


April 22, 2009
Kill Some Trees On Earth Day
By Chad Love
Today is Earth Day, and in honor of the occasion I'd like to make the admittedly counter-intuitive argument that the Earth would be a better place with a few more of these things:
No, I'm not crazy, and I'll explain why.
Everyone knows of the disasters unregulated commercial logging is causing in the world's tropical forests, disasters that are helped along by the frightening efficiency of machines like this monstrosity. Depending on what figure you read, about 1.5 acres of tropical forest disappears every second.
However, while those trees are falling to the saw, residents of the southern plains states are losing literally square mile chunks of native prairie every single day not to development or industrial pollution but - ironically enough - a tree.
But not just any tree. The eastern redcedar is the cockroach of the tree world. This ugly, useless and prolific pox on the landscape isn't a non-native species like the better-known tamarisk, but with the disappearance of the two primary shapers of the plains landscape - fire and bison - the opportunistic bastards have exploded across the plains.
How bad is the eastern redcedar? I am completely confident that even Joyce Kilmer would take a chainsaw to one.
It completely chokes out native vegetation and wildlife, has almost no commercial value, and once established is damn near impossible to get rid of. The state of Oklahoma alone loses 760 acres of native prairie and riparian area - over one square mile- every single day to the eastern redcedar invasion. That means one square mile with no more quail, no more prairie chickens, no more pheasants, no more anything.
So in honor of Earth Day I say to all the heavy machinery of environmental destruction: The Earth needs you. Just not in the places you're currently destroying. Leave the rainforest, please. Come to Oklahoma, to Texas, to Kansas. Bring on the tree harvesters, bring on the skidders, the chain saws. Rip, tear, burn, destroy and lay waste to it all. I can't think of a better way to celebrate Earth Day than to kill a few square miles of photosynthetic vermin. -- Chad Love
Comments (20)
Chad:
This is a very interesting take on Earth Day. In some instances people need to realize that in order to restore the natural landscape you must first destroy the current one. It is an outside-the-box form of thinking, but is sometimes necessary.
I'm all for it! The one thing they are useful for is making nice mulch for planting beds and I would love to be able to provide it to my clients at a good price. The landscaping industry needs all the help it can get right now. Not that we are alone, times are tough all over.
hoorah! I grew up in the Sooner State and what Mr. Love is saying is true. Those things cause so much damage to the western oklahoma landscape it's indescribable.
Yeah we have them too. The only thing they are good for is mature bucks like to hide in cedar thickets in winter time 'cause that is the thickest cover around then.
One other thing. If you can find a large one they make great stand trees. Deer never spot me in a Cedar. The smell is a good cover scent too.
One other thing. If you can find a large one they make great stand trees. Deer never spot me in a Cedar. The smell is a good cover scent too.
Thoses harvesters are pretty awesome. Whats nice is that they leave a very small footprint compared to traditional logging practices. They also leave all the bark and tops in a neat row for a grinder to come behind it and turn it into mulch for new trees to be planted in. As you can see the trees are part of a plantation forest designed for regeneration over and over again. That head alone costs more than your house.
Good call. There are two sides to everything! Yin and Yang! Metal destruction good in right place!
Hire me. If they give me gas money for my saws and the trip out, I will go nuts on these things for no charge.
We could use a few of those down here in Florida for the meleluecas--they're nasty invasives that are drying up the swamp. But I'm not so sure how those monsters would do in the everglades--probably just sink into the swamp.
that is one cool machine!
Funny how you think something good like a tree can even become harmful. It is a little ridiculous that we can not get this under control. Are they doing anything to fight this battle or is it one of those situations where, everything we try is not working and the tree is becoming immune to pesticides?
Kill Some Trees On Earth Day??
Now thats GET "R" DONE!
YAAA"BUDDY!
From what I read on wikipedia the red cedar makes good fence post because of its rot resistance, and is good for bedroom furniture because of its ability to repel moths. That sounds like an opportunity for someone to make a dollar by havesting these trees. So, there are plenty of money making oppurtunities out there for these trees to disappear.
this is a very interesting article. a mile a day is insanely fast growth. my dad is a logger here in northeast pa and i am going to show him this article later.
this, in my opinion, is one of the best articles on the field and stream site, it has a very strong attitude and gets the point across well. i cant stand when people say logging is bad for the environment, it actually has more benefits than repercussions. great article chad love.
I personally celebrated Earth Day by blowing the head off a turkey.
Read the fine print……
Yes the eastern red cedar is a pest BECAUSE the native tree’s were logged off years ago so the red cedar proliferated due to POOR LOGGING practices. so to say logging in of it’s self is good for nature as claimed by scottprice is well shall we say NOT SO MUCH…..
The devil is in the details…..
Muddog, with all due respect you're about as wrong as you can be.
I'll leave the debate over logging to others, however the rise of the eastern redcedar has absolutely nothing to do with logging. Nada. Zip. Zilch.
The eastern redcedar isn't spreading due to the logging of "native trees" because there simply aren't any commercially viable populations of native trees on the southern plains...that's why they're called "plains"...
The reasons for its spread are indeed man-made, but logging certainly isn't one of them.
chadlove.
It is a pioneer invader, which means that it is one of the first trees to repopulate cleared, eroded, or otherwise damaged land.
The tree started out as a hardy tree for re planting ( after logging ) and wind breaks in the south and midwest. The tree WILL NOT INVADE healthy eco systems. Logging, clearing for construction, farming and graze land etc is the HOST by which the tree spreads. The best and most effect way to control and burning as cutting down tree’s does not remove seeds or roots that can regenerate.
I digress as logging is NOT the sole reason...
I have to disagree on a few points. One: eastern redcedar doesn't sprout from a stump like, say, locust. Once you cut it it's dead. Two, it's also taking over native prairie that has never seen a plow and never been otherwise degraded. It cares not one wit whether the ground it's invading is damaged or healthy. It's an equal-opportunity invader
Now if by "healthy ecosystem" you mean a system in which fire and rotational grazing is practiced constantly then yes, it does tend to be somewhat controlled, but that's extremely labor-intensive work and trust me, an eastern redcedar will sprout in a beautiful, healthy pristine patch of short or midgrass prairie just as quickly as it will an eroded gully.
Ironically, it's the LACK of grazing and farming (and fire suppression) that's allowing the redcedar to spread. If you take a healthy quarter-section of good native grass and just let it sit with no grazing, no fire and no disturbance then I promise you in 15 years or so you'll have 160 acres of cedar.
sounds like some of the stuff like eurasian milfoil and purple loostrife in northern wisconsin that can take over water habitats.
Post a Comment
Chad:
This is a very interesting take on Earth Day. In some instances people need to realize that in order to restore the natural landscape you must first destroy the current one. It is an outside-the-box form of thinking, but is sometimes necessary.
I'm all for it! The one thing they are useful for is making nice mulch for planting beds and I would love to be able to provide it to my clients at a good price. The landscaping industry needs all the help it can get right now. Not that we are alone, times are tough all over.
hoorah! I grew up in the Sooner State and what Mr. Love is saying is true. Those things cause so much damage to the western oklahoma landscape it's indescribable.
Yeah we have them too. The only thing they are good for is mature bucks like to hide in cedar thickets in winter time 'cause that is the thickest cover around then.
One other thing. If you can find a large one they make great stand trees. Deer never spot me in a Cedar. The smell is a good cover scent too.
One other thing. If you can find a large one they make great stand trees. Deer never spot me in a Cedar. The smell is a good cover scent too.
Thoses harvesters are pretty awesome. Whats nice is that they leave a very small footprint compared to traditional logging practices. They also leave all the bark and tops in a neat row for a grinder to come behind it and turn it into mulch for new trees to be planted in. As you can see the trees are part of a plantation forest designed for regeneration over and over again. That head alone costs more than your house.
Good call. There are two sides to everything! Yin and Yang! Metal destruction good in right place!
Hire me. If they give me gas money for my saws and the trip out, I will go nuts on these things for no charge.
We could use a few of those down here in Florida for the meleluecas--they're nasty invasives that are drying up the swamp. But I'm not so sure how those monsters would do in the everglades--probably just sink into the swamp.
that is one cool machine!
Funny how you think something good like a tree can even become harmful. It is a little ridiculous that we can not get this under control. Are they doing anything to fight this battle or is it one of those situations where, everything we try is not working and the tree is becoming immune to pesticides?
Kill Some Trees On Earth Day??
Now thats GET "R" DONE!
YAAA"BUDDY!
From what I read on wikipedia the red cedar makes good fence post because of its rot resistance, and is good for bedroom furniture because of its ability to repel moths. That sounds like an opportunity for someone to make a dollar by havesting these trees. So, there are plenty of money making oppurtunities out there for these trees to disappear.
this is a very interesting article. a mile a day is insanely fast growth. my dad is a logger here in northeast pa and i am going to show him this article later.
this, in my opinion, is one of the best articles on the field and stream site, it has a very strong attitude and gets the point across well. i cant stand when people say logging is bad for the environment, it actually has more benefits than repercussions. great article chad love.
I personally celebrated Earth Day by blowing the head off a turkey.
Read the fine print……
Yes the eastern red cedar is a pest BECAUSE the native tree’s were logged off years ago so the red cedar proliferated due to POOR LOGGING practices. so to say logging in of it’s self is good for nature as claimed by scottprice is well shall we say NOT SO MUCH…..
The devil is in the details…..
Muddog, with all due respect you're about as wrong as you can be.
I'll leave the debate over logging to others, however the rise of the eastern redcedar has absolutely nothing to do with logging. Nada. Zip. Zilch.
The eastern redcedar isn't spreading due to the logging of "native trees" because there simply aren't any commercially viable populations of native trees on the southern plains...that's why they're called "plains"...
The reasons for its spread are indeed man-made, but logging certainly isn't one of them.
chadlove.
It is a pioneer invader, which means that it is one of the first trees to repopulate cleared, eroded, or otherwise damaged land.
The tree started out as a hardy tree for re planting ( after logging ) and wind breaks in the south and midwest. The tree WILL NOT INVADE healthy eco systems. Logging, clearing for construction, farming and graze land etc is the HOST by which the tree spreads. The best and most effect way to control and burning as cutting down tree’s does not remove seeds or roots that can regenerate.
I digress as logging is NOT the sole reason...
I have to disagree on a few points. One: eastern redcedar doesn't sprout from a stump like, say, locust. Once you cut it it's dead. Two, it's also taking over native prairie that has never seen a plow and never been otherwise degraded. It cares not one wit whether the ground it's invading is damaged or healthy. It's an equal-opportunity invader
Now if by "healthy ecosystem" you mean a system in which fire and rotational grazing is practiced constantly then yes, it does tend to be somewhat controlled, but that's extremely labor-intensive work and trust me, an eastern redcedar will sprout in a beautiful, healthy pristine patch of short or midgrass prairie just as quickly as it will an eroded gully.
Ironically, it's the LACK of grazing and farming (and fire suppression) that's allowing the redcedar to spread. If you take a healthy quarter-section of good native grass and just let it sit with no grazing, no fire and no disturbance then I promise you in 15 years or so you'll have 160 acres of cedar.
sounds like some of the stuff like eurasian milfoil and purple loostrife in northern wisconsin that can take over water habitats.
Post a Comment