


April 19, 2011
Marlin 336 Wins Whitetail Brush Rifle Championship
by Dave Hurteau
About a month ago, we started with The Sweet Sixteen of Whitetail Brush Rifles—a March Madness-style tourney to decide the top deer gun in the thick woods. In four rounds of head-to-head matchups, you voted the great Savage 99 out in the Elite Eight and sent the North Woods staple Remington 7600 packing in the Final Four. So it came down to the top seeds: Winchester 94 vs. Marlin 336.
And now, with more than 800 votes cast in the final matchup, it is all over—and it wasn’t even that close. While I admit I was rooting for the 94, my sentimental choice, I’m not surprised the 336 came out on top. I am mildly shocked, however, that it trounced the venerable 94, which got only about 40 percent of the vote.

I get the advantages of the 336, that the solid-top, side-eject receiver accepts a low, center-mounted scope (unlike all 94s prior to 1982 when angle-ejection became standard). I realize that the Marlin’s action is considered stronger, with a more positive feel (whereas the Winchester has some slop and rattle). But, even forgetting the 94’s traditional reputation as the American deer rifle, its light weight (6-1/4 pounds compared to the 336’s 7); its straight, slender wrist and trim receiver that snugs between just a thumb and forefinger; its waifish frame and graceful lines altogether make the 94 the nimblest, finest-looking little brush gun ever made.
The 94 is Kate Moss. The 336 ain’t bad looking, but she has man hands.
None of this is to say the 336 isn’t a deserving winner. I have one in .35 Rem with a 2x scope that I take over the 94 whenever I leave the low, evergreen thickets for the mixed ridges. Overall, it may well be the best practical choice. I just figured the 94’s mystique, looks, and handiness would make this a much closer contest. Anyway, to all you Savage 99 fans (myself included), take heart; it will get another chance in the All-Purpose Whitetail Rifle tourney to come. Meanwhile, all hail the 336—Whitetail Brush Rifle Champ.
Comments (32)
Nice summary, Dave!
My 336 in .35 Remington wears one of the new Redfield 2x7's and is my deer driving gun.
You were partially right in your comparison. But a 336 is naturally curvy and most men like things with curves. The 94, while it has it's positives, looks more like a microphone stand.
And let me be clear that I am not including women as "things". Most men like things (guns, cars, guitars, etc) to have curves like a woman.
If there's one thing I've learned, it's take something that's practical and put together for a strong, durable rilfe over anything else that might look prettier. The '94 is a GREAT rifle, but it looks like Marlin may have slightly one-upped their competitors - at least, according to the majority.
A Seinfeld reference? Thank you for brightening my day!
The Marlin 336...when the 900 dollar Browning BLR in 7mm-08 doesn't make sense. On with the greatest firewood chainsaw of all time. Cheers.
Excellent idea, AJ,
I'm counting on you to do the seeding and put together the bracket, though. And my Husqvarna better in there. Just saying.
AJ,
See if you can construct a poll that brings Stihl and the Husky head to head.
Dave,
Never cared much for Kate Moss or Twiggy. I prefer women and rifles with curves. Big hands aren't a problem either...
I'll leave that alone, Beekeeper. . .
Dave,
LMAO!
I love the 336 and think it is a bit better than the 94, but have to admit I was a bit surprised that the 94 lost. I thought its reputation would win the competition for it, even if it is not quite as good.
I think the half century decline of the Winchester name is to blame. The masses never really forgave Winchester for the whole 1964 incident. Marlins are more adaptable to mass production with a lower price point than Winchesters. Unfortunately the Japanese-made ones are about as expensive as a decent pre-64 rifle. Couldn't we sell rifles made in America for that price? Anyways, Marlins are great weapons, but like Glocks and Weatherby's, I just don't like them.
Beekeeper,
My opinion is as arrogant as yours; that's what makes the Web go round.
sweet, first gun i ever got, I have taken all my deer with it. PS best christmas present ive ever got and a great bush rifle
Beekeeper,
Well that must have seemed like a nonsequitur. I swear my eye are going already.
Now I see, You wrote LMAO--not IMAO ("in my arrogant opinion"). Sorry. I'll wear my glasses next time.
@Dave- Husky's, Stihls, Jonsered's, McCulloch, and others new and old and various sizes and models should be represented. It would be easier to narrow it down to 8, but with a little research "The best Firewood Chainsaw" might begin with 16 contenders. You have this, or the best all round mountain elk hunting rifle/caliber, the best whitetail rifle for a 13 year old, the best single shot deer rifle, the couldn't do without deer rifle, the best 22 plinker, the best splitting maul, the Best 150$ spent on hunting this year, the best 200 dollars spent on fishing, the best uninsulated camo coveralls, the best all round knife, or the best excuse to take a new to hunting neighbor hunting-to split gas money, or she has just been divorced, she has a pool, and her online dating profile says she "likes the outdoors." Keep the voting centered competitions coming, may democracy appear effective.
Best firewood saw is my Husquavarna 51, I've got about 5000 hours onit, been through 3 bars and 7 chains, can't beat it. I wouldn't steal a Stihl! Lets have a contest between the Marlin 336 and my Remington 740 in 30-06 and we'll see what gun will put 5 shots into a 12' circle at 25 yards faster!
I had a Marlin 336 in .44 Magnum a long time ago. I hear they are worth some money now. Wish I still had it.
It was far superior to the Winchester 94 30-30 I had, at least at the 50 yard range I usually kill my deer.
I still prefer my HCA 4RUNNER, gets me into areas where the big bucks are at, plus 5 solid months of hunting!
very unfortunate outcome.
No problem Dave. You are correct though, arrogant opinions do seem to make the internet what it is!
Cheers!
Bee
The brackets for "Best firewood" chainsaws is on the announcements, message board sections, I came up with 32 so they should be easy to use a similar system to the best brush rifle. Cheers. You have to cut firewood and you need the best all round tool for the job. Let the popularity competition begin.
All I ever wanted was a Winchester 94 30-30. got a nice pre-64. After first sight in, determined that I needed a scope. A side mounted 1.5 to 4 power was excellent. Then I tried a Marlin 336 and missed a deer as my glove would fit in the trigger guard like it would on the Winchester. Next tried a Ruger .44 semi-auto and it seems to be shorter & handier then either 30-30. The Ruger is now my favorite and the Winchester will stay as a back up, sold the Marlin.
AJ-You know you can't beat a Stihl when it comes to chainsaws, or any other small farm tool for that matter. My dad's got a Stihl from the early 1980's that can still outdo most saws around.
I bought a 336 new out of a discount store that was going out of business. That was almost 30 years ago. It's been in a case in the gun safe ever since. I think it's been fired possibly 5 or 6 times. One of those shots took a mule deer out of almost inpenetrable brush in the Guadalupe Mountains of southeastern New Mexico. I love the 336, just never use it because I like the open, long shots better. I'm 82 now. The Model 70 I bought on credit new when I was 18 still does a superb job in 30-06. I'll never get rid of the Marlin, just wish I had more need for it! Happy shooting!
Sorry for the typo.......... I'm 62, not 82!! Thanks.
While I had never been a big Lever Gun fan, my Mod 7 Rem in .308 w 2x7 compact is a slayer, the Adirondack woods can be tough on guns and gear. When I go up to the Camp, my go to gun is a 336Y in 30-30. The shorter barrel is much more handy. I swapped out the wood with a Ram Line synthetic (had to shorten the forearm a bit), mounted a Williams peep, a Leverscout mount and a 2.5x EER and stoke it with Leverevolution ammo. This off season I'm going to Duracoat it since it's always wet or frozen up there. It's a heck of a package and will give any Whitetail or Black Bear within 150yds a bad day. My pretty guns stay down here in the Hudson Valley..lol
All is good until I eject shells and the back of them rips off...Going to try different ammo today...I have had it for 3 weeks and have yet to not have to pry out the broken brass with a dental pick. I'm hoping it is the Remington core lokt 150 grain that I'm using.
Bought a Wally 336W, do my own 30-30 reloads and put a williams peep sight on it. Sighted it in at 50 yds and it's good to go out to 150 yds.
An eqasy gun to carry. Only trouble I ever had was the screw that holds the feeder tab in place loosened up real easy and gun wouldn't feed or eject. a little lock-tite on the screw fixed that.
I like the look and feel of the 94 better (got a pre-64 30/30, well 30 WCF to be precise). Very nice gun. Never owned a 336, but shot them. Good rifles. At least the 336 is still being made, cant say that for the Winchester.
I just bought myself a 336... chose that over the 94 (everything else considered equal) simply for the design, look, feel, and curves! I love the gun!
Post a Comment
You were partially right in your comparison. But a 336 is naturally curvy and most men like things with curves. The 94, while it has it's positives, looks more like a microphone stand.
And let me be clear that I am not including women as "things". Most men like things (guns, cars, guitars, etc) to have curves like a woman.
If there's one thing I've learned, it's take something that's practical and put together for a strong, durable rilfe over anything else that might look prettier. The '94 is a GREAT rifle, but it looks like Marlin may have slightly one-upped their competitors - at least, according to the majority.
A Seinfeld reference? Thank you for brightening my day!
AJ,
See if you can construct a poll that brings Stihl and the Husky head to head.
Dave,
Never cared much for Kate Moss or Twiggy. I prefer women and rifles with curves. Big hands aren't a problem either...
sweet, first gun i ever got, I have taken all my deer with it. PS best christmas present ive ever got and a great bush rifle
@Dave- Husky's, Stihls, Jonsered's, McCulloch, and others new and old and various sizes and models should be represented. It would be easier to narrow it down to 8, but with a little research "The best Firewood Chainsaw" might begin with 16 contenders. You have this, or the best all round mountain elk hunting rifle/caliber, the best whitetail rifle for a 13 year old, the best single shot deer rifle, the couldn't do without deer rifle, the best 22 plinker, the best splitting maul, the Best 150$ spent on hunting this year, the best 200 dollars spent on fishing, the best uninsulated camo coveralls, the best all round knife, or the best excuse to take a new to hunting neighbor hunting-to split gas money, or she has just been divorced, she has a pool, and her online dating profile says she "likes the outdoors." Keep the voting centered competitions coming, may democracy appear effective.
I bought a 336 new out of a discount store that was going out of business. That was almost 30 years ago. It's been in a case in the gun safe ever since. I think it's been fired possibly 5 or 6 times. One of those shots took a mule deer out of almost inpenetrable brush in the Guadalupe Mountains of southeastern New Mexico. I love the 336, just never use it because I like the open, long shots better. I'm 82 now. The Model 70 I bought on credit new when I was 18 still does a superb job in 30-06. I'll never get rid of the Marlin, just wish I had more need for it! Happy shooting!
While I had never been a big Lever Gun fan, my Mod 7 Rem in .308 w 2x7 compact is a slayer, the Adirondack woods can be tough on guns and gear. When I go up to the Camp, my go to gun is a 336Y in 30-30. The shorter barrel is much more handy. I swapped out the wood with a Ram Line synthetic (had to shorten the forearm a bit), mounted a Williams peep, a Leverscout mount and a 2.5x EER and stoke it with Leverevolution ammo. This off season I'm going to Duracoat it since it's always wet or frozen up there. It's a heck of a package and will give any Whitetail or Black Bear within 150yds a bad day. My pretty guns stay down here in the Hudson Valley..lol
Nice summary, Dave!
My 336 in .35 Remington wears one of the new Redfield 2x7's and is my deer driving gun.
The Marlin 336...when the 900 dollar Browning BLR in 7mm-08 doesn't make sense. On with the greatest firewood chainsaw of all time. Cheers.
Excellent idea, AJ,
I'm counting on you to do the seeding and put together the bracket, though. And my Husqvarna better in there. Just saying.
I'll leave that alone, Beekeeper. . .
Dave,
LMAO!
I love the 336 and think it is a bit better than the 94, but have to admit I was a bit surprised that the 94 lost. I thought its reputation would win the competition for it, even if it is not quite as good.
I think the half century decline of the Winchester name is to blame. The masses never really forgave Winchester for the whole 1964 incident. Marlins are more adaptable to mass production with a lower price point than Winchesters. Unfortunately the Japanese-made ones are about as expensive as a decent pre-64 rifle. Couldn't we sell rifles made in America for that price? Anyways, Marlins are great weapons, but like Glocks and Weatherby's, I just don't like them.
Beekeeper,
My opinion is as arrogant as yours; that's what makes the Web go round.
Beekeeper,
Well that must have seemed like a nonsequitur. I swear my eye are going already.
Now I see, You wrote LMAO--not IMAO ("in my arrogant opinion"). Sorry. I'll wear my glasses next time.
Best firewood saw is my Husquavarna 51, I've got about 5000 hours onit, been through 3 bars and 7 chains, can't beat it. I wouldn't steal a Stihl! Lets have a contest between the Marlin 336 and my Remington 740 in 30-06 and we'll see what gun will put 5 shots into a 12' circle at 25 yards faster!
I had a Marlin 336 in .44 Magnum a long time ago. I hear they are worth some money now. Wish I still had it.
It was far superior to the Winchester 94 30-30 I had, at least at the 50 yard range I usually kill my deer.
I still prefer my HCA 4RUNNER, gets me into areas where the big bucks are at, plus 5 solid months of hunting!
very unfortunate outcome.
No problem Dave. You are correct though, arrogant opinions do seem to make the internet what it is!
Cheers!
Bee
The brackets for "Best firewood" chainsaws is on the announcements, message board sections, I came up with 32 so they should be easy to use a similar system to the best brush rifle. Cheers. You have to cut firewood and you need the best all round tool for the job. Let the popularity competition begin.
All I ever wanted was a Winchester 94 30-30. got a nice pre-64. After first sight in, determined that I needed a scope. A side mounted 1.5 to 4 power was excellent. Then I tried a Marlin 336 and missed a deer as my glove would fit in the trigger guard like it would on the Winchester. Next tried a Ruger .44 semi-auto and it seems to be shorter & handier then either 30-30. The Ruger is now my favorite and the Winchester will stay as a back up, sold the Marlin.
AJ-You know you can't beat a Stihl when it comes to chainsaws, or any other small farm tool for that matter. My dad's got a Stihl from the early 1980's that can still outdo most saws around.
Sorry for the typo.......... I'm 62, not 82!! Thanks.
All is good until I eject shells and the back of them rips off...Going to try different ammo today...I have had it for 3 weeks and have yet to not have to pry out the broken brass with a dental pick. I'm hoping it is the Remington core lokt 150 grain that I'm using.
Bought a Wally 336W, do my own 30-30 reloads and put a williams peep sight on it. Sighted it in at 50 yds and it's good to go out to 150 yds.
An eqasy gun to carry. Only trouble I ever had was the screw that holds the feeder tab in place loosened up real easy and gun wouldn't feed or eject. a little lock-tite on the screw fixed that.
I like the look and feel of the 94 better (got a pre-64 30/30, well 30 WCF to be precise). Very nice gun. Never owned a 336, but shot them. Good rifles. At least the 336 is still being made, cant say that for the Winchester.
I just bought myself a 336... chose that over the 94 (everything else considered equal) simply for the design, look, feel, and curves! I love the gun!
Post a Comment