


August 20, 2010
Bestul: Summertime…And Even Now, The Living Ain’t Easy
By Scott Bestul
We all know that whitetail bucks run a gauntlet during fall. When they’re not dodging hunters, they’re fighting off rivals, chasing down does, evading predators, not eating right, or slipping past any of dozens of goofy accidents that could end their lives in a second. And once past those hurdles they face winter, when things only get tougher….
Of course summer is supposed to be Easy Street for a buck. What the heck does he have to do but sleep, drink a little water, maybe hit a salt lick, swat some gnats and flies, and pig out on a dozen pounds of forage a day?

As this photo proves, there is no such thing as “the salad days” for a deer. This monster whitetail was found dead last week in southeastern Minnesota, less than 30 miles from my home. As the photo proves, he clearly got tangled in a barbwire fence, couldn’t extricate himself, and won’t have to run gauntlets any more.
My first thought when viewing this photo was “how in the heck could a healthy, mature whitetail buck—especially one not in a hurry to do anything—not be able to negotiate a simple fence crossing?” And the only answers I could come up with were a) the buck was in a definite hurry or panic b) he was not healthy, or c) a combination of the above.
My theory: The buck was probably struck and injured by a vehicle first, made it off the road, then encountered the fence. But regardless of cause, the death of this gorgeous, apparently-prime-age monster clearly shows that there is no such thing as easy living for whitetail deer…
Comments (26)
Bestul, You should have never posted that photo! Now we're going to have every animal rights activist petitioning barbed wire fences!
Anyhow that is a sad sight to see.
That's a shame. What a beautiful buck!
Yep,you can hear all the food ploters in that area crying all the way over here in Michigan. Probably somebody poached him and when he didn't fall right away they lost intrest. Anybody have a strong enough stomach to roll him around and look for a hole??
A very sad sight.
Thats tough its a wonder how many great bucks live threw the season but don't live through the summer. I guess the odds are still stacked against them.
A heck of a lot of animals end up dead due to fences. This buck more than likely just got tangled. We lose thousands of deer and elk out here.
I read a web post by a tree hugger that had worked as a volunteer removing fences on a large ranch in New Mexico that has been donated to enlarge habitat. I disagree with the fella on quite a few things, but I think working on fence removal is a good thing when they are no longer needed.
Our dept of wildlife wrote up a thoughtful pamphlet on how to fence with wildlife in mind, some counties are starting to require fences to the standard of this booklet for all wire fences.
http://wildlife.state.co.us/NR/rdonlyres/B0D65D61-6CB0-4746-94F1-6EE194E...
Cant tell from the picture for certain how the deer died,,But I dont think it was hit by a car. There is litle damage done to the carcas,,,from what I can see, one small nick in the right inside beam. And if he had been struck in the head,,,by a car which will stone a deer,,his rack would have been severly damaged.
Over the years I have freed many deer and found many dead hunt up in a barb wire fence. All had two things in commin for the most part.....Did this deer leave any struggle marks on the ground? Or are there any places on his legs where he may have been tangled in the wire? It could be sickness,,,but he doesnt look sick, most sick deer are emnacaped,,
I am more enclined to think he broke his neck on the fence...just my 2 cents worth!! Longbeards,,,West Virginia
What a buck!
What a shame!
But, stuff happens!
Bubba
Sure does not look like enough struggle marks for a healthy buck to be tangled to death. May have vehicle marks on the other side, but the velvet probably would not look as pretty as it does. Anybody hearing of any EHD/bluetongue outbreaks yet? Gnats, flies and mosquitos are the biggest cause of stress around here this time of the year.Had alot of rain this summer makeing alot of wet ground for the noseeums that carry the EHD. If its gonna break it should be anytime now. Last time we had it here was three years ago. All the mature bucks on one farm I hunt, that I had been watching in a bean feild all summer, died from it almost overnight. The older nurseing does seem to die from it the most.
In today's spec-crazied world of no rifle is enough, I wonder if barbed wire manufacturers are clamoring over what gauge wire would have best brought down that monster buck. I mean, was it a Japanese-built wire? Maybe Canadian or gasp .... South American?
We've had rocky mountain elk get caught up in our fence, but they seem to just rip it out of the ground. Never had one stuck in it. I watched it happen once. he was just eating and walking and his rack got caught in the wire, he spooked, lifted his head and the t-post came out of the ground. he stood there and shook it all out and went on his way.
a terrible waste.
I've seen quit a few deer that were hit and made it a ways before succombing to internal injury that is my guess. Note the bloated stomach, Many deer hit in the body bloat quickly. He appears to have died shortly after getting in the fence. If there had been a struggle the ground would likely show it. The grass looks fine in this pic. Rmember the story of the hole in the horn buck? He died just this way after a train knocked him into a chain link fence. Last fall I found a very nice 8 point with both back legs broken by a car. His photo is in my photofiles.
This morning on Outdoor channel. There was a program on elk hunting in Nevada and the guy found a nice bull elk laying right out in the open with a bullet hole in his shoulder. He was starting to rot. Can't remember the name of the show. It was about DIY hunting.
More of "The Wire."
i have found two bucks hung up in a fence dead like that one had his back legs caught in woven wire
It's a darned shame for what looks to my uneducated eye to be a potential monster, to die such an ignomious death... The trials and tribulations of being wild, never know what will get you.
Best Regards,
Albert A Rasch™
The Rasch Outdoor Chronicles: Sleeping Bag Care
I would guess that something was wrong with the buck prior to it becoming entangled. Normally whitetails will jump over a fence, not try to go under or between the strands. I was told when hunting in Wyoming last year that pronghorns will go under rather than over though.
Del in KS: That show was Randy Newberg's "On Your Own Adventures," and I was the dummy who missed the shot at the bull elk. Shot right under his brisket at about 350 yards. We have no idea who shot that other bull and left it lying in the grass.
Hey guys, on the subject of hunter safety, what do you guys do to make sure you stay cool on hot days or warm on cool ones? I used a thing called a "V-Pac" last winter. Made by a company called Delta Gear. Has Hot Hands packs that are used in a vest.. worked great. I was in about 20 degree weather, and never got cold once. Zip cover-alls up over it, and man, it was nice. I hear they have a new thing coming out for warmer times called a Cool Neck or something. Reviews I've seen of it are all positive. Just curious as to if any of you guys have heard of them or what you may use for those situations. Thanks and happy hunting!
YOU ARE SO RIGHT SCOTT!! FROM THE DAY A DEER IS BORN IT IS A CONSTANT STRUGGLE TO SURVIVE. MOST BUT NOT ALL OF THE NATURAL PREDTORS HAVE BEEN GONE FOR SOME TIME. WE STILL HAVE DOGS AND COYOTES THO WHICH IS ONE THING THAT COULD HAVE CAUSED THE DEATH OF THE BUCK. DEER HAVE TO PUT UP WITH WEATHER, PARASITES AND DISEASE JUST TO MENTION A FEW OF THE THINGS THEY FACE IN THE WILD. IT'S A MIRACLE FOR TO SURVIVE TO A RIPE OLD AGE.
I have looked at enough bucks like this. I would be rolling him over looking for a hole. Not enough damage to him for a struggle in a fence or a tangle with a car. I have seen to many of those. There is a trenendous market for velvet antlers . I have seen alot of deer that died from blue toungue and he does not appear to have any of those symtomns. Usually the ground is torn up under the fence when a deer is tangled in the fence.
Sargeo1,What signs do you look for with bluetongue? The fresh ones I find look very healthy, since it kills them so quickly, but most have signs of hemorrhage comeing out of their mouth and nose, and are usually close to water. Most have been between august and the end of october.
You are right most have signs of hemorraging out of the mouth and nose and sometimes the eyes and they are close to water. I have seen some that look pretty nasty some time before they die and we have found several in one place. We found 19 in a very small area (200 yards) one time. That is the most that we have found in one place. I would be surprised if the buck in the picture had any signs. You have to examine pretty close when the deer looks this healthy. Sometimes in August when the hair is light on the skin you can almost see the veins come close to the skin. We have a bout with blue tounge about every 7 or 8 years it seams. The biologists can't really tell us why.
Sargeo1, Every couple years we have it come thru, but not real bad, mostly small pockets of deer. I wonder if being exposed to it regularly helps the younger deer build up some immunity. It seems that areas that have not seen it for a long time, when it does break, wipes out a majority of the adult deer.
My encounter with barbed wire, as a civilian, cost me a patch or two on the waders.
This 10 pointer did not fare as well as I.
Post a Comment
Hey guys, on the subject of hunter safety, what do you guys do to make sure you stay cool on hot days or warm on cool ones? I used a thing called a "V-Pac" last winter. Made by a company called Delta Gear. Has Hot Hands packs that are used in a vest.. worked great. I was in about 20 degree weather, and never got cold once. Zip cover-alls up over it, and man, it was nice. I hear they have a new thing coming out for warmer times called a Cool Neck or something. Reviews I've seen of it are all positive. Just curious as to if any of you guys have heard of them or what you may use for those situations. Thanks and happy hunting!
Bestul, You should have never posted that photo! Now we're going to have every animal rights activist petitioning barbed wire fences!
Anyhow that is a sad sight to see.
That's a shame. What a beautiful buck!
Yep,you can hear all the food ploters in that area crying all the way over here in Michigan. Probably somebody poached him and when he didn't fall right away they lost intrest. Anybody have a strong enough stomach to roll him around and look for a hole??
A very sad sight.
Thats tough its a wonder how many great bucks live threw the season but don't live through the summer. I guess the odds are still stacked against them.
A heck of a lot of animals end up dead due to fences. This buck more than likely just got tangled. We lose thousands of deer and elk out here.
I read a web post by a tree hugger that had worked as a volunteer removing fences on a large ranch in New Mexico that has been donated to enlarge habitat. I disagree with the fella on quite a few things, but I think working on fence removal is a good thing when they are no longer needed.
Our dept of wildlife wrote up a thoughtful pamphlet on how to fence with wildlife in mind, some counties are starting to require fences to the standard of this booklet for all wire fences.
http://wildlife.state.co.us/NR/rdonlyres/B0D65D61-6CB0-4746-94F1-6EE194E...
Cant tell from the picture for certain how the deer died,,But I dont think it was hit by a car. There is litle damage done to the carcas,,,from what I can see, one small nick in the right inside beam. And if he had been struck in the head,,,by a car which will stone a deer,,his rack would have been severly damaged.
Over the years I have freed many deer and found many dead hunt up in a barb wire fence. All had two things in commin for the most part.....Did this deer leave any struggle marks on the ground? Or are there any places on his legs where he may have been tangled in the wire? It could be sickness,,,but he doesnt look sick, most sick deer are emnacaped,,
I am more enclined to think he broke his neck on the fence...just my 2 cents worth!! Longbeards,,,West Virginia
What a buck!
What a shame!
But, stuff happens!
Bubba
Sure does not look like enough struggle marks for a healthy buck to be tangled to death. May have vehicle marks on the other side, but the velvet probably would not look as pretty as it does. Anybody hearing of any EHD/bluetongue outbreaks yet? Gnats, flies and mosquitos are the biggest cause of stress around here this time of the year.Had alot of rain this summer makeing alot of wet ground for the noseeums that carry the EHD. If its gonna break it should be anytime now. Last time we had it here was three years ago. All the mature bucks on one farm I hunt, that I had been watching in a bean feild all summer, died from it almost overnight. The older nurseing does seem to die from it the most.
In today's spec-crazied world of no rifle is enough, I wonder if barbed wire manufacturers are clamoring over what gauge wire would have best brought down that monster buck. I mean, was it a Japanese-built wire? Maybe Canadian or gasp .... South American?
We've had rocky mountain elk get caught up in our fence, but they seem to just rip it out of the ground. Never had one stuck in it. I watched it happen once. he was just eating and walking and his rack got caught in the wire, he spooked, lifted his head and the t-post came out of the ground. he stood there and shook it all out and went on his way.
a terrible waste.
I've seen quit a few deer that were hit and made it a ways before succombing to internal injury that is my guess. Note the bloated stomach, Many deer hit in the body bloat quickly. He appears to have died shortly after getting in the fence. If there had been a struggle the ground would likely show it. The grass looks fine in this pic. Rmember the story of the hole in the horn buck? He died just this way after a train knocked him into a chain link fence. Last fall I found a very nice 8 point with both back legs broken by a car. His photo is in my photofiles.
This morning on Outdoor channel. There was a program on elk hunting in Nevada and the guy found a nice bull elk laying right out in the open with a bullet hole in his shoulder. He was starting to rot. Can't remember the name of the show. It was about DIY hunting.
More of "The Wire."
i have found two bucks hung up in a fence dead like that one had his back legs caught in woven wire
It's a darned shame for what looks to my uneducated eye to be a potential monster, to die such an ignomious death... The trials and tribulations of being wild, never know what will get you.
Best Regards,
Albert A Rasch™
The Rasch Outdoor Chronicles: Sleeping Bag Care
I would guess that something was wrong with the buck prior to it becoming entangled. Normally whitetails will jump over a fence, not try to go under or between the strands. I was told when hunting in Wyoming last year that pronghorns will go under rather than over though.
Del in KS: That show was Randy Newberg's "On Your Own Adventures," and I was the dummy who missed the shot at the bull elk. Shot right under his brisket at about 350 yards. We have no idea who shot that other bull and left it lying in the grass.
YOU ARE SO RIGHT SCOTT!! FROM THE DAY A DEER IS BORN IT IS A CONSTANT STRUGGLE TO SURVIVE. MOST BUT NOT ALL OF THE NATURAL PREDTORS HAVE BEEN GONE FOR SOME TIME. WE STILL HAVE DOGS AND COYOTES THO WHICH IS ONE THING THAT COULD HAVE CAUSED THE DEATH OF THE BUCK. DEER HAVE TO PUT UP WITH WEATHER, PARASITES AND DISEASE JUST TO MENTION A FEW OF THE THINGS THEY FACE IN THE WILD. IT'S A MIRACLE FOR TO SURVIVE TO A RIPE OLD AGE.
I have looked at enough bucks like this. I would be rolling him over looking for a hole. Not enough damage to him for a struggle in a fence or a tangle with a car. I have seen to many of those. There is a trenendous market for velvet antlers . I have seen alot of deer that died from blue toungue and he does not appear to have any of those symtomns. Usually the ground is torn up under the fence when a deer is tangled in the fence.
Sargeo1,What signs do you look for with bluetongue? The fresh ones I find look very healthy, since it kills them so quickly, but most have signs of hemorrhage comeing out of their mouth and nose, and are usually close to water. Most have been between august and the end of october.
You are right most have signs of hemorraging out of the mouth and nose and sometimes the eyes and they are close to water. I have seen some that look pretty nasty some time before they die and we have found several in one place. We found 19 in a very small area (200 yards) one time. That is the most that we have found in one place. I would be surprised if the buck in the picture had any signs. You have to examine pretty close when the deer looks this healthy. Sometimes in August when the hair is light on the skin you can almost see the veins come close to the skin. We have a bout with blue tounge about every 7 or 8 years it seams. The biologists can't really tell us why.
Sargeo1, Every couple years we have it come thru, but not real bad, mostly small pockets of deer. I wonder if being exposed to it regularly helps the younger deer build up some immunity. It seems that areas that have not seen it for a long time, when it does break, wipes out a majority of the adult deer.
My encounter with barbed wire, as a civilian, cost me a patch or two on the waders.
This 10 pointer did not fare as well as I.
Post a Comment