


November 10, 2010
An Xtreme Knife for Extreme Times
by David E. Petzal
Unless you are still using flint tools, you are aware of Knives of Alaska, the Texas-based company whose president, Charles Allen, is in fact an Alaska guide and bush pilot. I’ve seen him at work, and he is the real deal, as is his cutlery. Knives of Alaska now has a new line of minimalist slicers and dicers called the Xtremes, and I had the opportunity of trying out the Model V, which is the largest of the series.
Like Models I through IV, the V is made of D2 steel (at Rc 59-61) with a skeleton grip. Its 5-inch drop-point blade has a one-inch serrated section at its rear. The entire knife is coated with Emralon, which is a very tough rustproofer. The XTremes come in Kydex sheaths and are supplied with a yard of parachute cord to wrap the handle, and I strongly recommend that you use it, as it makes for a much more comfortable grip than the bare steel.
In the sheath, handle wrapped, the Model 5 weighs only 8 ounces and is as flat as south Texas. It’s very tough, requires no maintenance except sharpening (and that pretty rarely), will do very well as a hunting knife, and costs $79.99.
The Xtremes are sold direct only, not through dealers. You can get one by going to knivesofalaskaextreme.com, where you can see all five models. Or you can get several. That’s fine with me, and probably with Charles Allen, too.
Comments (39)
thats one nice blade
Looks like a nice knife. I love tool steel
It looks like a nice knife. I would want to handle one before buying though. I'm not sure about how they skeletonized the grip. I would prefer to see at least a couple of support bars going across it for added strength in the handle.
A thin knife is very nice. I wouldn't quite call it maintenance free. The cord wrap would eventually get pretty funky and need to be replaced. Easy to do, though.
I don't like the skeletonized grip and I don't like serrations (and it is awful pricey).
The true "survival knife is whatever you happen to have with you in a survival situation. For that guy who they made the nausia inducing movie about, that had to cut his own arm off, I think it was a Swiss army knife. The major requirement is only that it be sharp.
It's nice looking, but those serrated teeth are a game killer for me. Not sure why "every" knife has to have them nowadays but they're a pain, cut dirty, and can't be easily sharpened.
It's also pricey for what's being offered.
i once saw a man bend a railroad spike into an "L" with his bare hands. he was 71 years old at the time. unless you have that kind of strength or put the knife to a job that no knife was designed to do the skeletonized handle on this knife will probably outlast you. i have another model from knives of alaska and would'nt trade it. if you think 80 bucks is too pricey then chances are you don't have any good steel. parachute cord? unless i was doing bloody work i would probably leave it bare.
Nice knife but it looks unfinished, as in no scales. Survival is fine but give me a handle please. That skeleton does not look comfortable to grip.
Knives of Alaska should be in every serious hunters pack. I bought a set a few years ago and am amazed everytime I use them to process elk at the incredible performance they provide. I even use them to breakdown the meat for vaccume sealing/freezing when I arrive home.
The Extreme model would be a good choice for an all-around but choose another model for hunting...
Don't care for that skeleton grip when I'm using the knife to gut a big animal, and parachute cord? KOA makes some fine models, and I have two of them, but I will have to give this one a pass.
For a survival knife I'd take a Swiss Army knife over that skeletonized thing any day of the week!
This looks like just the knife for the man who really needs a knife but doesn't want to carry one. A thin knife like this could ride in any pocket of a daypack and not be felt. At my age the idea of lightening the load a bit sounds pretty good. And if you needed to, a 5" D-2 blade would get the hide off a rhino. I'm not in love with those serrations either, but with an extra 4" of plain edge in front of them, I could manage.
This is one plain jane, all business, knife. Almost looks like an "unfinished" knife project? Too darn plain for my taste.
I have to admit that the skeletonized handles do not appeal to me... But I really like many of the other more conventional knives on their site!
Very well designed and thought out knife for the INTENDED PURPOSE.
Being one of Dave's pets I was expecting to see a price fit for Oil potentates. Instead it is within reach of nearly everyone.
I would have preferred a saw-tooth section such as some of the older Pumas had...works better for cutting rope instead of serrated.
Wrapping the handle with a multi-purpose piece of parachute cord will do the trick nicely for a grip - even better 2 or 3 yards of it, but that can be had anywhere.
"LESS IS MORE."
Overall an excellent AMERICAN MADE offering!
Nice knives,are they made in the USA? The Yukon is most impressive to me. It is nice to see the D.H. Russell patten with great steel at a reasonable price.
Nice knives, the whole series look task specific. The Yukons are quite impressive, it is great to see the D.H. Russell pattern executed with excellent tool steel.
Dave where are the knives made?
I may have spoken too soon.
I can't actually say they are American made.
Perhaps someone on this blog has the answer...
I may have spoken too soon.
I can't actually say they are American made.
Perhaps someone on this blog has the answer...
To kudukid: All KoA knives and Diamondblade knives are made in Texas. Also, sorry about the affordable price, but then nothing is perfect.
Diamondblade, now there is a knife. But, then you can't afford a rifle or the hunt.
Mr Petzal,
Different subject. You indicated last month that Mr Chivers would respond to questions regarding his book, The Gun. Did I miss this, or is it still in the offing? I finished this fascinating book and was looking forward to more discourse from readers with experience with the A 16 and the AK 47. I served between Korea and Vietnam, so look forward to reading others opinions
It has been my experience that the products made and sold by KoA have always been among the best. They are as advertised. Costs are not cheap but then the knives and saws will last longer than you will unless you lose them or they become the object of theft. The stag handled knives are really pretty and approach the quality of a good custom knife.
I make knives as a hobby. I have forged blades from 52100 ball bearing steel, used D2, AUS8 and most stainless steel knife makers stock produced in the USA. Nothing will match D2 for toughness. The Diamondblade knife is the best money can buy, period. You just cannot find a better steel used in knife blades anywhere and they are USA made.
Way over priced, and not worth the time or money. Walk away.
I remember an old man that made knifes from "saw blades".
Some of the best from 5' saw blades.
Considering how bad the fit and finish is on a Knives of Alaska,it's just as well that they started leaving the grip panels off of them.Leaving the grip panels on them just makes them harder to sell.Stevie Wonder must be in charge of quality control at KOA.
If you're going to buy D2 knife,just buy a dozier and get a knife built by someone who has a clue and actually perfected the use of D2 and quality control.
That's a lot of money for a knife that my grandfather would say is half completed.
not sure why the handle is made so crudely or why it is so pricey. i'm not a fan of serrations either. how about a review of a knife that at least some of us can afford.
Dave, they giving you knives,guns and such so you do advertisement "reviews"?
Keep your KOA, Ill stick to my High Country knife money actually well spent.
To Happy Myles: Chris is definitely answering questions on his blog, and I know he's sent some Q&A to this one, but I don't know when they will appear.
To Chris B: I've bought some KoA knives, and have been loaned some, and have been given some. Take your pick. I get a lot of knives and other stuff that I never review because I don't like it. Yes, I will keep my KoA, thank you very much.
Seeing as I spent around $50 for my big Buck folder I can't say the price is too high, however the serrated blade and lack of handle are turn offs to me.
If I want a saw I'll buy a saw, not a knife that makes 1/3 of it's blade useless by grinding teeth into it.
Some of you fellas would complain if they hung you with a new rope. Have a good weekend!
I think it needs one of those Estwing hammer handles in leather. http://www.hansbrunnertools.gil.com.au/imagesUsers/Eastwing15ozhammerr.j...
one scary tough looking knife
I like it, and that's coming from a knife maker who builds knives from bars of steel and pieces of maple with nothing but files, sand paper and a grinding wheel. (and some other assorted junk in the garage that doesn't deserve mention)
Looks like a nice enough knife, my only problem is with the serations, If they wouldnt have supplied the 550 cord I would wrap it like that anyway. but its a no sell due to the serations.
Looks nice, but I'd agree with the others on the serrations. For survival and bushcraft you need to be able to care out traps, and the serrations are in the spot that would be best for carving. So this knife looks solid except the serrations, which prevent it from doing some survival uses
I have to agree it does look unfinished but, I dont think its ment to look nice. It looks like a tatical dream. And 80 bucks I could afford one.
Post a Comment
I don't like the skeletonized grip and I don't like serrations (and it is awful pricey).
The true "survival knife is whatever you happen to have with you in a survival situation. For that guy who they made the nausia inducing movie about, that had to cut his own arm off, I think it was a Swiss army knife. The major requirement is only that it be sharp.
It's nice looking, but those serrated teeth are a game killer for me. Not sure why "every" knife has to have them nowadays but they're a pain, cut dirty, and can't be easily sharpened.
It's also pricey for what's being offered.
thats one nice blade
It looks like a nice knife. I would want to handle one before buying though. I'm not sure about how they skeletonized the grip. I would prefer to see at least a couple of support bars going across it for added strength in the handle.
Looks like a nice knife. I love tool steel
A thin knife is very nice. I wouldn't quite call it maintenance free. The cord wrap would eventually get pretty funky and need to be replaced. Easy to do, though.
i once saw a man bend a railroad spike into an "L" with his bare hands. he was 71 years old at the time. unless you have that kind of strength or put the knife to a job that no knife was designed to do the skeletonized handle on this knife will probably outlast you. i have another model from knives of alaska and would'nt trade it. if you think 80 bucks is too pricey then chances are you don't have any good steel. parachute cord? unless i was doing bloody work i would probably leave it bare.
Nice knife but it looks unfinished, as in no scales. Survival is fine but give me a handle please. That skeleton does not look comfortable to grip.
Don't care for that skeleton grip when I'm using the knife to gut a big animal, and parachute cord? KOA makes some fine models, and I have two of them, but I will have to give this one a pass.
This looks like just the knife for the man who really needs a knife but doesn't want to carry one. A thin knife like this could ride in any pocket of a daypack and not be felt. At my age the idea of lightening the load a bit sounds pretty good. And if you needed to, a 5" D-2 blade would get the hide off a rhino. I'm not in love with those serrations either, but with an extra 4" of plain edge in front of them, I could manage.
Knives of Alaska should be in every serious hunters pack. I bought a set a few years ago and am amazed everytime I use them to process elk at the incredible performance they provide. I even use them to breakdown the meat for vaccume sealing/freezing when I arrive home.
The Extreme model would be a good choice for an all-around but choose another model for hunting...
I have to admit that the skeletonized handles do not appeal to me... But I really like many of the other more conventional knives on their site!
To kudukid: All KoA knives and Diamondblade knives are made in Texas. Also, sorry about the affordable price, but then nothing is perfect.
Diamondblade, now there is a knife. But, then you can't afford a rifle or the hunt.
It has been my experience that the products made and sold by KoA have always been among the best. They are as advertised. Costs are not cheap but then the knives and saws will last longer than you will unless you lose them or they become the object of theft. The stag handled knives are really pretty and approach the quality of a good custom knife.
not sure why the handle is made so crudely or why it is so pricey. i'm not a fan of serrations either. how about a review of a knife that at least some of us can afford.
Looks nice, but I'd agree with the others on the serrations. For survival and bushcraft you need to be able to care out traps, and the serrations are in the spot that would be best for carving. So this knife looks solid except the serrations, which prevent it from doing some survival uses
For a survival knife I'd take a Swiss Army knife over that skeletonized thing any day of the week!
This is one plain jane, all business, knife. Almost looks like an "unfinished" knife project? Too darn plain for my taste.
Very well designed and thought out knife for the INTENDED PURPOSE.
Being one of Dave's pets I was expecting to see a price fit for Oil potentates. Instead it is within reach of nearly everyone.
I would have preferred a saw-tooth section such as some of the older Pumas had...works better for cutting rope instead of serrated.
Wrapping the handle with a multi-purpose piece of parachute cord will do the trick nicely for a grip - even better 2 or 3 yards of it, but that can be had anywhere.
"LESS IS MORE."
Overall an excellent AMERICAN MADE offering!
Nice knives,are they made in the USA? The Yukon is most impressive to me. It is nice to see the D.H. Russell patten with great steel at a reasonable price.
Nice knives, the whole series look task specific. The Yukons are quite impressive, it is great to see the D.H. Russell pattern executed with excellent tool steel.
Dave where are the knives made?
I may have spoken too soon.
I can't actually say they are American made.
Perhaps someone on this blog has the answer...
I may have spoken too soon.
I can't actually say they are American made.
Perhaps someone on this blog has the answer...
Mr Petzal,
Different subject. You indicated last month that Mr Chivers would respond to questions regarding his book, The Gun. Did I miss this, or is it still in the offing? I finished this fascinating book and was looking forward to more discourse from readers with experience with the A 16 and the AK 47. I served between Korea and Vietnam, so look forward to reading others opinions
I make knives as a hobby. I have forged blades from 52100 ball bearing steel, used D2, AUS8 and most stainless steel knife makers stock produced in the USA. Nothing will match D2 for toughness. The Diamondblade knife is the best money can buy, period. You just cannot find a better steel used in knife blades anywhere and they are USA made.
Way over priced, and not worth the time or money. Walk away.
I remember an old man that made knifes from "saw blades".
Some of the best from 5' saw blades.
Considering how bad the fit and finish is on a Knives of Alaska,it's just as well that they started leaving the grip panels off of them.Leaving the grip panels on them just makes them harder to sell.Stevie Wonder must be in charge of quality control at KOA.
If you're going to buy D2 knife,just buy a dozier and get a knife built by someone who has a clue and actually perfected the use of D2 and quality control.
That's a lot of money for a knife that my grandfather would say is half completed.
Dave, they giving you knives,guns and such so you do advertisement "reviews"?
Keep your KOA, Ill stick to my High Country knife money actually well spent.
To Happy Myles: Chris is definitely answering questions on his blog, and I know he's sent some Q&A to this one, but I don't know when they will appear.
To Chris B: I've bought some KoA knives, and have been loaned some, and have been given some. Take your pick. I get a lot of knives and other stuff that I never review because I don't like it. Yes, I will keep my KoA, thank you very much.
Seeing as I spent around $50 for my big Buck folder I can't say the price is too high, however the serrated blade and lack of handle are turn offs to me.
If I want a saw I'll buy a saw, not a knife that makes 1/3 of it's blade useless by grinding teeth into it.
I think it needs one of those Estwing hammer handles in leather. http://www.hansbrunnertools.gil.com.au/imagesUsers/Eastwing15ozhammerr.j...
one scary tough looking knife
I like it, and that's coming from a knife maker who builds knives from bars of steel and pieces of maple with nothing but files, sand paper and a grinding wheel. (and some other assorted junk in the garage that doesn't deserve mention)
Looks like a nice enough knife, my only problem is with the serations, If they wouldnt have supplied the 550 cord I would wrap it like that anyway. but its a no sell due to the serations.
I have to agree it does look unfinished but, I dont think its ment to look nice. It looks like a tatical dream. And 80 bucks I could afford one.
Some of you fellas would complain if they hung you with a new rope. Have a good weekend!
Post a Comment