How to Cook Instant Pot Wild Turkey

The latest rage in cooking deserves a place in your hunting camp

diced vegetables and paprika turkey
All of the ingredients are prepped and ready for the Instant Pot. Brad Fenson

Spring has arrived. The turkeys are gobbling, and with any luck, you’ll tag a big, old bird with a long beard, hooked spurs, and a full-tail fan. Turkey hunters dream about shooting an old gobbler, as it represents a well-earned trophy.

The downside to shooting an old bird is the challenge involved with cooking all the edible parts, including the thighs. The good news is, there is a new-fandangled kitchen appliance that can make even the oldest turkey taste tender and moist.

If you’ve never heard of a multifunction electric pressure cooker like the Instant Pot, you didn’t look at any flyers in the mailbox leading up to Christmas. They are the newest rage in cooking and are likely to dominate the sale aisles for Easter and Mother’s Day. The Instant Pot is a modern version of a pressure cooker, with functions to allow you to sauté or even use it as a rice cooker at the touch of a button. It works by cooking with liquid under pressure, which tenderizes meat while retaining flavor and moisture—paramount to successfully cooking a wild turkey.

The all-in-one pots expedite cooking for those on the run or short on time or patience. A dish that would normally braise or stew for hours can be cooked in less than an hour, with a superior finished product.

paprika turkey in an instant pot
With the Instant Pot in “Sauté” mode, lightly brown the seasoned turkey. Brad Fenson

Instant Pot 101

Just like the old pressure cookers they are fashioned after, the Instant Pot can be a little intimidating the first time you use it. Canadian inventor Robert Wang has turned a basic pressure cooker into an easy-to-use push-button device. The concept is quite simple: Use pressure and heat to reduce cooking time. What would take 6 to 8 hours in a crockpot, takes 20 to 30 minutes in an Instant Pot. For hunters, this not only means quick and easy meals, but moist and tender game meat that can sometimes be tricky to cook.

To learn the functions of your Instant Pot, and to estimate the cooking times for different types of food, take your Instant Pot for a test run.

  1. Plug the power cord into the back of the unit and a socket on the wall. The LED display will indicate the unit is “Off”.

  2. Learn how to place the lid on properly and turn it clockwise to lock it on. The unit locks for safety and to maintain the different pressures.

  3. A pressure weight must be inserted on top of the lid and is known as the “steam release handle.” There are clear instructions on the lid that tell you which way to turn the weight to lock it in place or to vent it after cooking.

  4. To see some of the different functions, hit a button, for example, “Soup/Broth,” and the LED will tell you the default amount of time and pressure being used for certain dishes. Hit “Cancel” and try another one to understand the basic default times required for cooking different foods.

  5. When it is time to try cooking a meal with the unit, make sure you follow the basic instructions including having a minimum of two cups (500 ml) of liquid when using the “Pressure Cook” function.

  6. Venting the pot after cooking can be done in two ways. One option is to allow the unit to Naturally Release, which can take up to 40 minutes or more for the float valve to drop completely. The other option is to do a Quick Release, which involves turning the steam release handle to the “Venting” position to force the pressure out more quickly.

An old gobbler is a good example of something that could be tough to keep palatable for the entire family. With an Instant Pot, you can break down the legs and thighs into tender morsels that are loaded with flavor. The breast meat is also a superior finished product when cooked in an Instant Pot as cooking under pressure maintains the moisture content in the white meat, which is the trick to keeping it tender. Here’s one great recipe we just tried.

instant pot turkey recipe
Remove the turkey, deglaze the pot with broth, and return the meat. Set on high for 20 minutes. Brad Fenson

Paprika Wild Turkey Recipe

Ingredients:

  • 2 lbs. boneless, skinless turkey breasts and thighs (about 2 thighs and 1 breast from a big tom will be enough)
  • 2 Tbsp. smoked paprika
  • 1 Tbsp. sweet Hungarian or Spanish paprika
  • 1 tsp. each salt and freshly ground black pepper
  • 3 Tbsp. vegetable oil, divided
  • 2 cups chicken or turkey broth
  • 1 medium yellow onion, finely chopped
  • 3 large garlic cloves, crushed and finely minced
  • 2 cups mushrooms, sliced
  • 2 cups carrots, chopped into 2x½-inch pieces (about 2 large carrots)
  • 4 medium yellow potatoes, skin on, cut into 1 ½-inch chunks
  • 2 Tbsp. flour
  • ¾ white wine
instant pot turkey and vegetables
Remove the turkey once again, and whisk the wine into the flour and deglaze. Add the vegetables. Brad Fenson

Directions:

  1. Combine the paprika, salt, and pepper in a small bowl. Sprinkle spices on both sides of each piece of turkey and rub it in until fully coated.

  2. Set the Instant Pot to Sauté, and heat 2 tablespoons of oil. Add the turkey pieces and brown each side for 2-3 minutes. Remove the turkey, set aside, and deglaze the pot with 2 cups of broth, ensuring any brown bits have been scraped off. Return the turkey to the pot and pressure-cook on high for 20 minutes. Then, do a natural release of steam for 15 minutes, before manually venting.

  3. Put the turkey and broth in a large bowl and set aside. Whisk the wine into the flour.

  4. Set the Instant Pot to Sauté and heat the remaining 1 tablespoon of oil. Add the onions and garlic and sauté for 2 minutes. Add the mushrooms, carrots and potatoes, season with salt and pepper, and sauté for an additional 2 minutes. Deglaze the pot with the wine-and-flour mixture and bring to simmer for 1 minute.

  5. Add the broth back to the pot, stir to combine, and place the turkey on top of the veggie mixture. Pressure-cook on high for 5 minutes, then do a natural release for 10 minutes.

*It is important to cook the turkey first, as it takes longer to break down and become tender. If you cooked the vegetables for the same amount of time, they would be overcooked.

instant pot paprika turkey recipe
Add the turkey and cook on high for an additional 5 minutes. Brad Fenson

Helpful Hints for the Paprika Turkey Recipe

The sauté function on the Instant Pot heats up fast and is great for searing or browning meat and vegetables. After browning your turkey meat, remove it from the pot and make sure you deglaze your pot, so any caramelized and browned bits on the bottom don’t block the heat sensor and trick the unit into thinking that something is burning. From this point, it’s easy to follow the recipe to complete the dish.

After pressure-cooking meat, let the pot vent naturally for some time. Many recipes call for the addition of vegetables as a second cooking step, so manually venting, in this case, prevents the vegetables from getting too mushy. As in this turkey recipe, we are cooking the meat first and adding vegetables in the second stage. When the turkey is cooked, we let it depressurize naturally for 20 minutes, however when the vegetables were added, we manually vented the unit at the end of the cooking time to ensure the veggies are cooked to the correct consistency.

paprika chicken instant pot recipe
Moist and tender wild turkey every time. Brad Fenson

Instant Pot Troubleshooting

Is It Really Burning??

Occasionally, the Instant Pot may give you a “burn” error message during pressure-cooking. There are a few reasons for this, but the most common causes are the pressure weight isn’t in the sealing position, or the pot wasn’t deglazed well enough, and there are brown bits stuck to the bottom that are blocking the heat sensor. Occasionally the weight can be lopsided on the steam vent, so make sure that you place the weight straight on and turn to the sealing position.

Is it On?

There is no “on” button. When you set the time and pressure, or select one of the preprogrammed functions, the unit will automatically turn on after a short delay.

One feature that can be very handy is the “Delay Start,” which offers the ability to postpone the cooking time. It’s important to know this function is available to cook your meal while you are out hunting, but for those who don’t read the manual, don’t think this is the on switch to get your meal cooking, or you’ll just end up delaying your meal inadvertently—like I did the first I used it. When the cooking time is up, the unit defaults to the “Keep Warm” mode and provides a time count.

Is The Pressure Off?

When you’re cooking meat, it’s always best to let the unit depressurize at least partially on its own. I would recommend doing the Natural Release for 20 minutes, which ensures everything is cooked to perfection and makes it easier to vent the pot manually after that. If you are impatient and want to move on to the next step, or just get the meal on the table, the unit can be vented manually by doing a Quick Release. Turn the pressure weight to the “Venting” position to release steam from within the pot and release the pressure. Be warned: The steam WILL burn you if you have exposed skin above the weight. Wear an oven mitt to turn the pressure weight and keep your arms and face away from the steam port. There is a safety feature within the unit that will not allow you to open the lid until the pressure is released and the float valve drops down. If you try to remove the lid while the float valve is up, the lid will not turn, so be patient and give it a few more minutes.

There is no need to be afraid of pressure-cookers, because the new models are idiot-proofed. Your biggest concern will be burning your fingers, or face if you try to get a close look while steam is venting from the pot.