


December 10, 2010
Montana Teen Suspended For Hunting Rifle in Trunk
By David Maccar
Several stories have come through Field Notes this year about high school students who absent-midedly leave a hunting rifle or shotgun in their vehicle, thereby violating their school's zero-tolerance weapons policy, landing them with a suspension or even expulsion. An expulsion was overturned in California early this year and some Michigan teens were suspended in November. Here’s another forgetful young hunter in Montana who finds herself in a similar circumstance.
From this story on FoxNews.com:
On the morning of Dec.1, Demari DeReu drove to Columbia Falls High School in Montana and parked her blue-green Honda Accord in the lot, just as she does every morning. The 16-year-old honor roll student, class treasurer and varsity cheerleader walked in to school, forgetting entirely about the unloaded hunting rifle locked in the trunk of her car.
Later that day, there was an announcement telling students contraband sniffing dogs were scouting the parking lot, sparking her memory. She immediately told administrators that she’d forgotten to remove her scoped hunting rifle from the trunk following a Thanksgiving family hunting excursion. She was suspended from school for violating federal and state gun laws.
On Monday, the school board will convene for a hearing to decide the fate and academic future of the high school junior, who recently was voted most dedicated cheerleader by her teammates and coach.
DeReu's supporters say her future success may be harmed irrevocably because of one mistake and a school board’s lack of common sense, and they have been sending e-mails en masse and campaigning to garner support from around the region, and across the country.
But the school district superintendent, Mike Nicosia, says the entire issue has been blown out of proportion and that the school board members will be fair and wouldn’t ruin the future of the bright honors student. He blamed outside influences for turning the whole thing into a circus.
The drama continues.
On Friday morning DeReu and her newly retained attorney are scheduled to hold a news conference outside the family’s home.
When reached by phone, Scott DeReu, her father, described his daughter as an avid deer and elk hunter.
"She got a couple of deer," he said. "Never an elk...they're tough to find."
He declined to talk specifically about his daughter's issue.
And her supporters vow to descend Monday upon the school district building to protest during the school board hearing.
DeReu’s high school has a zero tolerance policy about guns on campus — in a accordance with both state and federal law — and could lose funding under the terms of the federal Gun Free School Act if the law is not enforced.
State criminal law also prevents weapons from being brought into schools and provides for leniency on a case-by-case basis; DeReu did not bring the gun into school, but it was in the school parking lot, which falls under the purviews of the federal law.
Violators of the federal law face no less than a year expulsion — but the law provides some wiggle room, allowing school boards to show leniency on a case-by-case basis.
Comments (31)
I have a feeling this girl is going to get screwed over. There isn't any common sense left in politics. People should realize the difference in a kid with hunting rifle or shotgun with maybe a partial box of ammo, and a kid with a multiple guns and multiple boxes of ammo intent on shooting up the school.
My uncle talks about having his .22 rifle in his back glass after going coon hunting before school, and all of them have grown up ok.
It's quite ridiculous that a student who had her gun locked up in her trunk would be suspended. Especially when it is so obvious that she had it there only because she had been hunting recently. And what murdering maniac tells the school administrators that the gun is there? The whole thing is pathetic.
It's quite ridiculous that a student who had her gun locked up in her trunk would be suspended. Especially when it is so obvious that she had it there only because she had been hunting recently. And what murdering maniac tells the school administrators that the gun is there? The whole thing is pathetic.
we can bring guns to school as long as they are locked up and in a gun rack
It's quite ridiculous that a student who had her gun locked up in her trunk would be suspended. Especially when it is so obvious that she had it there only because she had been hunting recently. And what murdering maniac tells the school administrators that the gun is there? The whole thing is pathetic.
It's quite ridiculous that a student who had her gun locked up in her trunk would be suspended. Especially when it is so obvious that she had it there only because she had been hunting recently. And what murdering maniac tells the school administrators that the gun is there? The whole thing is pathetic.
It's quite ridiculous that a student who had her gun locked up in her trunk would be suspended. Especially when it is so obvious that she had it there only because she had been hunting recently. And what murdering maniac tells the school administrators that the gun is there? The whole thing is pathetic.
Hey sorry for the multiple posts. my computer was being weird.
why cant the cheerleaders in my school be smart and also hunt?
Honest mistake? Or Stupid mistake? I think it's up for debate. There are somethings you just don't forget and this is one of them. I know she meant no harm but she needs to be more responsible, and resposible for her actions. I don't wish her to be an example, but common sense has been lost in society and it needs to be found again.
I can understand the suspension - she broke a zero-tolerance rule. Granted, it was an honest mistake and she meant no harm, but a rule is a rule. Should she be expelled? Absolutely not. But she shouldn't be totally absolved. She forgot she had a gun in her car and brought it to school. If she forgot she had pot in her purse, she'd be punished. School officials should take into consideration the fact that is was an honest mistake with no harm intended, though.
This is pathetic. She admitted to it! She wasn't saying "Oh crap, you cought me. I was coming to shoot everybody in this school with a rifle and maybe a box of shells." She was letting the school know that she had a gun from a trip that she made and it was an honest mistake forgetting it in the vehicle. I mean who was it Bourjaily that wrote a post about forgetting his gun in the field. It happens. I'm just wondering what would have happened had she not told of the gun and the school found it.
I watch Fox News every day, have lived in Montana the last 25 years and haven't seen or heard a word about this in the local newspaper or on Fox. In any case, if it is true, it is another insane "zero tolerance" policy of the liberal education cabal.
Finally saw a small piece in this morning's paper where the school superintendent said he "didn't think the girl would be expelled by the school board." I certainly hope not!
I can see getting expelled for a week or two. But criminal charges on the same bassis as an active shooter heel bent on death and destruction, not so mutch. If the school or the federal gopobers feel the need to charge her with something it should mme some form (a low form) of misdomeener(spelling?) she did break a rule and a law aftyer all wether we like that law or rule or not. As for the comments on her making a stupid mistake I think I'll agree with that. She knows that a firearm needs to be secured for many reason or at least she should know. Reguardless you take the gun out of the trunk before you go to school I did when I was in High school.
I think that there should have been a little leiency she went and told the principal or whatever she had accidentally left her gun in car with that being said I feel as though if its a small school not sure that the principal could have let her go home real quick if she didnt live far and take it out no harm no foul. On a second note who uses a Honda Accord to go hunting in?
Muleynut30.06 i think the honda question is an issue all it's own. I had a friend in High School that sold his truck and bought a civic and then posted mathews stickers all over the glorified four wheeler. Pokeing fun at him became everyones favorite pastime. Ah the good ole days.
when I was at the University of Iowa in the early '80s we could have shotguns for hunting but we had to have them kept in a special locker- of course I didn't and kept it in my dorm room and shot it right out the window a couple of times to blast squirrels for Sunday nite dinner (toaster oven, basted in butter hooked from the cafeteria)- never got caught! we also made pipe bombs for fun but never damaged any property or persons
To Dcast:
I realize what point you are trying to make with the questioning comment "Honest mistake? Or stupid mistake?..." and I do not disagree AT ALL about the fact that people need to be much more responsible and careful. But at the same time this is a 16 year old girl who has a lot going on in her life. Between school--not to mention honor roll, out-of-school programs(cheerleading), and then trying to squeeze in hobbies like hunting, is something almost to be admired in itself! So in my eyes one minor slip up, for instance; leaving a gun (*unloaded and locked away) in the trunk of her car is not an act of stupidity or irresponsibility but just honest mistake-*by the way everyone makes them-.
Oh Come On Now! Why can't people use their brains anymore. If this city is in an area where hunting is common, this shouldn't have been an issue. The contraband dogs weren't looking for guns, they most likely were out to find drugs. The girl told them about an unloaded huinting rifle in her trunk, which is totally out of view. And I would imagine it was cased in accordance with the law. They could have searched her car or something if the dog found it. Then provide a copy and reminder of the schools zero tolerance policy to everyone. Or they could have told the officers which car it was so they could use it for a test for the dog. Turn an accident into a positive. Instead they act like mindless jerks and read what the paper says to do and go do it. I think actual mindless robots could make better judgement calls than far too many people these days.
When I was a teen in high school (the 80s), during hunting season it would have been easy to find probably a hundred deer rifles/shotguns/bows in vehicles in the parking lot of our high school during deer season. We'd even bring friends and teachers out to the truck to show them some new rifle we got or something. There wasn't ever any problem.
these people are so stupid. at my school lots of cars have firearms during deer season in them. i know a guy who works construction and carries his tools with him to school. does that mean his saws and razor knives are weapons
these people are so stupid. at my school lots of cars have firearms during deer season in them. i know a guy who works construction and carries his tools with him to school. does that mean his saws and razor knives are weapons
This sounds like another case of stupid. It also smacks of a law based on urban more's imposed on a rural population. Apparently the legislators drafting the law never thought that 1,some good kids hunt or 2, if you don't encourage the good kids to hunt but restrict them with zero tolerance discouragement, they won't hunt and the state will have fewer adult hunters in the future to support conservation. While I don't think any kid needs an AK47 (unless he is in Somalia and taking up piracy) still if kids don't get to shoot, they won't.
I went to my police chief and offered my collection of historical replicas for a history based gun safety course I had dreamed up-"Outa the Question" was the response. I suspect federal zero tolerance has something to do with why you can't teach gun safety to all the kids in the school where you have there attention already. It is also likely why guys like my old history teacher can't dress up like Minutemen and bring their Brown Bess for show and tell...But waitaminute! The Feds don't consider Black powder guns firearms! So why not?
Anyway they should get real and let the cheerleader off (and give her gun back!) It ain't like she was terrorizing the mall with it...
The School Board decided not to expel her.
That's ridiculous. I'm a sophmore and if I did that I'd be in jail. The girl obviously meant no harm.
That's ridiculous. I'm a sophmore and if I did that I'd be in jail. The girl obviously meant no harm.
To quote Tim Wilson, "It's a sorry world." Thank
God this happened in Montana,where there remains some of the last common sense found in the U.S. in the west and southeast, with the exception of Atlanta, Ga. I hope she will not be crucified over this oversight.
Common sense isn't so common anymore... She had the moral being to come clean and they slammed her for it? The police should have let it go in the first place. Frankly, she wasn't breaking any laws. It was locked up unloaded in a privately owned vehicle.
Senkoman 12 actually knives and saws are considered weapons at schools today and if caught with them you can be in serious trouble. Nowadays you can't even insult someone at school without punishment. It's crazy I'm a high school student and guys have it in their nature to mess with eachother but if I were to even call a friend stupid I would receive a in school suspension
everyone is overlooking the fact that she was doing the right thing,locking the gun in the trunk as SHE WAS SUPPOSED TO. Even though, she had it on school property by AN HONEST ACCIDENT the school board authorities should have realized this fact and took in WHO AND WHAT type of person she is and never should have taken any more action than safely putting the rifle in the schools possession. And calling the parents to come and get it. And giving the girl a rep-remand and THAT SHOULD HAVE BEEN ALL.! Especially after looking at all of her scholastic achievements.That poor girl is really getting ROYALLY SCREWED and that's wrong!
Post a Comment
I have a feeling this girl is going to get screwed over. There isn't any common sense left in politics. People should realize the difference in a kid with hunting rifle or shotgun with maybe a partial box of ammo, and a kid with a multiple guns and multiple boxes of ammo intent on shooting up the school.
My uncle talks about having his .22 rifle in his back glass after going coon hunting before school, and all of them have grown up ok.
why cant the cheerleaders in my school be smart and also hunt?
Honest mistake? Or Stupid mistake? I think it's up for debate. There are somethings you just don't forget and this is one of them. I know she meant no harm but she needs to be more responsible, and resposible for her actions. I don't wish her to be an example, but common sense has been lost in society and it needs to be found again.
I watch Fox News every day, have lived in Montana the last 25 years and haven't seen or heard a word about this in the local newspaper or on Fox. In any case, if it is true, it is another insane "zero tolerance" policy of the liberal education cabal.
I can understand the suspension - she broke a zero-tolerance rule. Granted, it was an honest mistake and she meant no harm, but a rule is a rule. Should she be expelled? Absolutely not. But she shouldn't be totally absolved. She forgot she had a gun in her car and brought it to school. If she forgot she had pot in her purse, she'd be punished. School officials should take into consideration the fact that is was an honest mistake with no harm intended, though.
Oh Come On Now! Why can't people use their brains anymore. If this city is in an area where hunting is common, this shouldn't have been an issue. The contraband dogs weren't looking for guns, they most likely were out to find drugs. The girl told them about an unloaded huinting rifle in her trunk, which is totally out of view. And I would imagine it was cased in accordance with the law. They could have searched her car or something if the dog found it. Then provide a copy and reminder of the schools zero tolerance policy to everyone. Or they could have told the officers which car it was so they could use it for a test for the dog. Turn an accident into a positive. Instead they act like mindless jerks and read what the paper says to do and go do it. I think actual mindless robots could make better judgement calls than far too many people these days.
That's ridiculous. I'm a sophmore and if I did that I'd be in jail. The girl obviously meant no harm.
This sounds like another case of stupid. It also smacks of a law based on urban more's imposed on a rural population. Apparently the legislators drafting the law never thought that 1,some good kids hunt or 2, if you don't encourage the good kids to hunt but restrict them with zero tolerance discouragement, they won't hunt and the state will have fewer adult hunters in the future to support conservation. While I don't think any kid needs an AK47 (unless he is in Somalia and taking up piracy) still if kids don't get to shoot, they won't.
I went to my police chief and offered my collection of historical replicas for a history based gun safety course I had dreamed up-"Outa the Question" was the response. I suspect federal zero tolerance has something to do with why you can't teach gun safety to all the kids in the school where you have there attention already. It is also likely why guys like my old history teacher can't dress up like Minutemen and bring their Brown Bess for show and tell...But waitaminute! The Feds don't consider Black powder guns firearms! So why not?
Anyway they should get real and let the cheerleader off (and give her gun back!) It ain't like she was terrorizing the mall with it...
Finally saw a small piece in this morning's paper where the school superintendent said he "didn't think the girl would be expelled by the school board." I certainly hope not!
these people are so stupid. at my school lots of cars have firearms during deer season in them. i know a guy who works construction and carries his tools with him to school. does that mean his saws and razor knives are weapons
To Dcast:
I realize what point you are trying to make with the questioning comment "Honest mistake? Or stupid mistake?..." and I do not disagree AT ALL about the fact that people need to be much more responsible and careful. But at the same time this is a 16 year old girl who has a lot going on in her life. Between school--not to mention honor roll, out-of-school programs(cheerleading), and then trying to squeeze in hobbies like hunting, is something almost to be admired in itself! So in my eyes one minor slip up, for instance; leaving a gun (*unloaded and locked away) in the trunk of her car is not an act of stupidity or irresponsibility but just honest mistake-*by the way everyone makes them-.
Senkoman 12 actually knives and saws are considered weapons at schools today and if caught with them you can be in serious trouble. Nowadays you can't even insult someone at school without punishment. It's crazy I'm a high school student and guys have it in their nature to mess with eachother but if I were to even call a friend stupid I would receive a in school suspension
The School Board decided not to expel her.
I think that there should have been a little leiency she went and told the principal or whatever she had accidentally left her gun in car with that being said I feel as though if its a small school not sure that the principal could have let her go home real quick if she didnt live far and take it out no harm no foul. On a second note who uses a Honda Accord to go hunting in?
That's ridiculous. I'm a sophmore and if I did that I'd be in jail. The girl obviously meant no harm.
To quote Tim Wilson, "It's a sorry world." Thank
God this happened in Montana,where there remains some of the last common sense found in the U.S. in the west and southeast, with the exception of Atlanta, Ga. I hope she will not be crucified over this oversight.
When I was a teen in high school (the 80s), during hunting season it would have been easy to find probably a hundred deer rifles/shotguns/bows in vehicles in the parking lot of our high school during deer season. We'd even bring friends and teachers out to the truck to show them some new rifle we got or something. There wasn't ever any problem.
This is pathetic. She admitted to it! She wasn't saying "Oh crap, you cought me. I was coming to shoot everybody in this school with a rifle and maybe a box of shells." She was letting the school know that she had a gun from a trip that she made and it was an honest mistake forgetting it in the vehicle. I mean who was it Bourjaily that wrote a post about forgetting his gun in the field. It happens. I'm just wondering what would have happened had she not told of the gun and the school found it.
Common sense isn't so common anymore... She had the moral being to come clean and they slammed her for it? The police should have let it go in the first place. Frankly, she wasn't breaking any laws. It was locked up unloaded in a privately owned vehicle.
everyone is overlooking the fact that she was doing the right thing,locking the gun in the trunk as SHE WAS SUPPOSED TO. Even though, she had it on school property by AN HONEST ACCIDENT the school board authorities should have realized this fact and took in WHO AND WHAT type of person she is and never should have taken any more action than safely putting the rifle in the schools possession. And calling the parents to come and get it. And giving the girl a rep-remand and THAT SHOULD HAVE BEEN ALL.! Especially after looking at all of her scholastic achievements.That poor girl is really getting ROYALLY SCREWED and that's wrong!
these people are so stupid. at my school lots of cars have firearms during deer season in them. i know a guy who works construction and carries his tools with him to school. does that mean his saws and razor knives are weapons
when I was at the University of Iowa in the early '80s we could have shotguns for hunting but we had to have them kept in a special locker- of course I didn't and kept it in my dorm room and shot it right out the window a couple of times to blast squirrels for Sunday nite dinner (toaster oven, basted in butter hooked from the cafeteria)- never got caught! we also made pipe bombs for fun but never damaged any property or persons
we can bring guns to school as long as they are locked up and in a gun rack
It's quite ridiculous that a student who had her gun locked up in her trunk would be suspended. Especially when it is so obvious that she had it there only because she had been hunting recently. And what murdering maniac tells the school administrators that the gun is there? The whole thing is pathetic.
It's quite ridiculous that a student who had her gun locked up in her trunk would be suspended. Especially when it is so obvious that she had it there only because she had been hunting recently. And what murdering maniac tells the school administrators that the gun is there? The whole thing is pathetic.
It's quite ridiculous that a student who had her gun locked up in her trunk would be suspended. Especially when it is so obvious that she had it there only because she had been hunting recently. And what murdering maniac tells the school administrators that the gun is there? The whole thing is pathetic.
Hey sorry for the multiple posts. my computer was being weird.
Muleynut30.06 i think the honda question is an issue all it's own. I had a friend in High School that sold his truck and bought a civic and then posted mathews stickers all over the glorified four wheeler. Pokeing fun at him became everyones favorite pastime. Ah the good ole days.
It's quite ridiculous that a student who had her gun locked up in her trunk would be suspended. Especially when it is so obvious that she had it there only because she had been hunting recently. And what murdering maniac tells the school administrators that the gun is there? The whole thing is pathetic.
It's quite ridiculous that a student who had her gun locked up in her trunk would be suspended. Especially when it is so obvious that she had it there only because she had been hunting recently. And what murdering maniac tells the school administrators that the gun is there? The whole thing is pathetic.
I can see getting expelled for a week or two. But criminal charges on the same bassis as an active shooter heel bent on death and destruction, not so mutch. If the school or the federal gopobers feel the need to charge her with something it should mme some form (a low form) of misdomeener(spelling?) she did break a rule and a law aftyer all wether we like that law or rule or not. As for the comments on her making a stupid mistake I think I'll agree with that. She knows that a firearm needs to be secured for many reason or at least she should know. Reguardless you take the gun out of the trunk before you go to school I did when I was in High school.
Post a Comment