


November 04, 2008
Special Report: The "Field & Stream Buck" Falls
Special Report by Field & Stream Senior Editor Colin Kearns
On September 4, we posted a video on our Whitetail 365 blog of a monster buck walking around unfenced property in Buffalo County, Wisconsin, that many hunters and deer experts speculated could be a new typical world record. Now, two months later, we have more images of the deer—courtesy of Bob Decker, the Wisconsin bowhunter who shot the deer on November 1.

Decker had been in a tree stand for more than three hours, seeing nothing, before he heard a twig snap below him. There, 40 yards away and coming closer, was a big buck. At the time, Decker only knew the deer was plenty big enough to shoot, so when the deer was 6 or 7 yards below, he released his arrow. The buck ran for 50 yards and dropped.
It wasn’t until Decker and his hunting buddy Paul Olson approached the deer that they realized just how big it was. As soon as they saw the buck, Olson started shouting that Decker had killed “the Field & Stream buck!”
F&S contributing editor Scott Bestul, who reported on the buck in the November issue of F&S, has not seen the actual rack, but based on the photos, he said he is almost certain that the buck Decker shot is the same from the video. However, Bestul believes the deer is not a world record and will be scored as a non-typical.
Decker said a score has not been released and added that it will be a close call on whether his buck will be scored typical or non-typical. “I’ve heard people say it could either way,” says Decker. “It’ll just be a judgment call. I have mixed feelings about [its potential as a world record]. I’d love it if it was the record. But if it’s not, maybe I can quietly ride off into the sunset and get out of the spotlight. Either way, I’m proud to have taken the deer.”
What do you think: World record or not? Typical or non-typical? And keep checking whitetail365.com for the latest on this story.
Comments (134)
As alongtime freind of Bob Decker I just learned that the buck was scored non-typical. I saw the buck first hand and can only say this, "Thousands of hunters like myself hit the woods every year in Wisconsin after the elusive trophy whitetail. You've broken the state record and I couldn't be more proud. You're the top seed among many great hunters and fallen trophys,something you can treasure forever. Congradulations Bob!"
i think it is typical and it probley ant the world record but its a nice buck
and im sure that it was not hand feed even if it was ohh well he still killed it theres nothing wrong with feeding deer i do that i think it is a good kill with a bow good joe
that was the buck because i looked at it over a houndred times good job killing it
that is unbelievable sir. That buck read the script but wasnt planning on showing up anytime early. better late than never ofcourse
it's not truly amazing to shoot a buck like that with a bow when there hand fed.
wow what an amazing buck. i've seen a lot of monsters harvested from people and a lot of tv hunts and none of them come close to this beast. this buck is going to score big as a typical or non-typical. and to take it with a bow that is truly amazing.
wow congrats to begin with i've seen a lot of big bucks people have harvested and also a lot of tv hunts and i have never seen such a monster whitetail.
Will Barhnes needs to grow up and shouldn't even talk. Its all jealousy.
In the northwest you are lucky to get a 5-by-5 with a good spreadcongrats
Unbelievable. Not too many like that in Central New Jersey.
Wow too bad all the big bass are down south and all the big bucks are in Wisconsin so we get to hit them with our cars. Don't get me wrong, big deer are great, but if deer and fish were spread out, everyone would get a better chance of a trophy buck or bass. Spread those genes!!!!!
I don't have words to think of! but my 8 year old son says "that is cool wow dad"
Thats A great Buck we would like to post the pictures on our website our website is listed belowwww.dnoadventures.webs.com
thats a sucky buck i shot a fawn last year and it weighed 340 pounds it weighed more than a buffalowhen i shot it it started squecking then i took a dump on its head beat that
theres no need for you to hunt anymore
How big was the bait pile?
I heard that from Dodge and read the article with that posting in it also. All you people talking about bottling up the genes, ha ha ha. More then 50% of the genes come from the doe. Yall need to do sum more research before you just sit at the computer and start typing away.
"The deer, a 16 point, 3 1/2 year old buck that was reported to weigh 200 pounds after field dressing, was measured by Jack Dodge of Dodge’s Taxidermy in Elk Lake. Dodge declined to reveal the score noting that it would definately score over 200 inches."
wow nice buck,good shot with the bow how did you keep the peep on him.
Nice Buck. But it is not even close to the nontypical or typical record that F&S hoped when they first showed the video. There are too many deductions for a typical score and it would be lucky to fall into the 170 range. There are not enough nontypical points to have it score even 270.
i heard they planted a big one from a deer farm with a monster rack and that there is soposet to be three of them up there that size.
i dont think its the same deer as the 365 because the top parts of the tines curve inward more than the 365 buck and i have also herd that there was another sighting in the about the same area as before so sorry not the same deer but nice one though
Ha Ha Ha. So Jim, your telling me that there was two possible "WORLD RECORD" deer miles apart from each other. Dought it buddy. Stay off the refer.
beagle,I said the same thing and people said I was wrong. I still think thats a different deer than the video. Tines don't disappear or get shorter. He's still out there.
i dont think the pictures do the buck justice, if it is the same buck as in the video. i would have to say it looks much larger in the video. but maybe that is because the video was taken from 400 yards
WOW !!! great buck! we have lots of big bucks here in Tx but i have yet to see 1 that big !the score ? who cares! the age ? who cares ! if i see a buck with spots on it & a rack like that im shootin !!!!congrats on a 1/10000000 buck!
WOW!! GREAT JOB!!
Very nice deer !!!!! I did not get out this year to bow hunt (no time)wish I had,and hay Trent read dont just look at the pictures.
Very nice. im glad it was taken with a bow from very close range and not with a rifle from 600 yds away. it just makes it that much better.
Passing the smaller bucks. That's what its all about. I see deer camps near ours proudly displaying year and a half deer all the time. It hurts my heart unless its some kid that is maybe taking his first.'We all gotta let em grow up.I learned from a good friend who only killed big bucks that you have to wait for the big one. I just thought I only saw small ones.Anyway, congrats and glad to see an archer (a real deer hunter) and a local boy score well.Shoot straight!
Holy Deer Thats a Monster that will look nice in the record books!!!
Holy Deer Thats a Monster that will look nice in the record books!!!
I've lived in buffalo county for over 30yrs I remember just asking the farmer to hunt and they would say go ahead. I'm just an average person living here I don't have 10 G's for a 3day hunt I'd like to see a disease hit buffalo county and have to eradicate the deer just like down below. It would lower taxes and everything else. It's cheaper to go hunting in a different state than in your own county!
Bob, great deer. Only a dream to some of us poor country boys from NC. What do you guys feed em' up there? Congrats on your trophy buck!
well Joe, the guy that is doing the mount has had dozen of people coming and looking at this deer. Aging it, scoring it. It was aged at 3 1/2 by everyone of them. So its just like saying a fawn is 3 1/2 when he said the deer is 6 1/2. Thats to funny. There was another big buck killed Nov 6th at the same place as this one and they said that one might be the one they have been watching for the last 3yrs. Both bucks look the same but the 18pts body is way bigger then this 16pt. I hope like heck this buck will be a world record so know one can hunt in b/c for less then 10 g's. All the people paying for hunts made it this way.
Wizbang, very funny comment! You'll have to go to Heckel's Big Steer (Eau Claire area restaurant chain for those of you not familiar with the area) to eat. I'd have to say the Decker Buck is more than the deer of a lifetime - more like THE DEER OF MILLIONS OF LIFETIMES due to it being bigger than almost every deer ever shot with archery gear. Kudos to you Mr. Decker!!!
The video was shot by Buffalo County Outfitters on an "unfenced" property, more than likely they posted it to drum up business.
I live in Minnesota, and im only 15 but if you ask me that is a buck of a lifetime. I am actually good friends with Scott Bestul and i have to say that it doesnt matter whether or not its a record. Great job on executing the shot Decker.
Great buck and congratulations. We don't get them that big here in North Carolina so if I ever saw and was fortunate enough to kill one that big, I'd probably keel over from a heart attack and it'd take the undertaker 3 days just to wipe the big silly grin off my face! Whether its a world record or not is immaterial, that's one great deer by anyone's standards.
I hunt near Buffalo county. Now I'm going to have to contend with prick TV hosts and big-name idiots eating all the broasted chicken out of my favorite bar. What does hunting mean again?
'ha ha ha'....you are a douche, i don't know where you come up with the comment directed toward Smith. He is going off of sightings of the deer and other info that i'm guessing indicate that people have seen the deer for a few years now...i don't know what you are talking about with the whole fawn being 3-1/2 comment.But all of the criticism aside, AWESOME DEER!! We don't get em quite that big in North Dakota.
Way to stay composed and bury the shot. As Tiffany Lakosky would say "BIG BUCK DOWN" Congrats. Wisconsin is where its at.
does anyone know what the deer scored?
I agree with Decker the sooner he is out of the spotlight the better. Leave the guy to enjoy a job well done,and a unbelieveable hunt anyone would want.
wow...why must there be so much contraversy.its a shame what this sport and deer hunting has become...
great deer! kinda looks as though the deer in the video is still in velvet, this would make it look like a different animal, anyway, great job, should have it posed with the RACKS calendar.
Wow! thats a big deer nice job
FRICKIN SMOKE EM, BIG OR SMALL I KILL EM ALL
The deer was aged at 3 1/2 not 6 1/2 nor 4 1/2. So smith if someone shoots a fawn your going to say its 3 1/2?????
For the people that are saying this is not the same deer on Whitetail 365, you must be looking at a different deer. It is the same deer.Based on putting some of the information and dates of sightings, the deer was likely 6 1/2 years old. If the deer was 3 1/2 years old as others stated, then yes we should bottle up some of the genetics of this giant.
Lawman, the significance of unfenced property is that this is not a game farm. The deer was shot legally on private land.
Brian Demenge wrote "Nice deer, but I want to know why the guy that got the footage of it would broadcast it. Think you would want to keep that secret to yourself."Not if you are an outfitter that wants to market their product. Buffalo County Outfitters has purchased and leased so much of the hunting land in Buffalo County that they have made it pretty much impossible for the average person to hunt there, unless you were a landowner 20 years ago.
how can I get a lucky horse like this guy???? congrats on a nice buck bud.....
hey im caden im 16 and im from MN and ive only got a big 9 point buck but i wish it was as big as that one. nice one
Who cares whether it's a typical or non-typical rack? It's gorgeous, as is the rest of the buck! My prayer is, he bred lots of does before he went to the spirit world. Just to see one like him is a huge thrill. What wonderful luck! Congratulations!
great whitetail by any standards bob,closer the shot better the hunter!congrats on your trophy
Great buck and are more around the area..lived around the Mondovi area all my life..we are blessed!!!!!!!!!
I absolutely love the fact that this deer was taken at 6 or 7 yards with a bow... what a thrill what an experience what a buck!!! Who cares what it scores? Congratulations Mr. Decker. Hang that bad boy on your wall and start charging admission.
Congratulations!! I was wondering how long it would take someone to take that deer. Very nice and who really cares if its typical or non, its just an awesome deer and to have taken it with a bow makes it even more awesome!!
did u shoot on public land or private?
Congratulations, Record or not thats a nice buck.
Has anyone thought about asking Mr. Decker about getting a DNA sampling from his monster deer for future reference?
This buck is huge, just absolutely gigantic. The G-4's or G-5's are almost a foot long! This is not only a buck of a lifetime, but THE buck of a lifetime, and Bob Decker deserves applause for being able to even draw his bow back on the giant. Congrats, Mr. Decker.
Nice Job!! I saw that video in my wildlife class at school, i just about crapped my pants! NICE!!
What's the significance of "unfenced" property in Wisconsin? Where I come from, unless it is public land, legally leased land private land, or private land hunted by permission - just hunting "unfenced" property without permission would still be poaching and the deer would not be legal.
Great deer dont see many of those in the south.When will we know what he scores?I wish we could bring the record back to the states where it belongs!
thats an amazing buck any way you put it... truly a once in a lifetime experience...I believe it should go non-typical, but like everyone else here, i dont think it should matter...How much did it weigh?
Doesn't matter if it's a world record, typical or non typical. It's a superb creature that gave Mr. Decker a once in a lifetime experience he will never, ever forget. Congratulations!
Jeez! It would be a world record type experience just to have seen this behemoth. How much did it weigh, and how many points?
I BET NO BRAIN BRIAN VOTED FOR OBAMA
I eat those things for breakfast! Yumm.
I'm not a hunter. I'm not a tree hugger or pita person either. But my initial thought was the same as Brian and Drew's. Doesn't the animal world rely on survival of the fittest? If you kill the top dogs then you'll be left with the dregs of the world.
WOW!!!!! Thats what dreams are made of! From the footage provided, it appears to be the same buck. I'd like to know the distance from where the film footage was taken and the site harvested. What a deer!!!
thats the same buck no doubt. congrats. i'd be happy with 150 here in va.
What a beast!! I really hope this does turn out to be a world record because i am from Wisconsin and that would be awesome to have a world record buck taken in our state. Congrats on the tank!!
What a buck. My buddies and I all were watching the video on youtube with our shop teacher and then the next day we found out you shot that beast... Way to go!!! Thats what I call a TRUE WISCONSIN WHITETAIL!
This comes from the taxidermist that is doing the mount, as of right now the buck will be scored as a typical 7X7 even though its an 8X8. The choice of it being scored as a typical was by the B&C. Hunting should be fun for all not just for some score. The score just adds a little axtra to it. I feel you should never have to pay to hunt a deer and if you do you should be able to shoot whatever you want to shoot.
Holy @#%^#$ ^%$&(&^% #$%^ I wet my pants lokkin at the photos. I'm really curious how it scores!!!!?
excellent job man your fellow bow hunters can only wish to someday take an awesome animal like that.Record or not no one can EVER take away that moment.Again awesome job. How long of a drag did you have? Not long I hope he's a monster
You're gonna end up scoring it non typical only because of the deductions. It'll still be very high no matter what.
It clearly IS the F&S buck. I don't know how anyone could say otherwise.
Beautiful- not even the word Awesome is good enough. Just imagine the feeling he had! Truly priceless!! I bet he said " Yeeesssssss"!! Continue on in your love of this sport, enjoy the stories with your kids, enjoy the stories with your friends.It would have been bitter sweet to say he shot it in Wisconsin rather than Buffalo CO. But all i can say is, i wish i were able to experience the afternoon he had...i would love the experience just to sit day in day out in the woods from there on out!Great Memory for you Bill!!
Fantastic deer but I just watched the video again and I don't think this is the F&S buck.
Great buck!! NOT a record, will be scored a non-T. the junk will add up. again super buck.
Bob Decker,Play it smart and don't tell anyone what brand bow, arrows, or anything you were using. Endorsments goes to highest bidder. You deserve it so take it while the takins good.
Always hard to score deer, especially from a photo, best guess is that this Monster will score as a 12, at best, probably a 10, and thats if the G1-G5s arent consideder points off of other vertical points, best way to have a better idea is print off the P& Y score sheet and see how a buck is actually scored. Symetry is the key to typical and I dont think this has it. Thats why taking a 200" plus buck bow or gun is like winning the lottery.
Just Wondering --- I read that the taxidermist that capped it out aged it at 3 1/2 year old.My 187 buck from last year was also a 3 1/2 year old; otherwise I would not believe it.Andrew --- If you ask me it’s the 365 blog buck.
Great job Bob, I know how it feels. I shot a 187 buck last year in St. Croix County. The Buffalo County genetics are finally spreading our way.
Not the same deer as the 365 blog. Good kill though. Records mean nothing. It's memories that matter.
What do you think the age of the buck was ? To me I would be amazed how he lived and dodge hunters for all this time.
holy cow is that a fricken monster!great job man thats a once and a lifetime buck rite there!!!!!!i hope it hits the records. that would look nice in there....
holy cow is that a fricken monstergreat job man!!! thats a nice 1
Congrats on the huge trophy! Long distance = Target PracticingShooting 7 yards...now that's hunting!!!To comment on Brian's post, I think/hope what Brian was trying to say is that there is only a small percentage of deer that have the genes to actually get that big. Imagine if this buck would've been passed-up and could've spread more of those "huge buck genes" on down the line. In a lot of respect, hunters have it all backwards. We take the biggest and healthiest, thus making the remaining heards weaker and smaller.Before I get criticized too heavily, let me also say that I am just as guilty of this as any...
I'd take it if it had that much horn growing out of its rump. Nontypical or not-ya'll put too much heed into scoring these days.
Wow! MAke sure that one is secured to the wall! No broken antlers, looks pretty perfect to me! Wonder if he stopped shaken yet. Great job!
well played out Bob.... once in a life time buck right there
Ya, Brian. I guess that big buck deserves ta be eaten alive by coyotes, or slowly killed by disease or starvation rather than being immortalized by that proud hunter. Much more dignified...
what is brian thinking is all i got to say!
Thats quite an accomplishment for any hunter congrats Mr. Decker and send some giants like that over my way please..... p.s. have fun with all the endorsement opportunities with that deer i wish i was in your shoes
Brian should stick to video games and leave hunting to the people who know what they are talking about but any ways you make me proud to be a bowhunter in wisconsin.
Brian should stick to video games and leave hunting to the people who know what they are talking about but any ways you make me proud to be a bowhunter in wisconsin.
great job that guy who said let it live never seen a true monster you are very lucky great job.
Great shot sure makes me miss the badger state. Hope to see more Pic's of that one in a million deer
THATS THE REASON I GO TO THE WOODS EVERY CHANCE I GET.GREAT JOB!!!!!!!
I can't believe that Brian guy. "deserves to live" what is that all about. What a magnificent Wisconsin deer. Glad one of our residents shot a big one once. Maybe it's time to bring the world record back to Wisconsin to join it's place with the Jordan buck. Excellent job!!!
Qhote from Brian "I love hunting, but a buck that big deserves to live" So your saying that you would pass it up? I don't get it...anyway that deer is huge...congrats
AWESOME! Congrats Mr Decker! I have to agree with the other poster who was happy this deer went to a true local hunter. I hear that Decker has been hunting this land since long before the video was posted online. He grew up hunting in Wisconsin and didn't buy his way to this deer. It would have been a shame if someone from outside had flown in and paid big money to shoot down this animal on a drive. Nope. This was the way it should be. One man with a bow, relying on his own skill and determination, making a clean and ethical kill. Whether it's a world record or not, it's a once-in-a-lifetime experience.
Absolutely amazing to be done with a bow!
As a native Wisconsinite and being that I grew up close to Mondovi and Buffalo County, all I can say is thank goodness a local true hunter was the one to take this deer as opposed to an out of stater who pays $4800 to spend 4 days in a stand on a ranch. The boom in popularity of this region for deer hunting has made it near impossible for many average people to even think of taking a deer like this. Congratulations Mr. Decker!
I love hunting, but a buck that big deserves to live.
It may be a record, i dont have time to try to score it right now. The important thing is that this is a trophy that seems to have been taken in non-shady circumstances by a legit hunter. I hope this turns out to be true, as many large deer killed each year have very suspicious stories to go along with them. As for how it will be scored, I think it shold be scored as a typical, but it is definitely close. My personal opinion is that all deer should be officially scored as total gross antler (gross non-typical) because this is the only thing that truly measures how much antler there is. Regardless, this is an enormous deer. Congratulations to the hunter.
I've seen bigger in my backyard.
Nice work! Wow! Awesome! Amazing! Jaw Dropping! Not sure if those words do it justice. Love the new pictures here on F & S. The local paper in Eau Claire showed only one photo on Monday and it wasn't nearly as nice as these. The hardest part for me would be knowing that I will never probably have a chance like that again........still have to dig deep and find the grit to put all that preseason work and those early mornings to the woods. I agree....that is what Wisconsin Whitetail Hunters dream about at night!!
Way to go! Glad to see someone local get him, especially with the bow! What a dream come true. Way to go Bob!!
Can I get a shout out for Quality Deer Management?! Buffalo County has proven again why it works. Let the little ones go and let em grow!!!! Nice job!!-Wisconsin Northwoods
That's amazing - especially to get him at bow range. Like everyone else, I wouldn't care if it was a world-record or not. If I took that one, I'd almost be tempted to stop hunting after that - almost.
If I was graced by the Lord enough to shoot a deer like that, I wouldn't care if it was a world record or not. I would be shaking to bad to even fill out the paperwork. Congratulations on a awesome trophy.
Bob that is truly a beautiful WISCONSIN White-Tailed Deer. Being from Wisconsin myself, I can surely appreciate what you've done. I spend everyday in tree stand during the season when I'm not working. I know how 3 hours can feel when you see nothing, and then all of sudden the woods comes alive. You have made us Wisconsinites proud.
I could care less of boone and crockett or pope and young !!! That deer is what white tailed deer hunting in Wisconsin is all about!!!!!!!!
Nice deer, but I want to know why the guy that got the footage of it would broadcast it. Think you would want to keep that secret to yourself. But oh well, nice deer!
HE WONT GET ANOTHER LIKE THAT AGAIN! GREAT SHOT - BOW HUNTERSARE ALWAYS UP CLOSE !!
hey billie bryson, this is wisconsin. There are no blacktails in wisconsin. Blacktails live in the Northwest. jeez.
what a sweet deer, i cannot wait until shot gun season to take a good buck good job man
No need to have any doubt you arrowed A world class whitetail world record or not........
I think it looks like a couple tines fork at the beam, so non-typical is my guess, but agian like everyone is saying who cares it's a buck of a lifetime! Good job. I would like to know if it was a paid hunt or if it was just a landowner, or owner friend. ?
I"ll bet it goes non typical but who cares about score when u have killed a True Monarch by ANYONE'S standards
nice. record or no record thats big.
very nice buck, thats the time not to miss haha
is that there a whitetailed buck or a black tailed? how many points?
wish we could get a few more pics,Great job!
Well done. Nice shot.
Nice shot, this is a once in a lifetime buck,put yourself in this man's boots,could you make that shot,that is why to much bow practice is never enough,be thankful for this magical time of year,god bless the u.s.ak.w hurley wi.
who really cares typical or non-typical. record or not its a once in a lifetime buck and I believe that you should be thankful to take a deer like that.
Post a Comment
As alongtime freind of Bob Decker I just learned that the buck was scored non-typical. I saw the buck first hand and can only say this, "Thousands of hunters like myself hit the woods every year in Wisconsin after the elusive trophy whitetail. You've broken the state record and I couldn't be more proud. You're the top seed among many great hunters and fallen trophys,something you can treasure forever. Congradulations Bob!"
i think it is typical and it probley ant the world record but its a nice buck
and im sure that it was not hand feed even if it was ohh well he still killed it theres nothing wrong with feeding deer i do that i think it is a good kill with a bow good joe
that was the buck because i looked at it over a houndred times good job killing it
that is unbelievable sir. That buck read the script but wasnt planning on showing up anytime early. better late than never ofcourse
wow what an amazing buck. i've seen a lot of monsters harvested from people and a lot of tv hunts and none of them come close to this beast. this buck is going to score big as a typical or non-typical. and to take it with a bow that is truly amazing.
wow congrats to begin with i've seen a lot of big bucks people have harvested and also a lot of tv hunts and i have never seen such a monster whitetail.
Will Barhnes needs to grow up and shouldn't even talk. Its all jealousy.
In the northwest you are lucky to get a 5-by-5 with a good spreadcongrats
Unbelievable. Not too many like that in Central New Jersey.
Wow too bad all the big bass are down south and all the big bucks are in Wisconsin so we get to hit them with our cars. Don't get me wrong, big deer are great, but if deer and fish were spread out, everyone would get a better chance of a trophy buck or bass. Spread those genes!!!!!
I don't have words to think of! but my 8 year old son says "that is cool wow dad"
Thats A great Buck we would like to post the pictures on our website our website is listed belowwww.dnoadventures.webs.com
theres no need for you to hunt anymore
How big was the bait pile?
I heard that from Dodge and read the article with that posting in it also. All you people talking about bottling up the genes, ha ha ha. More then 50% of the genes come from the doe. Yall need to do sum more research before you just sit at the computer and start typing away.
"The deer, a 16 point, 3 1/2 year old buck that was reported to weigh 200 pounds after field dressing, was measured by Jack Dodge of Dodge’s Taxidermy in Elk Lake. Dodge declined to reveal the score noting that it would definately score over 200 inches."
wow nice buck,good shot with the bow how did you keep the peep on him.
Nice Buck. But it is not even close to the nontypical or typical record that F&S hoped when they first showed the video. There are too many deductions for a typical score and it would be lucky to fall into the 170 range. There are not enough nontypical points to have it score even 270.
i heard they planted a big one from a deer farm with a monster rack and that there is soposet to be three of them up there that size.
i dont think its the same deer as the 365 because the top parts of the tines curve inward more than the 365 buck and i have also herd that there was another sighting in the about the same area as before so sorry not the same deer but nice one though
Ha Ha Ha. So Jim, your telling me that there was two possible "WORLD RECORD" deer miles apart from each other. Dought it buddy. Stay off the refer.
beagle,I said the same thing and people said I was wrong. I still think thats a different deer than the video. Tines don't disappear or get shorter. He's still out there.
i dont think the pictures do the buck justice, if it is the same buck as in the video. i would have to say it looks much larger in the video. but maybe that is because the video was taken from 400 yards
WOW !!! great buck! we have lots of big bucks here in Tx but i have yet to see 1 that big !the score ? who cares! the age ? who cares ! if i see a buck with spots on it & a rack like that im shootin !!!!congrats on a 1/10000000 buck!
WOW!! GREAT JOB!!
Very nice deer !!!!! I did not get out this year to bow hunt (no time)wish I had,and hay Trent read dont just look at the pictures.
Very nice. im glad it was taken with a bow from very close range and not with a rifle from 600 yds away. it just makes it that much better.
Passing the smaller bucks. That's what its all about. I see deer camps near ours proudly displaying year and a half deer all the time. It hurts my heart unless its some kid that is maybe taking his first.'We all gotta let em grow up.I learned from a good friend who only killed big bucks that you have to wait for the big one. I just thought I only saw small ones.Anyway, congrats and glad to see an archer (a real deer hunter) and a local boy score well.Shoot straight!
Holy Deer Thats a Monster that will look nice in the record books!!!
Holy Deer Thats a Monster that will look nice in the record books!!!
I've lived in buffalo county for over 30yrs I remember just asking the farmer to hunt and they would say go ahead. I'm just an average person living here I don't have 10 G's for a 3day hunt I'd like to see a disease hit buffalo county and have to eradicate the deer just like down below. It would lower taxes and everything else. It's cheaper to go hunting in a different state than in your own county!
Bob, great deer. Only a dream to some of us poor country boys from NC. What do you guys feed em' up there? Congrats on your trophy buck!
well Joe, the guy that is doing the mount has had dozen of people coming and looking at this deer. Aging it, scoring it. It was aged at 3 1/2 by everyone of them. So its just like saying a fawn is 3 1/2 when he said the deer is 6 1/2. Thats to funny. There was another big buck killed Nov 6th at the same place as this one and they said that one might be the one they have been watching for the last 3yrs. Both bucks look the same but the 18pts body is way bigger then this 16pt. I hope like heck this buck will be a world record so know one can hunt in b/c for less then 10 g's. All the people paying for hunts made it this way.
Wizbang, very funny comment! You'll have to go to Heckel's Big Steer (Eau Claire area restaurant chain for those of you not familiar with the area) to eat. I'd have to say the Decker Buck is more than the deer of a lifetime - more like THE DEER OF MILLIONS OF LIFETIMES due to it being bigger than almost every deer ever shot with archery gear. Kudos to you Mr. Decker!!!
The video was shot by Buffalo County Outfitters on an "unfenced" property, more than likely they posted it to drum up business.
I live in Minnesota, and im only 15 but if you ask me that is a buck of a lifetime. I am actually good friends with Scott Bestul and i have to say that it doesnt matter whether or not its a record. Great job on executing the shot Decker.
Great buck and congratulations. We don't get them that big here in North Carolina so if I ever saw and was fortunate enough to kill one that big, I'd probably keel over from a heart attack and it'd take the undertaker 3 days just to wipe the big silly grin off my face! Whether its a world record or not is immaterial, that's one great deer by anyone's standards.
I hunt near Buffalo county. Now I'm going to have to contend with prick TV hosts and big-name idiots eating all the broasted chicken out of my favorite bar. What does hunting mean again?
'ha ha ha'....you are a douche, i don't know where you come up with the comment directed toward Smith. He is going off of sightings of the deer and other info that i'm guessing indicate that people have seen the deer for a few years now...i don't know what you are talking about with the whole fawn being 3-1/2 comment.But all of the criticism aside, AWESOME DEER!! We don't get em quite that big in North Dakota.
Way to stay composed and bury the shot. As Tiffany Lakosky would say "BIG BUCK DOWN" Congrats. Wisconsin is where its at.
does anyone know what the deer scored?
I agree with Decker the sooner he is out of the spotlight the better. Leave the guy to enjoy a job well done,and a unbelieveable hunt anyone would want.
wow...why must there be so much contraversy.its a shame what this sport and deer hunting has become...
great deer! kinda looks as though the deer in the video is still in velvet, this would make it look like a different animal, anyway, great job, should have it posed with the RACKS calendar.
Wow! thats a big deer nice job
FRICKIN SMOKE EM, BIG OR SMALL I KILL EM ALL
The deer was aged at 3 1/2 not 6 1/2 nor 4 1/2. So smith if someone shoots a fawn your going to say its 3 1/2?????
For the people that are saying this is not the same deer on Whitetail 365, you must be looking at a different deer. It is the same deer.Based on putting some of the information and dates of sightings, the deer was likely 6 1/2 years old. If the deer was 3 1/2 years old as others stated, then yes we should bottle up some of the genetics of this giant.
Lawman, the significance of unfenced property is that this is not a game farm. The deer was shot legally on private land.
Brian Demenge wrote "Nice deer, but I want to know why the guy that got the footage of it would broadcast it. Think you would want to keep that secret to yourself."Not if you are an outfitter that wants to market their product. Buffalo County Outfitters has purchased and leased so much of the hunting land in Buffalo County that they have made it pretty much impossible for the average person to hunt there, unless you were a landowner 20 years ago.
how can I get a lucky horse like this guy???? congrats on a nice buck bud.....
hey im caden im 16 and im from MN and ive only got a big 9 point buck but i wish it was as big as that one. nice one
Who cares whether it's a typical or non-typical rack? It's gorgeous, as is the rest of the buck! My prayer is, he bred lots of does before he went to the spirit world. Just to see one like him is a huge thrill. What wonderful luck! Congratulations!
great whitetail by any standards bob,closer the shot better the hunter!congrats on your trophy
Great buck and are more around the area..lived around the Mondovi area all my life..we are blessed!!!!!!!!!
I absolutely love the fact that this deer was taken at 6 or 7 yards with a bow... what a thrill what an experience what a buck!!! Who cares what it scores? Congratulations Mr. Decker. Hang that bad boy on your wall and start charging admission.
Congratulations!! I was wondering how long it would take someone to take that deer. Very nice and who really cares if its typical or non, its just an awesome deer and to have taken it with a bow makes it even more awesome!!
did u shoot on public land or private?
Congratulations, Record or not thats a nice buck.
Has anyone thought about asking Mr. Decker about getting a DNA sampling from his monster deer for future reference?
This buck is huge, just absolutely gigantic. The G-4's or G-5's are almost a foot long! This is not only a buck of a lifetime, but THE buck of a lifetime, and Bob Decker deserves applause for being able to even draw his bow back on the giant. Congrats, Mr. Decker.
Nice Job!! I saw that video in my wildlife class at school, i just about crapped my pants! NICE!!
What's the significance of "unfenced" property in Wisconsin? Where I come from, unless it is public land, legally leased land private land, or private land hunted by permission - just hunting "unfenced" property without permission would still be poaching and the deer would not be legal.
Great deer dont see many of those in the south.When will we know what he scores?I wish we could bring the record back to the states where it belongs!
thats an amazing buck any way you put it... truly a once in a lifetime experience...I believe it should go non-typical, but like everyone else here, i dont think it should matter...How much did it weigh?
Doesn't matter if it's a world record, typical or non typical. It's a superb creature that gave Mr. Decker a once in a lifetime experience he will never, ever forget. Congratulations!
Jeez! It would be a world record type experience just to have seen this behemoth. How much did it weigh, and how many points?
I BET NO BRAIN BRIAN VOTED FOR OBAMA
I eat those things for breakfast! Yumm.
I'm not a hunter. I'm not a tree hugger or pita person either. But my initial thought was the same as Brian and Drew's. Doesn't the animal world rely on survival of the fittest? If you kill the top dogs then you'll be left with the dregs of the world.
WOW!!!!! Thats what dreams are made of! From the footage provided, it appears to be the same buck. I'd like to know the distance from where the film footage was taken and the site harvested. What a deer!!!
thats the same buck no doubt. congrats. i'd be happy with 150 here in va.
What a beast!! I really hope this does turn out to be a world record because i am from Wisconsin and that would be awesome to have a world record buck taken in our state. Congrats on the tank!!
What a buck. My buddies and I all were watching the video on youtube with our shop teacher and then the next day we found out you shot that beast... Way to go!!! Thats what I call a TRUE WISCONSIN WHITETAIL!
This comes from the taxidermist that is doing the mount, as of right now the buck will be scored as a typical 7X7 even though its an 8X8. The choice of it being scored as a typical was by the B&C. Hunting should be fun for all not just for some score. The score just adds a little axtra to it. I feel you should never have to pay to hunt a deer and if you do you should be able to shoot whatever you want to shoot.
Holy @#%^#$ ^%$&(&^% #$%^ I wet my pants lokkin at the photos. I'm really curious how it scores!!!!?
excellent job man your fellow bow hunters can only wish to someday take an awesome animal like that.Record or not no one can EVER take away that moment.Again awesome job. How long of a drag did you have? Not long I hope he's a monster
You're gonna end up scoring it non typical only because of the deductions. It'll still be very high no matter what.
It clearly IS the F&S buck. I don't know how anyone could say otherwise.
Beautiful- not even the word Awesome is good enough. Just imagine the feeling he had! Truly priceless!! I bet he said " Yeeesssssss"!! Continue on in your love of this sport, enjoy the stories with your kids, enjoy the stories with your friends.It would have been bitter sweet to say he shot it in Wisconsin rather than Buffalo CO. But all i can say is, i wish i were able to experience the afternoon he had...i would love the experience just to sit day in day out in the woods from there on out!Great Memory for you Bill!!
Fantastic deer but I just watched the video again and I don't think this is the F&S buck.
Great buck!! NOT a record, will be scored a non-T. the junk will add up. again super buck.
Bob Decker,Play it smart and don't tell anyone what brand bow, arrows, or anything you were using. Endorsments goes to highest bidder. You deserve it so take it while the takins good.
Always hard to score deer, especially from a photo, best guess is that this Monster will score as a 12, at best, probably a 10, and thats if the G1-G5s arent consideder points off of other vertical points, best way to have a better idea is print off the P& Y score sheet and see how a buck is actually scored. Symetry is the key to typical and I dont think this has it. Thats why taking a 200" plus buck bow or gun is like winning the lottery.
Just Wondering --- I read that the taxidermist that capped it out aged it at 3 1/2 year old.My 187 buck from last year was also a 3 1/2 year old; otherwise I would not believe it.Andrew --- If you ask me it’s the 365 blog buck.
Great job Bob, I know how it feels. I shot a 187 buck last year in St. Croix County. The Buffalo County genetics are finally spreading our way.
Not the same deer as the 365 blog. Good kill though. Records mean nothing. It's memories that matter.
What do you think the age of the buck was ? To me I would be amazed how he lived and dodge hunters for all this time.
holy cow is that a fricken monster!great job man thats a once and a lifetime buck rite there!!!!!!i hope it hits the records. that would look nice in there....
holy cow is that a fricken monstergreat job man!!! thats a nice 1
Congrats on the huge trophy! Long distance = Target PracticingShooting 7 yards...now that's hunting!!!To comment on Brian's post, I think/hope what Brian was trying to say is that there is only a small percentage of deer that have the genes to actually get that big. Imagine if this buck would've been passed-up and could've spread more of those "huge buck genes" on down the line. In a lot of respect, hunters have it all backwards. We take the biggest and healthiest, thus making the remaining heards weaker and smaller.Before I get criticized too heavily, let me also say that I am just as guilty of this as any...
I'd take it if it had that much horn growing out of its rump. Nontypical or not-ya'll put too much heed into scoring these days.
Wow! MAke sure that one is secured to the wall! No broken antlers, looks pretty perfect to me! Wonder if he stopped shaken yet. Great job!
well played out Bob.... once in a life time buck right there
Ya, Brian. I guess that big buck deserves ta be eaten alive by coyotes, or slowly killed by disease or starvation rather than being immortalized by that proud hunter. Much more dignified...
what is brian thinking is all i got to say!
Thats quite an accomplishment for any hunter congrats Mr. Decker and send some giants like that over my way please..... p.s. have fun with all the endorsement opportunities with that deer i wish i was in your shoes
Brian should stick to video games and leave hunting to the people who know what they are talking about but any ways you make me proud to be a bowhunter in wisconsin.
Brian should stick to video games and leave hunting to the people who know what they are talking about but any ways you make me proud to be a bowhunter in wisconsin.
great job that guy who said let it live never seen a true monster you are very lucky great job.
Great shot sure makes me miss the badger state. Hope to see more Pic's of that one in a million deer
THATS THE REASON I GO TO THE WOODS EVERY CHANCE I GET.GREAT JOB!!!!!!!
I can't believe that Brian guy. "deserves to live" what is that all about. What a magnificent Wisconsin deer. Glad one of our residents shot a big one once. Maybe it's time to bring the world record back to Wisconsin to join it's place with the Jordan buck. Excellent job!!!
Qhote from Brian "I love hunting, but a buck that big deserves to live" So your saying that you would pass it up? I don't get it...anyway that deer is huge...congrats
AWESOME! Congrats Mr Decker! I have to agree with the other poster who was happy this deer went to a true local hunter. I hear that Decker has been hunting this land since long before the video was posted online. He grew up hunting in Wisconsin and didn't buy his way to this deer. It would have been a shame if someone from outside had flown in and paid big money to shoot down this animal on a drive. Nope. This was the way it should be. One man with a bow, relying on his own skill and determination, making a clean and ethical kill. Whether it's a world record or not, it's a once-in-a-lifetime experience.
Absolutely amazing to be done with a bow!
As a native Wisconsinite and being that I grew up close to Mondovi and Buffalo County, all I can say is thank goodness a local true hunter was the one to take this deer as opposed to an out of stater who pays $4800 to spend 4 days in a stand on a ranch. The boom in popularity of this region for deer hunting has made it near impossible for many average people to even think of taking a deer like this. Congratulations Mr. Decker!
I love hunting, but a buck that big deserves to live.
It may be a record, i dont have time to try to score it right now. The important thing is that this is a trophy that seems to have been taken in non-shady circumstances by a legit hunter. I hope this turns out to be true, as many large deer killed each year have very suspicious stories to go along with them. As for how it will be scored, I think it shold be scored as a typical, but it is definitely close. My personal opinion is that all deer should be officially scored as total gross antler (gross non-typical) because this is the only thing that truly measures how much antler there is. Regardless, this is an enormous deer. Congratulations to the hunter.
I've seen bigger in my backyard.
Nice work! Wow! Awesome! Amazing! Jaw Dropping! Not sure if those words do it justice. Love the new pictures here on F & S. The local paper in Eau Claire showed only one photo on Monday and it wasn't nearly as nice as these. The hardest part for me would be knowing that I will never probably have a chance like that again........still have to dig deep and find the grit to put all that preseason work and those early mornings to the woods. I agree....that is what Wisconsin Whitetail Hunters dream about at night!!
Way to go! Glad to see someone local get him, especially with the bow! What a dream come true. Way to go Bob!!
Can I get a shout out for Quality Deer Management?! Buffalo County has proven again why it works. Let the little ones go and let em grow!!!! Nice job!!-Wisconsin Northwoods
That's amazing - especially to get him at bow range. Like everyone else, I wouldn't care if it was a world-record or not. If I took that one, I'd almost be tempted to stop hunting after that - almost.
If I was graced by the Lord enough to shoot a deer like that, I wouldn't care if it was a world record or not. I would be shaking to bad to even fill out the paperwork. Congratulations on a awesome trophy.
Bob that is truly a beautiful WISCONSIN White-Tailed Deer. Being from Wisconsin myself, I can surely appreciate what you've done. I spend everyday in tree stand during the season when I'm not working. I know how 3 hours can feel when you see nothing, and then all of sudden the woods comes alive. You have made us Wisconsinites proud.
I could care less of boone and crockett or pope and young !!! That deer is what white tailed deer hunting in Wisconsin is all about!!!!!!!!
Nice deer, but I want to know why the guy that got the footage of it would broadcast it. Think you would want to keep that secret to yourself. But oh well, nice deer!
HE WONT GET ANOTHER LIKE THAT AGAIN! GREAT SHOT - BOW HUNTERSARE ALWAYS UP CLOSE !!
hey billie bryson, this is wisconsin. There are no blacktails in wisconsin. Blacktails live in the Northwest. jeez.
what a sweet deer, i cannot wait until shot gun season to take a good buck good job man
No need to have any doubt you arrowed A world class whitetail world record or not........
I think it looks like a couple tines fork at the beam, so non-typical is my guess, but agian like everyone is saying who cares it's a buck of a lifetime! Good job. I would like to know if it was a paid hunt or if it was just a landowner, or owner friend. ?
I"ll bet it goes non typical but who cares about score when u have killed a True Monarch by ANYONE'S standards
nice. record or no record thats big.
very nice buck, thats the time not to miss haha
is that there a whitetailed buck or a black tailed? how many points?
wish we could get a few more pics,Great job!
Well done. Nice shot.
Nice shot, this is a once in a lifetime buck,put yourself in this man's boots,could you make that shot,that is why to much bow practice is never enough,be thankful for this magical time of year,god bless the u.s.ak.w hurley wi.
who really cares typical or non-typical. record or not its a once in a lifetime buck and I believe that you should be thankful to take a deer like that.
it's not truly amazing to shoot a buck like that with a bow when there hand fed.
thats a sucky buck i shot a fawn last year and it weighed 340 pounds it weighed more than a buffalowhen i shot it it started squecking then i took a dump on its head beat that
Post a Comment