Please Sign In

Please enter a valid username and password
  • Log in with Facebook
» Not a member? Take a moment to register
» Forgot Username or Password

Why Register?
Signing up could earn you gear (click here to learn how)! It also keeps offensive content off our site.

Are Stickbaits Part of your Trout Stream Arsenal?

Recent Comments

Categories

Recent Posts

Archives

Syndicate

Google Reader or Homepage
Add to My Yahoo!
Add to My AOL

The Honest Angler
in your Inbox

Enter your email address to get our new post everyday.

December 06, 2011

Are Stickbaits Part of your Trout Stream Arsenal?

by Joe Cermele

Over the years I've made an observation about trout fishermen, particularly those that chase a lot of stocked fish. By and large, they remain loyal to the first lure their dads or grandpas gave them at a young age. For me that lure is a Panther Martin spinner. Is a Panther really better than other spinners? Probably not, but that's what dad used. Friends of mine are loyal to the Mepps or the C.P. Swing or the Phoebe. I usually have some combo of those other spinners in my box, but I always tied up a Panther first. One lure I never carried growing up, however, was a stickbait. Dad never used them, so I never used them. I reserved such lures for smallmouth. It's taken a while for me to come around, but I realize now what a mistake I was making.

During the last five trout seasons or so, my beloved Panther Martin has actually become the "on deck" lure. Most of the time I'll start a trip with a small stickbait, especially in the fall and winter when it's beneficial to have the ability to work a bait slowly for sluggish fish in colder water. Growing up I suppose I always thought stickbaits were just too big for trout. That changed during a late-spring smallmouth wade a few years ago when I couldn't catch bass because holdover trout in a run were beating them all to my lure.

Though I'm still never on the river without a Panther Martin, I am also never without a 2 1/2-inch Rapala X-Rap, a 2-inch Yo-Zuri PINS Minnow, and a 2 1/2-inch Trout Magnet Trout Crank, which took the brookie above a few weeks ago. I like these particular lures because with a little effort you can get them near the bottom of a deep pool, but they don't dive deep enough while subtly twitching or swinging that they'll hang in a shallow riffle. 

I realize that there is likely a bunch of you who have been tossing similar lures since you were knee high to a grasshopper, but I promise in my Northeast neck of the woods, I still get the occasional odd stare from the gents I know have nothing but Panthers, Roostertails, Mepps, and Little Cleos in their boxes.

Comments (22)

Top Rated
All Comments
from Outsider wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

I was gonna comment on the X-Rap, i just recently found them and now have 4 of them in my trout box for when i spin fish.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from rjw wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

I would have to say I am guilty of sticking to Panthers when it comes to fishing trout in streams/creeks. Although the next time I hit my favorite trout waters I will be throwing a stick bait.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Koldkut wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

We throw rogues here for trout Joe. They work well in the winter time.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from derik wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

Some of our best days are throwing rapalas in teh deep holes.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from WesternMassHole wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

I prefer spinners to Rapala in trout waters because if you snag spinner on a rock or branch you are only out $3-$4 while a rapala will cost you $8-$10.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from rdorman wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

only ever use them late fall/early winter...

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from jeffo52284 wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

I love my rapala and its my go to when the fish aren't biting but in summer time you still cant beat a good spinner

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from jcarlin wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

It was the Lehigh up at Jim Thorpe that taught me to keep some stick baits at hand for trout fishing. Was having no luck on trout all morning in a nice slack pool with a good current line throwing my normal trout repertoire. Gave up and told My Father-in-Law that I was switching to see if I couldn't catch a few smallies. If I remember the lure in question was a 3" Rapella in a perch pattern. The second cast brought in a 15".. I can't believe I'm not remembering if it was a Brown or Rainbow, but I believe a Brown off the wall. Father in law imitated and caught a significantly larger one.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from 2lb.test wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

Joe this is right up my ally. I've been using them for a couple years now, but my go to bait is a tiny little pink worm made by powerbait on a tiny 1/16th oz. jig head. It drifts well in fast water, or can be twitched in slack pools.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from vayotehowler wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

Pumokin seed rosetertail with gold blade. Buddy of mine was fishing side by side and dragging another rooster tail in a honneyhole of mine and they would seim under his lure to get the roostertail

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Chinook627 wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

I also never leave my house without a few of these lures in the box. For the stocked trout, a small gold floating rapala crushes them when spinners or spoons stop working. These lures seem to favor the bigger browns by me which is why I like them so much and some of the hits feel like the the rod is being pulled out of your hands. I've also found that the floating versions work well on stocked lakes and ponds when the fish are rising to a hatch. A lot of guys by me never think to throw these lures but that's ok by me, because its just like you say, they don't know what they're missing.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from tourneyking734 wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

Just an F.Y.I. the jointed rapalas are much better in the early spring and fall, cause they have action at speeds way slower than any normal stickbait.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Blue Ox wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

Mepps!!! A #1 or 2 mepps aglia- dressed in white with either silver or gold blade.
Never fails!

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from varmit slayer wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

got a few in my box but never had much luck with em.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from fliphuntr14 wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

i have never thought to try a stick bait in trout waters but i think i will have to in some of the larger streams I fish in the early spring. There is a rather large hole in the ice in a local lake i fish and i may have to try and run a few of these across it this winter, suppose to hold the large browns the lake has that few people catch. I fish the walleye spawn with these in good tributaries to lake michigan and I think the trout get wary of them in these places and they are the bait of choice of everyone fishing the walleye.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from jakenbake wrote 24 weeks 2 days ago

I started with Roostertails and Panther Martins but I always have one of the Pin-Minnows in my box now. And a crawfish crank as well, especially in the fall.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from labrador12 wrote 24 weeks 2 days ago

Flatfish is another sleeper.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from yukonpetey wrote 24 weeks 2 days ago

the majority of my 17 inch plus trout have fallen victim to a #3, 5 or 7 rapala in black/gold, either floating or Countdown, depending on water levels. started carrying pins minnos over the years as well, and after reading your article in F&S last year on the new generation of classic lures, I started experimenting with xraps, which have done very well for me this past summer on the Musconetcong and Big Flatbrook. Last thing I need is to clear another space in my vest lure box for a trout magent crankbait, but I must say you have got me thinking about it, Joe.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from willedebeast wrote 24 weeks 2 days ago

Heck yes rapalas are in my trout tackle box, right along with 4" turtle back worms. I kept getting what I though were short strikes while Texas rigged for bass, when I added a stinger hook to the worm I caught trout after trout on them. I have used the setup several times since and it has nearly always worked wonderfully.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from themadflyfisher wrote 24 weeks 2 days ago

A couple years ago on a semi-crowded stream when nobody was catching anything, this guy comes walking threw throwing a silverish stickbait and getting hits and catching fish literaly on every cast. After talking with him he said it's all he uses. Since then I have always tried them but only ever had minimal success.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from AmericanFishFinder wrote 24 weeks 16 hours ago

Good post. My favorite Rapala Lure is a 4inch countdown Perch. I have caught many a good fish down at Fish Lake in Utah including a Lake Trout. This particular is cursed in my tackle box however. Every trip so far I have taken down to Fish Lake I have lost the lure some way or other after catching a few good sized fish. I now stock up on those whenever I hit up on Cabelas to ensure I have plenty for my next trip down to Fish Lake.

Good Post thanks.

Come get your fishing reports, fishing regulations and other information to give you a great fishing adventure. Join our forum to participate with other fishermen in your area.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from North-Georgia-O... wrote 20 weeks 3 days ago

We live around small streams and in the summer we throw Rapala Original Floaters in the small sizes and catch the bigger trout in our stream. And the Spotted Bass also come up out of the lakes into the streams and we catch almost more Bass than we do Trout.

0 Good Comment? | | Report

Post a Comment

from WesternMassHole wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

I prefer spinners to Rapala in trout waters because if you snag spinner on a rock or branch you are only out $3-$4 while a rapala will cost you $8-$10.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from derik wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

Some of our best days are throwing rapalas in teh deep holes.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from labrador12 wrote 24 weeks 2 days ago

Flatfish is another sleeper.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from Outsider wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

I was gonna comment on the X-Rap, i just recently found them and now have 4 of them in my trout box for when i spin fish.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from rjw wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

I would have to say I am guilty of sticking to Panthers when it comes to fishing trout in streams/creeks. Although the next time I hit my favorite trout waters I will be throwing a stick bait.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Koldkut wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

We throw rogues here for trout Joe. They work well in the winter time.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from rdorman wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

only ever use them late fall/early winter...

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from jeffo52284 wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

I love my rapala and its my go to when the fish aren't biting but in summer time you still cant beat a good spinner

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from jcarlin wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

It was the Lehigh up at Jim Thorpe that taught me to keep some stick baits at hand for trout fishing. Was having no luck on trout all morning in a nice slack pool with a good current line throwing my normal trout repertoire. Gave up and told My Father-in-Law that I was switching to see if I couldn't catch a few smallies. If I remember the lure in question was a 3" Rapella in a perch pattern. The second cast brought in a 15".. I can't believe I'm not remembering if it was a Brown or Rainbow, but I believe a Brown off the wall. Father in law imitated and caught a significantly larger one.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from 2lb.test wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

Joe this is right up my ally. I've been using them for a couple years now, but my go to bait is a tiny little pink worm made by powerbait on a tiny 1/16th oz. jig head. It drifts well in fast water, or can be twitched in slack pools.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from vayotehowler wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

Pumokin seed rosetertail with gold blade. Buddy of mine was fishing side by side and dragging another rooster tail in a honneyhole of mine and they would seim under his lure to get the roostertail

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Chinook627 wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

I also never leave my house without a few of these lures in the box. For the stocked trout, a small gold floating rapala crushes them when spinners or spoons stop working. These lures seem to favor the bigger browns by me which is why I like them so much and some of the hits feel like the the rod is being pulled out of your hands. I've also found that the floating versions work well on stocked lakes and ponds when the fish are rising to a hatch. A lot of guys by me never think to throw these lures but that's ok by me, because its just like you say, they don't know what they're missing.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from tourneyking734 wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

Just an F.Y.I. the jointed rapalas are much better in the early spring and fall, cause they have action at speeds way slower than any normal stickbait.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Blue Ox wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

Mepps!!! A #1 or 2 mepps aglia- dressed in white with either silver or gold blade.
Never fails!

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from varmit slayer wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

got a few in my box but never had much luck with em.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from fliphuntr14 wrote 24 weeks 3 days ago

i have never thought to try a stick bait in trout waters but i think i will have to in some of the larger streams I fish in the early spring. There is a rather large hole in the ice in a local lake i fish and i may have to try and run a few of these across it this winter, suppose to hold the large browns the lake has that few people catch. I fish the walleye spawn with these in good tributaries to lake michigan and I think the trout get wary of them in these places and they are the bait of choice of everyone fishing the walleye.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from jakenbake wrote 24 weeks 2 days ago

I started with Roostertails and Panther Martins but I always have one of the Pin-Minnows in my box now. And a crawfish crank as well, especially in the fall.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from yukonpetey wrote 24 weeks 2 days ago

the majority of my 17 inch plus trout have fallen victim to a #3, 5 or 7 rapala in black/gold, either floating or Countdown, depending on water levels. started carrying pins minnos over the years as well, and after reading your article in F&S last year on the new generation of classic lures, I started experimenting with xraps, which have done very well for me this past summer on the Musconetcong and Big Flatbrook. Last thing I need is to clear another space in my vest lure box for a trout magent crankbait, but I must say you have got me thinking about it, Joe.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from willedebeast wrote 24 weeks 2 days ago

Heck yes rapalas are in my trout tackle box, right along with 4" turtle back worms. I kept getting what I though were short strikes while Texas rigged for bass, when I added a stinger hook to the worm I caught trout after trout on them. I have used the setup several times since and it has nearly always worked wonderfully.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from themadflyfisher wrote 24 weeks 2 days ago

A couple years ago on a semi-crowded stream when nobody was catching anything, this guy comes walking threw throwing a silverish stickbait and getting hits and catching fish literaly on every cast. After talking with him he said it's all he uses. Since then I have always tried them but only ever had minimal success.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from AmericanFishFinder wrote 24 weeks 16 hours ago

Good post. My favorite Rapala Lure is a 4inch countdown Perch. I have caught many a good fish down at Fish Lake in Utah including a Lake Trout. This particular is cursed in my tackle box however. Every trip so far I have taken down to Fish Lake I have lost the lure some way or other after catching a few good sized fish. I now stock up on those whenever I hit up on Cabelas to ensure I have plenty for my next trip down to Fish Lake.

Good Post thanks.

Come get your fishing reports, fishing regulations and other information to give you a great fishing adventure. Join our forum to participate with other fishermen in your area.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from North-Georgia-O... wrote 20 weeks 3 days ago

We live around small streams and in the summer we throw Rapala Original Floaters in the small sizes and catch the bigger trout in our stream. And the Spotted Bass also come up out of the lakes into the streams and we catch almost more Bass than we do Trout.

0 Good Comment? | | Report

Post a Comment

bmxbiz-fs