Please Sign In

Please enter a valid username and password
» Not a member? Take a moment to register
» Forgot Username or Password

Why Register?
Signing up could earn you gear (click here to learn how)! It also keeps offensive content off our site.

Enough with the "Extreme" Fishing Already!

May 27, 2009

Enough with the "Extreme" Fishing Already!

Photo by Kirk Deeter

Let's get something straight.  Rodeo is an "extreme" sport.  Perhaps the original extreme sport.  Doing back flips on motorcycles (on purpose) over jumps is pretty extreme.  BASE jumping is extreme.  Fly fishing is not an extreme sport.  Never has been. Never will be.

I keep getting press releases and pitch letters telling be about the next totally awesome, "extreme" fly fishing adventure.  The word "oxymoron" comes to mind when "extreme" and "fly fishing" are bundled together. Please, people who send me these things, omit extreme fly fishing from your vocabulary.

So you dodge some heavy rapids.  Not extreme.  Jumping tarpon in the Everglades.  Not extreme.  You catch fish that might bite you.  Not extreme.  Well, okay, Conway Bowman and Dave Trimble, who catch big mako sharks on flies from 20-foot boats 16 miles offshore... that's a little nutty.  But even they don't say "extreme."

Mind you, I've been in the bush planes in Alaska, landed on jungle airstrips in Bolivia (then went upriver in dugout canoes to fish for dorado... please do check out the July issue of Field & Stream magazine to see that feature story), and been bit, scratched and all that.  I call that iffy.  Dicey sometimes.  But not extreme.

Am I missing something?  Do you have a real "extreme" fishing story that might change my mind?

Deeter

 

Comments (12)

Top Rated
All Comments
from buckhunter wrote 1 year 9 weeks ago

It was the night of the Tyson vs Holyfield fight. (ear biting). I was in California with some friends fishing the Sierra Nevadas. The 10 of us had plans on leaving early in the morning and hiking miles into the mountains for some good native fishing. Judd reccomended a small stream in the foothills that is loaded with bows. Everyone said he was crazy because there were too many rattlesnakes. I asked how good the fishing was. Judd said it was phenomenal. "Hell, let's go" was my response. Everyone thought I was nuts. Of course Judd was a rodeo cowboy so we all knew he was already nuts.

It was just the two of us. We had to climb straight down a 30 foot cliff loaded with nooks and crannies. It was the longest climb of my life. Every rock and every hole I thought held a rattle snake. Once we got to the water I spent the entire time watching carefully each step. To be honest, I never enjoyed it. I was catching fish but the fear of rattle snakes was ever present. We were 6 hours from the closest hospital.

The good news is we caught plenty of fish and never saw a snake.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from peter wrote 1 year 9 weeks ago

fishing can get extreme when on a canoe in giant rabids, but i guess thats more of canoing then fishin

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from chuckles wrote 1 year 9 weeks ago

My friends and I used to haul all our gear, rafts etc. down Chukar Trail into the Black Canyon. It was fish, fish, fish, paddle, paddle, paddle all day and depending on the river stage could get downright exhilarating in the rapids but I wouldn't compare it to rodeo.
I have definitely been to "dicey" in alpine river environments trying to get to that one hole you were pretty sure no one had fished (for good reason).
I'm with you, "extreme fishing" is oxymoronic.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from Big O wrote 1 year 9 weeks ago

How about a float trip(canoe) during "cotton-mouth" mating season ? That was pretty "extreme".

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from Evan V wrote 1 year 9 weeks ago

What about fly fishing with your mouth? I do it all the time! I get way stranger looks doing that than anything else.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from FloridaHunter1226 wrote 1 year 9 weeks ago

Fishing off a boat and in a pair of waders is as "extreme" as it gets for me.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from Fishing Jones wrote 1 year 9 weeks ago

Amen. No matter how heavy the soundtrack you put behind it, calling fly fishing extreme doesn't compute.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from Koldkut wrote 1 year 9 weeks ago

I think in most cases you could substitute Extreme with Insane, which would bring us closer if you wanted to play with words to justify the meaning. I've had a few run-ins with nesting geese while I've had a fish on the line.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from Jeff4066 wrote 1 year 9 weeks ago

How much of this "extreme" is either publicity or plain macho posturing?

Putting yourself in a dangerous situation for any sport is just plain dumb.

Those of us who have been in dangerous places before don't need the "thrill" of that.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from shane wrote 1 year 8 weeks ago

Fishing in Devil's Hole is pretty nuts.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from conway wrote 1 year 8 weeks ago

kd

I agree. fly fishing is not extreme. it's kinda' like calling Curling and extreme sport... i hate it when people try to define what others are doing.
as for dave and me...well some say it's just crazy! in fact i think i am crazy...just ask my wife.
I'm headed back out to the loony bin 6 miles offshore tomorrow to chase those big ass makos we have around at the moment...i"ll report back upon my return

best

conman

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from Smithhammer wrote 1 year 7 weeks ago

Well said. "Extreme" fly fishing is an obvious marketing ploy, nothing more.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report

Post a Comment

from conway wrote 1 year 8 weeks ago

kd

I agree. fly fishing is not extreme. it's kinda' like calling Curling and extreme sport... i hate it when people try to define what others are doing.
as for dave and me...well some say it's just crazy! in fact i think i am crazy...just ask my wife.
I'm headed back out to the loony bin 6 miles offshore tomorrow to chase those big ass makos we have around at the moment...i"ll report back upon my return

best

conman

+2 Good Comment? | | Report
from buckhunter wrote 1 year 9 weeks ago

It was the night of the Tyson vs Holyfield fight. (ear biting). I was in California with some friends fishing the Sierra Nevadas. The 10 of us had plans on leaving early in the morning and hiking miles into the mountains for some good native fishing. Judd reccomended a small stream in the foothills that is loaded with bows. Everyone said he was crazy because there were too many rattlesnakes. I asked how good the fishing was. Judd said it was phenomenal. "Hell, let's go" was my response. Everyone thought I was nuts. Of course Judd was a rodeo cowboy so we all knew he was already nuts.

It was just the two of us. We had to climb straight down a 30 foot cliff loaded with nooks and crannies. It was the longest climb of my life. Every rock and every hole I thought held a rattle snake. Once we got to the water I spent the entire time watching carefully each step. To be honest, I never enjoyed it. I was catching fish but the fear of rattle snakes was ever present. We were 6 hours from the closest hospital.

The good news is we caught plenty of fish and never saw a snake.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from peter wrote 1 year 9 weeks ago

fishing can get extreme when on a canoe in giant rabids, but i guess thats more of canoing then fishin

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from chuckles wrote 1 year 9 weeks ago

My friends and I used to haul all our gear, rafts etc. down Chukar Trail into the Black Canyon. It was fish, fish, fish, paddle, paddle, paddle all day and depending on the river stage could get downright exhilarating in the rapids but I wouldn't compare it to rodeo.
I have definitely been to "dicey" in alpine river environments trying to get to that one hole you were pretty sure no one had fished (for good reason).
I'm with you, "extreme fishing" is oxymoronic.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from Big O wrote 1 year 9 weeks ago

How about a float trip(canoe) during "cotton-mouth" mating season ? That was pretty "extreme".

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from Evan V wrote 1 year 9 weeks ago

What about fly fishing with your mouth? I do it all the time! I get way stranger looks doing that than anything else.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from FloridaHunter1226 wrote 1 year 9 weeks ago

Fishing off a boat and in a pair of waders is as "extreme" as it gets for me.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from Fishing Jones wrote 1 year 9 weeks ago

Amen. No matter how heavy the soundtrack you put behind it, calling fly fishing extreme doesn't compute.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from Koldkut wrote 1 year 9 weeks ago

I think in most cases you could substitute Extreme with Insane, which would bring us closer if you wanted to play with words to justify the meaning. I've had a few run-ins with nesting geese while I've had a fish on the line.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from Jeff4066 wrote 1 year 9 weeks ago

How much of this "extreme" is either publicity or plain macho posturing?

Putting yourself in a dangerous situation for any sport is just plain dumb.

Those of us who have been in dangerous places before don't need the "thrill" of that.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from shane wrote 1 year 8 weeks ago

Fishing in Devil's Hole is pretty nuts.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from Smithhammer wrote 1 year 7 weeks ago

Well said. "Extreme" fly fishing is an obvious marketing ploy, nothing more.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report

Post a Comment