Written By
Published Sep. 24, 2021

A boat anchor is one of the most important accessories on any boat. Not only does a boat anchor hold the boat in one position for docking and fishing, but it can prevent a bad situation from becoming worse if the boat loses power.

The most common type of anchor for most boats is a Danforth or fluke anchor. This anchor features two sharp blades that stick into sandy or muddy bottom. 

For rocky bottom and structure, anglers choose a mushroom anchor with a wide, heavy head that holds the boat in place. 

Kayak and canoe anglers prefer a collapsable grapple anchor that folds up to save space.

To pull the boat up on a sandbar and join the party, boaters prefer a spike anchor that sticks into the sand to keep the boat in place without causing a tripping hazard.

Whatever you are doing in the boat, the best anchor is essential for docking, fishing and safety.

Best Boat Anchor for Sand: Fortress Danforth Anchor

Best Boat Anchor for Sand

Key Features 

  • Weight: 4.8 pounds
  • Dimensions: 25”X5”X3”
  • Materials: Anodized Aluminum

Why It Made The Cut

A fluke style anchor is the most common and effective way to secure a boat in sandy bottom. Fortress Anchors are famous for their high-quality build and strong and light aluminum/magnesium alloy construction making it our pick for the best boat anchor for sand.

Pros

  • Light, anodized aluminum
  • Corrosion resistant
  • Sharpened flukes

Cons

  • Expensive

A Danforth or fluke anchor uses two sharp blades that will insert themselves into soft bottom. To work properly, a fluke anchor is attached to a length of chain and an anchor rope. As the anchor drags across the bottom, the heavy chain forces the anchor shaft down and pushes the flukes into the bottom. To remove the anchor, retrieve the rope until you can lift the anchor shaft up, and pull the flukes out of the bottom. 

A common misconception is that a Danforth anchor has to be heavy to hold the boat. But, since the flukes that stick into the bottom hold the boat, not the anchor weight, super strong and sharp flukes are what matters. 

The Fortress Anchors is made of anodized aluminum and magnesium that is lighter and more corrosion resistant than similar galvanized steel anchors. In tests, the Fortress Anchor was able to hold more weight with a smaller, lighter anchor.

In addition to the lightest and toughest material, the Fortress Anchor uses sturdy construction to hold boats from 16 to 27 feet long in strong current and heavy seas. 

Best Boat Anchor for Muddy Bottom and Rocky Bottom: Seachoice Grapnel Anchor

Best for Muddy Bottom and Rocky Bottom

Key Features 

  • Weight: 1.5 pounds to 9 pounds 
  • Dimensions: 4 ¾” x 6 ¾”
  • Materials: Galvanized iron

Why It Made The Cut

For small fishing boats, dinghies, kayaks and canoes that anchor over both muddy and rocky bottoms, a grapnel anchor is the best choice, and the Seachoice is tough and strong and the best boat anchor for muddy bottoms and rocky bottoms. 

Pros

  • Folding flukes 
  • Can also be used in rocky bottom
  • Inexpensive

Cons

  • Galvanized iron can eventually rust

The Seachoice grapnel anchor features four flukes and a shaft with a locking ring. When it’s not in use, the four flukes fold flat against the shaft for easy storage in a small boat.

On a soft or muddy bottom, unfold the flukes and lock them in place so they stick in the bottom. To use the anchor in rocky or hard bottom, leave the flukes folded and use the weight of the anchor to hold the boat. Keeping the flukes folded prevents the anchor from getting stuck in rocks.

The Seachoice grapnel anchor has a Clevis link to attach the anchor rope. For deeper water or a heavier boat, add a short length of light chain to help drive the flukes into the bottom.

For a small kayak or canoe in light current, a 1.5-pound grapnel anchor will suffice. A skiff or dinghy requires a heavier nine-pound grapnel anchor. Grapnel anchors aren’t appropriate for anchoring a boat unattended, because the flukes can pull out of the bottom. 

Best River Anchor: Seachoice 41500 River Anchor

Best River Anchor

Key Features 

  • Weight: 12 pounds
  • Dimensions: 8”X9.5”
  • Materials: Vinyl coated iron

Why It Made The Cut

Seachoice is one of the most popular makers of boating accessories. Their 41500 river anchor is made of heavy vinyl-coated iron, and the design holds the bottom better than standard mushroom anchors.

Pros

  • Heavy, vinyl coated iron
  • Galvanized shackle included
  • Modified mushroom anchor grips hard bottoms

Cons

  • Not corrosion resistant

For anchoring a small boat in swift water with a hard bottom, the weight and rounded shape of a mushroom anchor holds the bottom without getting stuck. The Seachoice 41500 River Anchor improves on the traditional mushroom anchor. The head of the mushroom is notched to better grip the bottom. The anchor is made of heavy iron with a vinyl coating to prevent corrosion.

Using Seachoice 41500 is easy. Just attach a rope to the included galvanized shackle and drop the anchor in the water. The anchor is designed to slip free under high pressure, making it the safest and best river anchor..

Best Kayak Anchor for Mud: YakAttack Two-Piece ParkNPole

Best Kayak Anchor for Mud

Key Features 

  • Weight: 1.8 pounds
  • Dimensions: 8 feet long
  • Materials: Fiberglass and reinforced plastic

Why It Made The Cut

A stakeout pole is best for quickly and safely anchoring a kayak or standup paddleboard in shallow water with soft mud. YakAttack’s ParkNPole is light and strong, and the wide handle means it can double as a push pole when flipped.

Pros

  • Two-piece for easy storage
  • Tough UV stabilized fiberglass
  • Hardened spike for anchoring

Cons

  • Takes up space on the deck

For anchoring in soft sand or mud, a stakeout pole is the best kayak anchor for mud and quick and easy to deploy and retrieve. Simply stick the pole in the bottom and secure the boat with a short line. To retrieve the anchor, pull it from the mud and store it on the deck.

YakAttack’s ParkNPole has been a standard for shallow-water anglers in saltwater and freshwater. The two-piece model makes it easier to store the pole inside a kayak or in an under-deck rod holder.

The fiberglass shaft is tough and light while providing flex to absorb the shock of the boat pulling against the pole. The hardened pointed tip easily pierces the bottom for a solid grip.

Flip the ParkNPole over, and the wide, reinforced plastic foot makes it a convenient push pole. The advantage of the stakeout pole is stopping the boat quickly to make a cast. Then, pull up the stakeout pole, flip it over and push to the next spot.

Best Boat Anchor for Sandbars: Slide Anchor Spike

Best Boat Anchor for Sandbars

Key Features 

  • Weight: 2 Pounds
  • Dimensions: 32” x 3.2” x 3.2”
  • Materials: Galvanized steel

Why It Made The Cut

Designed specifically for quickly and safely securing a boat to a beach or shoreline, the Slide Anchor Spike incorporates a powerful driver that allows you to easily pound the spike into the sand. 

Pros

  • Galvanized for corrosion resistance
  • High visibility for safety
  • Secure connections

Cons

  • Bungee cord secures driver

The Slide Anchor Spike is the best boat anchor for sandbars. It uses a heavy sliding handle to hammer the spike into the sand. Place the tip of the spike a few inches into the sand then slide the tubular handle against the stop to drive the spike into the ground. 

Clip the anchor line to the lower ring on the spike and use the top ring for a buoy or flag to mark the spike’s location. Since the line and the spike are above ground level, Slide Anchor is easier for people to see, while providing a solid anchoring point for the boat. 

Methodology 

We compared various anchors on their merits in a specific category. The most important quality is performance when holding the boat in wind, waves and current.

Next, we evaluated build quality by looking at materials and construction. An anchor takes a beating, so we favored corrosion-resistant metals and sturdy components and connections.

To make the cut, boat anchors in this review had to excel at their intended use. 

The best boat anchor isn’t always the most expensive, but we didn’t let an anchor’s cost restrict our considerations.

Things to Consider Before Buying a Boat Anchor

Before buying a boat anchor, consider how it will be used and the build quality. A boat anchor is one of the most important boating accessories. With an expensive boat literally on the line, the best boat anchor is responsible for securing the boat in any condition. To choose the best boat anchor, consider these questions. 

Where do you intend to anchor the boat? Consider the bottom composition before choosing a boat anchor. Anchoring in soft sand or mud is best with a Danforth or fluke anchor that digs into the bottom. To anchor in a river, a heavy mushroom anchor will hold the boat without getting stuck in the rocks. If you anchor often while fishing shallow water, a stakeout pole is a quick and effective way to anchor a small boat. A grapnel anchor is adjustable for either soft or hard bottom. Beaching the boat on a sandbar requires a spike-style anchor that sticks into the sand so it is easier to see.

What size anchor is best for your boat? A large boat requires a Danforth anchor with long, wide flukes and a long chain to ensure that the anchor lays on its side, allowing the flukes to dig into the bottom.

The chain should be equal to the length of the boat and the same diameter as the anchor rope. Use rope ⅛-inch thick for every nine feet of boat, so ¼-inch rope will hold an 18-foot boat. Carry enough anchor line to equal at least three times the deepest water you plan to fish.

Mushroom anchors come in sizes and weights to match smaller boats.

For kayaks and canoes, a grapnel anchor will secure the boat in heavy current. A smaller grapnel may be appropriate for lakes and ponds while rivers or tidal passes call for a larger, heavier anchor.

Sand spikes come in small and large sizes to match the size of the boat. To anchor a large boat, use two spikes. 

Look for an anchor that is corrosion resistant. Aluminum will not rust and stainless steel is very rust resistant. Heavy anchors made of iron or steel should be galvanized or coated in vinyl. Connections and hinges should be oversized and sturdy to take a beating. Don’t forget shackles and links to connect the anchor to a chain or rope.  

FAQs

Q: How much does an anchor cost?

Anchor cost depends on the size and quality of the anchor. Larger anchors cost more than smaller ones, but size isn’t all that affects the cost. Boat anchors vary in build and materials. A more expensive anchor may have tougher construction to last longer. Boat anchors take a lot of abuse, so an anchor with corrosion resistant materials and heavy-duty components will cost more. Part of boating is losing an anchor. Despite best efforts, broken lines and weakened components will lead to replacing an anchor, so keep that in mind when shopping.

Q: How big of an anchor do I need for my boat?

The size of an anchor correlates to the size of the boat and the conditions where the anchor will be used. A Danforth anchor is measured with holding power, not weight or size. Anchors are tested and rated by holding power to match the size of the boat and conditions. Also, consider the length and weight of the anchor chain and rope to match the boat size and weight. 

Mushroom anchors are rated by weight. A smaller boat under 16 feet long can be secured with a 12-pound anchor. Larger boats require a heavier anchor. For docking or heavy conditions, add a length of heavy chain equal to the length of the boat.

Grapnel anchors are best for kayaks and canoes. Match the size of the anchor to the water depth and conditions. In shallow, calm water, a 1.5-pound anchor will work. In deeper water or swift current, use a 7-pound anchor. Use the lightest anchor required to reduce weight in the kayak or canoe.

Q: How much anchor line should you use if the water is 20 feet deep?

Anchor line and chain, called anchor rode, is as important as the anchor. The general rule is to use an anchor chain the same length as the boat. Then, pay out anchor rode at least three times the depth of the water. For rough conditions, use more line to provide greater scope pulling on the anchor. At 10 feet of rode for every foot of depth, holding power is near 100%.

Final Thoughts

The best boat anchor is strong and reliable to secure a boat fast whether docking, fishing or in an emergency. We chose the Fortress Anchor as the best boat anchor because it is light, strong, very effective, and folds flat for storage.

MORE TO READ