


March 02, 2012
Book Review: One With the Wilderness
by Scott Bestul

Bowhunting is largely a solo endeavor. But how often is the modern bowhunter truly alone? Like most bowhunters, my primary game is the whitetail, and though I spend many hours chasing them each fall I’m rarely far from other people; there seem to always be nearby farms and homes, traffic noise is common from many of my stands, and it’s getting to be a rare hunt when I don’t have a cell phone in my pocket so my family can reach me “just in case.”
Though Illinois hunter Mike Mitten is no stranger to such experience, he’s also unafraid to tackle serious solo adventure, hunts where he is miles and days away from anything resembling help or civilization. Mitten has detailed some of his adventures in this great book, which takes readers on bowhunts for Illinois whitetail, Colorado elk, Ontario black bear, Alaskan moose, and other species. The primary theme of “One With the Wilderness” (order copies at www.brothersofthebow.com) is one of simple self-reliance. Mitten argues that hard-won woodsmanship skills , coupled with a sense of adventure, make for a deeper, more satisfying hunt…Whether you’re sitting in a treestand or have just been dropped off by a floatplane for a two weeks in the wilderness.
The tales that Mitten spins used to be fairly common in outdoor writing. Sadly, they’ve largely disappeared as the focus changed to more instructional pieces. Interestingly, even Mitten can’t resist the urge to lapse into how-to mode, and in my opinion these are the weakest moments of this book. Mitten is at his best when he simply tells us how he spent days chasing one maddening bull elk, or managed to shoot a giant moose with a recurve on a solitary hunt. If you’re like me, you’ll want to read “One With the Wilderness” to share in adventures you’ll likely never achieve. And if you should, finally, want to plan that solo wilderness hunt, you’ll want to order a different book, full of practicality and how-to advice.
Meanwhile, enjoy a vicarious adventure with this one.
Comments (3)
I almost always hunted big game alone. Back in the days before Ontario exploited our moose hunting to death, I would take my wall tent seventy plus miles north of here and stay for at least a week. Although my camp was at the end of a road, I almost never saw anyone. The last trip I made up there lasted two weeks and not a single vehicle arrived during that time. I never started the truck again once my camp was planted (and for good reason - the alternator went out so I needed to save the battery for trip home). My elk hunting camp in Montana was about thirty miles from the trail head. I always stayed at least a week and sometimes two. You can see photos in my profile album. This kind of long-term solo hunting takes some getting used to. For a normal person the silence can be pretty unnerving the first day or so. It’s also very strenuous. Taking care of myself was always a challenge and dealing with the horses every day was even more exhausting. Preparation was critical. And that doesn't mean packing the homestead on your back every time you head out for a day's hunting. It's a real science learning how to balance what you need versus weight and bulk. It's also a science learning what the physical limits of your body are on any given day (and at any given year - the aging process is not something that just happens one morning after you've turned fifty - it's slow and insidious). As experienced and careful as I was I still had a number of terribly close calls (which were usually self-imposed because I overextended myself). Nevertheless, I certainly recommend being alone in the wilderness. What it will do for the hunter or fisherman is without measure. It will ultimately change your whole perspective on what nature is all about and our place in it. However, I would never recommend jumping into this kind of thing cold turkey. An overnighter is a good first step. Then a three or four night stretch. Always break into this with situations where you can pack it in and get out if you need to. I cannot stress enough how much of a shock this can be for some folks. I had a city kid from LA with me for a day fishing trip up in Alaska. By the time I got him to the other end of Lake Naknek (forty miles) that guy was totally freaked out. I mean he was PANICKING. I thought he was going to jump overboard which would have been deadly in those waters. If someone had dropped him off up there in the middle of nowhere with a floatplane for a week, he would have been dead by the next morning.
It’s too bad the book devolved into a lot of how-to stuff. I’ll keep that in mind when I write mine. I agree, it seems that’s all editors and sponsors think audiences are interested in these days. Hopefully guys like this can get the art of outdoors storytelling back to what it once was.
I am always amazed at how difficult it is sometimes to be alone in the wilderness for days at a time. People fantasize about it being all super peaceful but I find that at times I have to do some serious soul searching in order to stay.
sounds good, thanks.
Post a Comment
I almost always hunted big game alone. Back in the days before Ontario exploited our moose hunting to death, I would take my wall tent seventy plus miles north of here and stay for at least a week. Although my camp was at the end of a road, I almost never saw anyone. The last trip I made up there lasted two weeks and not a single vehicle arrived during that time. I never started the truck again once my camp was planted (and for good reason - the alternator went out so I needed to save the battery for trip home). My elk hunting camp in Montana was about thirty miles from the trail head. I always stayed at least a week and sometimes two. You can see photos in my profile album. This kind of long-term solo hunting takes some getting used to. For a normal person the silence can be pretty unnerving the first day or so. It’s also very strenuous. Taking care of myself was always a challenge and dealing with the horses every day was even more exhausting. Preparation was critical. And that doesn't mean packing the homestead on your back every time you head out for a day's hunting. It's a real science learning how to balance what you need versus weight and bulk. It's also a science learning what the physical limits of your body are on any given day (and at any given year - the aging process is not something that just happens one morning after you've turned fifty - it's slow and insidious). As experienced and careful as I was I still had a number of terribly close calls (which were usually self-imposed because I overextended myself). Nevertheless, I certainly recommend being alone in the wilderness. What it will do for the hunter or fisherman is without measure. It will ultimately change your whole perspective on what nature is all about and our place in it. However, I would never recommend jumping into this kind of thing cold turkey. An overnighter is a good first step. Then a three or four night stretch. Always break into this with situations where you can pack it in and get out if you need to. I cannot stress enough how much of a shock this can be for some folks. I had a city kid from LA with me for a day fishing trip up in Alaska. By the time I got him to the other end of Lake Naknek (forty miles) that guy was totally freaked out. I mean he was PANICKING. I thought he was going to jump overboard which would have been deadly in those waters. If someone had dropped him off up there in the middle of nowhere with a floatplane for a week, he would have been dead by the next morning.
It’s too bad the book devolved into a lot of how-to stuff. I’ll keep that in mind when I write mine. I agree, it seems that’s all editors and sponsors think audiences are interested in these days. Hopefully guys like this can get the art of outdoors storytelling back to what it once was.
I am always amazed at how difficult it is sometimes to be alone in the wilderness for days at a time. People fantasize about it being all super peaceful but I find that at times I have to do some serious soul searching in order to stay.
sounds good, thanks.
Post a Comment