Please Sign In

Please enter a valid username and password
» Not a member? Take a moment to register
» Forgot Username or Password

Why Register?
Signing up could earn you gear (click here to learn how)! It also keeps offensive content off our site.

PrinterPrint EMail Email Share This Icon Share

Message Boards

Rate This Thread100%0%

Deer Hunting

Looking for the perfect rifle for hunting in Maine...help please

Uploaded on January 18, 2009

I am moving to Maine for college to pursue a career in Conservation Law Enforcement, and one of the benefits is that I get to hunt on the lands surrounding my campus for whitetail, bear, and moose. I am in the market for a rifle that would take down all 3 without a problem. I am currently considering the Marlin 1895 SBL in .45/70 or a Remington 700 in .30-06...Any suggestions are greatly appreciated!

Thanks to all that can give me some input!

Top Rated
All Replies
from Jim in Mo wrote 1 year 6 weeks ago

I have two 30-06s and they're dandy weapons but everything I've read about the hunting in Maine is that most shots are fairly close or at least in heavey cover. Th 45/70 sure would be nice. Aways wanted one especially ammo loaded stronger by specialist like Garrets or Superior for bear or moose. I imagine standard loadings would be more than enough for deer.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from stumpthumper wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

I've hunted moose and deer with the Marlin 1895 in .45/70. To me, that is the perfect rifle for Maine. Quick handling, easy to carry and shoot, with plenty of knock-down power. I think that's the perfect pick.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from Clay Cooper wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

As a former range master and avid shooter all the above I’ll put the Remington 700 in .30-06 out of the box against any other rifle hands down!

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from bigajvigs wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

If I handload with the 30-06 with 200 and 220 grain Sierra bullets will that suffice for my needs?

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from SBell wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

While your looking, you ought to check out a Remington 700, chambered in .308 ... like Clay said, I'll put a Remington 700 out of the box up against any other rifle out there. I have one and feel confident going up against any game in North America, using a bullet with the right weight for the job.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from summit229 wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

Jim, I would give the nod to the 45/70. The '06 or .308 would be fine for the whitetail and moose, but not ideal for blackbear because although they are quite capable of taking the bear, because of the bears thick fur the problem comes in TRACKING the bear----- big bullet = big hole = big bloodtrail.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Happy Myles wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

Writing with the full authority of complete ignorance on Maine Hunting, stick with the advice from Jim in Mo and Clay Cooper. Buy a Rem 700 in 30-06. When you are as old as we three are, you'll be hunting elsewhere besides Maine, and thank us after we are long gone.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from infantry08 wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

I'd opt for a rifle of your choice in .338 Winchester Magnum, or if you're recoil shy, a .338 Federal. The larger slugs are just more effective on moose and bears.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from AlaskanExile wrote 1 year 4 weeks ago

Either rifle would work just fine, but I would go with the 30-06 because it's good both near and far. A 180 grain bullet from any manufacturer (Core-Lokt, Silvertip, or anything else) would do just fine for moose or black bears. 220's would be outstanding too. Best of all, you don't have to handload, you can get ammo for the Springfield for less than $20 per box, there is surplus ammo available for less than that.
That hot-rodded 45-70 ammo is upwards of $50 per box, and absolutely no fun to practice with (ouch!). I have an 1895G guide gun and I've shot a lot of the Cor-Bon and Garrett, and Buffalo Bore stuff in it, but it's a religious experience for the shooter and any witnesses, let me tell you. Just go with the 30-06, six generations of riflemen can't all be wrong.
Alaskan Exile

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from AlaskanPride wrote 1 year 4 weeks ago

I totally agree with Happy Myles. When I purchase anything to do with firearms, I think of the long run. .30-06 will take any head of game in North America. I currently have a M70 in .30-06 for moose up here in Alaska. My buddy also has taken black bear without a hiccup. Trust me, anything you shoot down in Maine, you can count on it being bigger in Alaska! Just be smart on your bullet choice.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from greenmtboy1965 wrote 50 weeks 5 days ago

personaly id get the 1895g 45-70 with the xs sight's and forward mounted scout scope, thats what I use in vt, it will take anything down and i do mean anything !!!

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from shane wrote 50 weeks 1 day ago

Big bore Marlins are classic and perfect for Maine.

Take a look at their MXLR series too, They chamber them in 45-70, as well as their new .338MXLR, which could prove to be useful and versatile in Maine and beyond.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from max wrote 50 weeks 21 hours ago

I live in New Brunswick just a little east of the state of Maine and have about the same type of forests. I think a 270 in any manufacturer would do. It really depends on what type of hunting you like to do. Some people like sitting in a tree or blind with a shooting field of 200 to 350 yds. Some like driving around to find deer in fields or on the road(cadillac hunting) Personally I like and have had some luck right in the bush still hunting or creeping around slowly. Never the less a 270 is not heavy or too long for the brush and has good killing power under 400yds. My opinion a good all purpose weapon

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Clay Cooper wrote 49 weeks 6 days ago

From Varmints to Moose, I have never in my life have seen a Remington 700 in 30-06 let anyone down, except for a couple of poor sportsman (IDIOTS THEY ARE)!

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Stephen D. Rexrode wrote 4 weeks 6 days ago

Check out the Tikka T 3 Lite in 300 WSM or .338 Federal. I have both and they are great shooters and excellent cartridges for the animals you want to hunt.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from steve182 wrote 4 weeks 6 days ago

The time tested .30-06 would be my choice

0 Good Comment? | | Report

Post a Reply

from Jim in Mo wrote 1 year 6 weeks ago

I have two 30-06s and they're dandy weapons but everything I've read about the hunting in Maine is that most shots are fairly close or at least in heavey cover. Th 45/70 sure would be nice. Aways wanted one especially ammo loaded stronger by specialist like Garrets or Superior for bear or moose. I imagine standard loadings would be more than enough for deer.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from stumpthumper wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

I've hunted moose and deer with the Marlin 1895 in .45/70. To me, that is the perfect rifle for Maine. Quick handling, easy to carry and shoot, with plenty of knock-down power. I think that's the perfect pick.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from Clay Cooper wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

As a former range master and avid shooter all the above I’ll put the Remington 700 in .30-06 out of the box against any other rifle hands down!

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from Stephen D. Rexrode wrote 4 weeks 6 days ago

Check out the Tikka T 3 Lite in 300 WSM or .338 Federal. I have both and they are great shooters and excellent cartridges for the animals you want to hunt.

+1 Good Comment? | | Report
from bigajvigs wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

If I handload with the 30-06 with 200 and 220 grain Sierra bullets will that suffice for my needs?

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from SBell wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

While your looking, you ought to check out a Remington 700, chambered in .308 ... like Clay said, I'll put a Remington 700 out of the box up against any other rifle out there. I have one and feel confident going up against any game in North America, using a bullet with the right weight for the job.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from summit229 wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

Jim, I would give the nod to the 45/70. The '06 or .308 would be fine for the whitetail and moose, but not ideal for blackbear because although they are quite capable of taking the bear, because of the bears thick fur the problem comes in TRACKING the bear----- big bullet = big hole = big bloodtrail.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Happy Myles wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

Writing with the full authority of complete ignorance on Maine Hunting, stick with the advice from Jim in Mo and Clay Cooper. Buy a Rem 700 in 30-06. When you are as old as we three are, you'll be hunting elsewhere besides Maine, and thank us after we are long gone.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from infantry08 wrote 1 year 5 weeks ago

I'd opt for a rifle of your choice in .338 Winchester Magnum, or if you're recoil shy, a .338 Federal. The larger slugs are just more effective on moose and bears.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from AlaskanExile wrote 1 year 4 weeks ago

Either rifle would work just fine, but I would go with the 30-06 because it's good both near and far. A 180 grain bullet from any manufacturer (Core-Lokt, Silvertip, or anything else) would do just fine for moose or black bears. 220's would be outstanding too. Best of all, you don't have to handload, you can get ammo for the Springfield for less than $20 per box, there is surplus ammo available for less than that.
That hot-rodded 45-70 ammo is upwards of $50 per box, and absolutely no fun to practice with (ouch!). I have an 1895G guide gun and I've shot a lot of the Cor-Bon and Garrett, and Buffalo Bore stuff in it, but it's a religious experience for the shooter and any witnesses, let me tell you. Just go with the 30-06, six generations of riflemen can't all be wrong.
Alaskan Exile

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from AlaskanPride wrote 1 year 4 weeks ago

I totally agree with Happy Myles. When I purchase anything to do with firearms, I think of the long run. .30-06 will take any head of game in North America. I currently have a M70 in .30-06 for moose up here in Alaska. My buddy also has taken black bear without a hiccup. Trust me, anything you shoot down in Maine, you can count on it being bigger in Alaska! Just be smart on your bullet choice.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from greenmtboy1965 wrote 50 weeks 5 days ago

personaly id get the 1895g 45-70 with the xs sight's and forward mounted scout scope, thats what I use in vt, it will take anything down and i do mean anything !!!

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from shane wrote 50 weeks 1 day ago

Big bore Marlins are classic and perfect for Maine.

Take a look at their MXLR series too, They chamber them in 45-70, as well as their new .338MXLR, which could prove to be useful and versatile in Maine and beyond.

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from max wrote 50 weeks 21 hours ago

I live in New Brunswick just a little east of the state of Maine and have about the same type of forests. I think a 270 in any manufacturer would do. It really depends on what type of hunting you like to do. Some people like sitting in a tree or blind with a shooting field of 200 to 350 yds. Some like driving around to find deer in fields or on the road(cadillac hunting) Personally I like and have had some luck right in the bush still hunting or creeping around slowly. Never the less a 270 is not heavy or too long for the brush and has good killing power under 400yds. My opinion a good all purpose weapon

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from Clay Cooper wrote 49 weeks 6 days ago

From Varmints to Moose, I have never in my life have seen a Remington 700 in 30-06 let anyone down, except for a couple of poor sportsman (IDIOTS THEY ARE)!

0 Good Comment? | | Report
from steve182 wrote 4 weeks 6 days ago

The time tested .30-06 would be my choice

0 Good Comment? | | Report

Post a Reply