likes. Old Ugly is very discriminating, and will only take a very few 165 gr. loads with consistency. Usually, the hotter, the better.
I have found that the Nosler Ballistic Tip is the most effective bullet for one shot kills,
hence, I shoot 165 gr.NBTs when hunting with that rifle.
The other '06, a Winchester Model 70, will shoot 150, 165, and 180 gr. with equal accuracy. I am working on a table to adjust the scope for different grains of bullets. Again, shoot what the rifle likes and what works for the game you hunt.
On dgbroox, and your inane comments, I would have to agree with WA Mtnhunter that you have not acquired enough time on this planet, and certainly not enough time on this blog, to have an understanding of Dave Petzal. Until you do, I would suggest a "listen and learn" attitude. Petzal, and several others who post here, have more general knowledge on guns and life in their little toe than you seem to have acquired in your lifetime, and most of us appreciate Petzal's no bulls@%t
style, and understand his humor.
WA Mthunter,
Love to buy you a drink sometime. Kindest regards
Happy Myles-
When are we going to see some of those hunting stories, and I see your postings on some of the fishing blogs also? Huh? Huh? Please?
I remember that hunting season when this City Slicker from Dallas Texas slid off into a ditch on Westside Road near Sunspot New Mexico in his brand new 1994 Eddie Bauer Ford Bronco pulling a camping trailer. YA’the old boy I found leaning back on the driver’s door drinking beer and pissed off as hell. So I pulled him out with my brand new 1994 GMC ½ ton 4x4 and also hauled his trailer up to his camping spot.
Fancy stuf may be nice, but is it worth a hoot in the woods!
============================
To accomplish what you want in the outdoors, got to be in shape. One day at a State High Power Match, I was feeling really lousy so I took two Sudafed without realizing that NON DROWSY Sudafed will affect your shooting even if it makes you feel totally better.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Hey Dave
Getting old really sucks doesn’t it!
Old injuries of our youth coming back
My 03-A3 my Father bought and had it customized just for me at age 12. Total price for it all including a Weaver K-6 scope, $200 dollars.
To me, that 03-A3 30-06 rifle is worth more than any E.R. Shaw Mark VII .30/06 hands down and its not for trade
Go figure!
I have just made my opinion known. I have been around long enough to develop my own opinion. There is no need for you guys to attack me because I don't agree. I say we agree to disagree, no need for personal attacks!
Thanks 60256, sometimes some folks just like to kiss tail to get their little stars. Others have a an opinion of their own.
Speak it Clay Cooper! Speak it!
Clay Cooper makes a great point! Which would you cherish the most? A good shooting shotgun passed down from someone or some gun you paid an arm and a leg for because you read in an article that it was "the gun to shoot"? Who do you think shoots said gun better? The man who is comfortable with is equiment or the man who paid the most for his gun?
The one who always wants
Always gluts for more
Becomes fat and lazy
Always will they be hungry!
And never be satisfied with what they got!
I rather lose a Match and learn something new, rather than win the match and learn nothing. For the next match what have I learned and not won has given me insight to excel beyond my wildest dreams!!!!
WAmthunter, I have no problem with Dave's comments. In fact I've been reading his blog daily for the past few years. I don't, however, tend to post on every subject. I try not to post unless I actually feel as though I can add something of substance to the conversation.
As to dgbroox, I have no problem with him, but his comment about me not forming my own opinion hit me the wrong way. I defended Zumbo because in MY opinion he didn't say anything wrong on the blog post. It's sad that in this day and time a person can say one thing that is completely misconstrued, and before you know he's got a lynch mob after him.
About Jim Zumbo
When they outright viciously pushed Mr Jim Zumbo under the buss and backed over him time and time again, I pulled every copy of Field and Stream out of our Medical Clinic and to this date you will not find a copy in my place of business or my house.
About the view David Petzal and I have, I say this
As for Master Gun Makers, I truly believe without reservation David and I will agree on the following short list of names like E.R. Shaw, Dale Goens, Len Brownell, Jerry Fisher, Keith Stegall, Al Beisen, Goens, Hal Hartley, and Tom Fashingbauer,; If they were around when a European Master Gun Maker was visiting a US Firearms Plant and was asked what he really thought about American made Firearms, he defiantly wouldn’t have replied “UNFINISHED”!
The problem I have today is how cheap firearms are being made and the ridicules price they have. Take the Ruger Mini 14 and the Remington Model 11-87™ Sportsman® ShurShot™ Synthetic Turkey I have. If you break them down and take a close look, I ask one thing. Where is the craftsmanship!!
As for the rotator-cuff problems, I too have the same problem and the orthopedic surgeon wants to cut on it. I cannot throw a baseball, but as long as I can pull back my bow and climb a tree I’m going to stay away from the knife!
Beginning of last deer season, I had my left knee operated on for a torn meniscus and I was walking up and down ridges the following Saturday!
For the record!
I know I really tick off Mr David Petzal and is probably seeing a shrink because of it, but I got to say one thing. I may not agree with this Man that never smiles. Let it known, in case of a fight David Petzal has this “Crusty Ol’NCO” standing at his side!!!!!
DP-- arrogant??? maybe just a little, but with a lot og good natured BS. Narcissistic-- ever take a good look at his picture---lolo-- anyway his blog is one of the best around. I do an exercise a couple of time a day that keeps my shoulders and back in excellent shape. Stand an arms length away from a wall--spread feet to match shoulder width--palms straight out from shoulder and on the wall--up on your toes--then start with 15 push-ups on wall--do twice a day and in no time you'll be doing 40 or 50 each time you do this exercise. Your upper body and arms and back will be alined and strong. Works for me, I'm 75 and have no problems doing this exercise. Lets me stand on my hind legs and shoot a rifle like they were ment to be shot. try it--you'll see what I mean.
Well this may help some of you out there. For years I had problems with my left rotator cup and even concidered surgery.I couldn't even lift my arm above my shoulder. Then I remembered an old Vermont Folk Medicine recipe.
Alot of joint pain comes from the build up of acid chrystals, as was in my case. Being a Fly Fisherman I even gave up fishing for one season because of the pain.
Then I tried this remedy. To flush the acid chrystals from your joints take 2 tabelspoons of Apple Cider Vinegar daily. Forget the store bought stuff that has all the good stuff filtered out. You need to go to a health food store and get the good organic stuff. Mix with water and Honey if you like. Within 3 days the pain was gone for me and I had full mobility again.
Yes it comes back occasionally but all it takes is a day or 2 of ACV to releive the pain. Hope this helps for you too.
I just had to have that fancy o/u with the great looking engraved sidelocks and I saved every nickel that I could put away to one day be able to buy one like it. Eventually I bought A beautiful shotgun and I somehow knew that I would be a better person and shooter for having that piece of firearm art. I used it some at the skeet range and occasionally when I hunted grouse but somehow the old model 12 that had belonged to my father seemed to wind up in my hands as I took to the woods. I love quality and I certainly admire the artistry of a finely done firearm and I hope my son does as well because I have a beautiful shotgun for him! It's hardly been shot!
Clay
For the record, Jim Zumbo was not on the staff of F&S. He was an Editor for Outdoor Life. Not that it matters since both rags are owned by the same publishing house.
Remington was driving the biggest bus that ran over Jim Z. I have not bought one thing from Big Green since, and won't until they renew sponsorship and apologize.
WMH
WMH
5 years ago I made the longest shot of my life and killed a deer at 230 yards. I weighed 380 lb. was out of shape, and couldn't bench press a musket.
2 years ago I killed a deer at 60 yards after missing at 275, 180, and 95 yards and making my hunting partner from the previous hunt laugh in the treehouse we call a stand. I weighed 330 lb. could run 60 minutes on an elliptical without breaking a sweat, and could bench press 315.
Physical stamina is no substitute for being able to shoot well. I gained back some of the weight, and cant run as well now, but I can shoot 4 minute groups offhand.
Post a Comment
@ 60256, dgbroox, and alabamahunter:
Your situation consists of "not enough time on the planet" and certainly not much time on this blog. Mr. Petzal's comments are often salty and tongue in cheek. Your experience hasn't quite prepared you for the level of discernment required to fully appreciate his wit.
As for Jim Zumbo, only a reactionary would have interpreted his controversial blog as being anti-gun. What he said was true, although a bit narrow. Generally speaking, "black rifles" aren't suited for hunting, aside from varmint shooting, in most hunter's opinions, including mine. And don't give me 12 reasons why they are good for hunting. I own one and was using one in combat long before you were born and know that they are not really designed for that purpose. But, you certainly have the right to use one hunting if that's what cranks your tractor. Zumbo has been a defender of wildlife conservation and gun rights as well as a proponent of the shooting sports longer than you have been on the planet. Go check out what he is doing with hunts for our wounded warriors. Or better yet, go join the Marines.
WMH
On the .30-'06, shoot the load your rifle likes. Old Ugly is very discriminating, and will only take a very few 165 gr. loads with consistency. Usually, the hotter, the better.
I have found that the Nosler Ballistic Tip is the most effective bullet for one shot kills,
hence, I shoot 165 gr.NBTs when hunting with that rifle.
The other '06, a Winchester Model 70, will shoot 150, 165, and 180 gr. with equal accuracy. I am working on a table to adjust the scope for different grains of bullets. Again, shoot what the rifle likes and what works for the game you hunt.
On dgbroox, and your inane comments, I would have to agree with WA Mtnhunter that you have not acquired enough time on this planet, and certainly not enough time on this blog, to have an understanding of Dave Petzal. Until you do, I would suggest a "listen and learn" attitude. Petzal, and several others who post here, have more general knowledge on guns and life in their little toe than you seem to have acquired in your lifetime, and most of us appreciate Petzal's no bulls@%t
style, and understand his humor.
The case for expensive guns is
1. They ARE better (if competitive shotgunners could win with Mossberg 500s, they'd use them)
2. They are pretty (if you think that doesn't matter, sober up)
3. Since guns last almost forever, if you take care of them you won't lose any money on them over time.
The case against expensive guns is
1. You'd rather shoot now than miss ten years of hunting saving up for one.
2. You treat guns like farm implements, and you'd rather trash a $400 gun than a $4000 one.
That's it.
dgbroox, I myself have also defended Mr. Zumbo from time to time. If I'm not mistaken (and I could be, the incedent was a while back) Mr. Zumbo never stated that he supported a ban on assault weapons. His blog was in reference to HUNTING with assault weapons. He wrote it after a guide he had been predator hunting with brought up the growing number of people using "black" rifles while pursuing various game out west. To say that he supported a ban on all assault weapons is to prove your own ignorance.
I will also step out on a limb and say that both Mr. Petzal and Mr. Zumbo have more experience and knowledge of all things hunting and shooting than you could ever hope to obtain. Not to mention I was a big Zumbo fan. The man really was an excellent writer. Outdoor Life has lost their two best here recently; Jim Charmichael and Jim Zumbo.
I'm quite happy with my Beretta silver pidgeon 28 guage O/U. It didn't have the 5 figure price tag but I love to shoot it.
Agreed the 180 grain bullet probably is the best all around for a 30-06.
dgbroox, I can assure you that I have never formed an opinion from a Google search. The fact of the matter is; you realized you were wrong, and resorted to claiming that my opinion was based on faulty information. It is a common claim that kids do not think for themselves. I hear it repeated countless times by any adult that does not see eye to eye with me on politics. By claiming that kids are not thinking for themselves it allows adults something of a defense mechanism if you will, protecting you from a bruised ego because you realize someone considerably younger than you is actually right.
, Good Day
Clay Cooper makes a great point! Which would you cherish the most? A good shooting shotgun passed down from someone or some gun you paid an arm and a leg for because you read in an article that it was "the gun to shoot"? Who do you think shoots said gun better? The man who is comfortable with is equiment or the man who paid the most for his gun?
I have had surgery to both shoulders, and the rotator cuff shoulder is my shooting shoulder. Dave, do you have a website that will tell us what your shoulder exercises are? Thank you.
To Mr. Petzal:
You're choice of the partition is pretty hard to argue with. I use a 180 grain Hornady Interlock, but the biggest game I shoot is midwest cornfed whitetails. The bullets are very accurate in all of my rifles, have rarely recovered any, and the ones that I have held together very well. They are also relativelly inexpensive.
Can't go wrong with a Nosler Partition for just about any caliber!
I agree Beretta's are extremely nice to shoot in the field or in competition. I grudgingly admit I can shoot skeet and sporting clays as well with an 1100.
I also wonder why Italian names always end in a vowel.
BTW DP, you wrote...believe you wrote...the 200-grain bullet in a 30-06 makes it a different animal. Does this bullet pushes the 30-06 into medium bore territory?
mark-1,
Since Dave's comment I tried it and I don't think it does. I'll stick with 165gr Hornady softpoints for deer and 180gr Partitions for bigger. '06 has it's limits.
Jersey pig,
It is not the American work ethic that makes the gun cheap. It is the American management team that pushes quanity,quanity,quanity over quality. It is whatever pumps up the bottom line. What is the cheapest and fastest with the fewest workers to get this junk to the customer. For the most part the American worker wants to build Quality products. The blame all starts at the top.
I think dgbroox is new to the Blog and hasn't figured out yet that Mr. Petzal is far more arrogant and narcissistic than what he appears? It's okay though because after a while it becomes funny and when he doesn't let his true feelings be known, his posts aren't quite as interesting.
alabamahunter,
I just put my opinion regarding petzal out there, and so did you. No hard feelings. Both of us being alabama sportsmen i think we have more in common than most. We should get together and do a little fishing!
My 03-A3 my Father bought and had it customized just for me at age 12. Total price for it all including a Weaver K-6 scope, $200 dollars.
To me, that 03-A3 30-06 rifle is worth more than any E.R. Shaw Mark VII .30/06 hands down and its not for trade
Go figure!
The one who always wants
Always gluts for more
Becomes fat and lazy
Always will they be hungry!
And never be satisfied with what they got!
I rather lose a Match and learn something new, rather than win the match and learn nothing. For the next match what have I learned and not won has given me insight to excel beyond my wildest dreams!!!!
About Jim Zumbo
When they outright viciously pushed Mr Jim Zumbo under the buss and backed over him time and time again, I pulled every copy of Field and Stream out of our Medical Clinic and to this date you will not find a copy in my place of business or my house.
About the view David Petzal and I have, I say this
As for Master Gun Makers, I truly believe without reservation David and I will agree on the following short list of names like E.R. Shaw, Dale Goens, Len Brownell, Jerry Fisher, Keith Stegall, Al Beisen, Goens, Hal Hartley, and Tom Fashingbauer,; If they were around when a European Master Gun Maker was visiting a US Firearms Plant and was asked what he really thought about American made Firearms, he defiantly wouldn’t have replied “UNFINISHED”!
The problem I have today is how cheap firearms are being made and the ridicules price they have. Take the Ruger Mini 14 and the Remington Model 11-87™ Sportsman® ShurShot™ Synthetic Turkey I have. If you break them down and take a close look, I ask one thing. Where is the craftsmanship!!
As for the rotator-cuff problems, I too have the same problem and the orthopedic surgeon wants to cut on it. I cannot throw a baseball, but as long as I can pull back my bow and climb a tree I’m going to stay away from the knife!
Beginning of last deer season, I had my left knee operated on for a torn meniscus and I was walking up and down ridges the following Saturday!
For the record!
I know I really tick off Mr David Petzal and is probably seeing a shrink because of it, but I got to say one thing. I may not agree with this Man that never smiles. Let it known, in case of a fight David Petzal has this “Crusty Ol’NCO” standing at his side!!!!!
DP-- arrogant??? maybe just a little, but with a lot og good natured BS. Narcissistic-- ever take a good look at his picture---lolo-- anyway his blog is one of the best around. I do an exercise a couple of time a day that keeps my shoulders and back in excellent shape. Stand an arms length away from a wall--spread feet to match shoulder width--palms straight out from shoulder and on the wall--up on your toes--then start with 15 push-ups on wall--do twice a day and in no time you'll be doing 40 or 50 each time you do this exercise. Your upper body and arms and back will be alined and strong. Works for me, I'm 75 and have no problems doing this exercise. Lets me stand on my hind legs and shoot a rifle like they were ment to be shot. try it--you'll see what I mean.
Well this may help some of you out there. For years I had problems with my left rotator cup and even concidered surgery.I couldn't even lift my arm above my shoulder. Then I remembered an old Vermont Folk Medicine recipe.
Alot of joint pain comes from the build up of acid chrystals, as was in my case. Being a Fly Fisherman I even gave up fishing for one season because of the pain.
Then I tried this remedy. To flush the acid chrystals from your joints take 2 tabelspoons of Apple Cider Vinegar daily. Forget the store bought stuff that has all the good stuff filtered out. You need to go to a health food store and get the good organic stuff. Mix with water and Honey if you like. Within 3 days the pain was gone for me and I had full mobility again.
Yes it comes back occasionally but all it takes is a day or 2 of ACV to releive the pain. Hope this helps for you too.
Weight lifting huh?
How much were you bench pressing?
As one begins to age and looks into the mirror, the mind still has the fortitude to press on ...spirit is ready,but the flesh is weak.
My weight lifting program begins in June:}}
So far no rotator cuff problems although I am perfectly aware that no doubt my time will arrive. Until then I have to be satisfied with two buldged discs in the lumbar area and two in cervical. No I don't consider myself a surgical candidate, don't have time for such fixes. One of my hunting buddies showed up a few years ago with a Guerini. Neither of us even knew what it was but he figured it had to be a cheap shotgun since his wife had bought it brand new and gave it to him as a gift. I knew better. After doing a little research validating my initial impression regarding quality we really both enjoyed the gun for a couple years. The guy and his wife then divorced and he moved to California. Odd but I don't particularily miss him but I sure think about the Caesar everytime someone mentions the brand. High grade Berettas are OK but if you want continuous problems with your trap gun buy a Perazzi. Did you ever wonder why they always have a rep/repairman at the big trap tourniments? He usually is so busy he doesn't have time to visit.
ishawooa and 2Poppa, before you spend time hurting yourself with weights and suffering through chronic back pain try yoga and/or T'ai Chi. I know, I know, but it works. I saved myself from herniated disk surgery and a host of other problems and now I practice at least three times a week. I will meld your mind and body. 5000+ years of study on the human body might have something going for it. I even got a crusty old cowboy to try it and he won't admit it to anyone but he practices in secret. It is good for what ails ya.
I don't quite understand why you need an 180 gr bullet for a whitetail?
If something is trying to eat me I'll take a 220 grain Partition. I do however hunt Elk with the 180 Partition since a 200-300 yard shot is likely in this part of Colorado. The 30-06 zeroed with the 180 gain bullet zeroed at 200 yards doesnt require any drop inside 300 hundred yards or any adjustment at point blank timber ranges.
Shoot the very best you possess,
But shoot it very well.
If others don't like your finesse,
Let 'em jog to H___
Forgive the language.
Blue
I always thought it was fun shoot sporting clays with the guys who buy the real expensive guns.....and then wipe the floor with them shooting an 1100. I will admit that there is nothing finer than a shotgun that doesnt have any flaws in craftsmanship but it will be a hell of a long time before I am able/willing to throw money at one.
For over forty years I have mostly loaded 165 gr BT in my .30-'06. It always drops them immediately except for one buck years ago that hit the ground, hopped up, and hauled butt. Unfortunately a search party and I never found him. This of course could have happened with most any caliber and bullet as apparently exact bullet placement was lacking. That aside the 165 in front of the right powder is about as flat as a .25-'06 and comes scary close to matching a 7 Rem Mag for speed and energy. Look it up and try it yourself, it will make you smile.
ishawooa
Having been the proud owner of a .30-06 only since 2002, I have to confess that I have not hunted with it every year. But, the four deer and one elk I have taken with it using 165 grain Trophy Bonded Bear Claws and 165 gr Barnes TSX boatails have gone down like the Titanic. Even factory velocities are almost the same as 160 grain 7mm Rem Mag. Those 2 bullets shoot exceptionally well in my Weatherby and I doubt that I switch. I might try some of the new Hornady GMX if they are substantially cheaper than the Barnes. Otherwise, I'll shoot the Barnes TSX until something much better comes along.
I never quite understood the significance of 15 grains of bullet weight in a .30 cal premium bullet for deer/elk (other than BC )? Now the differnce between a 150 and a 180 I can understand...
Ish,
I agree with you on the 165 grain load in the '06. I use the Nosler Accubond and Ballistic Tip. The 'tip usually gets the nod for deer size game and the 'Bond gets the nod on tougher stuff. Both shoot to the same point of impact in my favorite old Ruger M77MKII. You are right on on the ballistics also.
chuckles-
Thanks for the low impact suggestion ... I may take you up on that!
I still think that shooting is fun. I enjoy the outing and the challenge, I shoot the best I can with the guns I've got. Turns out to be about on par with many others gunning with 10X what I've spent.
I have always wanted a custom or semi-custom gun. 32 years as an empoyee of the U.S. Postal Service left me short of extra cash. I have a good gun collection but it is Winchesters, Remington and Rugers. I have a 1940 era Browning A-5 as my only "best" gun. However, my dad and his friends made it with working man's guns. I have to. But it is nice to get a Weatherby catalog and dream.
Silvertip
I got the rotator tear throwing seed sacks up on a grain drill trying to beat a storm front. Tried rehab for 6 months then had surgery. Easy recovery, nice painkillers. Did rehab another 6 months or so,3 days/week (worker's comp). Did every exercise they had until I ran out of weights. Still creaked & was uncomfortable when fully extending arm or stretching up but now only hurts when I use it rather than all the time. Doc said he put a screw in there & it feels like maybe buttpad hits screw every shot off bench. Another good reason to keep off the bench. Glad I did it. If you suspect rotator tear, see Doc, SOON. Waiting lowers chance of complete recovery.
I find it interesting how the well to do look down on others by the equipment they have and how arrogant they are when they win. Funny thing though, when I showed up and whooped everyone’s ass they all got there thongs in a wad, slamming things down and around, cussing up a storm blaming there equipment and had the audacity to say I cheated. Several High masters asked the Range Ref to stand over the top of me to watch every single move knowing full well I wouldn’t cheat but they knew the outcome to be. I also find it interesting how a few of the High Master Teams when short of a person would gladly ask me to join.
I remember at age 12, I remember being at turkey shoots and kicking the adults butt with an open sighted Carl Gustaf Stads Gevarsfaktori Swedish 6.5x55 bolt-action carbine.
At age 15 against my parent’s wishes knowing I’d loose and be very upset; I entered a bike race against veterans with 10 speeds. You should have seen their faces when I put a whooping on them with a 3 speed! After the race the winning price was $100 dollars but for me it was $25 because I was an outsider. That’s OK because pretty boy didn’t get his picture in the paper and some stupid magazine!
There are two kinds of Sportsmen, the “Sportsmen” and the “UnSportsmen”!
How many ever gave a person a chance?
A leg up against all odds!
Ya’sure, this person isn’t worth messing with but I remember there were those, those who were the best in their field taken that moment to give me a crack at it!
Then there was that young Teenage Girl at Holloman AFB Sandra Worman who wanted to shoot alongside of us, the Holloman AFB High Power Team. Mike a NRA Coach and Captain of the Small Bore Team and I the Team Captain of the Base team brought her on board back around June of 85. She out grew me in 30 days and mike the following month and the call went out to another coach in Albuquerque NM. In June of 86 this young Lady was trying out for the US Olympics!
One of the most talented Teenage shooters and my pick for All American Sportsmen had a T-shirt that read,
“HOLD MY TROPHY WHILE I KISS YOUR GIRL!”
I have 2 Bolt action 30-06 rifles one is sighted in with Hornady 150 grain SST loaded with 54 grains of IMR4064 at 3080fps out of a 22 inch barrel and the other with Nosler 180 grain Partitions Loaded with 58.0 grains of IMR4831 with a Federal 215 Magnum Primer at 2850ish fps. Both loads are nestled in a Lake City Military Match brass.
NolanOsborn,
You don't need a 180 for deer but, it's nice to have at close range. The closer the deer the higher velocity the deer will be hit and more bullet weight loss, not to mention the bullet holding together. Don't get me started on the Federal Fusion, stay away. I split the difference in my 06 and shoot the 165 SPs on deer.
This is not on topic, but I am wonder if Dave hunts with a muzzle loader. I really appreciate the takes everyone has on their rifles and calibers and such but I have been getting more into old school and would love to be directed towards a blog about muskets, balls, and smoke poles.
Some of you already know my thoughts, so excuse me while set this one out and refill my glass of uncaffeinated glass of Ice Tea!
well, personally, i believe you are dead right on the strength / shooting topic. a year ago, i had sugery, that went terribly bad. i almost died. it took me many, many months to be able to semi-recover, and my muscles atrophied a lot. my shooting is no where near as good now as it used to be. i am working on that, but it will take some time.
as for the 30-06 loads, i personally like heavy bullets as opposed to lighter ones. there is just more real world killing power in heavier bullets than there is with light ones. IMO, 30 caliber just screams 180-190 grain bullets, unless of course you are dealing with the small end of the 30 caliber range (30 carbine, 30-30, etc). and then, i will still load as heavy a bullet as possible.
I find it humorous that only one blogger so far on this post has not agreed with Mr. Petzal, and therefore he gets thrown down. He is just stating his side of the opinion, and i don't see why you guys are so closed-minded about it.
I actually agree with 'dgbroox' first post.
Nate
Hey Dave...I too have rotator cuff problems. I used to play pro hockey and suffered dislocated shoulders-more than once. One surgery was a total reconstruct, then both cuffs have been done; and ripped again. The posts on varying results depending on the individual are right on. People I encounter have great to marginal results, and the follow-up and strict adherance to physio is critical. Today I do a shake to set them in place each morning (they go out of joint when I sleep on my side) and if I'm shooting or doing some other jerky shoulder stuff, I give them the same shake. It hurts but I'm used to it. You should hear the clunk...it makes my wife shiver.
I'd be very careful with the weights. Ligaments have little blood flow, and repaired ones like the r'cuff are so susceptble to tearing in this regard, you need to be low and slow. The yoga post may be the best suggestion.
The guys who shoot at my club mostly use Benelli Supersports...seems there's been a real run on them and the guys love 'em. Lot's of other guns but the most popular is the Benelli (clays and trap/skeet). I use my Citoris. Don't have the time for guns I can't use both in the field and for practicing for the field-which is what clays etc. is for me. Many like and have dedicated guns, and that's great-just not my deal.
Thanks!
WA Mthunter,
Love to buy you a drink sometime. Kindest regards
Happy Myles-
When are we going to see some of those hunting stories, and I see your postings on some of the fishing blogs also? Huh? Huh? Please?
I remember that hunting season when this City Slicker from Dallas Texas slid off into a ditch on Westside Road near Sunspot New Mexico in his brand new 1994 Eddie Bauer Ford Bronco pulling a camping trailer. YA’the old boy I found leaning back on the driver’s door drinking beer and pissed off as hell. So I pulled him out with my brand new 1994 GMC ½ ton 4x4 and also hauled his trailer up to his camping spot.
Fancy stuf may be nice, but is it worth a hoot in the woods!
============================
To accomplish what you want in the outdoors, got to be in shape. One day at a State High Power Match, I was feeling really lousy so I took two Sudafed without realizing that NON DROWSY Sudafed will affect your shooting even if it makes you feel totally better.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Hey Dave
Getting old really sucks doesn’t it!
Old injuries of our youth coming back
Speak it Clay Cooper! Speak it!
WAmthunter, I have no problem with Dave's comments. In fact I've been reading his blog daily for the past few years. I don't, however, tend to post on every subject. I try not to post unless I actually feel as though I can add something of substance to the conversation.
As to dgbroox, I have no problem with him, but his comment about me not forming my own opinion hit me the wrong way. I defended Zumbo because in MY opinion he didn't say anything wrong on the blog post. It's sad that in this day and time a person can say one thing that is completely misconstrued, and before you know he's got a lynch mob after him.
as much as i hate to say it, i have eased away from cheaper weapons as i have found the old adage is true in that you get what you pay for. this is true and expensive if you intend to learn the hard way. espicially if you want to do it with double barrel shotguns (for a pump gun i love the 870, own 3 of them) but that when compared with some other weapons on the market is closer to middle of the road than cheap. i have just completed an odyssey with double barrel products from a manufacturer (whom i won't name here) that has assured me that our american work ethic of why do it right when you can do it cheap is alive and well. actually it may be a brazillian work ethic. or wherever the hell they make that junk.
focusfront has it correct.
I read this mornings post, and after much thought, I can only say...
huh?
Don't forget to get up in the corners when you mop 'em up.
Mark-1 do you remember that a guy won the Grand Nationals a few years ago shooting a slightly modified M-870? That was hard on the Perazzi guys.
Chuckles I will look into your suggestions as a work associate mentioned a similiar idea which he says works wonders for him. Thanks
I have just made my opinion known. I have been around long enough to develop my own opinion. There is no need for you guys to attack me because I don't agree. I say we agree to disagree, no need for personal attacks!
I just had to have that fancy o/u with the great looking engraved sidelocks and I saved every nickel that I could put away to one day be able to buy one like it. Eventually I bought A beautiful shotgun and I somehow knew that I would be a better person and shooter for having that piece of firearm art. I used it some at the skeet range and occasionally when I hunted grouse but somehow the old model 12 that had belonged to my father seemed to wind up in my hands as I took to the woods. I love quality and I certainly admire the artistry of a finely done firearm and I hope my son does as well because I have a beautiful shotgun for him! It's hardly been shot!
Clay
For the record, Jim Zumbo was not on the staff of F&S. He was an Editor for Outdoor Life. Not that it matters since both rags are owned by the same publishing house.
Remington was driving the biggest bus that ran over Jim Z. I have not bought one thing from Big Green since, and won't until they renew sponsorship and apologize.
WMH
WMH
5 years ago I made the longest shot of my life and killed a deer at 230 yards. I weighed 380 lb. was out of shape, and couldn't bench press a musket.
2 years ago I killed a deer at 60 yards after missing at 275, 180, and 95 yards and making my hunting partner from the previous hunt laugh in the treehouse we call a stand. I weighed 330 lb. could run 60 minutes on an elliptical without breaking a sweat, and could bench press 315.
Physical stamina is no substitute for being able to shoot well. I gained back some of the weight, and cant run as well now, but I can shoot 4 minute groups offhand.
Thanks 60256, sometimes some folks just like to kiss tail to get their little stars. Others have a an opinion of their own.
The shooter makes the gun, the gun doesn't make a shooter. Petzal is what is wrong with this country. To think that someone will respect you as a shooter just because you carry an expensive shotgun is extremely narcissistic, arrogant, and ignorant!
dgbroox
You are as full of sh1^ as a Christmas goose.
alabamahunter,
Could you please get your opinions from somewhere other than google. I know you are a bright kid, but you need to start thinking for yourself.
I just find it humorous that you guys respect anything that this self proclaimed "gun nut" puts out. Petzal is the same "gun nut" who took up for Zumbo and his anti assault rifle comments. This gun nut would be all for infringing upon our rights in supporting a ban on assault rifles.
Post a Comment