The Six Best Lever Action Rifles (and When to Use Them) | Field & Stream

The Six Best Lever Action Rifles (and When to Use Them)

Browning BLR

The Browning BLR.

Browning

I CAN EASILY measure a rifle's worth in cold mechanical terms, but not so the lever action. Let me put it this way: Can you picture John Wayne with anything but a lever gun? It's easier to imagine Roy Rogers accompanying himself on the harp, or the Lone Ranger yelling "Hi-yo, Titanium." The lever action isn't just a type of rifle; it's part of our American culture.

For all that, what was once the hunting rifle has faded in popularity. It was long ago up-staged by the bolt action, whose greater precision and power won our hearts and minds and wallets. The lever has also suffered from our current worship of long-range shooting, and the fact that we now hunt deer from trees, where its wonderful handling qualities are not appreciated, instead of on our two legs.

But is it obsolete? Not likely, pilgrim.

A GUN OF SIMPLE VIRTUES...
The first practical lever-action repeater—the Henry—appeared during the Civil War, and its successor, the Winchester Model 66, arrived just as our great westward expansion began. Soldiers and frontiersmen alike doted on the lever action because, unlike all other rifles of the day, it shot a lot without reloading—and it kept on shooting no matter what you did to it. So that is the first of the lever's virtues: It is dead reliable, even when neglected.

Levers came in all shapes and sizes, but the most popular were short barreled. Few firearms ride as well in a saddle scabbard. You could have it in your hand and on target quickly. And you could get off repeat aimed shots quickly, with a minimum of practice. A really skillful shooter could fire rounds so fast, they sounded like a drumroll.

...AND LIMITATIONS
Of course, the lever rifle had its drawbacks. It wasn't as strong as single-shots and bolts. In the era of blackpowder cartridges, for which levers were originally chambered, this didn't matter so much, but when smokeless powder became the standard, and higher pressures along with it, the lever action lost ground to the bolt gun. The old levers could not tolerate the pressures generated by modern cartridges.

Their tubular magazines complicated matters. To shoot at long range, you must use pointed bullets, but if you load a tubular magazine with spitzers, the point of each slug rests on the primer of the round ahead of it. When you pull the trigger, the round in the chamber may not be the only one that goes off.

Nor was the lever action designed for precision shooting. The trigger pulls were nowhere near as good as those of bolt rifles, and the way the guns were constructed meant they would never be as accurate. When you attach a magazine tube to a barrel, or attach a fore-end with a barrel band, you doom the gun right there.

Over the years, several manufacturers have attempted to produce lever actions without the lever's limitations. Probably the most conspicuous failure was the Model 88 Winchester. Arguably the best-looking lever gun ever made, it fed from a box magazine, so you could use pointed bullets, and had the same type of bolt lockup as a bolt action, so you could use modern, high-intensity cartridges. It had a truly dreadful trigger, however, and was capable of only mediocre (by bolt-action standards) accuracy.

Still, this rifle action should be appreciated for what it is. Here's a short review of the state of the lever:

lever-action rifle

The Browning BLR Lightweight

Browning

1 The Browning BLR

It set new standards for frightfulness of line and disharmony of shape, but the BLR is a good gun, and its appearance has been improved in recent years. It feeds from a box magazine and is chambered for high-velocity cartridges. Thanks to a ratchet system that runs its bolt back and forward, the BLR is extremely smooth and fast. It remains handicapped by a trigger that you can sort of live with, and accuracy that is, for the most part, okay but no better.

Takedown lever actions are almost as old as lever actions, but the idea has been reborn. This year, Browning is offering takedown models in all its BLR variants. Locked into the receiver, the barrel is released by a lever mechanism. And instead of mounting the scope on the receiver, you put a long-eye-relief model on the barrel, which should eliminate any point-of-impact shift when you reassemble it.

winchester 94

The Winchester Model 94

Winchester

2 The Winchester Model 94
In production for 112 years, the Model 94 was the first sporting rifle to sell a million—and has now sold seven times that number. So anything I can say about it is moot. If it were my money, I'd look for a pre-64 model and be prepared to pay a few dollars. What I'm not crazy about are the host of commemorative 94s that have been produced—more than 90 models since 1966. Permit me to quote from the 2006 Standard Catalog of Firearms:

"The general liquidity of these commemoratives has not been as good as would be expected.... In our opinion, one should purchase weapons of this nature for their enjoyment factor as the investment potential is not sufficient reason for their purchase."

Which leads us to Winchester Rifles and Shotguns John Wayne Winchester Model 1892 100th Anniversary Rifle: a .44/40 lever action with all sorts of decoration and a price tag of nearly $3,500. If you'd like to own a gun just like the Duke carried in his movies but with far more bling, be my guest. I prefer to honor his memory by beating the hell out of someone whose politics are to the left of mine and who is much smaller than me.

For more, check out Range365: Gun of the Week: Winchester 1894

winchester model 71

The Winchester Model 71.

Winchester

3 The Winchester Model 71
Never popular, the 71 was made only from 1935 to 1957, in small numbers, and was chambered for an odd cartridge—the.348—that has never been used in another gun. All this aside, it is a superb and unique rifle that shares the virtues of the 94, but with a smoother action and a lot more power.

Winchester 88

The Winchester Model 88.

Winchester

4 The Winchester Model 88
This sleek rifle lasted only 18 years in the marketplace and does not command a lot of money today on the used-gun market. If you find one in .308 or .358 Winchester, look hard at it, but I can't get enthusiastic. The trigger varies from poor to awful and can't be fixed. Accuracy is good at best, and often much less than that. The 88 is a lever gun that wants to be a bolt action but can't hack it

marlin 1895

The Marlin 1895.

Marlin

5 The Marlin Model 336/1895
There are more Marlin lever variants around than I can possibly go into, but a Marlin 336 in .30/30 or .35 is about as good a deer gun as you can get. And my heart goes out to the Model 1895 Guide Gun in .45/70—very short, very handy, and loads of muscle when used with modern ammo.

If you're afflicted with Bolt-Action Inferiority Complex, Marlin has a pair of lever guns chambered for the new .308 Marlin Express cartridge, which duplicates the ballistics of the .308 and features, it is claimed, an effective range of 400 yards. They are the MX model (blued, 22-inch barrel, walnut stock) and the MXLR (pictured above; 24-inch barrel, all stainless, laminated stock). As for me, I will stick with the traditional models. They're closer than anything else on today's market to the guns of the good old days—blued steel and walnut done right.

savage 99

The Savage 99

Savage Arms

6 The Savage Model 99
Not only was this brilliant design a century ahead of its time, but it was around for a century—1899 to 1999—and was made in a profusion of models. The older, more desirable 99s have rotary magazines; newer, less sought-after versions have detachable-box magazines. Prices for used 99s are going up very sharply, and there is a lot of shuck, jive, and fraud out there, with people paying fancy prices for 99s that aren't worth it.

Look for a rotary-magazine model in .308 or .300 Savage, or—if you're willing to pay—hold out for a 99 in .250/3000 Savage. This wonderful little round drops deer with almost no recoil. Do not hesitate to take your 99 in for a trigger job. It's one of the few lever guns that can be given a decent pull. But some 99s are very accurate while others aren't, and never will be. Shoot the gun before you pay for it.

GOING LONG WITH THE LEVER
IF YOUR LIFE is a waking hell because you can't make long shots with your lever gun, Hornady may have the solution. LeverEvolution ammo consists of all the old, slow favorites—.45/70, .30/30, .35—loaded with newly designed spitzer bullets that have soft polymer tips, which will not detonate in a tubular magazine. I tried them in my Marlin .45/70, and my guess is they will add 100 to 200 yards to the effective range of any tubular-magazine lever gun. Price depends on caliber (hornady.com).

Latest


More Stories


Videos