


March 01, 2010
Petzal: A Pair of Peerless Pendletons
By David E. Petzal
When it comes to sheer variety, no cutlery company comes close to Cold Steel. Where else can you get Zulu spears, Russian Special Forces e-tools, machetes, tomahawks, and fixed- and folding-blade knives, and all other manner of weird edged weapons, all on the same website?
Lynn Thompson, the guy who heads the company, has long been friends with custom knifemaker Lloyd Pendleton, and is now offering two Pendleton-designed fixed-blade hunting knives which are more than worthy of your consideration.
The first is the Pendleton Custom Classic (bottom), a handmade knife with a black micarta handle, stainless steel hilt, and a 3 ½-inch blade of VG-1 San Mai steel. San Mai is Japanese for “three layers”—in this case, a hard steel core sandwiched between two softer steels. The spine is quite thick, but the blade is deeply hollow ground, and the edge can best be described as supernatural. I don’t think you can get a knife sharper than this. It comes with a most excellent tan-leather sheath. The price is a penny shy of $500, but for that you get an eminently usable, virtually indestructible tool that is as nicely made as anything you can get from anyone.
If that’s too rich for your blood, I commend to you the Pendleton Lite Hunter (top), which has essentially the same blade shape, but is made of Krupp 4116 stainless. It has a polypropylene handle, a Cordura sheath, and a price of $21.99. For the past three years I’ve kept a Cold Steel Finn Bear, which has the same construction, in my garage, and I use it for all the nasty, rotten jobs that come along. I have to resharpen it every few weeks, but otherwise I can’t make it blink. Nor will you be able to faze the Lite Hunter.
Comments (37)
To illustrate what an old geezer I am, I remember very clearly when a REAL Lloyd Pendleton knife sold for $250 to $300! It makes me wonder what a knife personally made by Pendleton would cost today!
Cold Steel makes some awesome blades and puts out an amusing cutting demonstration video. Their "cheap" blades hold an edge well and their expensive blades, well say no more...
I have a couple Cold Steel knives and have nothing but complements...
Dave, thanks for bringing in a knife for us poor working slobs that sells for less than $25. Sounds like a good "spare" to pack as an extra, heck at the price buy two! If it is a Cold Steal product it will be a good'un.
Dave,
Your kind words and recommendations of the Pendleton Lite Hunter has resulted in factory back order for the knife... and I was so excited...
Pretty. Until you handle a hand made knife you don't know why they are so expensive. After you handle one you wonder why they are so reasonable.
Own a couple of Lloyd's knifes from years Ago. They have great blades. The only caution I have is the knife pictured at the bottom has exposed metal where the lanyard hole is located. That exposed metal can, and will scratch a nice rifle stock if they come together. Lloyd and his wive are great folks, and he is a true craftsman. Nice to see some good press for him
I'm so glad that the article turned out to be about knives instead of sweaters!
I like the cold steel products I've bought and used. Their Latin Machetes are just not quite right, though. Too thick.
Nice looking blades. Since I have all the knives I need, I would opt for the $21.99 Lite Hunter since I want it for a spare.
To Beekeeper: This one ain't my fault. It's a brand-new knife, and they haven't been able to keep up with the orders, I guess.
Dave,
You just don't know the power your words have over the unwashed masses and even a few that wash periodically...
I'll keep an eye out for a fresh shipment!
If $500 is buying me a hunting/outdoors knife, it's gunna be a Randall.
I really like my Cold Steel knives and can't wait to get one of these. Guess which one? It won't be the one I want but it will be the one I'll use. Thanks for the good report, Dave.
Both are goodlooking blades, one is too rich for my budget, but very nice nonetheless.
Both are goodlooking blades, one is too rich for my budget, but very nice nonetheless.
To Beekeper: As Ed Zern once said: "The farther you get from centers of literacy, the more famous I am."
Those are both fine looking knives. I like that blade design for skinning and dressing.
hi_tail, no if $500 is going to buy me a knife it will be a Kraemer or two for the kitchen and I'd sneak one out for hunting, if I could get in line to have him make me one.
Nice knives; the $21.99 model is more in my budget...I like the blade design,too.
Dave,
When is the mutch anticipated review of the new R8 coming? Patience has to be saved for the woods, not on waiting for your prized reviews...
Wow!!!! I have a fin bear as well. I agree about the quality of cold steel they are a good company.
ypuve convinced me... im gonna get one of those 21 dollar ones, 500 dollars is way to much for a knife in my book, is the 21 dollar one hand made as well?
I like the look of the Light Hunter, and I've been looking for a wallet-friendly utility knife. I bought a Master Hunter when I was 15 for $80, and 15 years later it is still the best knife that I have ever owned.
To Chet 45: R8s were supposed to be available in February. I am waiting more or less patiently.
Dave,
I know this is not on subject but it is something good to read about our politicians and their failure to protect us. The level of BS coming from the current administration is unbelievable.
http://www.humanevents.com/article.php?id=35806
That looks like a good deal however my knife drawer runneth over. The recent purchase of the Buck Ergo hunter put me in the position of needing something to field dress more than needing another blade. I'll have a look at Beekeeper's blade when we go hunting this fall.
Many thanks Del for passing that info on!!
Cold Steel makes some nice products and they've been around a while, but the best hunting knifes I've come across is the cutco line. I have both their hunting and fishing knives received as gifts. They stay incredibly sharp and if they fail to do so, you can send them in for free factory sharpening. (although I've not had to do so yet) They also carry a lifetime replacement warranty. The serrated edge makes VERY quick work of field dressing, skinning, and butchering. They're under $100 and one of mine is engraved with my initials. They have blaze orange handles so I can find them even in low light conditions, and they're made right here in the US.
Jim in Mo-
Same idea, different maker. My point is that, $500 should buy me more than Japanese steel and Micarta scales [nothing against either, just the price].
The Pendleton Custom Classic is a fantastic piece of design and build, but $500 is way a lot of cash when you can have the same steel and $400 in change. The only place you can have VG-1 San Mai steel from is in Japan and they also make knives for a swedish knife company called Fallkniven. Have a look in google for Fallkniven F1 - used by lots of special forces guys and made as a survival knife for the sub arctic - lot of knife for $100.
SBW
PS Still want the Pendleton though
hi_tail, I totally agree, I was just saying I better get more out of a knife!
Nothing wrong with my old 15 year old or so Cold Steel Master Hunter, their blades last forever. The San Mui construction reminds me somewhat of my elderly Morseth that I no longer use because I am afraid I will loose it in the mountains and can't replace. I even pack one of their tomahawks on my saddle finding all kinds of uses for it from driving tent stakes into rocky ground to splitting elk pelvis easily.
$500 for a KNIFE??????
I can get a nice gun for that much! Not great, but nice.
I thought $50 for my Buck folder was alot......
$500 for a knife? Really? Do you just have to tell it "Go skin that deer," and it does it? Dave, I love ya, but you have compeletely lost it. Oh, I know it's a "classic, high-quality, once-in-a-lifetime purchase."
But, comeon man. Who in the real world of working for a living and hunting and fishing when we can would possibly shell out the airfare to a Canadian goose hunt for a knife?
My humble opinion.
As a Big Game Outfitter I know the value of a great knife. For the past 25 years I have used any number of knives and I know what works. While I have never owned a Pendleton, I do have knives by Ed Fowler, Weldon Whitley, Bob Dozier, Clyde Fisher and Ralph Bone. All are fantastic knives of superior steel with great edge holding ability and none with the exception of the Dozier can be had for under $500. You get what you pay for.
After reading the article I called Cold Steel and bought the Lite Hunter. They had just recieved a shipment so it arrived in less than a week. It is a great knife. The price was $17.99 plus $9.00 for shipping.
Thanks for the tip.
Silvertip
Why does no one ever mention the Chicago Cutlery 4" Skinning Knife? Apparantly hunters have gone the way of the marketing bandwagon, leave it to trappers to keep their common sense.
I may be biased, and may be ignored because I'm a rookie here, but I will take a Gerber and/or a Ka-Bar any day of the week, and twice on Sunday. They are very worthy of a hunting/fishing trip, and can get you out of almost as many jams as as a good length of rope. Just a thought.
Post a Comment
Dave, thanks for bringing in a knife for us poor working slobs that sells for less than $25. Sounds like a good "spare" to pack as an extra, heck at the price buy two! If it is a Cold Steal product it will be a good'un.
To Beekeper: As Ed Zern once said: "The farther you get from centers of literacy, the more famous I am."
Own a couple of Lloyd's knifes from years Ago. They have great blades. The only caution I have is the knife pictured at the bottom has exposed metal where the lanyard hole is located. That exposed metal can, and will scratch a nice rifle stock if they come together. Lloyd and his wive are great folks, and he is a true craftsman. Nice to see some good press for him
Nice looking blades. Since I have all the knives I need, I would opt for the $21.99 Lite Hunter since I want it for a spare.
Dave,
You just don't know the power your words have over the unwashed masses and even a few that wash periodically...
I'll keep an eye out for a fresh shipment!
Jim in Mo-
Same idea, different maker. My point is that, $500 should buy me more than Japanese steel and Micarta scales [nothing against either, just the price].
To illustrate what an old geezer I am, I remember very clearly when a REAL Lloyd Pendleton knife sold for $250 to $300! It makes me wonder what a knife personally made by Pendleton would cost today!
Cold Steel makes some awesome blades and puts out an amusing cutting demonstration video. Their "cheap" blades hold an edge well and their expensive blades, well say no more...
I have a couple Cold Steel knives and have nothing but complements...
I'm so glad that the article turned out to be about knives instead of sweaters!
I like the cold steel products I've bought and used. Their Latin Machetes are just not quite right, though. Too thick.
To Beekeeper: This one ain't my fault. It's a brand-new knife, and they haven't been able to keep up with the orders, I guess.
If $500 is buying me a hunting/outdoors knife, it's gunna be a Randall.
Those are both fine looking knives. I like that blade design for skinning and dressing.
That looks like a good deal however my knife drawer runneth over. The recent purchase of the Buck Ergo hunter put me in the position of needing something to field dress more than needing another blade. I'll have a look at Beekeeper's blade when we go hunting this fall.
Dave,
Your kind words and recommendations of the Pendleton Lite Hunter has resulted in factory back order for the knife... and I was so excited...
Pretty. Until you handle a hand made knife you don't know why they are so expensive. After you handle one you wonder why they are so reasonable.
I really like my Cold Steel knives and can't wait to get one of these. Guess which one? It won't be the one I want but it will be the one I'll use. Thanks for the good report, Dave.
Both are goodlooking blades, one is too rich for my budget, but very nice nonetheless.
hi_tail, no if $500 is going to buy me a knife it will be a Kraemer or two for the kitchen and I'd sneak one out for hunting, if I could get in line to have him make me one.
Nice knives; the $21.99 model is more in my budget...I like the blade design,too.
Dave,
When is the mutch anticipated review of the new R8 coming? Patience has to be saved for the woods, not on waiting for your prized reviews...
Wow!!!! I have a fin bear as well. I agree about the quality of cold steel they are a good company.
ypuve convinced me... im gonna get one of those 21 dollar ones, 500 dollars is way to much for a knife in my book, is the 21 dollar one hand made as well?
I like the look of the Light Hunter, and I've been looking for a wallet-friendly utility knife. I bought a Master Hunter when I was 15 for $80, and 15 years later it is still the best knife that I have ever owned.
To Chet 45: R8s were supposed to be available in February. I am waiting more or less patiently.
Dave,
I know this is not on subject but it is something good to read about our politicians and their failure to protect us. The level of BS coming from the current administration is unbelievable.
http://www.humanevents.com/article.php?id=35806
Cold Steel makes some nice products and they've been around a while, but the best hunting knifes I've come across is the cutco line. I have both their hunting and fishing knives received as gifts. They stay incredibly sharp and if they fail to do so, you can send them in for free factory sharpening. (although I've not had to do so yet) They also carry a lifetime replacement warranty. The serrated edge makes VERY quick work of field dressing, skinning, and butchering. They're under $100 and one of mine is engraved with my initials. They have blaze orange handles so I can find them even in low light conditions, and they're made right here in the US.
The Pendleton Custom Classic is a fantastic piece of design and build, but $500 is way a lot of cash when you can have the same steel and $400 in change. The only place you can have VG-1 San Mai steel from is in Japan and they also make knives for a swedish knife company called Fallkniven. Have a look in google for Fallkniven F1 - used by lots of special forces guys and made as a survival knife for the sub arctic - lot of knife for $100.
SBW
PS Still want the Pendleton though
$500 for a KNIFE??????
I can get a nice gun for that much! Not great, but nice.
I thought $50 for my Buck folder was alot......
$500 for a knife? Really? Do you just have to tell it "Go skin that deer," and it does it? Dave, I love ya, but you have compeletely lost it. Oh, I know it's a "classic, high-quality, once-in-a-lifetime purchase."
But, comeon man. Who in the real world of working for a living and hunting and fishing when we can would possibly shell out the airfare to a Canadian goose hunt for a knife?
My humble opinion.
Both are goodlooking blades, one is too rich for my budget, but very nice nonetheless.
Many thanks Del for passing that info on!!
hi_tail, I totally agree, I was just saying I better get more out of a knife!
Nothing wrong with my old 15 year old or so Cold Steel Master Hunter, their blades last forever. The San Mui construction reminds me somewhat of my elderly Morseth that I no longer use because I am afraid I will loose it in the mountains and can't replace. I even pack one of their tomahawks on my saddle finding all kinds of uses for it from driving tent stakes into rocky ground to splitting elk pelvis easily.
Why does no one ever mention the Chicago Cutlery 4" Skinning Knife? Apparantly hunters have gone the way of the marketing bandwagon, leave it to trappers to keep their common sense.
After reading the article I called Cold Steel and bought the Lite Hunter. They had just recieved a shipment so it arrived in less than a week. It is a great knife. The price was $17.99 plus $9.00 for shipping.
Thanks for the tip.
Silvertip
I may be biased, and may be ignored because I'm a rookie here, but I will take a Gerber and/or a Ka-Bar any day of the week, and twice on Sunday. They are very worthy of a hunting/fishing trip, and can get you out of almost as many jams as as a good length of rope. Just a thought.
As a Big Game Outfitter I know the value of a great knife. For the past 25 years I have used any number of knives and I know what works. While I have never owned a Pendleton, I do have knives by Ed Fowler, Weldon Whitley, Bob Dozier, Clyde Fisher and Ralph Bone. All are fantastic knives of superior steel with great edge holding ability and none with the exception of the Dozier can be had for under $500. You get what you pay for.
Post a Comment