By Tim Romano & Kirk Deeter
... Is Often No More Than A "BB"
I have never met an angler who doesn’t like or respect Pat Dorsey. For those of you who do not know Pat, he is, hands down, the “hot stick” guide on the trout rivers closest to Denver, namely the highly technical Cheesman Canyon section of the South Platte River, the “Dream Stream” section of the Platte (up in South Park), the Williams Fork of the Colorado (near Kremmling), and pretty much anywhere else he chooses to guide. He literally wrote the book on fly fishing the South Platte.
The fact that Pat is almost uniformly recognized as the best guide in one of the busiest trout fishing regions in America is tall praise. But despite all of that, he remains humble, hard working, and amazingly open with his “bag of tricks.” The most important lesson he ever shared came on a notoriously crowded day near Deckers – one of those days when conditions were challenging, the fish were stubborn, and the place was packed with so many anglers, we simply didn’t have the option of bouncing from one run to the next.... [ Read Full Post ]
By Tim Romano & Kirk Deeter
Runoff is in full swing in Colorado, so it may be the perfect time of year to explore other waters you have considered fishing and trek in to see what it is like, or fill up the belly boat to fish one of the many reservoirs that populate the great state of Colorado.
Currently Cheesman Canyon, Deckers, Arkansas, and the North Fork of the South Platte River are experiencing run-off coloration and levels. They are still fishable next to the banks and behind large structures, but why throw flies when you can’t see fish is my philosophy. If you do go, check the Colorado Division of Water Resources website for current flows. And use this scouting rig to find the fish: A standard two- or three-fly system with a San Juan worm, baetis, and emerger set-up. Give yourself 15 minutes in your starting position before changing flies or location. If you’re not having much luck, try seining the water or checking under rocks to see what bugs are moving, then imitate accordingly. [ Read Full Post ]
By Tim Romano & Kirk Deeter
Runoff is starting to bring all the major rivers up in Colorado. We’re still fishing the North Fork of the South Platte with good results using San Juan worms, caddis nymphs, and the like. The Arkansas is fishing well, with baetis still hatching between BV and Salida … the caddis are starting to pop up as well. Forecast calls for warm weather to continue, mixed with thunderstorms. As the rivers run high, we’ll turn our attention to lake fishing for brook trout. Standard streamers (woolly buggers) are already working in the lakes in areas that have melted. [ Read Full Post ]
By Tim Romano & Kirk Deeter
Look at these! Taken this past Sunday in Gore Canyon, Colorado by my good friend Jeff Rogers.
--Tim
[ Read Full Post ]
By Tim Romano & Kirk Deeter
[ Read Full Post ]
By Tim Romano & Kirk Deeter
But let’s not kid ourselves. Catch-and-release done wrong is selfish. It’s a simple issue of motive.
Jim Harrison offered the best perspective on the matter I’ve ever read. He said, “Catch-and-release is sensible, which shouldn’t be confused with virtuous. ‘I beat the shit out of you but I didn’t kill you’ is not clearly understood by the fish. This is a blood sport, and if you want a politically correct afterglow, you should return to golf.”
I advocate catch-and-release fishing, on the rivers, in the lakes, and on the ocean. But I’m not about to stand on this soap-box and say I haven’t kept a striper, or a salmon, or a redfish, or even a trout for a meal, now and then. And statistics will show you that mortality rates among fish caught and released are likely higher than you’d want to know, some say as high as 20 percent, depending on the species, and factors like water temperature. The guy who nets, manhandles, de-slimes, and half-suffocates 30 fish while his buddy fumbles for the camera -- but lets them all go -- is tougher on the resource than the guy who pops a couple... [ Read Full Post ]
By Tim Romano & Kirk Deeter
In the perfect scenario, a trout rises and sips down your dry fly. If you wait too long to set the hook then, what happens? Right. It spits the fly.
And, sometimes, in fact, you foul-hook that fish. I remember once fouling a brown on the Bighorn, and after guide Dan Stein plucked the nymph out of the trout’s tail, he said, “It ate it, and crapped it out … you were too slow.” Well, not literally, but the point was well taken.
All of which leads me to ask if it is really dirty pool to set the hook when you aren’t 100 percent sure? Isn’t that just improving your odds by getting the jump on the fish? Dare I say that being a bit quicker on the draw might actually decrease the snag factor?
No doubt, intentional snagging is bad form. Foul hookups will happen, but less often among good anglers.
Believe me, even if you mini-set, you’ll still miss a good percentage of takes that you cannot see under the surface. I’m just not sold on the argument that setting the hook first and asking questions later is an angling... [ Read Full Post ]
By Tim Romano & Kirk Deeter
For the record, Creature might be one of the most decorated big game fishermen on the Atlantic seaboard, but his closet fishing passion is chasing trout with flies.
“How do you figure,” I asked, totally perplexed by the comparison.
And he explained: “Fish like changes.” Changes in currents, changes in depth, changes in water color, changes in structure. If you find a patch of sea grass floating in the open ocean, you’ll find fish under it. If you find a place where currents converge and bait schools, fish will be there also. Reefs, wrecks, and rock formations attract fish too.
So apply that thinking when you go to the trout river. Look for changes in currents, where swift water meets slow water, changes in structure, where rocks and trees create holding water, changes in depth, like shelves and pools, or changes in color, which usually signals a depth or structural transition. “It’s all pretty much the same,” Creature laughed. “You trout guys can walk or row a boat to find those changes, and we have to run a bit out here to find them … but that’s how you locate fish.” Find the changes, and you... [ Read Full Post ]
By Tim Romano & Kirk Deeter
Here is another great backyard exercise Dan Wright taught me to help train the proper feel into my cast. First, tilt your rod sideways and cast from waist or chest level on a flat plane above the ground. You might use a measuring tape stretched straight along the ground to be your benchmark. Start with small flicks of line, maybe 15 feet long. As you look at the line shooting back and forth, you’ll be able to see and feel both good “U”-shaped loops and tailing loops. Make both forward and backward casts from a dead stop. Eventually, you can link those casts together. Build line length gradually. As those good loops become uniform and systematic, you’ll be able to lift that cast 90 degrees over your head, still watching, and feeling, how the line shapes. If you tail, start over. The key is keeping the tempo even. Good loops grow in distance with practice. [ Read Full Post ]
By Tim Romano & Kirk Deeter
So here’s the best tip I ever learned to straighten out the issue of going too far on the backcast. It came from Dan Stein, a guide on the Bighorn River in Montana. He simply suggests you keep your casting thumb in your
peripheral vision at all times. Lose sight of your thumb, and you’re going back too far. [ Read Full Post ]
By Tim Romano & Kirk Deeter
We graded each reel on a 1-5 scale in three areas:
1. Price
2. How the reel felt and reacted as the motorcycle sped away
3. How we like handling the reel
Then we made “judges deductions” for any beefs we had about the reels.
Price/Features
Suggested retail: $940 There’s no denying that Abel is the standard bearer of big game flyfishing reels. The record books speak for themselves. Along with Tibor/Pate reels, this is the M-16 of the saltwater army.
Score: 3 out of 5
How it “Met the Street”
This reel was also tested a bit above its pedigree at 55 mph. At $940, we felt that was fair. We heard a squeak at the start – not a problem lubricant cannot fix – and despite that, the reel hummed along as we hoped it would. It was actually a good run. A touch of dip on the startup, but once she started rolling (a half-second later) the Abel did all it was supposed to do. Not earthshakingly impressive, just steady. Honest.
Score: 3.5 out of 5
Functional Review
We’ll say it again, the screw to undo the spool is a pain... [ Read Full Post ]
By Tim Romano & Kirk Deeter
We graded each reel on a 1-5 scale in three areas:
1. Price
2. How the reel felt and reacted as the motorcycle sped away
3. How we like handling the reel
Then we made “judges deductions” for any beefs we had about the reels.
Price/Features
The Hatch Outdoors 9-Plus is the biggest reel the company markets … so far. There’s a bigger brother in development, but we threw this one to the lions. Retail is $800.
Score 3.5 out of 5
How it “Met the Street”
No warmup, no worries. We just tied it on and hit the gas. In terms of pure startup – that initial grab where the drag engages and the reel starts paying out line – this reel is one of the best. There are just no surprises. And that speaks very highly about the engineering of the drag.
Score: 4 out of 5
Functional Review
Aside from the motorcycle test, we recently fished Hatch reels down the length of the Baja and back. In the sand and the salt, and the grit … with all sorts of species pulling on them. The reels really perform well in terms of tolerance (no... [ Read Full Post ]
By Tim Romano & Kirk Deeter
We graded each reel on a 1-5 scale in three areas:
1. Price
2. How the reel felt and reacted as the motorcycle sped away
3. How we like handling the reel
Then we made “judges deductions” for any beefs we had about the reels.
Price/Features
Nautilus makes a 12 ($500), a 12T ($565), and a 12S (for $595). For this sized reel aimed at tarpon and above, those are all pretty fair prices. We tested the 12 S.
Score: 4.5 out of 5
How it “Met the Street”
A touch of bump felt at launch, but beyond that, the reel, with a carbon fiber and cork combo in the drag, did a very nice job of paying out line with a grudge against the bike. Jeff felt like he had a parachute dragging behind him as he accelerated. No heat, no stink. No problem.
Score: 4 out of 5
Functional Review
Nautilus is the only brand we tested in all three classes. The functionality attributes we described apply throughout the different series the company produces. Not a whole lot to argue with. Not a lot of bells and whistles; just a “shut up and fish”... [ Read Full Post ]
By Tim Romano & Kirk Deeter
We graded each reel on a 1-5 scale in three areas:
1. Price
2. How the reel felt and reacted as the motorcycle sped away
3. How we like handling the reel
Then we made “judges deductions” for any beefs we had about the reels.
Price/Features
$625. This is the standard in Orvis’ saltwater reel lineup. It has all the bells and whistles of most high-end saltwater reels, with a slightly more attractive pricepoint.
Score: 4 out of 5
How it “Met the Street”
Well … we darn near set ‘er on fire. Granted, we weren’t playing fair: We ran it at 55 mph, threw water on it during the run, and clamped the drag down fairly tight … but we charred the cork drag. This was an extreme test. This reel is rock star when we fish it on the flats. But the fact is, we tested four reels to the max, and this one smoked.
Score: 2 out of 5
Functional Review
The amount of cork incorporated in the drag surface is probably not quite enough. It’s a slick enough system, just a little underdone, like... [ Read Full Post ]