


November 23, 2009
Chad Love: Don't Be a Fishing Butthead
By Chad Love
I'm not a smoker, so I've never pondered the question of what to do with my cigarette butts while out fishing. However, if the number of butts I see bobbing along the surface of the water is any indication, many smokers don't ponder either, they just take one last drag and flick it. After all, it's a just a little cigarette butt, right?
Well, no. In fact, according to this story cigarette butts are highly toxic to fish.
From the story:
Cigarette butts, one of the most ubiquitous forms of garbage in the world, have been found to be toxic to saltwater and freshwater fish. Even with a small amount of unburnt tobacco clinging to it, a single cigarette butt soaked for a day is enough to turn a liter of water a sickly yellow brown and kill 50 percent of fish swimming in it. Without tobacco, it takes about 4 smoked filters to do the same job. That's a lot of butts in a small area, and the research team that conducted the laboratory study, led by Elli Slaughter of San Diego State University, is quick to point out that no research has been done yet to test how much poison leaches from butts into ponds, lakes, streams and the ocean. Still, humans are inadvertently carpeting the planet in cigarette butts. According to one estimate, some 4.5 trillion filters from spent smokes make their way into the environment every year. When immersed in water, each one becomes a time-released capsule of compounds like nicotine, cancer-causing benzenes, heavy metals and other dangerous compounds.
Now I'm not anti-smoking or anything and I don't wig out when someone lights up around me. I grew up with two chain-smoking parents and I figure if I survived to adulthood while living in a nicotine cloud it's no big deal. Hell, you only really need one lung, anyway, right?
But I've always disliked cigarette butts: they're ugly, they're nasty, they litter the environment and whenever I see one I get this mental image of a pair of nasty, tobacco-stained lips. I know, it's creepy...
So this gives me one more reason to hate them a little more. But that's just me. What do all you smokers think? Would you stop flicking those butts if you knew it killed fish?
Comments (28)
It astounds me the number of cigarette butt that I see being thrown out the car window as well. How can people have such a obvious disrespect for nature and the world we live in. I appreciate all the taxes that smokers pay, but have some respect and stop littering!
As a former smoker, I remember never thinking too much about tossing out butts in "the civilized world" because I thought they were just cotton or something that'd be gone shortly...not polymers that don't degrade that I've since learned they are...so regrets there. But I was still always mindful not to toss them in the water, woods, trail, etc. because they stand out like Light Bright pegs in nature. And I certainly never thought of them as harmful. Good info to know, hope more smokers take it to heart. Best plan, extinguish the cherry and put the butt in your pocket.
A couple of weeks back I had the pleasure of hunting on a beautiful Island off of our coast line. While walking down a road I was amazed at the amount of cigarette butts I came across. The smoke swilling Butt Heads were tossing them off the wagons as they carried the hunters in and out. Smokers are some of the most inconsiderate individuals I've ever seen when it comes to tossing out thier trash and blowing smoke into my personal space. Keep your butts to your self please!
I had my first cigarette when I was 6 and my last one when I was 12. Everyone else in the family smoked. Several died horrible drawn-out deaths from lung cancer. My mom and remaining aunt quit cold turkey after watching what my dad went through. Ever met anyone with advanced emphysema? Horrible. Haven't knowingly dated a smoker since I was 19. Will not hire another person that smokes - the lost time and the smoke and mess of butts around customer entry ways - bad for business, attitudes, and health insurance costs.
After all that, why don't I mind the occasional (not habitual) cigar? First time I saw a girl with a cigar my knees shook. Even though cigars decay, the butts probably contain more toxins than cigarettes. At least they decay but sounds like we should not be dropping them into streams. I had to laugh when some girls got disgusted when a bunch of guys lit up cigars. They moved to another table ... and lit up cigarettes. Sorry, no sympathy ladies.
im not a smoker but like the author of this article i have been around it plenty. it doesnt bother me but i have always lived by the motto pack it in, pack it out big or small its littering and its an eye sore and according to this research its harmful to an evironment that we all love.
I have worked around smokers in construction for quite a few years and one of the companies got so fed up with butts on the job site that they started charging 5 bucks for every one that they found and 25 bucks for an empty pack pretty extreme but it fixed the problem. wish there was a way to enforce that in the areas i hunt and fish i would be rich and im sure the problem would be cured fast
While I agree that smokers should carry out their butts....I have to wonder if the feds can ban lead, why can't they ban what cigarette butts are made of?
Surely a biodegradeable product is available.....
yes I smoke no I do not litter I put my butts in a zippy bag in my jacket just for that purpose it really frosts my cupcake to think you non-smokers lump me into a category because of my personal habit. what about the starbucks cups floating in virgin creeks, the slim jim wrappers in the marshes etc? Everyone has a habit and some of those people are jerks don't lump them all together please.
One of my best friends has been smoking for 40+ years, he ALWAYS carries out his butts. It is a simple thing to do, you just have to take a second and use the big hard thing between your ears!!!!! But this is not limited to smokers. a few years ago when I set up a business, I was debating what kind of bags I would use for the merchandise my customers bought, I was trying to justify the few cents it would cost to use cotton cloth totes rather than plastic. Later that day while fishing I saw a plastic bag blow across the stream and my decision was made, you can't put a price on it. My customers loved the cloth bags, and would not be so quick to through them away. and if they did, in a season the bags would be fertilizer. It only take a second to be responsible. Stupid is forever!
Cigarette butts are the best example of small things becoming a huge problem. I don't even think that butt droppers realize that they are littering sometimes.
While fishing in the Salmon river just outside of Riggins, Idaho,I was looking at the water,and a ciggarette butt floated by. I thought about how smokers don't bother me, but litterbugs do.
Smokers are typically the biggest litterbugs on this planet. What makes you think it's ok to flick that thing out the window? It's plastic you idiots.
when I did smoke I made sure those butts made it to the garbage. now and then it doesn't bother me when some one smokes around me, but it always bothered me when someone littered.
Working in parks and rec, it astounds me the number of butts I find in the park areas. I find a lot in the garbage can too, so there are responsible smokers, but I do tire of the inconsiderate slouches that leave a disgusting variety of garbage anywhere they wander.
Personally, I despise the habit, but I do not give people a hard time about it if they can smoke without affecting others with their cloud or their litter.
In DEFENSE of SOME smokers.
PACK IT IN, PACK IT OUT !
Leave LESS in the outdoors than what you took in !
One of my biggest pet peeves, and guaranteed to take my anger level from 0 to 100 in less than a second!
I don't care if folks want to kill themselves with cigarettes. That's none of my business (although I do take issue with folks dying slowly on the taxpayer dime due to consequences of a choice they couldn't afford).
But dumping your butts all over the place... that torques me off to no end... it's just plain lack of consideration for anyone else, not to mention the health of the habitat and the other critters we share the place with. And add to that the idiots who toss their butts out in the woods and highways here in the West. From July to November we see grassfires almost every day due to the blockheads who can't figure out how to use an ashtray.
It's just stupid. If you don't want to carry around those butts, then don't smoke! Or at least smoke un-filtered and grind the butt when you're done.
Pardon me for living in your frickin' ash tray!
How about leaving it better than you find it? Smoking is gross enough and does not need to be compounded by littering. As sportsman and outdoorsman, and woman, we have been entrusted with protecting the precious resources that so many enjoy. If you must smoke carry a bottle, or other receptical, to put your butts in.
Also something that nobody has talked about but is a BIG issue out west is the number or wildfires caused by a tossed lit cigarette. Hundreds of thousands of acres are lost and the game in them to careless butt tossers.
i keep hearing the same thing: pack it in, pack it out. the majority of smokers do this and don't litter. it's the few that do that gives everyone a bad rap. this blog is starting to look like Hunt the Smokers mission. now, back to the discussion of fishing and hunting please.
and while we are on this topic, do you have any idea how much fishing line i pull out of the water and off the bank everytime i go fishing? don't target just 1 class of people if you want to talk about litering. only one class of people are leaving all that fishing line around.
It has been 12 years since I quit,the last 3 years of my habit ,I rolled my own.So for 25 years I contributed to the problem.Although I had a conscience and a lot of ashtray fires.
That in mind,we have ice fishing coming up and I would like to know how would someone like me could tell someone like you [if you smoke]to leave the butts off the ice?
How would I sell it to you?
Sorry jamesti, i'm not buying that it's the minority of smokers doing all that littering. If you don't litter your butts, good for you but you're the minority.
Robert, that's a reasonable question. I'm not sure if I have the best answer, but I can tell you what I've done, both with clients and with strangers.
When I see a butt hit the ground, I don't yell and scream (much as I'd like to). I pick it up, and put it in an old 35mm film canister. Then I give the canister to the smoker and suggest that they use that instead of the ground. I've occasionally gone as far as lecturing about the long-term impacts of cig butts, and the fact that they never biodegrade.
I don't know if it makes a long-term impact, but those folks don't throw another butt on the ground in my presence.
I don't know what else you can do short of direct confrontation... which isn't totally uncalled for.
Thanks HogBlog,In this digital age I'll have to work a little harder to gather enough containers for our ice fishing derby.That day and the ones preceeding it are when the ice takes a dramatic change from white to brown.
Altoids tins work great too... but in a pinch, a water bottle or beer can is just as good. The bottom line is, anything to get the butt off the ground and make it easy to pack out, right? The reason people don't just put them in their pockets is because they're messy (and hot). Offer an alternative and get them thinking about what they were doing... it's really all you can do, short of kicking them out of camp.
Wow. I didn't know that cigarette butts don't degrade. I'm always telling my friends to pick up trash they just throw on the ground, but never about not putting their butts out in an ashtray or a garbage can. You can bet that I'll be getting on their case about this.
I'm GUILTY!!!
I will admit that I am a smoker and I've been a fishing butthead! After reading the article I have come to the conclusion that I need to change my ways. I promise that from now on I will no longer flick my butts in the water when fishing (or around any body of water) and will dispose of them in the trash. Chad Love can take satisfaction that his article made a difference for at least one person.
Grew up fishing and never spend as much time as I want to doing it but I must say that there does seem to be a rather high percentage of people that fish (not Fisherman in the true sense) that really need to "clean-up" their act. Lots of empty plastic worm containers, pop or beer cans, stripped fishing line, broken lures, seem to be left at fishing spots.
Gives the rest of us a bad image.
Post a Comment
As a former smoker, I remember never thinking too much about tossing out butts in "the civilized world" because I thought they were just cotton or something that'd be gone shortly...not polymers that don't degrade that I've since learned they are...so regrets there. But I was still always mindful not to toss them in the water, woods, trail, etc. because they stand out like Light Bright pegs in nature. And I certainly never thought of them as harmful. Good info to know, hope more smokers take it to heart. Best plan, extinguish the cherry and put the butt in your pocket.
A couple of weeks back I had the pleasure of hunting on a beautiful Island off of our coast line. While walking down a road I was amazed at the amount of cigarette butts I came across. The smoke swilling Butt Heads were tossing them off the wagons as they carried the hunters in and out. Smokers are some of the most inconsiderate individuals I've ever seen when it comes to tossing out thier trash and blowing smoke into my personal space. Keep your butts to your self please!
im not a smoker but like the author of this article i have been around it plenty. it doesnt bother me but i have always lived by the motto pack it in, pack it out big or small its littering and its an eye sore and according to this research its harmful to an evironment that we all love.
Smokers are typically the biggest litterbugs on this planet. What makes you think it's ok to flick that thing out the window? It's plastic you idiots.
It astounds me the number of cigarette butt that I see being thrown out the car window as well. How can people have such a obvious disrespect for nature and the world we live in. I appreciate all the taxes that smokers pay, but have some respect and stop littering!
I had my first cigarette when I was 6 and my last one when I was 12. Everyone else in the family smoked. Several died horrible drawn-out deaths from lung cancer. My mom and remaining aunt quit cold turkey after watching what my dad went through. Ever met anyone with advanced emphysema? Horrible. Haven't knowingly dated a smoker since I was 19. Will not hire another person that smokes - the lost time and the smoke and mess of butts around customer entry ways - bad for business, attitudes, and health insurance costs.
After all that, why don't I mind the occasional (not habitual) cigar? First time I saw a girl with a cigar my knees shook. Even though cigars decay, the butts probably contain more toxins than cigarettes. At least they decay but sounds like we should not be dropping them into streams. I had to laugh when some girls got disgusted when a bunch of guys lit up cigars. They moved to another table ... and lit up cigarettes. Sorry, no sympathy ladies.
While I agree that smokers should carry out their butts....I have to wonder if the feds can ban lead, why can't they ban what cigarette butts are made of?
Surely a biodegradeable product is available.....
yes I smoke no I do not litter I put my butts in a zippy bag in my jacket just for that purpose it really frosts my cupcake to think you non-smokers lump me into a category because of my personal habit. what about the starbucks cups floating in virgin creeks, the slim jim wrappers in the marshes etc? Everyone has a habit and some of those people are jerks don't lump them all together please.
One of my best friends has been smoking for 40+ years, he ALWAYS carries out his butts. It is a simple thing to do, you just have to take a second and use the big hard thing between your ears!!!!! But this is not limited to smokers. a few years ago when I set up a business, I was debating what kind of bags I would use for the merchandise my customers bought, I was trying to justify the few cents it would cost to use cotton cloth totes rather than plastic. Later that day while fishing I saw a plastic bag blow across the stream and my decision was made, you can't put a price on it. My customers loved the cloth bags, and would not be so quick to through them away. and if they did, in a season the bags would be fertilizer. It only take a second to be responsible. Stupid is forever!
Cigarette butts are the best example of small things becoming a huge problem. I don't even think that butt droppers realize that they are littering sometimes.
While fishing in the Salmon river just outside of Riggins, Idaho,I was looking at the water,and a ciggarette butt floated by. I thought about how smokers don't bother me, but litterbugs do.
Robert, that's a reasonable question. I'm not sure if I have the best answer, but I can tell you what I've done, both with clients and with strangers.
When I see a butt hit the ground, I don't yell and scream (much as I'd like to). I pick it up, and put it in an old 35mm film canister. Then I give the canister to the smoker and suggest that they use that instead of the ground. I've occasionally gone as far as lecturing about the long-term impacts of cig butts, and the fact that they never biodegrade.
I don't know if it makes a long-term impact, but those folks don't throw another butt on the ground in my presence.
I don't know what else you can do short of direct confrontation... which isn't totally uncalled for.
I have worked around smokers in construction for quite a few years and one of the companies got so fed up with butts on the job site that they started charging 5 bucks for every one that they found and 25 bucks for an empty pack pretty extreme but it fixed the problem. wish there was a way to enforce that in the areas i hunt and fish i would be rich and im sure the problem would be cured fast
Working in parks and rec, it astounds me the number of butts I find in the park areas. I find a lot in the garbage can too, so there are responsible smokers, but I do tire of the inconsiderate slouches that leave a disgusting variety of garbage anywhere they wander.
Personally, I despise the habit, but I do not give people a hard time about it if they can smoke without affecting others with their cloud or their litter.
In DEFENSE of SOME smokers.
PACK IT IN, PACK IT OUT !
Leave LESS in the outdoors than what you took in !
One of my biggest pet peeves, and guaranteed to take my anger level from 0 to 100 in less than a second!
I don't care if folks want to kill themselves with cigarettes. That's none of my business (although I do take issue with folks dying slowly on the taxpayer dime due to consequences of a choice they couldn't afford).
But dumping your butts all over the place... that torques me off to no end... it's just plain lack of consideration for anyone else, not to mention the health of the habitat and the other critters we share the place with. And add to that the idiots who toss their butts out in the woods and highways here in the West. From July to November we see grassfires almost every day due to the blockheads who can't figure out how to use an ashtray.
It's just stupid. If you don't want to carry around those butts, then don't smoke! Or at least smoke un-filtered and grind the butt when you're done.
Pardon me for living in your frickin' ash tray!
Also something that nobody has talked about but is a BIG issue out west is the number or wildfires caused by a tossed lit cigarette. Hundreds of thousands of acres are lost and the game in them to careless butt tossers.
i keep hearing the same thing: pack it in, pack it out. the majority of smokers do this and don't litter. it's the few that do that gives everyone a bad rap. this blog is starting to look like Hunt the Smokers mission. now, back to the discussion of fishing and hunting please.
and while we are on this topic, do you have any idea how much fishing line i pull out of the water and off the bank everytime i go fishing? don't target just 1 class of people if you want to talk about litering. only one class of people are leaving all that fishing line around.
when I did smoke I made sure those butts made it to the garbage. now and then it doesn't bother me when some one smokes around me, but it always bothered me when someone littered.
How about leaving it better than you find it? Smoking is gross enough and does not need to be compounded by littering. As sportsman and outdoorsman, and woman, we have been entrusted with protecting the precious resources that so many enjoy. If you must smoke carry a bottle, or other receptical, to put your butts in.
It has been 12 years since I quit,the last 3 years of my habit ,I rolled my own.So for 25 years I contributed to the problem.Although I had a conscience and a lot of ashtray fires.
That in mind,we have ice fishing coming up and I would like to know how would someone like me could tell someone like you [if you smoke]to leave the butts off the ice?
How would I sell it to you?
Thanks HogBlog,In this digital age I'll have to work a little harder to gather enough containers for our ice fishing derby.That day and the ones preceeding it are when the ice takes a dramatic change from white to brown.
Altoids tins work great too... but in a pinch, a water bottle or beer can is just as good. The bottom line is, anything to get the butt off the ground and make it easy to pack out, right? The reason people don't just put them in their pockets is because they're messy (and hot). Offer an alternative and get them thinking about what they were doing... it's really all you can do, short of kicking them out of camp.
Wow. I didn't know that cigarette butts don't degrade. I'm always telling my friends to pick up trash they just throw on the ground, but never about not putting their butts out in an ashtray or a garbage can. You can bet that I'll be getting on their case about this.
I'm GUILTY!!!
I will admit that I am a smoker and I've been a fishing butthead! After reading the article I have come to the conclusion that I need to change my ways. I promise that from now on I will no longer flick my butts in the water when fishing (or around any body of water) and will dispose of them in the trash. Chad Love can take satisfaction that his article made a difference for at least one person.
Grew up fishing and never spend as much time as I want to doing it but I must say that there does seem to be a rather high percentage of people that fish (not Fisherman in the true sense) that really need to "clean-up" their act. Lots of empty plastic worm containers, pop or beer cans, stripped fishing line, broken lures, seem to be left at fishing spots.
Gives the rest of us a bad image.
Sorry jamesti, i'm not buying that it's the minority of smokers doing all that littering. If you don't litter your butts, good for you but you're the minority.
Post a Comment