


December 18, 2009
A New Kentucky State-Record Buck?
By Scott Bestul
Got an email from a Buck Tracker reader with a simple request this week. Is the buck below the new Kentucky state record? I have no details beyond this fuzzy photograph and the following details; that the rumor is the buck was killed in Robertson County near Mount Olivet.
For the record, the Boone & Crockett state records for the Bluegrass State are some heady marks to beat. The typical mark belongs to a 204-2/8” buck killed by Robert Smith in 2000, and the non-typ category is ruled by a found (picked up) rack that measured 271 B&C and was discovered in 2004. The biggest hunter-killed buck was shot by Ben Brogle in 2002 and scored 260 B&C.
Kentucky has been relatively quiet this fall in B&C news…surprising due to its big-buck reputation. I’ve asked a few folk that might know, and they can’t toss a crumb of information my way about this deer. So I’m asking you guys…Know anything about this buck? It’s definitely a giant, but if there’s some solid info out there, I’d love to say readers of this blog unraveled the mystery!
Comments (24)
I know nothing about this deer, except that those tines are longer than the ones that the deer in my dream have!!!
Nate
This same picture showed up on an Oklahoma outdoor forum that I frequent back in October. Apparently the deer was taken illegally near Antlers, OK and is now in possession of the ODWC pending further investigation. But, you know how rumors go, so there is no telling if that information is accurate or not.
Correction: The deer was supposedly taken near Wilburton, OK
I haven't seen that one. I've got one similar on my cell phone, that a young man up the street arrowed back in September,but it was a typical that measured 200" without the 60 day drying period.
Robert (Smitty) Smith, is my hunting buddy and we saw one that would beat his typical record but couldn't get a bead on it.
Scott, there are some bruiser's fallin' in Caintukee,but just not enough to beat Smitty's record ...yet!
A link to some info on this buck: http://discussions.texasbowhunter.com/forums/showthread.php?s=77b66f9f21...
_c_a_c_-
Thanks for the link!
Case closed - http://oklahomabowhunter.com/main/index.php?topic=313.90
My Lord!! the brow tines are incredible!!
Wow, that buck is a monster!
I'm glad they got him! We had a young man here in NC just shoot possibly the state record on a sunday night with a spot light! What a shame and the guy had never hunted before just bought the rifle the day before I wonder who the fellow was that brought him up to hunt! Its a shame all together
That's an awesome buck...looks like the photo was taken with a cell phone.
Yeah, its a shame that such a magnificent animal had to meet his end that way. But, the real tragedy is the pickup load full of antlers the guy had stashed in his buddy's attic,of which many were undoubtedly taken illegally as well. (check out the second link to see what I'm talking about)
getholdofjoru - I believe the orignal picture was taken by the guy with his cell phone and sent to some of his "buddies". I am assuming that is how the ODWC tracked him down, along with the help of so many members of the online community.
Truly the buck of a lifetime. It pains me that a true sportsman didn't get the opportunity to harvest him as he deserved.
It's our own fault for making such a fuss over big racks and forgeting what huntings really about. There isn't a magazine out there with a picture of a 4 or 6 pointer in it. When I was growing up poachers were shooting deer for meat to feed their families. Now they could care less about the meat and only go after big racks to sell them for money or glory. If you tell someone you shot a 4 or 6 point their reaction is " Man, that could've been a shooter in a couple years! I'd say the commercialization of hunting is turning it into a freak show.
This kind of breaks my heart and im sure anyones who lives in there area this deer was killed. Of all the factors that bear down on a deer to not make it to this stature poaching is the most down right pointless and nasty thing such a magnificent animal such as this one should die from. the deer has not only the pressure of constantly being hunted by predators,cars, disease, hunters, and lack of food. If you can't play the game fair the deer deserves to live. Give this sport and animals some respect.
Those brow tines look like the Twin Towers!!! Then you have a whole bunch of kickers. That thing is NICE!!!
how can it be a kentucky state record if it was taken illeagy in OK ???????? awsome buck in anyway
Looks like Rudolph had a crash landing!
This flight Santa to Mission Control I'm declaring an IFE, Rudolph's landing gear will not deploy!
those are some nice brow tines!
Nice buck huge brow tines, would definitley make me happy.
i havent heard of no one killing any thing near boone and crocket except a guy i know killd a 22 point that was 10 points from being boone and crocket.
I know there is alot of talk about this buck bening taken in OK, but wat you hear is a lie ive seen the deer with my own eyes my best firend took this buck in robertson county,Kentucky opening weekend of rifle season and the pic is tru the deer was finally final scored and scored 205 6/8 boone and crockett.
Is there any way someone can get a clearer picture of this deer. If they could they would settle the dispute whether it was shot legal or not. I hunt Kentucky and Oklahoma and would like to see the shooter and the deer head together in the same photo, with proof of where they took it. This would settle the debate. I also agree with the coment about people shooting for racks and not meat too.
Did anyone ever tell you if this beat the record? Also, what camera did they use? Doesn't look like they used primos cameras.
Post a Comment
I know nothing about this deer, except that those tines are longer than the ones that the deer in my dream have!!!
Nate
A link to some info on this buck: http://discussions.texasbowhunter.com/forums/showthread.php?s=77b66f9f21...
It's our own fault for making such a fuss over big racks and forgeting what huntings really about. There isn't a magazine out there with a picture of a 4 or 6 pointer in it. When I was growing up poachers were shooting deer for meat to feed their families. Now they could care less about the meat and only go after big racks to sell them for money or glory. If you tell someone you shot a 4 or 6 point their reaction is " Man, that could've been a shooter in a couple years! I'd say the commercialization of hunting is turning it into a freak show.
This same picture showed up on an Oklahoma outdoor forum that I frequent back in October. Apparently the deer was taken illegally near Antlers, OK and is now in possession of the ODWC pending further investigation. But, you know how rumors go, so there is no telling if that information is accurate or not.
Case closed - http://oklahomabowhunter.com/main/index.php?topic=313.90
My Lord!! the brow tines are incredible!!
Wow, that buck is a monster!
That's an awesome buck...looks like the photo was taken with a cell phone.
Yeah, its a shame that such a magnificent animal had to meet his end that way. But, the real tragedy is the pickup load full of antlers the guy had stashed in his buddy's attic,of which many were undoubtedly taken illegally as well. (check out the second link to see what I'm talking about)
getholdofjoru - I believe the orignal picture was taken by the guy with his cell phone and sent to some of his "buddies". I am assuming that is how the ODWC tracked him down, along with the help of so many members of the online community.
Truly the buck of a lifetime. It pains me that a true sportsman didn't get the opportunity to harvest him as he deserved.
i havent heard of no one killing any thing near boone and crocket except a guy i know killd a 22 point that was 10 points from being boone and crocket.
Correction: The deer was supposedly taken near Wilburton, OK
I haven't seen that one. I've got one similar on my cell phone, that a young man up the street arrowed back in September,but it was a typical that measured 200" without the 60 day drying period.
Robert (Smitty) Smith, is my hunting buddy and we saw one that would beat his typical record but couldn't get a bead on it.
Scott, there are some bruiser's fallin' in Caintukee,but just not enough to beat Smitty's record ...yet!
_c_a_c_-
Thanks for the link!
I'm glad they got him! We had a young man here in NC just shoot possibly the state record on a sunday night with a spot light! What a shame and the guy had never hunted before just bought the rifle the day before I wonder who the fellow was that brought him up to hunt! Its a shame all together
This kind of breaks my heart and im sure anyones who lives in there area this deer was killed. Of all the factors that bear down on a deer to not make it to this stature poaching is the most down right pointless and nasty thing such a magnificent animal such as this one should die from. the deer has not only the pressure of constantly being hunted by predators,cars, disease, hunters, and lack of food. If you can't play the game fair the deer deserves to live. Give this sport and animals some respect.
Those brow tines look like the Twin Towers!!! Then you have a whole bunch of kickers. That thing is NICE!!!
how can it be a kentucky state record if it was taken illeagy in OK ???????? awsome buck in anyway
those are some nice brow tines!
Nice buck huge brow tines, would definitley make me happy.
I know there is alot of talk about this buck bening taken in OK, but wat you hear is a lie ive seen the deer with my own eyes my best firend took this buck in robertson county,Kentucky opening weekend of rifle season and the pic is tru the deer was finally final scored and scored 205 6/8 boone and crockett.
Is there any way someone can get a clearer picture of this deer. If they could they would settle the dispute whether it was shot legal or not. I hunt Kentucky and Oklahoma and would like to see the shooter and the deer head together in the same photo, with proof of where they took it. This would settle the debate. I also agree with the coment about people shooting for racks and not meat too.
Did anyone ever tell you if this beat the record? Also, what camera did they use? Doesn't look like they used primos cameras.
Looks like Rudolph had a crash landing!
This flight Santa to Mission Control I'm declaring an IFE, Rudolph's landing gear will not deploy!
Post a Comment