Winchester Model 12, 12 gauge, modified. Just call me old fashioned.

P.S. I'd pick the 391 because it is light, very reliable, and its gas operation makes it fairly soft-shooting. It would be one gun I could shoot for everything: birds, waterfowl, turkeys, deer and clay targets.

I will always have my Father's old Mossberg 500AT. I've used it most of my life, and it feels more natural than anything else.

I would take the Remington 870 in a 12ga. You can hunt anything with it and it is a reliable firearm .

I've always loved my Remington 1100 in 12 ga. but when I shot my buddys 12 ga. Benelli auto I broke every clay thrown! I also like my 16 ga. Ithaca 37 (new) and the Iver Johnson Champion 16 ga. like my Grandpa's last gun.... Picking a favorite is almost like trying to pick which one of your kids you love most, almost impossible. :-]

I guess I'd go with the 1100. It really feels good in my hands. :-)

i would pick my Ithaca 37 16 gauge or my semiauto charles daily 20 gauge

A second job. Maybe a move to a location that allows more than one. Maybe a new wife. I would remove the obstacle standing between me and another shotgun.

These I prefer more than choosing one shotgun.

benelli m2 field

Mossberg 500 in 12 gauge. Great for home defense and out in the field.

if I had to pick just one, would say Mossberg 500 12ga. not the prettiest, but well designed and reliable or my 16ga ithaca double yup my double if had to pick just one no more turkeys, ducks or geese just my double and upland birds but life would be much less fufilling with only one shotgun

You can't beat the Remingon 870 Special Purpose with interchangeable chokes and 3 inch chamber. Never fails and the interchangeable chokes allow it to be used for everything you can use a shotgun for. (And you don't get tempted by the 31/2 inch shells with their brutal recoil.)

I would go with the 11-87 also - the 1100 is not as versatile with different loads using the older gas system. The 11-87 has enough different chokes, barrels, and aftermarket accessories available that you can set it up for pretty much any task that can be done with a shotgun.

It would be my 12 gauge O/U that I feel the most comfortable with to hunt rabbit to moose is necessary.

a benelli m2 12 gauge