


March 31, 2009
Testing Fly Reels With A Four-Wheeler
By Tim Romano
Kirk and I like to test our flyfishing gear a little differently than most... Perhaps you remember we tested a number of reels with a motorcycle a couple of years ago. This time we went off-road.
In the March issue of Field and Stream Kirk names the Bauer Rogue the top reel in the Best of the Best for all Fly Reels. This was just one of the "tests" we did to ensure smooth drag start-up. Kirk and I have a number of other ideas as well, from sitting in a walk-in freezer and getting sprayed by a fire hose to test jackets or dropping a bowling ball attached to a rod to ensure "strength". Anyone out there have ideas they'd like to see tried on any fly gear? We're all ears.
TR
Comments (18)
I suggest you send them to me for some good old fashion on the water fish catching testing.
Get together with the Top Gear guys across the pond and see if they have anything that could push the drag limits.
personaly... I don't think that test was really much of a test
All you have shown is that a drag can handle speed.
Instead, start with 15ft of line at your feet. Allow the bike/ATV to speed away and pick the line off the ground and gain speed. Then as line is zipping put it to the reel.
on the video the line is tight and the reel is linked up so it sees the acceleration. with line at your fetl the drag will have to start from 0 to say 15mph, with now acceleratiopn but rather full force. i feel that would be a better test of what the drag could handle.
*no acceleration*
A good point, Ramcatt, but is the 15 feet of slack a test of the reel or the fisherman... I mean, should the slack be there in the first place?
it was more to test when the drag does have the acceleration crutch
start with 30' out the tip with the bike behind you
allow the bike to drive past you and then when 30' in front of rod the drag kicks in with no chance to "accelerate" the drag/line into the speed
this is when you are fishing will line at your feel and the fish bullets... screaming line through the guides til when the line gets tension... the fish is already moving and the drag has not been touched
Take the Rogue to the "David Letterman" show, hook it to a watermelon, and drop it off of the Ed Sullivan Theater, and hold on!
wow... i am no longer allowed to post with the blackberry
reads like the bestest 3rd grade book report
i think for one of the gear tests you do you should test the legibility of the ugly stik commercial, seeing if a rod could last a trash compactor.
Desperation has set in!
Power tools
If you really want to test a drag, hook it up to a front end loader and see what happens. If you hook it to the bucket and have the driver drive in reverse you can simulate a leaper as the bucket goes up and down.
All I know is that looks like fun, and I wish I had that in my job description.
If you want to test a reel tie your tippet to a wild rabbit and let it go. Try to reel that in.
If you want to test your rod give it to my son. If it's not broken at the end of the day then he didn't go fishing.
I will suggest testing your wading boots on West Virginia summer time rocks. I have experience none more slippery in the world.
Test your waders while walking the banks of the Colorado River. (I did so yesterday) The cactus and bushes there attack you at every angle with thorns and loose sharp rocks.
I'd like to see how all fly boxes hold up to a good drop in some whitewater.....all boxes must have the full gammit of flies, from dries to weighted buggers, and a small folded piece of paper in there with a name and phone number of the "owner". Send it 200 yards down stream and see how they and their contents fare. Then do a drop test on some rocks or other hard surfaces to see how each box holds up to a beating. This will simulate forces similar to the ones I exert on my boxes when I grab my vest by the scruff and toss it in the back of the car.
koldkut,
I like this. We'll have to work on a variation of this one...
Tim
Was walking through the local sportsmand warehouse in the Springs looking at the boxes and thought an old front load washing machine would work nicely for testing boxes...lol
Tie onto a decent Bonefish, and you will know.
Post a Comment
I suggest you send them to me for some good old fashion on the water fish catching testing.
Get together with the Top Gear guys across the pond and see if they have anything that could push the drag limits.
personaly... I don't think that test was really much of a test
All you have shown is that a drag can handle speed.
Instead, start with 15ft of line at your feet. Allow the bike/ATV to speed away and pick the line off the ground and gain speed. Then as line is zipping put it to the reel.
on the video the line is tight and the reel is linked up so it sees the acceleration. with line at your fetl the drag will have to start from 0 to say 15mph, with now acceleratiopn but rather full force. i feel that would be a better test of what the drag could handle.
*no acceleration*
A good point, Ramcatt, but is the 15 feet of slack a test of the reel or the fisherman... I mean, should the slack be there in the first place?
it was more to test when the drag does have the acceleration crutch
start with 30' out the tip with the bike behind you
allow the bike to drive past you and then when 30' in front of rod the drag kicks in with no chance to "accelerate" the drag/line into the speed
this is when you are fishing will line at your feel and the fish bullets... screaming line through the guides til when the line gets tension... the fish is already moving and the drag has not been touched
Take the Rogue to the "David Letterman" show, hook it to a watermelon, and drop it off of the Ed Sullivan Theater, and hold on!
wow... i am no longer allowed to post with the blackberry
reads like the bestest 3rd grade book report
i think for one of the gear tests you do you should test the legibility of the ugly stik commercial, seeing if a rod could last a trash compactor.
Desperation has set in!
Power tools
All I know is that looks like fun, and I wish I had that in my job description.
If you want to test a reel tie your tippet to a wild rabbit and let it go. Try to reel that in.
If you want to test your rod give it to my son. If it's not broken at the end of the day then he didn't go fishing.
I will suggest testing your wading boots on West Virginia summer time rocks. I have experience none more slippery in the world.
Test your waders while walking the banks of the Colorado River. (I did so yesterday) The cactus and bushes there attack you at every angle with thorns and loose sharp rocks.
I'd like to see how all fly boxes hold up to a good drop in some whitewater.....all boxes must have the full gammit of flies, from dries to weighted buggers, and a small folded piece of paper in there with a name and phone number of the "owner". Send it 200 yards down stream and see how they and their contents fare. Then do a drop test on some rocks or other hard surfaces to see how each box holds up to a beating. This will simulate forces similar to the ones I exert on my boxes when I grab my vest by the scruff and toss it in the back of the car.
koldkut,
I like this. We'll have to work on a variation of this one...
Tim
Was walking through the local sportsmand warehouse in the Springs looking at the boxes and thought an old front load washing machine would work nicely for testing boxes...lol
If you really want to test a drag, hook it up to a front end loader and see what happens. If you hook it to the bucket and have the driver drive in reverse you can simulate a leaper as the bucket goes up and down.
Tie onto a decent Bonefish, and you will know.
Post a Comment