


November 09, 2009
Chad Love: Bears Don't Play Hockey
By Chad Love
Here's an interesting story that highlights why I believe it's possible to be opposed to animal cruelty without falling into the hypocrisy of "animal rights." Ice-skating Bear Kills Circus Head
From the story:
A circus bear killed one person and injured another during rehearsals for an ice-skating show. The bear, which was part of the Russian State Circus, killed Dmitri Potapov, 25, a circus director who was visiting the show in Bishkek, the capital of Kyrgyzstan. An animal handler who tried to stop the attack suffered bruising to the brain and lacerations to his scalp. It is unclear why the bear, which was wearing ice skates at the time, attacked Mr Potapov. The bear was later shot by police. Deadly attacks are rare in the country's circuses, which often train bears to wear skates and play ice hockey.
We read all the time about animal trainers getting mauled by their students. This generally occurs as the animal trainer is coercing a large and/or dangerous animal into doing something completely alien to its nature for the purpose of entertainment. It's just one more side-effect of our species' stubborn insistence on inflicting Bambi fantasies on wild animals.
Watch this Youtube video of Russian bears actually playing ice hockey:
I find this sickening. I don't understand why anyone would want to watch these apex predators "performing," doing something so alien to what they are and the wildness they symbolize. I don't think it's entertaning, I think it qualifies as cruelty.
However, that doesn't make me a supporter of the concept of animal "rights" and it doesn't make me a hypocrite for seeing absolutely nothing wrong with things like rodeos, horse races and retriever field trials, either. Why, because those activities don't try to turn animals ino something they're not. Regardless of human involvement horses will run, bulls will buck and dogs will hunt. But the day I see a bear - of his won free will - strap on a pair of ice skates and start playing hockey is the day I check myself into therapy.
Comments (13)
Take off the skates and let em hunt terrorist's !
I most definitely don't agree with degrading an apex predator by teaching him to play hockey.But they can play better than most in the NHL. Kidding aside, it does show the intelligence of these animals and their ability to learn. Very intelligent!
A horse may be a horse etc but bears are apex predators. When their brains snap it's only NATURAL that they lash our by tooth and claw
Very sad indeed.
It's hard for the animal rights activist to understand how we as hunters can view this as cruelty but on the same token find it acceptable to hunt and kill these creatures.
It's the complete unnatural state these bears are in that I find disturbing.
Incredible trainers or drunk bored Russians in the woods with nothing else to do. gotta admit it is amazing to watch and how do you get them to learn skating?
I am thinking the enraged bear was still mad about a bad call or something.........cant imagine he was peeed off about skipping hibernation and having to play hockey. Lets send PETA moron over there to protest.
The founder must be a bit loopy on the vodka!
wow that seems very serial and almost fake but those are really bears... I was kidding when i said enlist them into the military when i heard about the terrorists getting killed by a bear but if you could teach them to play hockey ill bet we could train them to kill terrorists on command! for entertainment this seems a little wrong and how the hell did they teach them that?
Bears Playing Hockey? Is this a sport of no IQ required?? LOL!
I do love Superbowl weekends, I really do! That is when everyone is at home getting drunk and Alex and I have the woods to ourselves!
Bears eating humans in caves has been happening for 20,000 years. Perfectly natural, but Hockey is unnatural for humans let alone bears! I completely sympathize with the bear for not wanting to be forced to play hockey. I didn't like being made to play softball in gym (I liked archery much better), of course I didn't maul anybody to death over it (though I did strangle the JV football captain a little. He lived, I was considered justified and didn't get in trouble and he was dead in a drunken car wreck in 2 years.) Sic Semper Tyrannus.
That's why I don't watch hockey, to much violence!
I love hockey and I know its a little physical but not as much as that!
That is just not right...
Amazing that these bears were somehow taught to play a human sport- it definitely shows how intelligent these animals are. But to make them take part in an event so far removed from what their natural instincts tell them to do is another example mankind's wish to have control over everything.
It's a shame that someone had to die and another be seriously injured, but I don't blame the bear for acting on it's natural urges.
The last time i went to the circus many years ago I saw the trained bears and other trained animals. It really upset me to see these magnificent animals reduced to circus performers. I am most definitely not an animal rights person, but training animals to perform in a circus is cruelty.
I was amazed for a moment, then totally disgusted. It is apalling to see bears with ice skates on. What is wrong with our society? Even those of you who commented and expressed concern where still very amused. As you said it is hard to imagine hunters being upset by a bear playing hockey. When the truth is that most of you would love to shoot a bear that size during season. I felt humiliated for them. Why do we as humans feel the need to break everything? Do we think that by wearing this animal down to being so submissive; That it allows humans to strap iceskates to their paws; does that prove we are more powerful? We forget that the bear is allowing it to happen. All they have done is beaten the pride out of it. The one that killed the trainer decided he would rather be dead than be subjected to the humiliation of iceskates one more time. I hope that all of those bears go on a man killing rampage in one of those packed stadiums. We as humans should be ashamed at the mockery we have made of our eco-system. If you kill or torture for amusement or profit, or if you find amusement in watching death and torture you have a rotten place in your soul. Really do you think those bears started this willingly? For all of you who think im a "PETA moron" your wrong. I absolutely believe in the food chain. I hunted for 15 years. However, I believe in respecting the animals on this planet. ALL of them. From cattle to squirrels. I dont nor have ever been a "trophy" hunter. If you arent going to eat it dont shoot it. If you are going to eat it show it the respect it deserves. After all it died so you could live................
Post a Comment
Take off the skates and let em hunt terrorist's !
Incredible trainers or drunk bored Russians in the woods with nothing else to do. gotta admit it is amazing to watch and how do you get them to learn skating?
I am thinking the enraged bear was still mad about a bad call or something.........cant imagine he was peeed off about skipping hibernation and having to play hockey. Lets send PETA moron over there to protest.
I most definitely don't agree with degrading an apex predator by teaching him to play hockey.But they can play better than most in the NHL. Kidding aside, it does show the intelligence of these animals and their ability to learn. Very intelligent!
The founder must be a bit loopy on the vodka!
Very sad indeed.
It's hard for the animal rights activist to understand how we as hunters can view this as cruelty but on the same token find it acceptable to hunt and kill these creatures.
It's the complete unnatural state these bears are in that I find disturbing.
A horse may be a horse etc but bears are apex predators. When their brains snap it's only NATURAL that they lash our by tooth and claw
Bears Playing Hockey? Is this a sport of no IQ required?? LOL!
I do love Superbowl weekends, I really do! That is when everyone is at home getting drunk and Alex and I have the woods to ourselves!
Bears eating humans in caves has been happening for 20,000 years. Perfectly natural, but Hockey is unnatural for humans let alone bears! I completely sympathize with the bear for not wanting to be forced to play hockey. I didn't like being made to play softball in gym (I liked archery much better), of course I didn't maul anybody to death over it (though I did strangle the JV football captain a little. He lived, I was considered justified and didn't get in trouble and he was dead in a drunken car wreck in 2 years.) Sic Semper Tyrannus.
The last time i went to the circus many years ago I saw the trained bears and other trained animals. It really upset me to see these magnificent animals reduced to circus performers. I am most definitely not an animal rights person, but training animals to perform in a circus is cruelty.
I love hockey and I know its a little physical but not as much as that!
wow that seems very serial and almost fake but those are really bears... I was kidding when i said enlist them into the military when i heard about the terrorists getting killed by a bear but if you could teach them to play hockey ill bet we could train them to kill terrorists on command! for entertainment this seems a little wrong and how the hell did they teach them that?
That is just not right...
Amazing that these bears were somehow taught to play a human sport- it definitely shows how intelligent these animals are. But to make them take part in an event so far removed from what their natural instincts tell them to do is another example mankind's wish to have control over everything.
It's a shame that someone had to die and another be seriously injured, but I don't blame the bear for acting on it's natural urges.
I was amazed for a moment, then totally disgusted. It is apalling to see bears with ice skates on. What is wrong with our society? Even those of you who commented and expressed concern where still very amused. As you said it is hard to imagine hunters being upset by a bear playing hockey. When the truth is that most of you would love to shoot a bear that size during season. I felt humiliated for them. Why do we as humans feel the need to break everything? Do we think that by wearing this animal down to being so submissive; That it allows humans to strap iceskates to their paws; does that prove we are more powerful? We forget that the bear is allowing it to happen. All they have done is beaten the pride out of it. The one that killed the trainer decided he would rather be dead than be subjected to the humiliation of iceskates one more time. I hope that all of those bears go on a man killing rampage in one of those packed stadiums. We as humans should be ashamed at the mockery we have made of our eco-system. If you kill or torture for amusement or profit, or if you find amusement in watching death and torture you have a rotten place in your soul. Really do you think those bears started this willingly? For all of you who think im a "PETA moron" your wrong. I absolutely believe in the food chain. I hunted for 15 years. However, I believe in respecting the animals on this planet. ALL of them. From cattle to squirrels. I dont nor have ever been a "trophy" hunter. If you arent going to eat it dont shoot it. If you are going to eat it show it the respect it deserves. After all it died so you could live................
That's why I don't watch hockey, to much violence!
Post a Comment