


February 02, 2006
High-Fence Hunting: Indiana legislature votes to end canned hunts
By Dave Hurteau & Chad Love
Indiana House Bill 1349 would have legalized fenced hunting despite a state agency’s decision last year to end the practice. But an amendment passed yesterday that reverses the bill would stop new high-fence operations from opening and allow existing preserves to operate for just seven more years—eventually ending the practice altogether in the state. What do you think about high-fence hunting? Should it be legal? Click here for the story
Comments (4)
If you were to hunt on an island of only a few thousand acres, could that be considered a canned hunt? My guess is no. If someone wants to grow big deer on their property is their right to do so. Why do people care so much about what other people are doing as long as they don't hurt the environment or someone else? If we could get everyone to let the small deer go so that they have a chance to reach mature then there would be no need for high fences but history has proven that is not possible. I don't have a high fence operation, nor do I hunt in them.
30,000 acres.Still BS.Esp. if the only reason is the "management of trophy whitetail deer".Why not just bottle raise them and feed them cyanide when they score 170 B&C??Unless the fence is used in agricultural operations (i have yet to see a bull clear 8 feet) it is pen hunting at best...a big pen, but still a pen. Like I said before...LAZY.
How do you define a high fence? If it's 30,000 acres but it's still enclosed is that still high fence? Still BS?
good for indiana.high fence hunting is BS..if you have to resort to that, I bet youre the type of guy who likes to pay to catch trout at a hatchery.a lot of folks like to call them selves outdoorsmen, but they are too fat and lazy to get 200yards off the road w/o an atv.those are the kind of folks who sing on high the praises of fences.T. Roosevelt (of Boone & Crockett fame...) would vomit if he saw all of these so called high fence hunts.
As a resident of Indiana, I am vehemently opposed to the business of game farming, and don't want it in my state. This opinion is shared by 85% of Indiana residents according to numerous polls. The Bellar preserve incident was a stain on the integrity of Hoosiers in general, and Hoosier hunters in particular. Most of us weren't even aware of the existence of these operations, and on the heels of Bellargate the citizenry clearly expressed to both our DNR and Legislature that we wanted these operations banned. Recently, several of them have been quarantined for bovine tuberculosis incidents, a disease that hasn't been detected in any Hoosier livestock in over thirty years. The threat to the rest of our agricultural industry is immediate and serious. If game farms haven't sprouted up in your state contact your representatives and ensure that they never do.
Post a Comment
If you were to hunt on an island of only a few thousand acres, could that be considered a canned hunt? My guess is no. If someone wants to grow big deer on their property is their right to do so. Why do people care so much about what other people are doing as long as they don't hurt the environment or someone else? If we could get everyone to let the small deer go so that they have a chance to reach mature then there would be no need for high fences but history has proven that is not possible. I don't have a high fence operation, nor do I hunt in them.
30,000 acres.Still BS.Esp. if the only reason is the "management of trophy whitetail deer".Why not just bottle raise them and feed them cyanide when they score 170 B&C??Unless the fence is used in agricultural operations (i have yet to see a bull clear 8 feet) it is pen hunting at best...a big pen, but still a pen. Like I said before...LAZY.
How do you define a high fence? If it's 30,000 acres but it's still enclosed is that still high fence? Still BS?
good for indiana.high fence hunting is BS..if you have to resort to that, I bet youre the type of guy who likes to pay to catch trout at a hatchery.a lot of folks like to call them selves outdoorsmen, but they are too fat and lazy to get 200yards off the road w/o an atv.those are the kind of folks who sing on high the praises of fences.T. Roosevelt (of Boone & Crockett fame...) would vomit if he saw all of these so called high fence hunts.
As a resident of Indiana, I am vehemently opposed to the business of game farming, and don't want it in my state. This opinion is shared by 85% of Indiana residents according to numerous polls. The Bellar preserve incident was a stain on the integrity of Hoosiers in general, and Hoosier hunters in particular. Most of us weren't even aware of the existence of these operations, and on the heels of Bellargate the citizenry clearly expressed to both our DNR and Legislature that we wanted these operations banned. Recently, several of them have been quarantined for bovine tuberculosis incidents, a disease that hasn't been detected in any Hoosier livestock in over thirty years. The threat to the rest of our agricultural industry is immediate and serious. If game farms haven't sprouted up in your state contact your representatives and ensure that they never do.
Post a Comment