Please Sign In

Please enter a valid username and password
  • Log in with Facebook
» Not a member? Take a moment to register
» Forgot Username or Password

Why Register?
Signing up could earn you gear (click here to learn how)! It also keeps offensive content off our site.

AnswersASK YOUR QUESTION

Answers

Q:
Best hunting revolver. S&W X-Frame revolvers (.460 and .500) are not acceptable answers. Go.

Question by shane. Uploaded on May 14, 2009

Answers (22)

Top Rated
All Answers
from hnestle wrote 3 years 1 week ago

I would have to say my ruger blackhawk with a 9 1/2 in. barrel in a 44 mag.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from jay wrote 3 years 1 week ago

S&W 629 .44mag 8 and three eights inch barrel.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from cAnyBux90 wrote 3 years 1 week ago

Nothing beats a 44 mag. I really enjoy my ruger blackhawk although the barrel is not quite long enough. Anything in 44 mag makes quite a hunting handgun though

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from idahooutdoors wrote 3 years 1 week ago

My S&W 7 shot 686 6 inch stainless in .357 has been a faithful companion on my hip in the wolf, cougar, and bear infested mountains of Idaho. I hit what I aim at, and it doesn't weight me down as badly as some of the larger magnums.... 158 grain semi Flat Point Oregon Trail Laser Cast Silver bullets loaded over a stiff dosage of Lil Gun seem to penetrate into the vitals of about any animal I encounter around my neck of the woods out to 100 yards or so....

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from dodge power wrote 3 years 1 week ago

S&w 686 7 shot is a very nice revolver. In 357mag its good on deer. Good self deffense gun to.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from idduckhntr wrote 3 years 1 week ago

Freedom Arms 454.

+3 Good Comment? | | Report
from CPT BRAD wrote 3 years 1 week ago

Well you took out the best two but a 454 or a AMT 30 carbine come to mind.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from Big O wrote 3 years 1 week ago

T/C Contender .44mag,30TC,7mm Waters,.30-30,.270,.30-06

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from jasonb wrote 3 years 1 week ago

.454 Casull. It delivers similar energy to a 30-30. The Freedom Arms revolvers are awesome; but you can get a Ruger Super Redhawk for half the cost.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from 007 wrote 3 years 1 week ago

Super Blackhawk in barrel length appropriate to the task at hand.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from DakotaMan wrote 3 years 1 week ago

I really like my Ruger Redhawk in .44mag, 7 1/2 inch barrel. I can actually hit accurately enough to deer hunt at 100 yards with practice. The recoil is manageable but it has enough thump to drop anything up to deer size. The only slight issue with it is that it is heavy to carry at 4 pounds + a ton of lead but I rationalize that away knowing the fact that it is reducing felt recoil. (Oh, also there is a slight problem with having to carry a fire extinguisher on my back to put out the trees and bushes when I shoot! I like real hot loads and they shoot flames about three feet to each side causing severe forest fire risk! lol).

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from ishawooa wrote 3 years 1 week ago

As much as I like Super Blackhawks and various versions of the M-29, I would have to go with the Freedom Arms single action revolvers. Regardless of caliber they have at least two things that everyone agrees on: high quality and high price. Unfortunately the last piece keeps me from buying one. I would pay that much for a rifle but somehow can't bring myself to ante up a couple grand for a revolver.
Even if in the rare event that you locate a used one it is still unacceptably expensive. I suppose that speaks highly of the inherent quality.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from shane wrote 3 years 1 week ago

Yeah I was wondering how much Freedom Arms were going to be mentioned. I would love one too, but the price, whooeee.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from ishawooa wrote 3 years 1 week ago

DakotaMan: Long ago I got John Linebaugh to help out with my old model Super Blackhawk three screw 7 1/2". After much persuading he agreeded to cut the barrel back to 4 5/8" and put an absolutely outstanding trigger job on it. This makes an awesome revolver to pack when walking or horseback. I carry it in a reworked Bianchi holster in crossdraw fashion. With this carry I can easily reach the gun with a coat on, if I encounter a bear and have to assume the "fetal position" I might be able to pull the .44, and I can glance down to see if it is still in the holster after a fall or a bucking horse episode. But as you mentioned the muzzle blast with HOT 265 gr hard cast wide meplat bullets is horrendous as is the flame of the 296 residue. Five quick rounds from this little piece makes you and everything around you think that the gates of hell were temporarily opened so we all can feel the heat and say a prayer. I really don't notice any increase in recoil although physics dictates that there should be more than a 7 1/2 incher. I learned to prefer the weight in hand balance of the shorter barrel although it felt a bit odd initially.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from jbird wrote 3 years 1 week ago

Love my .41 mag. Feels like half the recoil compared to my .44, deadly accurate. Love my .44 too, and have seen it do impressive things to whitetails.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from hjohn429 wrote 3 years 5 days ago

Ruger RedHawk in 44 Magnum is great for anything from antelope to Moose. For the bigger things I would say the BFR revolvers chambered in 444 Marlin , 450 Marlin or 45/70 Govt.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from Rem700-06 wrote 3 years 5 days ago

T/C Encore, currently chambered in 45-70. One of the best things about the gun is it's versatility, for half the price of a new pistol you can buy a new barrel in a different caliber.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from Fardarrigger wrote 2 years 28 weeks ago

I inherited what was my dream revolver as a kid from my Dad, a Ruger Redhawk .41 Magnum with a 7 1/2 inch barrel. It shoots like a dream, and is more accurate than I am. Recoil on the loads I have used is pretty minimal, and it is altogether a sweet gun. Love it.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from dangerous game wrote 2 years 22 weeks ago

ruger super redhawk .454 cassull.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from shane wrote 2 years 22 weeks ago

What does revolver mean to you, Rem700-06?

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from rudyglove27 wrote 1 year 51 weeks ago

Agreed with idduckhntr and + 1 for you sir!!!

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from John Benjamin Tatum wrote 1 year 6 weeks ago

I have extensive hunting experience with the following three revolvers... Smith & Wesson 627 N Frame - .357 Magnum - w/scope, Smith & Wesson 629 N Frame - .44 Magnum - w/scope, Smith & Wesson 500 X Frame - .500 S&W Magnum w/scope... and when I go hunting with a handgun I carry all three with me.
It all depends on what my game is, and what predators are in the field. Some areas, a Model 627 is considered illegal for taking game due to it being too small of a caliber (but great for taking down predators). The Model 500 is the ultimate game weapon, but the starter of this thread excluded the X-Frame models (why? Perhaps due to the retail price, mine is "second hand" because five rounds ONLY were fired in it, by someone with no large frame handgun experience, and the price was half retail).
So the Model 629 is the only weapon that is legal in every jurisdiction in the United States for Game Hunting. So if I MUST exclude the Model 500, the Model 629 is my choice for a handgun for all size game and predators if I must have only one.
But, I believe in the Model 500 because it is a "sniper revolver" or "hunter revolver"... where if you are a true hunter, it should be a situation where cruelty never occurs, so "one shot, one kill". A Model 627 or Model 629, while you can do the same... you must be much closer for a similar effect or have a heavier grain load and different bullet.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from shane wrote 1 year 6 weeks ago

I excluded them because I knew they would come up. I wanted to hear about others.

0 Good Comment? | | Report

Post an Answer

from idduckhntr wrote 3 years 1 week ago

Freedom Arms 454.

+3 Good Comment? | | Report
from hnestle wrote 3 years 1 week ago

I would have to say my ruger blackhawk with a 9 1/2 in. barrel in a 44 mag.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from cAnyBux90 wrote 3 years 1 week ago

Nothing beats a 44 mag. I really enjoy my ruger blackhawk although the barrel is not quite long enough. Anything in 44 mag makes quite a hunting handgun though

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from Big O wrote 3 years 1 week ago

T/C Contender .44mag,30TC,7mm Waters,.30-30,.270,.30-06

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from 007 wrote 3 years 1 week ago

Super Blackhawk in barrel length appropriate to the task at hand.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from ishawooa wrote 3 years 1 week ago

As much as I like Super Blackhawks and various versions of the M-29, I would have to go with the Freedom Arms single action revolvers. Regardless of caliber they have at least two things that everyone agrees on: high quality and high price. Unfortunately the last piece keeps me from buying one. I would pay that much for a rifle but somehow can't bring myself to ante up a couple grand for a revolver.
Even if in the rare event that you locate a used one it is still unacceptably expensive. I suppose that speaks highly of the inherent quality.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from ishawooa wrote 3 years 1 week ago

DakotaMan: Long ago I got John Linebaugh to help out with my old model Super Blackhawk three screw 7 1/2". After much persuading he agreeded to cut the barrel back to 4 5/8" and put an absolutely outstanding trigger job on it. This makes an awesome revolver to pack when walking or horseback. I carry it in a reworked Bianchi holster in crossdraw fashion. With this carry I can easily reach the gun with a coat on, if I encounter a bear and have to assume the "fetal position" I might be able to pull the .44, and I can glance down to see if it is still in the holster after a fall or a bucking horse episode. But as you mentioned the muzzle blast with HOT 265 gr hard cast wide meplat bullets is horrendous as is the flame of the 296 residue. Five quick rounds from this little piece makes you and everything around you think that the gates of hell were temporarily opened so we all can feel the heat and say a prayer. I really don't notice any increase in recoil although physics dictates that there should be more than a 7 1/2 incher. I learned to prefer the weight in hand balance of the shorter barrel although it felt a bit odd initially.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from hjohn429 wrote 3 years 5 days ago

Ruger RedHawk in 44 Magnum is great for anything from antelope to Moose. For the bigger things I would say the BFR revolvers chambered in 444 Marlin , 450 Marlin or 45/70 Govt.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from Rem700-06 wrote 3 years 5 days ago

T/C Encore, currently chambered in 45-70. One of the best things about the gun is it's versatility, for half the price of a new pistol you can buy a new barrel in a different caliber.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from Fardarrigger wrote 2 years 28 weeks ago

I inherited what was my dream revolver as a kid from my Dad, a Ruger Redhawk .41 Magnum with a 7 1/2 inch barrel. It shoots like a dream, and is more accurate than I am. Recoil on the loads I have used is pretty minimal, and it is altogether a sweet gun. Love it.

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from jay wrote 3 years 1 week ago

S&W 629 .44mag 8 and three eights inch barrel.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from idahooutdoors wrote 3 years 1 week ago

My S&W 7 shot 686 6 inch stainless in .357 has been a faithful companion on my hip in the wolf, cougar, and bear infested mountains of Idaho. I hit what I aim at, and it doesn't weight me down as badly as some of the larger magnums.... 158 grain semi Flat Point Oregon Trail Laser Cast Silver bullets loaded over a stiff dosage of Lil Gun seem to penetrate into the vitals of about any animal I encounter around my neck of the woods out to 100 yards or so....

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from dodge power wrote 3 years 1 week ago

S&w 686 7 shot is a very nice revolver. In 357mag its good on deer. Good self deffense gun to.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from CPT BRAD wrote 3 years 1 week ago

Well you took out the best two but a 454 or a AMT 30 carbine come to mind.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from jasonb wrote 3 years 1 week ago

.454 Casull. It delivers similar energy to a 30-30. The Freedom Arms revolvers are awesome; but you can get a Ruger Super Redhawk for half the cost.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from DakotaMan wrote 3 years 1 week ago

I really like my Ruger Redhawk in .44mag, 7 1/2 inch barrel. I can actually hit accurately enough to deer hunt at 100 yards with practice. The recoil is manageable but it has enough thump to drop anything up to deer size. The only slight issue with it is that it is heavy to carry at 4 pounds + a ton of lead but I rationalize that away knowing the fact that it is reducing felt recoil. (Oh, also there is a slight problem with having to carry a fire extinguisher on my back to put out the trees and bushes when I shoot! I like real hot loads and they shoot flames about three feet to each side causing severe forest fire risk! lol).

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from shane wrote 3 years 1 week ago

Yeah I was wondering how much Freedom Arms were going to be mentioned. I would love one too, but the price, whooeee.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from jbird wrote 3 years 1 week ago

Love my .41 mag. Feels like half the recoil compared to my .44, deadly accurate. Love my .44 too, and have seen it do impressive things to whitetails.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from dangerous game wrote 2 years 22 weeks ago

ruger super redhawk .454 cassull.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from shane wrote 2 years 22 weeks ago

What does revolver mean to you, Rem700-06?

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from rudyglove27 wrote 1 year 51 weeks ago

Agreed with idduckhntr and + 1 for you sir!!!

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from John Benjamin Tatum wrote 1 year 6 weeks ago

I have extensive hunting experience with the following three revolvers... Smith & Wesson 627 N Frame - .357 Magnum - w/scope, Smith & Wesson 629 N Frame - .44 Magnum - w/scope, Smith & Wesson 500 X Frame - .500 S&W Magnum w/scope... and when I go hunting with a handgun I carry all three with me.
It all depends on what my game is, and what predators are in the field. Some areas, a Model 627 is considered illegal for taking game due to it being too small of a caliber (but great for taking down predators). The Model 500 is the ultimate game weapon, but the starter of this thread excluded the X-Frame models (why? Perhaps due to the retail price, mine is "second hand" because five rounds ONLY were fired in it, by someone with no large frame handgun experience, and the price was half retail).
So the Model 629 is the only weapon that is legal in every jurisdiction in the United States for Game Hunting. So if I MUST exclude the Model 500, the Model 629 is my choice for a handgun for all size game and predators if I must have only one.
But, I believe in the Model 500 because it is a "sniper revolver" or "hunter revolver"... where if you are a true hunter, it should be a situation where cruelty never occurs, so "one shot, one kill". A Model 627 or Model 629, while you can do the same... you must be much closer for a similar effect or have a heavier grain load and different bullet.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from shane wrote 1 year 6 weeks ago

I excluded them because I knew they would come up. I wanted to hear about others.

0 Good Comment? | | Report

Post an Answer