Ruger Model 77
Designed in 1968, the Ruger M77 is heavy-duty and rugged gun.. Reader Submitted

Today’s gunfight pits a couple of smallish deer calibers against each other in a pair of bolt-action deer rifles. The .243 was developed in 1955 as a dual purpose varmint-deer cartridge. It has killed tons and tons—literally—of deer, but you can still start a lively gun-camp argument about whether it is too light for deer hunting. The .257 lets you shoot heavier bullets faster, although at a higher price if you buy factory cartridges instead of hand loading. It was reportedly Roy Weatherby’s favorite, and a round he developed as a wildcat in the 40s.

Alexander’s 700

Remington 700 .257 Weatherby
A hard-working, bolt gun, the Remington 700 pairs well with just about any caliber. Reader Submitted

I’m not one to give inanimate objects names but there are exceptions: this is my rifle Sweet Sixteen. It’s the Remington 700 rifle chambered in .257 Weatherby my father gave me as a 16th birthday present. I didn’t get a car or pickup like most kids; I received a rifle instead. Here in Iowa I don’t get to use it as much as I would like, but when Iowa had the special late antlerless centerfire season a couple of years back this rifle hit like Thor’s hammer with hand-loaded 120-grain Nolser Partions, on top of 70 grains of Rl-25 powder. With hand-loaded 115 grain Nosler ballistic tips, it makes the local coyotes shiver and quiver like none other. I plan on taking it to North Dakota this winter when I go to see family and see how well Sweet Sixteen will do on big Northern ‘yotes.

Tracy’s M77


Gun Fight Friday: .257 vs .243

Designed in 1968, the Ruger M77 is heavy-duty and rugged gun.

This is a .243 Ruger M77 with a tang safety, red recoil pad, and a Redfield 3×9. It shoots 1-inch groups at 100 yards, with about any 100-grain bullet. I bought it last year to give my shoulder a rest and shot a 6-point whitetail in southwest Oklahoma with it. It was 110 yard heart shot. The deer ran 60 yards, and that was that. I’m not sure I am ready to give up my .270 and .308, but the .243 sure is fun to shoot.

Vote and comment below, and keep the gun pictures coming to

Which gun do you prefer?
Alexander’s 700
Tracy’s M77
Poll Maker

RELATED: Gun Fight Friday: Lightweight Rifles