



September 14, 2012
Odd Advice From The Guy at the Gun Store
By David E. Petzal

There used to be a song whose refrain went: “Oh, lay it on the ground, and spread it all around, it’ll make your garden grow.” This could be applied to much of the advice I hear given about guns. The most recent piece which can double as fertilizer comes from a friend who asked me, very worried, if it was all right to use Birchwood-Casey Gun Scrubber on his rifles because the guy at the gun store had told him that “…it would dry out the wood.” This is so addled that it’s worth examining in detail.
But first, I have to say for the record that Birchwood-Casey Gun Scrubber is a gun nut’s best friend, and that right now I have one big can on my workbench and three more in reserve. It is one of the great boons of technology, along with big-screen TV and the Shu mine. But let us examine this statement that it will dry out your wood.
1. Why are you spraying it on your stock? It’s designed for use on metal. Are you simple or something?
2. Gun Scrubber is so volatile that it evaporates in seconds. To kiln-dry a piece of walnut, you need a couple of weeks, more or less. To air-dry it, you sometimes need years. How will the Gun Scrubber accomplish this miracle in the few ticks of the clock before it’s all gone?
3. Point number 2 refers to unfinished wood. Gun Scrubber will not get through modern gun finishes.
4. Walnut is supposed to be dry.
I will continue to spray Gun Scrubber with wild abandon. On metal, not on stocks or scopes. But one caution: Always wear safety glasses when you use it. It comes out under considerable pressure, and if you get it in your eyeball, your shrieks will make the welkin ring.
Comments (42)
Most advice your obtain from gun counters is fertilizer at best.
Yep. I have used it to clean my firearm barrels for a few years now and have found it to be efficient in cleaning the barrel of any residual powder as well as through. It is very harmful to any wood finish so remove the barrel to treat it. It is faster than a wire brush and running an endless number of wads to get a barrel clean. Make sure you use it in a vented area.
does it come in a 55 gallon drum? home depot has a pressure washer on sale and I have a high school trap team in need of a gun cleaning lesson
Save your money and use carburetor cleaner. It's the same stuff, only cheaper.
Be careful with the carburetor cleaner (aka Gun Scrubber). Don't get it on your skin, breathe it or have it anywhere near a flame. The resulting explosion will rearrange your gun room faster than a shu mine doing the same to your foot.
Carb cleaner, and in this case gun scrubber, is an oxydizer. Mixing it with wood may not dry it out, but mixing wood that has come in contact with the scrubber and an ignition source will give a new meaning to the word firearm.
I've gotten it both in my eye and on my skin. Probably explains a lot right there.
Carb cleaner and Gun Scrubber aren't the same. The closest thing to Gun Scrubber in an automotive product is a chlorinated brake cleaner.
Does Gun Scrubber work for muzzleloaders, too? ie, Pyrodex?
Longbeard, Mix equal parts Murphy oil soap, Denatured alcohol and Hydrogen peroxide. Store it in a brown bottle it is the best solvent for Black powder and bp substitutes I have ever used. Also much cheaper than store bought.
I use windex to clean black powder guns' must be the amonia...
Gun scrubber--Kerosene. Cheap and effective. Soaking parts takes a while, but is safe on bluing and other metal coatings. Worried about the wood? Take the stock off.
Black powder—tough to beat a mix of windshield solvent cleaner and plain soap.
I have received a lot of very odd advice and comments, most stated as indisputable fact, from the Guy at the gun store.
Among the classics:
1. CCI Mini-Mag solids are "armour piercing" rounds.
2. There is no such thing as a .222. "Sir, it is a .223."
3. A Springfield Armory M1A is a "machine gun" and cannot be bought.
4. Only Savage makes left-handed rifles, and they are "cheap and no good."
5. There is no such thing as a .41 Remington Magnum. "it is a .44 Magnum, like Dirty Harry used."
6. 7 1/2 shot won't kill doves. It is only a trap load.
7. "A .30-'06 won't kill a deer past 300 yds."
8. Have been offered .45 ACP for .45 LC, and told "They are the same thing."
9. "You can't change the barrels in a Remington 1100. It has to be done at the factory."
10. "You don't need to clean your black powder rifle if you use lard for patch lube. That's what the mountain men did."
There are more, but I think these are the top ten.
For Black powder I've always used old fashioned HOT water and dish detergent, take the barrel off, use a tight fitting wet patch and jag, stick the flash hole under the water and work the ramrod. It will draw the water in thru the flash hole and clean it out real well in a few minutes. Repeat with Clean Hot water as a rinse, Dry patch the barrel til dry then coat the bore with bore butter or other patch lube type grease.
Personally I'd worry more about the wood getting wet with oil or water than drying it out!
crm3006
Did you drop of a "SIGN" for them? LMAO!
I don't know about goofy advice from gun salesmen, but here is my favorite......When I ask the buffoon behind the counter for a box of .250 Savage, the usual answer is "Whut?"
Dave and All,
Gun Scrubber is excellent. I've been using it for four years. It's the application that's harmful to guns.
The full power stuff cannot be used on pistols or rifles with synthetic stocks. The first can I bought I ruined the plastic grips on my Ruger MkII pistol. Can't imagine how I would react if I had sprayed it on a rifle with a McMillan stock.
Remove barreled actions when using this stuff. I do understand they are making plastic friendly stuff, haven't seen it though.
Dave;
That din't work so good did it/
Rest assured "I still love ya".
By the way, what the hell is a welkin ring ?
I also use break cleaner. You can get chlorinated and non-chlorinated break cleaner at Wal-Mart for a lot less than you can get Gun Scrubber.
Works great for getting into cracks and crevices.
Break cleaner does a great job of removing crud, oil and grease, which if not followed by some sort of oil, can result in rust.
I would avoid getting it on your skin, in your eyes, or on plastic or a wood stocks. The stuff is pretty nasty.
Oh, by the way, if you heat up chlorinated break cleaner, the resulting gas can do really harmful things to your nervous system.
Welkin is an archaic, English term; it refers to the sky, the upper air, the firmament, the heavens or the Celestial sphere. Heaven and Earth, in other words. When you make the welkin ring, the sound is only comparable to Hiroshima and Nagasaki after a visit from the Enola Gay and Bockscar, a hand grenade in your own personal foxhole, or the stupid next door neighbors playing rap music at full volume.
Oh read not the instructions, for the guy behind the counter knows more than the guy who made it.
@ dale freeman
There, now you know Dave is archaic.
Really? I cant think of anything else to say?
Zermoid: That is the method I have used to date and, of course, it works.
Del in KS: I have read of your method, but being naturally lazy, I'm not crazy about running around town to get all that stuff.
Sarge: never heard of Windex, but it does appeal to my lazy nature.
Which is why I asked whether Gun Scrubber works on BP/substitutes - I already have some of that and it is muzzleloader season here in SWFLA. But I don't think anyone answered the question. What say ye, gang?
To Ed J.
I don't believe a word of it.
I am an American, he's my uncle, so that makes him an AMERICAN ##
To Ed J.
I don't believe a word of it.
I am an American, he's my uncle, so that makes him an AMERICAN ##
As previously stated, most of the lugnuts at "gun shops" last gig was selling cell phones at the mall or Best Buy. The comments by 'crm3006' ring all too true. I have heard countless ludicrous pearls of wisdom while waiting to ask if an item was in stock, etc.
Me-Two boxes of .22 rimfire please. Checkout person-Wadda ya huntin, deers ?
Sounds like gun counter salesman are about like computer salesman.
Q: What's the difference between a computer salesman and a used car salesman.
A: A used car salesman knows when he's lying to you.
I shoot yotes at 1000 yards on the run. Overheard at a gun counter in Billings. The old boy spinning that yarn couldn't have walked a 100 yards let alone 1000 without having a massive heart attack.
"son are you sure you want a .300 weatherby? this thing will kick you death, most men cant handle it". yea im sure give me the damn gun!
gun counter folks LOL
scratchgolf72
How's that .300 Roy working out for you?
I'm just happy if they hold the pickle, hold the lettuce. I have found that in 95% of the cases it's better if you rely on your own judgement. If you think about it it wasn't MIT or becoming a Barista.
I like good ole hoppes #9 by the way someone should tell John_written_words that it's brake fluid not break fluid!
Actually I used this gun scrubber on my pre-1970, fox/savage 16 gauge side by side and it took patches of the clear coat off the stock and forearm. I did not mean to get it on the wood but it is all most impossible not to.
gun scrubber is awesome for cleaning inside the actions and barrels. when i need to clean regular firearms of others before i work on them i use a lot of rubbing alcohol that is 95% or more. don't be a moron only use gun products on your guns. c.v.a. makes some of the best cleaner for black powder substitutes. when some person puts on his big girl panties behind the counter and tries to give me some of his minimal experienced advice i just tell him or her that i'm a gunsmith so you can't tell me something i don't already know. it shuts them up. to the guy who tells you i can hit something running at anything over about 300 yards needs is eyes checked and better turn his guns into the ethical hunting police.
ME - Do you have any 303 ammo?
Young man behind counter - 303, 303, never heard of it
Me - British 303, 303 Infield ??
Young man - No I have 3030 and 3006 ....
Me - Never mind...........
Ballistol this stuff really works well for a lot of applications. That reminds me I need to buy an other can it comes in spray cans or non aerosol containers. Look it up.
[quote]Use Ballistol and experience all that this wonderful product has to offer!
FIREARMS - Cleans & dissolves traces of copper, lead, brass, zinc, & tombac. Lubricates & protects firearms, lock, stock & barrel. Forms a film that protects against rust. Will never gum-up or harden. Ideal for pistol grips, & rifle stocks. Removes residue from corrosive ammo.
BLACK POWDER - Dissolves black powder residues. Emulsifies with water. Mildly alkaline, neutralizes acids. Excellent patch lube.
LEATHER - Use on boots, shoes, gloves, holsters, slings, & saddles. Protects leather against water. Keeps leather soft & pliable, will darken lighter colors. Do not use on suede.
KNIVES & TOOLS - Lubricates, cleans, & protects metal, plastic, rubber, & wood. Outstanding penetrating oil, creeps into the finest cracks, loosens nuts & bolts. Also use as a cutting/boring oil (5:1 or 10:1).
MARINE - Use in motor compartments, on joints, links, wire pulls, & around battery terminals. Protects electrical contacts. Beautifies faded gel coats. Lubricates zippers, push buttons, & winches. Great for fishing rods, reels, & tackle. Protects Aluminum, prevents pitting.
ROAD & TRAIL - Lubricates autos, motorcycles, bicycles, rollerblades, skateboards, skis, & sports equipment. Protects all camping gear.[/quote]
@ Del in KS
What grade hydrogen peroxide? The drug store 1% or something stronger?
I use the drug store stuff works fine. Made a batch couple weeks ago. Now I'm set for at least a year.
I went to the gun counter at a Bass Pro:
"Do you have any black powder?"
The lights went out in the clerk's eyes. He points to the reloading section and says, "All our powder is over there, but I don't know what color it is."
Sigh
My method of cleaning muzzleloading rifles:
1. Remove barrel from stock.
2. Remove nipple.
3. Squirt some soap into the commode. I usually flush it first. :-)
4. Put breech end of barrel into the same commode.
5. Run cotton mop up and down through the barrel. This pull water into the barrel and then pushes it out.
6. Flush. Now you have clean rinse water. Rinse barrel the same way.
7. Dry and oil barrel. I like to use Ballistol or Bore Butter.
Pulp, That's a good idea if you don't have a wife. Now to figure out how to haul the toilet to the range.
Post a Comment
I have received a lot of very odd advice and comments, most stated as indisputable fact, from the Guy at the gun store.
Among the classics:
1. CCI Mini-Mag solids are "armour piercing" rounds.
2. There is no such thing as a .222. "Sir, it is a .223."
3. A Springfield Armory M1A is a "machine gun" and cannot be bought.
4. Only Savage makes left-handed rifles, and they are "cheap and no good."
5. There is no such thing as a .41 Remington Magnum. "it is a .44 Magnum, like Dirty Harry used."
6. 7 1/2 shot won't kill doves. It is only a trap load.
7. "A .30-'06 won't kill a deer past 300 yds."
8. Have been offered .45 ACP for .45 LC, and told "They are the same thing."
9. "You can't change the barrels in a Remington 1100. It has to be done at the factory."
10. "You don't need to clean your black powder rifle if you use lard for patch lube. That's what the mountain men did."
There are more, but I think these are the top ten.
Most advice your obtain from gun counters is fertilizer at best.
Yep. I have used it to clean my firearm barrels for a few years now and have found it to be efficient in cleaning the barrel of any residual powder as well as through. It is very harmful to any wood finish so remove the barrel to treat it. It is faster than a wire brush and running an endless number of wads to get a barrel clean. Make sure you use it in a vented area.
Sounds like gun counter salesman are about like computer salesman.
Q: What's the difference between a computer salesman and a used car salesman.
A: A used car salesman knows when he's lying to you.
does it come in a 55 gallon drum? home depot has a pressure washer on sale and I have a high school trap team in need of a gun cleaning lesson
Carb cleaner, and in this case gun scrubber, is an oxydizer. Mixing it with wood may not dry it out, but mixing wood that has come in contact with the scrubber and an ignition source will give a new meaning to the word firearm.
I've gotten it both in my eye and on my skin. Probably explains a lot right there.
For Black powder I've always used old fashioned HOT water and dish detergent, take the barrel off, use a tight fitting wet patch and jag, stick the flash hole under the water and work the ramrod. It will draw the water in thru the flash hole and clean it out real well in a few minutes. Repeat with Clean Hot water as a rinse, Dry patch the barrel til dry then coat the bore with bore butter or other patch lube type grease.
Personally I'd worry more about the wood getting wet with oil or water than drying it out!
Welkin is an archaic, English term; it refers to the sky, the upper air, the firmament, the heavens or the Celestial sphere. Heaven and Earth, in other words. When you make the welkin ring, the sound is only comparable to Hiroshima and Nagasaki after a visit from the Enola Gay and Bockscar, a hand grenade in your own personal foxhole, or the stupid next door neighbors playing rap music at full volume.
"son are you sure you want a .300 weatherby? this thing will kick you death, most men cant handle it". yea im sure give me the damn gun!
gun counter folks LOL
Be careful with the carburetor cleaner (aka Gun Scrubber). Don't get it on your skin, breathe it or have it anywhere near a flame. The resulting explosion will rearrange your gun room faster than a shu mine doing the same to your foot.
Carb cleaner and Gun Scrubber aren't the same. The closest thing to Gun Scrubber in an automotive product is a chlorinated brake cleaner.
Does Gun Scrubber work for muzzleloaders, too? ie, Pyrodex?
Longbeard, Mix equal parts Murphy oil soap, Denatured alcohol and Hydrogen peroxide. Store it in a brown bottle it is the best solvent for Black powder and bp substitutes I have ever used. Also much cheaper than store bought.
I use windex to clean black powder guns' must be the amonia...
Gun scrubber--Kerosene. Cheap and effective. Soaking parts takes a while, but is safe on bluing and other metal coatings. Worried about the wood? Take the stock off.
Black powder—tough to beat a mix of windshield solvent cleaner and plain soap.
crm3006
Did you drop of a "SIGN" for them? LMAO!
I don't know about goofy advice from gun salesmen, but here is my favorite......When I ask the buffoon behind the counter for a box of .250 Savage, the usual answer is "Whut?"
Dave and All,
Gun Scrubber is excellent. I've been using it for four years. It's the application that's harmful to guns.
The full power stuff cannot be used on pistols or rifles with synthetic stocks. The first can I bought I ruined the plastic grips on my Ruger MkII pistol. Can't imagine how I would react if I had sprayed it on a rifle with a McMillan stock.
Remove barreled actions when using this stuff. I do understand they are making plastic friendly stuff, haven't seen it though.
Dave;
That din't work so good did it/
Rest assured "I still love ya".
By the way, what the hell is a welkin ring ?
I also use break cleaner. You can get chlorinated and non-chlorinated break cleaner at Wal-Mart for a lot less than you can get Gun Scrubber.
Works great for getting into cracks and crevices.
Break cleaner does a great job of removing crud, oil and grease, which if not followed by some sort of oil, can result in rust.
I would avoid getting it on your skin, in your eyes, or on plastic or a wood stocks. The stuff is pretty nasty.
Oh, by the way, if you heat up chlorinated break cleaner, the resulting gas can do really harmful things to your nervous system.
Oh read not the instructions, for the guy behind the counter knows more than the guy who made it.
@ dale freeman
There, now you know Dave is archaic.
Really? I cant think of anything else to say?
Zermoid: That is the method I have used to date and, of course, it works.
Del in KS: I have read of your method, but being naturally lazy, I'm not crazy about running around town to get all that stuff.
Sarge: never heard of Windex, but it does appeal to my lazy nature.
Which is why I asked whether Gun Scrubber works on BP/substitutes - I already have some of that and it is muzzleloader season here in SWFLA. But I don't think anyone answered the question. What say ye, gang?
To Ed J.
I don't believe a word of it.
I am an American, he's my uncle, so that makes him an AMERICAN ##
To Ed J.
I don't believe a word of it.
I am an American, he's my uncle, so that makes him an AMERICAN ##
As previously stated, most of the lugnuts at "gun shops" last gig was selling cell phones at the mall or Best Buy. The comments by 'crm3006' ring all too true. I have heard countless ludicrous pearls of wisdom while waiting to ask if an item was in stock, etc.
Me-Two boxes of .22 rimfire please. Checkout person-Wadda ya huntin, deers ?
I shoot yotes at 1000 yards on the run. Overheard at a gun counter in Billings. The old boy spinning that yarn couldn't have walked a 100 yards let alone 1000 without having a massive heart attack.
scratchgolf72
How's that .300 Roy working out for you?
I'm just happy if they hold the pickle, hold the lettuce. I have found that in 95% of the cases it's better if you rely on your own judgement. If you think about it it wasn't MIT or becoming a Barista.
I like good ole hoppes #9 by the way someone should tell John_written_words that it's brake fluid not break fluid!
Actually I used this gun scrubber on my pre-1970, fox/savage 16 gauge side by side and it took patches of the clear coat off the stock and forearm. I did not mean to get it on the wood but it is all most impossible not to.
gun scrubber is awesome for cleaning inside the actions and barrels. when i need to clean regular firearms of others before i work on them i use a lot of rubbing alcohol that is 95% or more. don't be a moron only use gun products on your guns. c.v.a. makes some of the best cleaner for black powder substitutes. when some person puts on his big girl panties behind the counter and tries to give me some of his minimal experienced advice i just tell him or her that i'm a gunsmith so you can't tell me something i don't already know. it shuts them up. to the guy who tells you i can hit something running at anything over about 300 yards needs is eyes checked and better turn his guns into the ethical hunting police.
ME - Do you have any 303 ammo?
Young man behind counter - 303, 303, never heard of it
Me - British 303, 303 Infield ??
Young man - No I have 3030 and 3006 ....
Me - Never mind...........
Ballistol this stuff really works well for a lot of applications. That reminds me I need to buy an other can it comes in spray cans or non aerosol containers. Look it up.
[quote]Use Ballistol and experience all that this wonderful product has to offer!
FIREARMS - Cleans & dissolves traces of copper, lead, brass, zinc, & tombac. Lubricates & protects firearms, lock, stock & barrel. Forms a film that protects against rust. Will never gum-up or harden. Ideal for pistol grips, & rifle stocks. Removes residue from corrosive ammo.
BLACK POWDER - Dissolves black powder residues. Emulsifies with water. Mildly alkaline, neutralizes acids. Excellent patch lube.
LEATHER - Use on boots, shoes, gloves, holsters, slings, & saddles. Protects leather against water. Keeps leather soft & pliable, will darken lighter colors. Do not use on suede.
KNIVES & TOOLS - Lubricates, cleans, & protects metal, plastic, rubber, & wood. Outstanding penetrating oil, creeps into the finest cracks, loosens nuts & bolts. Also use as a cutting/boring oil (5:1 or 10:1).
MARINE - Use in motor compartments, on joints, links, wire pulls, & around battery terminals. Protects electrical contacts. Beautifies faded gel coats. Lubricates zippers, push buttons, & winches. Great for fishing rods, reels, & tackle. Protects Aluminum, prevents pitting.
ROAD & TRAIL - Lubricates autos, motorcycles, bicycles, rollerblades, skateboards, skis, & sports equipment. Protects all camping gear.[/quote]
@ Del in KS
What grade hydrogen peroxide? The drug store 1% or something stronger?
I use the drug store stuff works fine. Made a batch couple weeks ago. Now I'm set for at least a year.
I went to the gun counter at a Bass Pro:
"Do you have any black powder?"
The lights went out in the clerk's eyes. He points to the reloading section and says, "All our powder is over there, but I don't know what color it is."
Sigh
My method of cleaning muzzleloading rifles:
1. Remove barrel from stock.
2. Remove nipple.
3. Squirt some soap into the commode. I usually flush it first. :-)
4. Put breech end of barrel into the same commode.
5. Run cotton mop up and down through the barrel. This pull water into the barrel and then pushes it out.
6. Flush. Now you have clean rinse water. Rinse barrel the same way.
7. Dry and oil barrel. I like to use Ballistol or Bore Butter.
Pulp, That's a good idea if you don't have a wife. Now to figure out how to haul the toilet to the range.
Save your money and use carburetor cleaner. It's the same stuff, only cheaper.
Post a Comment