


January 08, 2010
How's Your Deer Wreck Record?
By Scott Bestul
Virtually every mile I’ve driven since age 16 has been logged in whitetail country. Somehow I’ve managed to hit only two deer during that span. Actually both of those whitetails ran into me, but this is a technicality insurance companies don’t recognize.
Statistically, I’ve been pretty lucky. According to State Farm Insurance, the nation’s leading auto insurer, the number of deer/vehicle collisions is on the rise; an estimated 2.4 million deer were hit by vehicles from July 2007 to July 2009. That averages out to 100,000 incidents per month, or one every 26 seconds.

Some 35 states will notch at least 7,000 deer/car collisions each year. States with the top increases in deer wrecks were New Jersey and Nebraska, up 54% from the previous recording period. Kansas wasn’t far behind with a 41% increase, followed by 38% jumps in Florida, Mississippi and Arkansas.
The state where you’re most likely to whack a whitetail? West Virginia! State Farm says your chances of bonking a deer there in a one-year period is 1 in 39. Michigan is distant second; Wolverine State drivers have a 1 in 78 chance of striking a whitetail. Pennsylvania tallied a 1 in 94 chance, Montana and Iowa tied at 1 in104, and rounding out the top five was Arkansas with the odds at 1 in 106. The least likely state for a deer to wreck a car is predictable; Hawaiian drivers stand only a 1 in 9,931 chance, about the same odds they enjoy for finding a four-leaf clover.
So how ‘bout you guys? Have you managed to avoid deer wrecks, or do you somehow figure into the statistics in the State Farm report?
Comments (51)
i have never been in a deer wreck, but my mom has hit 2, none of hers were as bad as the picture. the one in the picture looks like the worst one ive probably ever seen
My record is also two deer/vehicle collisions and I was also run into both times---on one, the doe tried to dive under and between my headlights after I had almost come to a complete stop and the other, a buck slammed into the driver's side door of my pickup. On both occasions, the vehicle won. Both were out of season so I took the carcases to the county jail where they were much appreciated.
i had one deer run into the side of my truck in arkasas but i think it was ok. couldn't find it afterward.
I've spent my life in many parts of WV, MD, and PA, and have seen countless deer grazing on the side of highways, in pastures, and making the dash across the road. I've witnessed a couple collisions, but have only tapped one deer that trotted off fine (knock on wood). Part of the key is being ready for it! I always assume a deer may bound out at any second...kind of another form of defensive driving. It's helped me hit the brakes in time a few times when it'd have turned out otherwise if I'd been dilly dallying along.
Never hit a deer, but had a collision with a buffalo in northern Canada. Here is a story about it with pictures my buddy put together. The buffalo is about half way down.
http://pensacolafishingforum.com/fishingforum/Topic163343-3-1.aspx
One deer met my bumper, shook me up pretty good, on my way to hunt elk no less. Being from Pennsylvania, most folks don't know to tell the insurance companies that the deer hit you. The moment you say you hit the deer you are at fault. Sounds funny, but it's all in the wording. If they try to correct you in any way like "Sir, did you mean to say that you hit a deer with your truck", just keep just keep correcting them and say that the deer hit you.
My dad and I hit a deer with our semi while hauling corn, it almost hit our raidiator.
My wife hit a deer two days before New Years eve. No accident report though. That Expedition didn't even get a scratch but the 140lb doe took a dirt nap! FORD TOUGH!! Fortunately it is a 1997 Expedition. A newer one probably wouldn't have been so lucky with their plastic covered bumpers. I don't even think my 2008 F250 would have held up as well.
I've hit 2 doe and one 8 point in velvet in Arkansas. I'm always on the look out, the 8 point ran across the road ahead of me so I was slowing, he reached the other ditch and decided to jump back onto the road as I went by. I lay on the horn and slap the outside of the door anytime I see road side deer now, a little traffic education for deer is good in these situations.
I'm getting my permit soon so I am really worried about hitting deer.
i live in saskatchewan and i have never hit a deer
Some areas have much higher odds than the state odds. The area around a local college with acres of woods and golf courses on the edge of urban sprawl has one of the highest rates in the country.
Lots of close calls for me but only one direct hit - at ... um, speed ... on the interstate.
Conventional wisdom (don't you love that term) says to hit the deer rather than try to avoid it. Damned if you do ... or don't. Deaths and injuries can result either way, but apparently less if you hit the deer. Also, if you hit a deer and wreck a vehicle the damage is covered under comprehensive coverage. If you avoid the deer and damage the vehicle then it is covered under collision coverage, and is considered an at-fault accident, which is likely to raise your insurance rates.
A guy tried to avoid a cat and missed me head-on by inches - I swerved and he hit my rear quarter and ripped off my bumper. Could have been really bad if I wasn't paying attention. He was just so focused on avoiding the animal that he didn't even see me.
Been driving for 14 years and have yet to hit a deer. However my dad hit one about 10 years ago, he dropped his truck off to get fixed. When he was on his way home from getting it fixed he hit another one. Sadly there was no warranty for teh work that was just done.
I took out a nice 8pt in velvet in WV while there on business. It was the company truck thank goodness because the bumper went clean through the radiator.
knock on wood i have never hit one and hope to keep it like that
a friend of mines mom went threw 3 cars in one year she did the newspaper route and she was on the road from 3-6 in the morning she hit one very nice 8 pointer what horns were left on the deer were stuck in the radiator
I've hit two deer in 30 years of driving. Neither impact was hard enough to damage my F150.
On another note, I wonder how many of the report deer collisions were actually caused by something else but were reported as deer for the lower comprehensive deductible.
The closest thing I've had to a deer collision was a a couple of years ago. I was driving down a backroad and came up on on two young 4 pts in the road. One fled to the shoulder, while the other simply switched lanes. As I approached the one in the road, he started to run in the direction of the vehicle. I watched him from the window as I passed him, and then the side mirror. For some reason, he then decided to make a right turn and ran into the side of my truck. He acted like he was surprised the truck was there. Both the deer and truck were ok.
I had several close calls but I've only actually hit one. It was a yearling that darted right out in front of me. It was a tiny little thing, but at 65 mph it did a number on my truck--grill, bumper, fender, headlight. The F-150 could be fixed--the deer wasn't so lucky.
I've hit two deer on separte occusions within the city limits of my Alabama hometown, once during morning rush hour. I did recover the meat. A kidde pool makes a good catcher for skinning and gutting in the garage. LOL
I've been lucky enough not to hit one,but have seen my share and even had a close call living here in Pa.
But none compare to the photo,what happened to the driver?
My brother tells a good story--true, as far as I know. He took my nephew on his first hunting trip & they never saw a deer the entire weekend, but they hit one with the truck on the drive home.
That's a nice buck pictured above. I've gently tapped a few but never hard enough to hurt one or my truck. Had a couple jump the hood.
I clocked on 2 months ago, first one. 4 grand in repairs (covered by insurance). Amazing how hard a full grown mule deer doe can hit a car.
I have hit a couple myself but both vehicles were still driveable. The worst pic I have ever seen is of a GMC truck that hit a deer on rt side of windshield and somehow it was severed in two and one half exited out the right quarter glass and a big piece was in back seat. will look for the pics but the blood on beige leather is just nasty, and the driver was ok. Gotta drive alert in deer country and slower.
I live in the country in iowa, been driving for
39 years and have never hit a deer. From the
former posts, I now consider myself very lucky..
Im on top 7 so far!! LOL Hit one doe with my old toyota camery, dented it up pretty good, a fawn with my Ford Explorer(no damage), 4 with my Ford F 150 (2 in one day!)(no damage) FORD TUFF!!!! and 1 with a semi (Peter Built) going 70mph! There was noting I mean nothing left of that deer! (no damage)
Totaled my Ford Ranger on a nice 8 pointer in northern Minnesota last fall. It was about the 17th deer I'd seen that night, and i saw about 10 more on the ride the rest of the way home. It was like a deer gauntlet.
Nice buck!
I have hit 2 both were button bucks. Last fall saw a huge 8 pt buck watching traffic go by. Turned out both back legs were broken at the hocks. Police put him down and issued a salvage tag. You can see the buck in my photo file by clicking my username and looking in the pics. The meat was good and was donated to the needy.
I have never hit one myself but have seen several hit by a car ahead of me.
come close in ny but still lucky yet :)
For every truck I've ever owned, I installed those anti-dog/deer whistle gizmos on my front bumper. Either luck has been on my side or they actually work because I've never hit anything.
Ive been driving for 10 years now and I have hit one deer. Had many many close calls though. The very first day i got my license i put the plates on my truck and took off to town. Went down towards the river and out of the ditch jumped two does. Didnt have time to even hit the brakes. I drove bout a quarter mile and pulled over. Busted the raditor pretty good. Got back in the truck to call someone to pick me up when a truck pulled up to the passenger window. Out jumped a little enraged guy who cussed me up one side and down the other. He said I hit it on purpose. (which is exactly what i wanted to do 20 minutes into my first drive.) Said he was gonna kick my ass and jumped half way through the passenger window. I took off like a bat outta hell. He jumped out as soon as i took off. He called the cops but nothin happened. Never seen him again.
48 years old have never hit one. Live in Iowa deer country. Hope I did not just jinks myself.
I hit four deer in a period of about year in a half, but they barely did any damage to my truck. Only broke a little bit of plastic on the grill or caused a bulb in my headlight to break but never any serious damage. I've only had my license for nearly 4 years so figure them odds.
5 deer in 20 years, lot of backroad driveing thouth it would be more!!
Just another reason to put more bonus deer on a permit. Give us another bonus tag to use and one bonus deer to be donated for a shelter.
I've never hit a deer, but came close to a wild boar in Germany with a military vehicle.
I have lived in northern Wisconsin my whole life but up until 2000 I had only 1 minor run in with a deer. Since moving to a more rural area I have hit or been hit by 10 deer, only 1 was bad enough to make an insurance claim (thanks to a heavy duty brush guard)and my wife has hit 2, since 2008 the close calls have dropped off significantly as have overall deer sightings.
I've hit one.. and it took me a while to do so considering the country I drove every day for much of my licensed career. Every day from age 14 through my senior year at 18 I had to drive 20 miles each way to school. That might not seem terrible but there are deer hiding in every inch of that 20 miles. I had at least a dozen very near misses. It wasn't until I was 22 and on my way home from college for Christmas when I finally took my hit. Right at dusk, couldn't see a thing in the ditches, of course there was no snow this year. But I have been very lucky to only bag one deer with the bumper..
Thank goodness and knock on wood I've never had a deer collision that caused real damage. AS you say I've had several run into me. Including one that dived off a 15 foot high bank into the side of my Pickup...
There's a reason only one deer has run into the side of my car in 40 years of driving (and she got up and ran off): I take every opportunity to see deer regardless of season...and I guess I simply enjoy driving slow, watching. Yes, they can come from anywhere...but most people have so much on their minds, so busy and in a hurry, that they forget we are all driving through wildlife habitat. Its taken moose to slow people down. For years, cars were killing deer...its a different story now that moose are killing drivers!
i seem to pretty damn lucky when it comes to missing deer i see alot of them just feet from the edge of the road.. I would like to think hunters have slimmer chance of hitting deer as we look for them lol
I'm 1 for 3. Killed on I-70 eastbound near Greenfield Indiana back in 1990. Some very kind local auto mechanics took my car in of a Saturday in early December, strapped a new radiator on to the hulk, and got me on my way to Buffalo in a day. Insurance company totaled the car and then ripped me off on the settlement. I switched to State Farm and have been happy with them.
The two others were glancing blows from which both the deer and the vehicle walked away without lasting harm.
"going 70mph! There was noting I mean nothing left of that deer! (no damage)"
I know what you mean. The one I picked off in my Subaru GL station wagon at 70 mph broke into three large pieces, one of which (the head) went flying over the roof. The remains of the remains weren't even fit for sausage.
i hit a deer once, but its head wasn't stuck inside the truck.
i live in ohio and ive hit one since i got my license 6 years ago
I hit a mulie with my little souped-up Pontiac going about 80 km/h (50 mph), when I was a kid. She was coming up a deep ditch out of tall grass and bounced out in front of the car - I saw her land in the headlights, barely a few feet in front of me. Apparently, I just muttered a resigned "Ah, s***...," and wham.
She took out the radiator and A/C condenser, destroyed the hood and passenger side fender (and headlight) - then landed on the roof behind the sunroof (missing the windshield completely), stove the roof in a few inches and then slid off the back.
It was a real mess - but I was glad that it only scared the bejeezus out of my girlfriend (later, wife) who was sitting in the passenger seat.....
deer "love the car guys, how much was it?" lol
Here in WV I have managed to hit two deer. That is not too bad seeing that I spent my time where all the deer are. I am a retired Conservation Officer and when the rut comes in it is almost sucicide to drive . We have trees and brush close to our roads and the deer are in the road before the driver can react. Most of our state is prime deer country and that is what makes things worse. There is no where in the state that you can go that you don't have a chance at hitting a deer. Our roads are curvy and that makes it worse also. It seems like people don't want to slow down but drive like there is not a deer in the world.
Post a Comment
i have never been in a deer wreck, but my mom has hit 2, none of hers were as bad as the picture. the one in the picture looks like the worst one ive probably ever seen
Never hit a deer, but had a collision with a buffalo in northern Canada. Here is a story about it with pictures my buddy put together. The buffalo is about half way down.
http://pensacolafishingforum.com/fishingforum/Topic163343-3-1.aspx
My wife hit a deer two days before New Years eve. No accident report though. That Expedition didn't even get a scratch but the 140lb doe took a dirt nap! FORD TOUGH!! Fortunately it is a 1997 Expedition. A newer one probably wouldn't have been so lucky with their plastic covered bumpers. I don't even think my 2008 F250 would have held up as well.
I've hit two deer in 30 years of driving. Neither impact was hard enough to damage my F150.
On another note, I wonder how many of the report deer collisions were actually caused by something else but were reported as deer for the lower comprehensive deductible.
I live in the country in iowa, been driving for
39 years and have never hit a deer. From the
former posts, I now consider myself very lucky..
Totaled my Ford Ranger on a nice 8 pointer in northern Minnesota last fall. It was about the 17th deer I'd seen that night, and i saw about 10 more on the ride the rest of the way home. It was like a deer gauntlet.
My record is also two deer/vehicle collisions and I was also run into both times---on one, the doe tried to dive under and between my headlights after I had almost come to a complete stop and the other, a buck slammed into the driver's side door of my pickup. On both occasions, the vehicle won. Both were out of season so I took the carcases to the county jail where they were much appreciated.
i had one deer run into the side of my truck in arkasas but i think it was ok. couldn't find it afterward.
I've spent my life in many parts of WV, MD, and PA, and have seen countless deer grazing on the side of highways, in pastures, and making the dash across the road. I've witnessed a couple collisions, but have only tapped one deer that trotted off fine (knock on wood). Part of the key is being ready for it! I always assume a deer may bound out at any second...kind of another form of defensive driving. It's helped me hit the brakes in time a few times when it'd have turned out otherwise if I'd been dilly dallying along.
One deer met my bumper, shook me up pretty good, on my way to hunt elk no less. Being from Pennsylvania, most folks don't know to tell the insurance companies that the deer hit you. The moment you say you hit the deer you are at fault. Sounds funny, but it's all in the wording. If they try to correct you in any way like "Sir, did you mean to say that you hit a deer with your truck", just keep just keep correcting them and say that the deer hit you.
My dad and I hit a deer with our semi while hauling corn, it almost hit our raidiator.
I've hit 2 doe and one 8 point in velvet in Arkansas. I'm always on the look out, the 8 point ran across the road ahead of me so I was slowing, he reached the other ditch and decided to jump back onto the road as I went by. I lay on the horn and slap the outside of the door anytime I see road side deer now, a little traffic education for deer is good in these situations.
I'm getting my permit soon so I am really worried about hitting deer.
i live in saskatchewan and i have never hit a deer
Some areas have much higher odds than the state odds. The area around a local college with acres of woods and golf courses on the edge of urban sprawl has one of the highest rates in the country.
Lots of close calls for me but only one direct hit - at ... um, speed ... on the interstate.
Conventional wisdom (don't you love that term) says to hit the deer rather than try to avoid it. Damned if you do ... or don't. Deaths and injuries can result either way, but apparently less if you hit the deer. Also, if you hit a deer and wreck a vehicle the damage is covered under comprehensive coverage. If you avoid the deer and damage the vehicle then it is covered under collision coverage, and is considered an at-fault accident, which is likely to raise your insurance rates.
A guy tried to avoid a cat and missed me head-on by inches - I swerved and he hit my rear quarter and ripped off my bumper. Could have been really bad if I wasn't paying attention. He was just so focused on avoiding the animal that he didn't even see me.
Been driving for 14 years and have yet to hit a deer. However my dad hit one about 10 years ago, he dropped his truck off to get fixed. When he was on his way home from getting it fixed he hit another one. Sadly there was no warranty for teh work that was just done.
I took out a nice 8pt in velvet in WV while there on business. It was the company truck thank goodness because the bumper went clean through the radiator.
knock on wood i have never hit one and hope to keep it like that
a friend of mines mom went threw 3 cars in one year she did the newspaper route and she was on the road from 3-6 in the morning she hit one very nice 8 pointer what horns were left on the deer were stuck in the radiator
The closest thing I've had to a deer collision was a a couple of years ago. I was driving down a backroad and came up on on two young 4 pts in the road. One fled to the shoulder, while the other simply switched lanes. As I approached the one in the road, he started to run in the direction of the vehicle. I watched him from the window as I passed him, and then the side mirror. For some reason, he then decided to make a right turn and ran into the side of my truck. He acted like he was surprised the truck was there. Both the deer and truck were ok.
I had several close calls but I've only actually hit one. It was a yearling that darted right out in front of me. It was a tiny little thing, but at 65 mph it did a number on my truck--grill, bumper, fender, headlight. The F-150 could be fixed--the deer wasn't so lucky.
I've hit two deer on separte occusions within the city limits of my Alabama hometown, once during morning rush hour. I did recover the meat. A kidde pool makes a good catcher for skinning and gutting in the garage. LOL
I've been lucky enough not to hit one,but have seen my share and even had a close call living here in Pa.
But none compare to the photo,what happened to the driver?
My brother tells a good story--true, as far as I know. He took my nephew on his first hunting trip & they never saw a deer the entire weekend, but they hit one with the truck on the drive home.
That's a nice buck pictured above. I've gently tapped a few but never hard enough to hurt one or my truck. Had a couple jump the hood.
I clocked on 2 months ago, first one. 4 grand in repairs (covered by insurance). Amazing how hard a full grown mule deer doe can hit a car.
I have hit a couple myself but both vehicles were still driveable. The worst pic I have ever seen is of a GMC truck that hit a deer on rt side of windshield and somehow it was severed in two and one half exited out the right quarter glass and a big piece was in back seat. will look for the pics but the blood on beige leather is just nasty, and the driver was ok. Gotta drive alert in deer country and slower.
Im on top 7 so far!! LOL Hit one doe with my old toyota camery, dented it up pretty good, a fawn with my Ford Explorer(no damage), 4 with my Ford F 150 (2 in one day!)(no damage) FORD TUFF!!!! and 1 with a semi (Peter Built) going 70mph! There was noting I mean nothing left of that deer! (no damage)
Nice buck!
I have hit 2 both were button bucks. Last fall saw a huge 8 pt buck watching traffic go by. Turned out both back legs were broken at the hocks. Police put him down and issued a salvage tag. You can see the buck in my photo file by clicking my username and looking in the pics. The meat was good and was donated to the needy.
Ive been driving for 10 years now and I have hit one deer. Had many many close calls though. The very first day i got my license i put the plates on my truck and took off to town. Went down towards the river and out of the ditch jumped two does. Didnt have time to even hit the brakes. I drove bout a quarter mile and pulled over. Busted the raditor pretty good. Got back in the truck to call someone to pick me up when a truck pulled up to the passenger window. Out jumped a little enraged guy who cussed me up one side and down the other. He said I hit it on purpose. (which is exactly what i wanted to do 20 minutes into my first drive.) Said he was gonna kick my ass and jumped half way through the passenger window. I took off like a bat outta hell. He jumped out as soon as i took off. He called the cops but nothin happened. Never seen him again.
I have never hit one myself but have seen several hit by a car ahead of me.
come close in ny but still lucky yet :)
For every truck I've ever owned, I installed those anti-dog/deer whistle gizmos on my front bumper. Either luck has been on my side or they actually work because I've never hit anything.
48 years old have never hit one. Live in Iowa deer country. Hope I did not just jinks myself.
I hit four deer in a period of about year in a half, but they barely did any damage to my truck. Only broke a little bit of plastic on the grill or caused a bulb in my headlight to break but never any serious damage. I've only had my license for nearly 4 years so figure them odds.
5 deer in 20 years, lot of backroad driveing thouth it would be more!!
Just another reason to put more bonus deer on a permit. Give us another bonus tag to use and one bonus deer to be donated for a shelter.
I've never hit a deer, but came close to a wild boar in Germany with a military vehicle.
I have lived in northern Wisconsin my whole life but up until 2000 I had only 1 minor run in with a deer. Since moving to a more rural area I have hit or been hit by 10 deer, only 1 was bad enough to make an insurance claim (thanks to a heavy duty brush guard)and my wife has hit 2, since 2008 the close calls have dropped off significantly as have overall deer sightings.
I've hit one.. and it took me a while to do so considering the country I drove every day for much of my licensed career. Every day from age 14 through my senior year at 18 I had to drive 20 miles each way to school. That might not seem terrible but there are deer hiding in every inch of that 20 miles. I had at least a dozen very near misses. It wasn't until I was 22 and on my way home from college for Christmas when I finally took my hit. Right at dusk, couldn't see a thing in the ditches, of course there was no snow this year. But I have been very lucky to only bag one deer with the bumper..
i seem to pretty damn lucky when it comes to missing deer i see alot of them just feet from the edge of the road.. I would like to think hunters have slimmer chance of hitting deer as we look for them lol
I'm 1 for 3. Killed on I-70 eastbound near Greenfield Indiana back in 1990. Some very kind local auto mechanics took my car in of a Saturday in early December, strapped a new radiator on to the hulk, and got me on my way to Buffalo in a day. Insurance company totaled the car and then ripped me off on the settlement. I switched to State Farm and have been happy with them.
The two others were glancing blows from which both the deer and the vehicle walked away without lasting harm.
"going 70mph! There was noting I mean nothing left of that deer! (no damage)"
I know what you mean. The one I picked off in my Subaru GL station wagon at 70 mph broke into three large pieces, one of which (the head) went flying over the roof. The remains of the remains weren't even fit for sausage.
Thank goodness and knock on wood I've never had a deer collision that caused real damage. AS you say I've had several run into me. Including one that dived off a 15 foot high bank into the side of my Pickup...
There's a reason only one deer has run into the side of my car in 40 years of driving (and she got up and ran off): I take every opportunity to see deer regardless of season...and I guess I simply enjoy driving slow, watching. Yes, they can come from anywhere...but most people have so much on their minds, so busy and in a hurry, that they forget we are all driving through wildlife habitat. Its taken moose to slow people down. For years, cars were killing deer...its a different story now that moose are killing drivers!
i hit a deer once, but its head wasn't stuck inside the truck.
i live in ohio and ive hit one since i got my license 6 years ago
I hit a mulie with my little souped-up Pontiac going about 80 km/h (50 mph), when I was a kid. She was coming up a deep ditch out of tall grass and bounced out in front of the car - I saw her land in the headlights, barely a few feet in front of me. Apparently, I just muttered a resigned "Ah, s***...," and wham.
She took out the radiator and A/C condenser, destroyed the hood and passenger side fender (and headlight) - then landed on the roof behind the sunroof (missing the windshield completely), stove the roof in a few inches and then slid off the back.
It was a real mess - but I was glad that it only scared the bejeezus out of my girlfriend (later, wife) who was sitting in the passenger seat.....
deer "love the car guys, how much was it?" lol
Here in WV I have managed to hit two deer. That is not too bad seeing that I spent my time where all the deer are. I am a retired Conservation Officer and when the rut comes in it is almost sucicide to drive . We have trees and brush close to our roads and the deer are in the road before the driver can react. Most of our state is prime deer country and that is what makes things worse. There is no where in the state that you can go that you don't have a chance at hitting a deer. Our roads are curvy and that makes it worse also. It seems like people don't want to slow down but drive like there is not a deer in the world.
Post a Comment