


June 23, 2010
Do You Feed Your Dog Table Scraps?
By David DiBenedetto
For the better part of a year I held off from feeding anything to Pritchard that wasn’t dog food or a puppy biscuit. (Though on a tip from a trainer I often used Goldfish as a treat when doing early training work. They’re cheap and easy to carry in a pocket. Problem is, I ended up eating a hell of a lot of Goldfish, too.) I remained strong against my wife’s pleas to share our dinner leftovers with Pritchard—often a nugget of steak or strip of chicken. I refused simply because I did not want Pritch to become a table beggar or, worse, a dog that lunges for the tabletop and grabs a quick bite.
I eventually cracked. These days after a great training session or if I’m feeling especially generous, I’ll sneak a piece of meat in Pritchard’s bowl when our dinner is over. (I still will not feed Pritch anything directly from the table.) My wife swears she can see the delight on the dog’s face when she discovers her bonus morsel.
There is, of course, an entire sect of the dog owners who only feed their dogs home cooked meals. In fact, the Healthy Dog Cookbook has recipes ranging from a Doggie Delight Omelet to Salmon Pasta in Yogurt Dill Sauce. No Joke. I don’t have the time, the inclination, or the cash to cook for my pup, but I guess some people do. As always, I’m curious of your routine. You ever feed the pup table scraps? Would you cook a full meal for your dog? Or do you strictly stick to dog food? (If so, click here for some feeding guidelines.)
Comments (36)
I mostly feed Hoss dry dog food and I give him vitamins daily. I will sometimes give him bits of steak or chicken. When I take him to my bar sometimes I'll get one of the cooks to fix him a piece of grilled chicken. My wife informed me Sunday that he really likes strawberries. I've been told that I should get some frozen green beans to give as a healthy treat.
I have three all-time outdoor dogs and we mostly feed them dog food and a few treats here and there, but on saturdays they get all of the weeks scraps (besides very small chicken bones) Feeding your dog good-sized bones makes there jaw and teeth stronger and meat is healthy for dogs. We keep our dogs fenced into a 2 acre yard so they have good space. A lot of the dogs in the neighborhood are allowed to roam(All the cats too) the streets so they are usually used to people we got our newest and biggest dog 2 years ago to be a guard of us and the other dogs (the other dogs are can do a good job too though. When he weighed about 20 pounds we let him go aoutside with the other dogs and beong smaller he learned to defend himself. Just a few weeks after we put him outside he and the other dogs killed the biggest armadillo I have ever seen. When he is fighting he is unstoppable unless you can call him off. He does not feel much pain. When i kill a squirrel he eats it if I don't get it fast enough.
oh yeah and you have a very pretty dog. Reminds me of my spaniel mix dog that died she was so crazy and would fight anything. She climbed 20 feet up into trees to make sure the squirrel stayed in the tree.
My dog's act as our garbage disposal. They're outside dogs though, so we don't have the table-beggar issue. We usually just mix what scraps we have w/their dog food.
I'm in the same boat as you. I didnt want my pup being a table beggar or to steal my dinner if I stepped away. She sticks to her food and treats and thats it, and she couldn't be happy. Occasionally I'll throw a small piece of meat in with her food, but like you, not from the table.
Should have said "couldn't be happier"!
My dogs eat table scraps whenever I can't manage to finish(which isn't very often). They will even eat off the fork after I'm done. They also lick all the plates and pans clean for me. I know none of this is recommended but it works for me. They do sit patiently next to me while I eat but no one else is bothered. I really don't mind them sitting next to me while I eat so I just go with it. Feel free to thrash me if you feel like it.....
sloth-- No thrashing here. Whatever works for you and the dogs. Sounds like a patient bunch. -Dave
As a pre-vet medicine student, I asked professors, the vets I worked for in HS and college about this very topic. My parents raised papered and pedigree German Shepherds for as long as I can remember. I have had labs since I left college. The consensus among those I asked was, no table scraps directly from the table. Meat left on the bone, because of the protein, is great fare for the 4 legged member of the family. Stipulation: never feed pooch the same thing you're eating, at the same time you're at the dinner table. While doing the dishes is the time for scraps to be deposited in pooch's dish. Dogs will know by smell you have given him the same fare he smelled being prepared, that you ate, but will not make a "I eat when you eat and what you eat" connection.
I like how countitanddone said it. I hate to throw something away that my dog would love to gobble up, so when we're done and we get up from the table to clean up then if there's something left over she will get it in her bowl (if appropriate). If it's too much then I might save some for another day. She sits patiently under the table while we eat even though my toddler daughter frequently drops and sometimes tries to give things to her. Much better than my in-laws' dogs the tall one will try and get his nose up to your plate and the short one will try and climb your leg, but they get fed straight from the table, it really makes a big difference I guess.
yep, all my dogs have gotten table scraps but only AFTER the meal is done- I've never had a beggar in the whole bunch- they love people food and with only few exceptions everything we eat is A-OK for them- I hate wasting food!!
When I was weeding our vegetable garden last night I found out that my Setter pup Zip loves him some fresh collard greens. My old dog Bud has a strange hankering for cucumbers. Heck, even Cheese will go for some fresh green beans off the vine if she's not too busy chasing the pup. They all seem to like the raspberry patch quite a bit.
I toss 'em leftovers from time to time but nowhere near what I use to. I make sure they don't get into any chocolate, grapes and such. I figure if it's good enough for me to eat, then it's good enough for my pack to eat.
Had a lab the liked fried eggs or scrambled eggs.
Got a Walker that loves bacon.
I do not make a habit of feeding my dogs table scraps on a regular basis though
You fellows have it all wrong. I am happy feeding my dog at the table, and my dog loves it too. I find it keeps my mother-in-law from eating supper with us.
I started training my first dog with treats and what I got was a dog that ate the first bird he ever retrieved. This continued and worsened to the point you chased him down to get the bird. Not saying lots of dogs haven't successfully been trained with treats, just saying with my experience "Never again!" There are other successful ways to train that do not use it. My second dog lives on her dog food. She was raised that way and I have found a lot of hunting dogs to have stomachs that a change in diet like a treat of meat can lead to some killer gas that just isn't needed. I also abhor a dog that begs or follows people for food, I have tried to raise my son with manners why wouldn't I do the same thing with my dog? I have also really been convinced by pro trainers as well as vets to feed my dogs the best dog food expensive when it gets right down to it but it is the best of all worlds for your dog. Think of it, if they eat and love there food and don't know the difference all there lives they aren't missing out on anything. On the other hand if you feed your dog everything you eat, well lets face it very few of us eat like we really should and put our health at risk because of it but with your dog you have an easy choice to have them on an almost perfect diet. Your dog will live longer and suffer less ills in it's lifetime. And I just think when it comes to a gundog who definitely works more than I do she should have the best of it all. Happy, healthy and here for as long as I can control it. Of course thats what I do with mine everybody is different and I try hard not to tell another man what to do with his dog. Unless I am asked obviously! LOL
I normally don't intentionally give my lab "people food". We had steak the other night and my wife gave her a little piece of trimming. She took it back into the kitchen, spit it out, licked it a bit and then returned to her usual spot. I don't know if she knows what to do with it... maybe a bit more spoiling is in order. She tries to sneak into the dining room during dinner, but knows to vacate when I give her the "stink eye"
my dog has never been fed people food for as long as i have had him. he likes to lay under the table while i eat but he knows not to beg. one thing i have found is a treat from that fast food place called Good Times that serves the custard and burgers. it is custard mixed with dig treats and is meant for pets. Chaos gets one of those once a week and looks forward to it.
i steer clear from giving my lab any table scraps such as beef,chicken,etc. i will however share pieces of fruit/veggies with him at times. He loves strawberries, grapes, cantaloupe, and green bell peppers.
I have read that feeding dogs grapes can be serious. Is it true?
Here is a handy list I found: http://www.peteducation.com/article.cfm?c=2+1661&aid=1030
Mine look forward to "Rinsing" the plates, anything large enough to fall off the plate goes into their dishes.
My primary Setter taught all of the other dogs last summer the technique of finding the "ripe" grape tomatoes. I'd look out at the plants and see 4 setters picking tomatoes.
My dog camps out under my young son's dinner chair whenever we eat and nothing makes it to the floor.
Mostly just dry food but occationally i will give them a piece of chicken or steak. my wife thinks its funny to give them cheese if she cant get them to come back inside. I make them go lay down when we are eating dinner and don't let them get anywhere near the dinner table.
I've fed all my hunting dogs table scraps. The ones that have inside privledges do get scraps from the table but they have manners and are not beggars. Never had a problem with one.
My father was a DVM (vet) and our English Springer Spaniels lived on our table scraps. The next door old lady did all her cooking on Sunday and put each meal in tupperware for the entire week. Whatever was left she gave to our dog Gypsy.
Pardon me while I try an experiment...
So does this work? [youtube:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qXo3NFqkaRM]
Apparently not sorry for the wasted time and space.
no when i had a dog as of 3ish weeks ago (R.I.P tank) but i still whouldt what whould i eat fro breakfast
yes i feed my dog scraps
yes, I feed mine some scraps but no bones or anything sharp and she must behave and show good manners
I'm the only one in the household that doesn't feed our dog any scraps and I truly enjoy the fact that she doesn't bother to come sit and beg by me whenever I have any food. the only time she gets food from me is when it falls on the ground.
My dog is outside it will never be under the table.
I normally only give my dog leftover meat from dinner, and i always make her shake for it too.
I give my dog table scraps on occasion, but I try to keep it to meat, veggies and a french fry or two. And ALWAYS, ALWAYS, ALWAYS wait until a) the dog is patiently and quietly sitting or laying down or b) you're done eating to give him the scraps.
My girl gets people food, but only if she is laying in her bed. When the people sit down for a meal we tell her "Go to bed." If she stays in bed we give her scraps once we are done eating.
I don't let her make eye contact with me or get within three feet of me while I'm eating.
However I also want her to have the good life and get to try a little bit of people food now and then.
Post a Comment
My dogs eat table scraps whenever I can't manage to finish(which isn't very often). They will even eat off the fork after I'm done. They also lick all the plates and pans clean for me. I know none of this is recommended but it works for me. They do sit patiently next to me while I eat but no one else is bothered. I really don't mind them sitting next to me while I eat so I just go with it. Feel free to thrash me if you feel like it.....
I mostly feed Hoss dry dog food and I give him vitamins daily. I will sometimes give him bits of steak or chicken. When I take him to my bar sometimes I'll get one of the cooks to fix him a piece of grilled chicken. My wife informed me Sunday that he really likes strawberries. I've been told that I should get some frozen green beans to give as a healthy treat.
oh yeah and you have a very pretty dog. Reminds me of my spaniel mix dog that died she was so crazy and would fight anything. She climbed 20 feet up into trees to make sure the squirrel stayed in the tree.
My dog's act as our garbage disposal. They're outside dogs though, so we don't have the table-beggar issue. We usually just mix what scraps we have w/their dog food.
I'm in the same boat as you. I didnt want my pup being a table beggar or to steal my dinner if I stepped away. She sticks to her food and treats and thats it, and she couldn't be happy. Occasionally I'll throw a small piece of meat in with her food, but like you, not from the table.
Should have said "couldn't be happier"!
As a pre-vet medicine student, I asked professors, the vets I worked for in HS and college about this very topic. My parents raised papered and pedigree German Shepherds for as long as I can remember. I have had labs since I left college. The consensus among those I asked was, no table scraps directly from the table. Meat left on the bone, because of the protein, is great fare for the 4 legged member of the family. Stipulation: never feed pooch the same thing you're eating, at the same time you're at the dinner table. While doing the dishes is the time for scraps to be deposited in pooch's dish. Dogs will know by smell you have given him the same fare he smelled being prepared, that you ate, but will not make a "I eat when you eat and what you eat" connection.
You fellows have it all wrong. I am happy feeding my dog at the table, and my dog loves it too. I find it keeps my mother-in-law from eating supper with us.
I started training my first dog with treats and what I got was a dog that ate the first bird he ever retrieved. This continued and worsened to the point you chased him down to get the bird. Not saying lots of dogs haven't successfully been trained with treats, just saying with my experience "Never again!" There are other successful ways to train that do not use it. My second dog lives on her dog food. She was raised that way and I have found a lot of hunting dogs to have stomachs that a change in diet like a treat of meat can lead to some killer gas that just isn't needed. I also abhor a dog that begs or follows people for food, I have tried to raise my son with manners why wouldn't I do the same thing with my dog? I have also really been convinced by pro trainers as well as vets to feed my dogs the best dog food expensive when it gets right down to it but it is the best of all worlds for your dog. Think of it, if they eat and love there food and don't know the difference all there lives they aren't missing out on anything. On the other hand if you feed your dog everything you eat, well lets face it very few of us eat like we really should and put our health at risk because of it but with your dog you have an easy choice to have them on an almost perfect diet. Your dog will live longer and suffer less ills in it's lifetime. And I just think when it comes to a gundog who definitely works more than I do she should have the best of it all. Happy, healthy and here for as long as I can control it. Of course thats what I do with mine everybody is different and I try hard not to tell another man what to do with his dog. Unless I am asked obviously! LOL
Mostly just dry food but occationally i will give them a piece of chicken or steak. my wife thinks its funny to give them cheese if she cant get them to come back inside. I make them go lay down when we are eating dinner and don't let them get anywhere near the dinner table.
I have three all-time outdoor dogs and we mostly feed them dog food and a few treats here and there, but on saturdays they get all of the weeks scraps (besides very small chicken bones) Feeding your dog good-sized bones makes there jaw and teeth stronger and meat is healthy for dogs. We keep our dogs fenced into a 2 acre yard so they have good space. A lot of the dogs in the neighborhood are allowed to roam(All the cats too) the streets so they are usually used to people we got our newest and biggest dog 2 years ago to be a guard of us and the other dogs (the other dogs are can do a good job too though. When he weighed about 20 pounds we let him go aoutside with the other dogs and beong smaller he learned to defend himself. Just a few weeks after we put him outside he and the other dogs killed the biggest armadillo I have ever seen. When he is fighting he is unstoppable unless you can call him off. He does not feel much pain. When i kill a squirrel he eats it if I don't get it fast enough.
sloth-- No thrashing here. Whatever works for you and the dogs. Sounds like a patient bunch. -Dave
I like how countitanddone said it. I hate to throw something away that my dog would love to gobble up, so when we're done and we get up from the table to clean up then if there's something left over she will get it in her bowl (if appropriate). If it's too much then I might save some for another day. She sits patiently under the table while we eat even though my toddler daughter frequently drops and sometimes tries to give things to her. Much better than my in-laws' dogs the tall one will try and get his nose up to your plate and the short one will try and climb your leg, but they get fed straight from the table, it really makes a big difference I guess.
yep, all my dogs have gotten table scraps but only AFTER the meal is done- I've never had a beggar in the whole bunch- they love people food and with only few exceptions everything we eat is A-OK for them- I hate wasting food!!
When I was weeding our vegetable garden last night I found out that my Setter pup Zip loves him some fresh collard greens. My old dog Bud has a strange hankering for cucumbers. Heck, even Cheese will go for some fresh green beans off the vine if she's not too busy chasing the pup. They all seem to like the raspberry patch quite a bit.
I toss 'em leftovers from time to time but nowhere near what I use to. I make sure they don't get into any chocolate, grapes and such. I figure if it's good enough for me to eat, then it's good enough for my pack to eat.
Had a lab the liked fried eggs or scrambled eggs.
Got a Walker that loves bacon.
I do not make a habit of feeding my dogs table scraps on a regular basis though
I normally don't intentionally give my lab "people food". We had steak the other night and my wife gave her a little piece of trimming. She took it back into the kitchen, spit it out, licked it a bit and then returned to her usual spot. I don't know if she knows what to do with it... maybe a bit more spoiling is in order. She tries to sneak into the dining room during dinner, but knows to vacate when I give her the "stink eye"
my dog has never been fed people food for as long as i have had him. he likes to lay under the table while i eat but he knows not to beg. one thing i have found is a treat from that fast food place called Good Times that serves the custard and burgers. it is custard mixed with dig treats and is meant for pets. Chaos gets one of those once a week and looks forward to it.
i steer clear from giving my lab any table scraps such as beef,chicken,etc. i will however share pieces of fruit/veggies with him at times. He loves strawberries, grapes, cantaloupe, and green bell peppers.
I have read that feeding dogs grapes can be serious. Is it true?
Here is a handy list I found: http://www.peteducation.com/article.cfm?c=2+1661&aid=1030
Mine look forward to "Rinsing" the plates, anything large enough to fall off the plate goes into their dishes.
My primary Setter taught all of the other dogs last summer the technique of finding the "ripe" grape tomatoes. I'd look out at the plants and see 4 setters picking tomatoes.
My dog camps out under my young son's dinner chair whenever we eat and nothing makes it to the floor.
I've fed all my hunting dogs table scraps. The ones that have inside privledges do get scraps from the table but they have manners and are not beggars. Never had a problem with one.
My father was a DVM (vet) and our English Springer Spaniels lived on our table scraps. The next door old lady did all her cooking on Sunday and put each meal in tupperware for the entire week. Whatever was left she gave to our dog Gypsy.
Pardon me while I try an experiment...
So does this work? [youtube:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qXo3NFqkaRM]
Apparently not sorry for the wasted time and space.
no when i had a dog as of 3ish weeks ago (R.I.P tank) but i still whouldt what whould i eat fro breakfast
yes i feed my dog scraps
yes, I feed mine some scraps but no bones or anything sharp and she must behave and show good manners
I normally only give my dog leftover meat from dinner, and i always make her shake for it too.
I'm the only one in the household that doesn't feed our dog any scraps and I truly enjoy the fact that she doesn't bother to come sit and beg by me whenever I have any food. the only time she gets food from me is when it falls on the ground.
My dog is outside it will never be under the table.
I give my dog table scraps on occasion, but I try to keep it to meat, veggies and a french fry or two. And ALWAYS, ALWAYS, ALWAYS wait until a) the dog is patiently and quietly sitting or laying down or b) you're done eating to give him the scraps.
My girl gets people food, but only if she is laying in her bed. When the people sit down for a meal we tell her "Go to bed." If she stays in bed we give her scraps once we are done eating.
I don't let her make eye contact with me or get within three feet of me while I'm eating.
However I also want her to have the good life and get to try a little bit of people food now and then.
Post a Comment