


October 22, 2009
Cermele: Can This Bag Save Dunked Electronics?
By Joe Cermele

Just yesterday, Merwin posted a blog on essential items you should never forget to bring out on a boat. I might have a new essential item if the Bheestie Bags I received the other day do what they're supposed to.
I have a terrible history of ruining electronic devices on fishing trips. I've burned I don't know how many phones, a hand-held GPS, and most recently, $2,000 worth of video and still-camera equipent when some high-salinity water found its way into my dry bag. I baked all the gear on the dashboard of a fellow angler's truck, but it didn't matter. It was trashed. That was in Texas, and I had to waste a whole fishing day driving 67 miles in the lodge truck to the closest Best Buy. What can I say? I'm dedicated to my craft and wasn't going home without a video.
Though there are all sorts of tricks for saving wet electronics (salt, bag of rice, etc.), Bheestie Bags weigh nothing, travel easily, and are loaded with beads that are supposed to draw water out like no other and hold it there without re-wetting the gear. I haven't tried one yet, so I can't swear they work, but $20 a bag is cheaper than replacing spent cameras and iPods or paying for cell phone insurance. Perhaps this could have saved me 2K a few months ago, but it's a little late for that.
Are you a chronic soaker of pricey gizmos, or are you just more careful than I am? -- JC
Comments (18)
sign me up Cermele. I've ruined my fair share of camera stuff. Thanks for the heads up. Never seen this stuff before...
Worth the price, if they work. Would be nice to have something right there right now. Ruined a nice camera earlier this year - dunked it while landing a rainbow. Rice didn't work, but I tried it several hours after the dunk.
I killed two business cell phones. One in Europe - the only wall plug just happened to be right over the toilet. The other one dead centered a toilet in the US. It was still working when I got it to the repair shop, but when I told the tech what happened he just proclaimed it dead ... at a distance ... and gave me a new one. Perhaps they should market these bags through dispensers mounted in office and gas station toilets.
I have a bad habit of storing my cell and camera in my chest pocket for easy removal. My cell is necessary because I'm always working 24/7. On several occasions while bending over the items have slipped out into the water. The advice from the electronics guy was to remove the battery immediately. It may have saved a camera but for cell phones it's 0 for 3.
JC, you mean that F&S didn't front you 100 bones to buy two cheapie digitals and a dry bag, dunk both cameras, one in the bag, the other on the bank, let sit for X number of hours and test.
This sounds like it's worth a try. But if you add a dry bag to the list from Merwin's post yesterday, you might not need this bag so often.
Why write a 'blog-ad' for something you haven't even tried yet?
Sounds like a gimmick to me. Buckhunter has the best advice - remove the batteries immediately and hope for the best. When you drop an electronic device in the water, the water is likely to short circuit something in the device and it usually happens almost immediately and your toast.
But hey, if you want to buy that bag go ahead . . . and while you're at it, if you lock your keys out of your vehicle and you a wireless transmitter for unlocking your car just call your spouse and have her/him activate their fob while holding near a phone while you hold your phone next the vehicle . . . hehehe . . . did I mention I have a bridge in Brooklyn that I could sell to you, cheap too . . .
Hell, I'm in too, I dropped a 700 dollar Cannon into the water (Not mine either) so it cost me a lot of gear paying the person back.
Yeah Ive ruined many cameras and phones too. This past trip i got a camera and my phone under water....as well as myself... but was lucky. I just let them dry out fo 24 hours and they are still working
That could be a perfect Christmas gift for anyone who has everything or is as clumsy as I am.
Hey JBird...gimme a break, man. You've never read an article informing the masses about new gear they may not have heard of yet? I call saying "I haven't tried it yet" honesty.
I like to use the Otterbox stuff, water-proof, crush-proof cases
I tend to take the approach that i can make a call or take a picture after i get done on the water. That usually keeps me from ever having to take the chance i'll drop it into the water, now if only the pavement and ground were a little more forgiving.
This will be a perfect gift for my wife...When it comes to pricey gizmos, she always have an accident...This year alone she had 10 cell phone replaced due to water damage or phone being broken!!!
I would like to try one of these. I could use on eof these and so could my blackberry.....may it rest in peace
Keep my stuff in a small Pelican case when I'm out on the water.
I can't help but think that this is nothing more than a material very similar if not the same stuff as the superabsorbent materials inside a disposable diaper put inside a ziplock baggie - for which they are charging $20 and which probably works marginally better than a bag of rice to dry out your gear . . . no, I haven't done the testing to prove this, but I could never buy this product without feeling like someone was taking advantage of me.
my uncle has been through almost 5 phones duck hunting and fishing I believe I know what to buy him for christmas.
Post a Comment
Hey JBird...gimme a break, man. You've never read an article informing the masses about new gear they may not have heard of yet? I call saying "I haven't tried it yet" honesty.
I have a bad habit of storing my cell and camera in my chest pocket for easy removal. My cell is necessary because I'm always working 24/7. On several occasions while bending over the items have slipped out into the water. The advice from the electronics guy was to remove the battery immediately. It may have saved a camera but for cell phones it's 0 for 3.
sign me up Cermele. I've ruined my fair share of camera stuff. Thanks for the heads up. Never seen this stuff before...
Worth the price, if they work. Would be nice to have something right there right now. Ruined a nice camera earlier this year - dunked it while landing a rainbow. Rice didn't work, but I tried it several hours after the dunk.
I killed two business cell phones. One in Europe - the only wall plug just happened to be right over the toilet. The other one dead centered a toilet in the US. It was still working when I got it to the repair shop, but when I told the tech what happened he just proclaimed it dead ... at a distance ... and gave me a new one. Perhaps they should market these bags through dispensers mounted in office and gas station toilets.
JC, you mean that F&S didn't front you 100 bones to buy two cheapie digitals and a dry bag, dunk both cameras, one in the bag, the other on the bank, let sit for X number of hours and test.
This sounds like it's worth a try. But if you add a dry bag to the list from Merwin's post yesterday, you might not need this bag so often.
Sounds like a gimmick to me. Buckhunter has the best advice - remove the batteries immediately and hope for the best. When you drop an electronic device in the water, the water is likely to short circuit something in the device and it usually happens almost immediately and your toast.
But hey, if you want to buy that bag go ahead . . . and while you're at it, if you lock your keys out of your vehicle and you a wireless transmitter for unlocking your car just call your spouse and have her/him activate their fob while holding near a phone while you hold your phone next the vehicle . . . hehehe . . . did I mention I have a bridge in Brooklyn that I could sell to you, cheap too . . .
Hell, I'm in too, I dropped a 700 dollar Cannon into the water (Not mine either) so it cost me a lot of gear paying the person back.
Yeah Ive ruined many cameras and phones too. This past trip i got a camera and my phone under water....as well as myself... but was lucky. I just let them dry out fo 24 hours and they are still working
That could be a perfect Christmas gift for anyone who has everything or is as clumsy as I am.
I like to use the Otterbox stuff, water-proof, crush-proof cases
I tend to take the approach that i can make a call or take a picture after i get done on the water. That usually keeps me from ever having to take the chance i'll drop it into the water, now if only the pavement and ground were a little more forgiving.
This will be a perfect gift for my wife...When it comes to pricey gizmos, she always have an accident...This year alone she had 10 cell phone replaced due to water damage or phone being broken!!!
I would like to try one of these. I could use on eof these and so could my blackberry.....may it rest in peace
Keep my stuff in a small Pelican case when I'm out on the water.
I can't help but think that this is nothing more than a material very similar if not the same stuff as the superabsorbent materials inside a disposable diaper put inside a ziplock baggie - for which they are charging $20 and which probably works marginally better than a bag of rice to dry out your gear . . . no, I haven't done the testing to prove this, but I could never buy this product without feeling like someone was taking advantage of me.
my uncle has been through almost 5 phones duck hunting and fishing I believe I know what to buy him for christmas.
Why write a 'blog-ad' for something you haven't even tried yet?
Post a Comment